[Advanced] Red Wedding Mafia - Post Game, MakersMark

[dicetosser1]

But if you are scum you'd obviously know he was the cop. Makes no sense.

 

Head asplode

unless mafia had a rolecop they found out about Corey being the cop same time we all did. When he claimed. Daawn has been calling him scum all game and even voted him after the claim. I cant see a mafia team, esp one with Verbal on it, letting her do that. they would have explained to her why you dont do that as mafia

 

I'm caetlyn stark and I'm the town doc. That's why I've been pushing at red last night.

 

I protected myself all three nights thinking if verb was lying about his alignment but not role it wouldn't be the smartest thing to protect cory.

 

let me get this straight. You didn't believe Red. You did believe Yates. yet you DIDNT protect yates????  Seriously????

 

 

 

Okay, Jack IS the guy I thought was soft claiming doc. And if I noticed, scum noticed. But I don't get your justification for only self protecting. Why not protect Yates N2? Regardless you should have protected Cory last night 100% of the time.

 

No matter what there shouldn't be a seraph knight doc and bodyguard in the same game. Period. So one of Jack and Red is lying.

I didn't protect Yates because I wanted to see if red would vet herself.

 

Agreed I dropped the ball on Corey. But figured verb was telling the truth about the bus driver and not about his alignment

 

 

Ok never done this myself but as Doc if you are thinking there is a bus driver dont you protect HIM so that if he switches with corey corey ends up with the protection?

 

 

 

And why did you decide to role reveal now?

 

 

 

Nyn

Cause our cops dead and I had a strong opinion of who another scum was based on my role. Also no mafia role stopper so I can Wifom who to protect tonight

 

 

You could have stated a strong opinion on someone you think is mafia WITHOUT CLAIMING!!!!!! then you wouldnt NEED bloody WIFOM!!!!!!!!

[dicetosser1]

Im not going to vote Jack. he may indeed be the doc but also thats just too stupid to be a mafia play.

[Xthrax]

 

 

 

Well Dawn, if you have a claim to make, now is the time.

So people have finally decided to vote me. You're making a big mistake. I'm not scum. I'm VT, and my character is Arya Stark.

Arya Stark? Just no.

Arya was very far away, she had no clue even about the Red Wedding

 

I for one don't believe that claim

 

Not true. Arya arrived at the Twins just as the Red Wedding happened. She definitely knew about it.

 

She did? I don't remember the series happening that way in book or tv. I will go back read and come. Was it an Arya themed chapter? Maybe thats why-I only remember the killing chapter 

[dicetosser1]

im voting

 

##megaloud.

 

 

I think they are mafia and i am going on the advice our flipped cop gave. Will quite happily lynch tommy (actually he is my preference) or X

[Lenlo]

 

 

 

 

Well Dawn, if you have a claim to make, now is the time.

So people have finally decided to vote me. You're making a big mistake. I'm not scum. I'm VT, and my character is Arya Stark.

Arya Stark? Just no.

Arya was very far away, she had no clue even about the Red Wedding

 

I for one don't believe that claim

 

Not true. Arya arrived at the Twins just as the Red Wedding happened. She definitely knew about it.

 

She did? I don't remember the series happening that way in book or tv. I will go back read and come. Was it an Arya themed chapter? Maybe thats why-I only remember the killing chapter 

 

Yes, she was. The Hound knocks her out and takes her away from the wedding.

 

Tommyrod 517     Nynaeve 197     Lenlo 144         _CLOUD 110     Xthrax 89 Jack_D 85     dawnflower8 80     Krakalakachkn 59 amegakure 43     dicetosser1 32     Kathleen 10    

 

 

Total game posts: 2970

 

Tommy: 17.4%

NyanCat: 06.9%

MegaLoud: 05.1%

Len: 04.9%

X: 02.9%

Jack: 02.7%

Dawn: 02.6%

Krak: 01.9%

Dice: 01.1%

 

 

If you have less than 5% rounded you aren't posting enough.  If you have less than 100 posts in a game of 3000 posts you aren't posting enough.  Please be more active.  

 

I find it funny that only one person who isnt a hydra has more than 5% of the posts in the game. Tommy, single person, hydra, hydra, then singles all the way down. :P

[dicetosser1]

Darthe take a look at your numbers and realise they are a bit skewed. Half the players are under 5% and one person is way above even the next person. number of posts doesnt neccesarily equal activity.

 

if i had broken my responses to X up into an individual post per point id have an extra 20+ posts but would nopt have been any more active.

[Xthrax]

 

This is assuming you are a doc. On a scale of 1 to 10. 3 points gor you being doc.

 

I believe that Red has the other protective role. I think Red may not have protected since she wasn't here.

For scum , it was a pretty poor fake claim.

 

But on the really small chance you are doc , I don't what you were thinking when you protected yourself

I admit I played poorly. But I did think verb was a bus driver. And it doesn't matter. Scum had an unblock able kill on cory last night with verbs role. So he'd of died anyway. Or did you miss his role in the coroner report? If I'm lynched. Cloud needs to be the lynch. It's apparent the vig is still alive so let him shoot me.

 

And red was supposed to be on Yates. And what happened to if Yates turns up dead we lynch red? That was one of my major points against her.

 

In my knowledge a NK can be blocked by a doc or any protective role for that matter. I think there is even a role which takes down a mafia with the NK. If you were the Doc, you could have blocked it.

 

As with Red same as you. Your role can be vetted by protecting a PR. The important PR died. Your role is not vetted. Ergo, I think you should be lynched

[dicetosser1]

@len  and if averaged the hydras they would all be less then 5% too

[Xthrax]

Jeez. I'll stop posting so other people can look better.

Tom quit posting. Everyone is looking lame.

[Xthrax]

 

 

 

 

 

Well Dawn, if you have a claim to make, now is the time.

So people have finally decided to vote me. You're making a big mistake. I'm not scum. I'm VT, and my character is Arya Stark.

Arya Stark? Just no.

Arya was very far away, she had no clue even about the Red Wedding

 

I for one don't believe that claim

 

Not true. Arya arrived at the Twins just as the Red Wedding happened. She definitely knew about it.

 

She did? I don't remember the series happening that way in book or tv. I will go back read and come. Was it an Arya themed chapter? Maybe thats why-I only remember the killing chapter 

 

Yes, she was. The Hound knocks her out and takes her away from the wedding.

 

Tommyrod 517     Nynaeve 197     Lenlo 144         _CLOUD 110     Xthrax 89 Jack_D 85     dawnflower8 80     Krakalakachkn 59 amegakure 43     dicetosser1 32     Kathleen 10    

 

 

Total game posts: 2970

 

Tommy: 17.4%

NyanCat: 06.9%

MegaLoud: 05.1%

Len: 04.9%

X: 02.9%

Jack: 02.7%

Dawn: 02.6%

Krak: 01.9%

Dice: 01.1%

 

 

If you have less than 5% rounded you aren't posting enough.  If you have less than 100 posts in a game of 3000 posts you aren't posting enough.  Please be more active.  

 

I find it funny that only one person who isnt a hydra has more than 5% of the posts in the game. Tommy, single person, hydra, hydra, then singles all the way down. :P

 

Ok my bad. About that. I thought Arya was still fleeing from Harrenhal & joined up with that people who call themselves king's men and execute the wrong-dooers

[Tommyrod]

Im not going to vote Jack. he may indeed be the doc but also thats just too stupid to be a mafia play.

 

???

[Xthrax]

 

 

 

 

 

Well Dawn, if you have a claim to make, now is the time.

So people have finally decided to vote me. You're making a big mistake. I'm not scum. I'm VT, and my character is Arya Stark.

Arya Stark? Just no.

Arya was very far away, she had no clue even about the Red Wedding

 

I for one don't believe that claim

 

Not true. Arya arrived at the Twins just as the Red Wedding happened. She definitely knew about it.

 

She did? I don't remember the series happening that way in book or tv. I will go back read and come. Was it an Arya themed chapter? Maybe thats why-I only remember the killing chapter 

 

Yes, she was. The Hound knocks her out and takes her away from the wedding.

 

Tommyrod 517     Nynaeve 197     Lenlo 144         _CLOUD 110     Xthrax 89 Jack_D 85     dawnflower8 80     Krakalakachkn 59 amegakure 43     dicetosser1 32     Kathleen 10    

 

 

Total game posts: 2970

 

Tommy: 17.4%

NyanCat: 06.9%

MegaLoud: 05.1%

Len: 04.9%

X: 02.9%

Jack: 02.7%

Dawn: 02.6%

Krak: 01.9%

Dice: 01.1%

 

 

If you have less than 5% rounded you aren't posting enough.  If you have less than 100 posts in a game of 3000 posts you aren't posting enough.  Please be more active.  

 

I find it funny that only one person who isnt a hydra has more than 5% of the posts in the game. Tommy, single person, hydra, hydra, then singles all the way down. :P

 

Len, do advice me, how do you get so close to 5%?

[Darthe]

Darthe take a look at your numbers and realise they are a bit skewed. Half the players are under 5% and one person is way above even the next person. number of posts doesnt neccesarily equal activity.

 

if i had broken my responses to X up into an individual post per point id have an extra 20+ posts but would nopt have been any more active.

 

I accept that this isn't true.  We can still acknowledge that you've never been in the top 25% of posters in a game.  Also, I don't have time to qualify all of the posts in a 150 page game.  Quantification is the best I can do and I generally only kill one or two really weak links in the game.  No worries Dice, it is just a prod.

[dicetosser1]

ok @ darthe

 

Tommy what dont you get?

[Xthrax]

Darthe take a look at your numbers and realise they are a bit skewed. Half the players are under 5% and one person is way above even the next person. number of posts doesnt neccesarily equal activity.

 

if i had broken my responses to X up into an individual post per point id have an extra 20+ posts but would nopt have been any more active.

True

[Xthrax]

ok @ darthe

 

Tommy what dont you get?

IMO, mafia was going for that angle. But then what they intended got messed up. 

[Tommyrod]

ok @ darthe

 

Tommy what dont you get?

You're saying you think he's the doc because his claim is too stupid to be coming from scum? Did you see the way he reacted to being questioned today? He used a false talking about about the rolestopper and mumbled. Someone who is making a real claim would have far more conviction and energy; he basically gave up against Xthrax. His responses were borderline illegible. His response as to why he didn't continue casing Hallia doesn't make any sense given her posting actually got worse after his infamous catchup post. None of it adds up. So what exactly are you buying from him?

[Lenlo]

 

 

Len, do advice me, how do you get so close to 5%?

 

Screw around. Alot. 

 

Disclaimer: Some peoples versions of alot are different.

[Lenlo]

 

 

 

Len, do advice me, how do you get so close to 5%?

 

Screw around. Alot. 

 

Disclaimer: Some peoples versions of alot are different.

 

Also know that games like this only happen for Darthe.

[Tommyrod]

Len, what's your take on all this?

[Darthe]

 

 

 

 

Len, do advice me, how do you get so close to 5%?

 

Screw around. Alot. 

 

Disclaimer: Some peoples versions of alot are different.

 

Also know that games like this only happen for Darthe.

 

QFT

[Lenlo]

Len, what's your take on all this?

On Jack and the Doc claim? I think either him or Red is lying and im leaning towards Red being the one. Jacks been a crappy doc and I generally dont listen to character claims but his coincides/works with mine which makes me want to believe it more. I still say Dawn is the best bet today and we can see what happens tonight with Jack, Red and the NK. This time Red best be around to submit if she has a role at all.

 

If you want I can also reveal to help shed light on Jacks claim, but im not sure thated be a good idea.

[dicetosser1]

that whole explanation is not something i would expect from a mafia BECAUSE it was disjointed and showed absolutely disgusting Doc play.

 

and if he IS the doc and we lynch him? We lose a town PR . Yes we lose a doc who has been useless but more importantly we lose a townie. We are getting to the point where every townie counts

[Tommyrod]

I'm not sure what you mean by works with yours. Mechanically or in terms of theme, like the characters?

 

We know for a fact there was a seraph knight, which is a perma-doc basically. I find it hard to believe that in a game this size we would have a seraph knight AND a doctor. A seraph knight and a bodyguard actually makes more sense because a bodyguard is less powerful (by quite a lot). I also can't get over the self protects every night. I'm not even sure Darthe would allow that, but that's a hunch.

 

So if you have some way to back him up, go for it. I'm having a really hard time buying any of it.

[Tommyrod]

that whole explanation is not something i would expect from a mafia BECAUSE it was disjointed and showed absolutely disgusting Doc play.

 

and if he IS the doc and we lynch him? We lose a town PR . Yes we lose a doc who has been useless but more importantly we lose a townie. We are getting to the point where every townie counts

You could say that about any player.