[Advanced] Avengers - Age of Ultron (GAME OVER!)

[Xthrax]

There are two things conflicting me right now, Tommy. You could be a jester using Galactus as a fake claim to get lynched. But there is something else too. 

 

This is a 24 player game, I'm guessing lynch is 13 players. You need 6 more votes to be lynched. If you were Jester, you would not have needed to say anything. There are bound to be some more sheep who would follow others. Or you would have thrown the thread into more confusion.

 

Or you could be scum like some others believe. There are two trains of thought here-You are a townie who was trolling. Or you are scum who tried to be too smart. On normal occasions, I would have gone with the less obvious-that you are town. But from my game, scum can execute dumb moves and pull it off because town thinks scum wouldn't be that dumb. I'm Wifom'ing myself here but I like this puzzle     

 

[Tsukibana]

*by Marvel, I meant X-Men

[Xthrax]

 

 

I actually thought Rand wrote it.

Stupid avatar.

I'm curious as to your interpretation of the voters, please analyze.

 

It'll take some time-hold on.

[Xthrax]

I mean that I am curious as to what shenanigans you are able to pull on that vote train - I have seen at least one game where someone could only Lie Detect someone who voted for them. I predict similar conditions on your Power.

If this was Marvel, I would give Rogue an ability similar - she could only "steal" Powers from someone who touches her (ie Votes)

That could easily be the Absorber role.

[Tommyrod]

There are two things conflicting me right now, Tommy. You could be a jester using Galactus as a fake claim to get lynched. But there is something else too.

 

This is a 24 player game, I'm guessing lynch is 13 players. You need 6 more votes to be lynched. If you were Jester, you would not have needed to say anything. There are bound to be some more sheep who would follow others. Or you would have thrown the thread into more confusion.

 

Or you could be scum like some others believe. There are two trains of thought here-You are a townie who was trolling. Or you are scum who tried to be too smart. On normal occasions, I would have gone with the less obvious-that you are town. But from my game, scum can execute dumb moves and pull it off because town thinks scum wouldn't be that dumb. I'm Wifom'ing myself here but I like this puzzle

 

I don't actually understand what you're saying. You realize I was just scum in your game right?

[Tommyrod]

I mean that I am curious as to what shenanigans you are able to pull on that vote train - I have seen at least one game where someone could only Lie Detect someone who voted for them. I predict similar conditions on your Power.

If this was Marvel, I would give Rogue an ability similar - she could only "steal" Powers from someone who touches her (ie Votes)

That's a good guess. Do xmen cross over with avengers though?

[Tsukibana]

Technically, they could (Quicksilver (one of the Twins) was supposed to be Magneto's kid) - But not in the films, because Fox owns the rights to X-Men

[Tommyrod]

Technically, they could (Quicksilver (one of the Twins) was supposed to be Magneto's kid) - But not in the films, because Fox owns the rights to X-Men

Oh quicksilver is an xman? Okay I know he's in the game so yes there's xmen here.

[Xthrax]

 

There are two things conflicting me right now, Tommy. You could be a jester using Galactus as a fake claim to get lynched. But there is something else too.

 

This is a 24 player game, I'm guessing lynch is 13 players. You need 6 more votes to be lynched. If you were Jester, you would not have needed to say anything. There are bound to be some more sheep who would follow others. Or you would have thrown the thread into more confusion.

 

Or you could be scum like some others believe. There are two trains of thought here-You are a townie who was trolling. Or you are scum who tried to be too smart. On normal occasions, I would have gone with the less obvious-that you are town. But from my game, scum can execute dumb moves and pull it off because town thinks scum wouldn't be that dumb. I'm Wifom'ing myself here but I like this puzzle

I don't actually understand what you're saying. You realize I was just scum in your game right?

 

I know, that's what I factored in the bold sentence

[Xthrax]

 

Technically, they could (Quicksilver (one of the Twins) was supposed to be Magneto's kid) - But not in the films, because Fox owns the rights to X-Men

Oh quicksilver is an xman? Okay I know he's in the game so yes there's xmen here.

 

How do you know Quicksilver is in the game?

[Tommyrod]

 

 

 

Technically, they could (Quicksilver (one of the Twins) was supposed to be Magneto's kid) - But not in the films, because Fox owns the rights to X-Men

Oh quicksilver is an xman? Okay I know he's in the game so yes there's xmen here.

How do you know Quicksilver is in the game?

I know lots of things!

[keyholder21]

I don't even know what Tommy's trying to do, unless he's the dreaded J-word.

 

I'm putting my money where my mouth is right now though.

 

[v]Nolder[/v]

I just don’t see the point of nolder’s argument from the point of scum. From town or 3rd party either. I think it’s null and he’s just stubborn about his opinion.

 

[v]Tommy[/v]

 

His "I am Galactus" just looks like he's trying to make himself seem incredibly obvious. I bet his strategy here is to make people think "it would be too obvious if he's scum" and ignore him – which was his plan from the beginning, if he really is scum. I'm not sure if he is Galactus or not though. If scum told each other roles on their QT, then he'd know Galactus was in the game, even if it wasn't him. But I'm pretty certain he's scum.

First bold - is giving me trouble. How would you know that it was his plan from the beginning?

Second bold – if he knew Galactus was in the game and it wasn’t his role what would be the point in him claiming it?

 

Recall that I fake claimed when Wombat pushed on me and Mynd wrote my claim into one of his scenes before confirming I was Loki.

Mynd tries to follow the narrative in the thread and you shouldn't necessarily trust that he'd confirm someone in a scene like that.

I don’t know why I find this so funny, but I am laughing here at my desk. Troll mod is troll.

 

 

Didn't Tommy hint at being "unkillable" or some like that? I'll try to dig it up later, but might be scum trying to get people to vote him because he knows he is lynchproof, thus deflecting attention on team-mates?

I really like this post. First one to bring it up and it’s a possible reason for his claim.

 

 

 

Ok, my bad. Was under the impression game ended when someone won, and mafiascum listed is as "mostly a bastard role". But that changes things.

 

Still don't see any pro-town motives behind fake-claiming a Marvel Villain?

meh, I could vote him again, but I am not really feeling him as a bad guy. He does odd things in-game, from what I've seen. Why not leave him for tomorrow, or later in the day?

 

This could easily be used as an excuse for later “odd” behavior.

 

If it’s going to be something you plan to revisit tomorrow or later in D1 then does it not just serve as a distraction? What would be the point of putting it off if you plan to go back?

 

 

[v]Red[/v]

For her reaction. Not the case but what came after. After conclusive evidence was shown but her insistence for pushing later with nonsensical reasoning.

 

But mainly for her comments. A partial attempt to reinforce her bulldog meta. Itseemed as partly trying to seem understanding but also trying to fake her meta so that no one tries to call that out

not a fan of this vote. why would she push such a silly thing which really shouldn't get you lynched anyway? no reason for mafia to do it. Sure she still might be mafia, but the kerfuffle with you about the PR just seemed like a nonsense townie move based on a few mistakes. Maybe not, but I'm not feeling it.

 

Another time I would agree with you here, Hoof, but after Des’s game, I am not putting anything past Red.

 

The third option could be that he was simply trolling.

I suspect this is the case.

[keyholder21]

Ok, wow a ton of posts since I was writing that. I have to take the baby to the dr, but I'll be back later.

[Tommyrod]

Key, there's no reason to like Vos's point. Lynchproof is not a scum role. That's a game breaker.

[Tommyrod]

Second of all if I'm scum I don't "deflect attention from teammates" on day friggin ONE. I push townies. BS reasoning is BS.

 

[v]Vos[/v]

[Xthrax]

Ok, looking at your train

 

Rand and Dawn seem to have put some thought into this and don't atleast seem to be bandwagoning by quoting some obvious reason. 

 

Both of Tina and Dice have done the above-both just said that he's an evil character so he must be killed. I don't like that.

 

I like Hoof so far. He seemed to be willing to consider other trains of thought.

 

I don't know what Vos is doing there. He's voting you for popcorn?

 

Darthe seemes to be doing the same as Tina or Dice, so I'll put him in the same pile.

 

But Tina and Dice-don't like it at all. Tina had points against other people which made sense but instead of voting them she just went with claimed a bad guy.

 

Dice partially berates Hoof for his unvote and then goes with biggest villain in Marvel reason.

[Tommyrod]

And dawns post is just full of fail. 60% chance she's scum, minimum. It would be higher if she didn't have a history of dubious logic as is.

[Tommyrod]

Ok, looking at your train

 

Rand and Dawn seem to have put some thought into this and don't atleast seem to be bandwagoning by quoting some obvious reason.

 

Both of Tina and Dice have done the above-both just said that he's an evil character so he must be killed. I don't like that.

 

I like Hoof so far. He seemed to be willing to consider other trains of thought.

 

I don't know what Vos is doing there. He's voting you for popcorn?

 

Darthe seemes to be doing the same as Tina or Dice, so I'll put him in the same pile.

 

But Tina and Dice-don't like it at all. Tina had points against other people which made sense but instead of voting them she just went with claimed a bad guy.

 

Dice partially berates Hoof for his unvote and then goes with biggest villain in Marvel reason.

Agree on Tina. Noted something's off with her so far. As for dice, idk, he might believe what he's saying. He tends to be mechanical and useless in early game.

[Xthrax]

And one thing which I forgot, 

 

Dawn, you seemed to be doing a lot of wondering in your post. But you end with I'm pretty certain he's scum. How are you pretty certain of that? 

[Darthe]

Second of all if I'm scum I don't "deflect attention from teammates" on day friggin ONE. I push townies. BS reasoning is BS.

 

[v]Vos[/v]

Logical fallacy. What you would or wouldnt do as sxum is WIFOM since you could do anything.

[Xthrax]

 

 

 

Technically, they could (Quicksilver (one of the Twins) was supposed to be Magneto's kid) - But not in the films, because Fox owns the rights to X-Men

Oh quicksilver is an xman? Okay I know he's in the game so yes there's xmen here.

How do you know Quicksilver is in the game?

I know lots of things!

 

Do explain

[Tsukibana]

So, which Twin are you, Tommy - Scarlet Witch or Quicksilver?

[Xthrax]

Tommy, the reason you're voting Vos is because?? 

[Tommyrod]

 

Second of all if I'm scum I don't "deflect attention from teammates" on day friggin ONE. I push townies. BS reasoning is BS.

 

[v]Vos[/v]

Logical fallacy. What you would or wouldnt do as sxum is WIFOM since you could do anything.

Who cares? It's still a bad reason on his part. Then he throws it all out the window and votes me for "popcorn." Even if that's a gag it looks conspicuous.

[Xthrax]

So, which Twin are you, Tommy - Scarlet Witch or Quicksilver?

Why do you consider him to be one of the twins?