[Advanced] Twilight Mafia Game over - Mafia win

[Tommyrod]

 

I'm here. Cory, Des, who we lynchin'?

Cory's dead :(

Basically everyone make your respective cases and I'll be the judge and jury 

Tina is scum cause I say so. ^.^

 

Gimme the CLIFFS

[Tommyrod]

GG Cory (I assume)

[Lenlo]

She voted a random person ((Jack)) to get the game started, Des and someone else picked up the baton and started pushing that persons lynch because they didnt like his responses, Tina disappeared. Then she reappered and voted someone else, giving null reads to everyone involved in the Jack train, didnt take a stand on anyone, and once again left to let Des push the lynch and defend her cause he thought her initial vote to get the game going was town.

 

Basically she has let everyone else do the legwork while she profits from the pro town points Des is throwing at her without doing much herself. Every scum list she has given has been safe bets that Des and others share without actually giving her own reasoning for it. She never stands out with an opinion that goes against the grain.

 

Ill need to look back to make sure there wasnt more but thats the gist of it I think.

[Tommyrod]

She voted a random person ((Jack)) to get the game started, Des and someone else picked up the baton and started pushing that persons lynch because they didnt like his responses, Tina disappeared. Then she reappered and voted someone else, giving null reads to everyone involved in the Jack train, didnt take a stand on anyone, and once again left to let Des push the lynch and defend her cause he thought her initial vote to get the game going was town.

 

Basically she has let everyone else do the legwork while she profits from the pro town points Des is throwing at her without doing much herself. Every scum list she has given has been safe bets that Des and others share without actually giving her own reasoning for it. She never stands out with an opinion that goes against the grain.

 

Ill need to look back to make sure there wasnt more but thats the gist of it I think.

 

Okay. Why is Des giving her town points?

 

Tina, your response?

[Lenlo]

Des believes that her vote put her into the limelight, something scum tina wouldnt do, and that her initial vote on a random person to get the game going was also town because scum wouldnt want the attention. He ignores the fact that shes left her def to him though.

[Tommyrod]

Des believes that her vote put her into the limelight, something scum tina wouldnt do, and that her initial vote on a random person to get the game going was also town because scum wouldnt want the attention. He ignores the fact that shes left her def to him though.

Well without having read literally anything, that sounds like a thing / foolish reason to clear someone. Des should know better, but I know he doesn't.

[Tommyrod]

*thin / foolish

[Lenlo]

Wait till Des gets here and he can give a clearer answer im sure, but thats the general feel ive gotten from his def of her.

[Tommyrod]

Des I'll need the midnight report whenever you are around for that 

[Darthe]

I'm here. Cory, Des, who we lynchin'?

 

You would be an idiot to trust Des/Tina this game.  One of the two is almost certainly scum.  Just skip to page 9, not much happened to that point worth note and it will provide enough info for you to get good reads on the early game.  I've already fought my battles here Tommy.

[Darthe]

 

Des believes that her vote put her into the limelight, something scum tina wouldnt do, and that her initial vote on a random person to get the game going was also town because scum wouldnt want the attention. He ignores the fact that shes left her def to him though.

Well without having read literally anything, that sounds like a thing / foolish reason to clear someone. Des should know better, but I know he doesn't.

 

 

Actually she disappeared as soon as I brought it up during the day.  Des/Cory/Tina voted THREE trains together yesterday with one liners for reasoning and they each moved to the trains within an hour of one another.  Now that Cory has flipped town (I pushed him hard last night for info) Des is trying to say that I am scum and that we shouldn't check the other two.  He uses selective quotes from cory and myself to back this up  and he is trying to use that he has had his vote stolen today to clear himself as town.

[Tommyrod]

Sounds like there's a chance Des is scummin' then? A little dash of TMI wrt Tina's role, perhaps?

[Lenlo]

Entirely possible. Either Des or Tina is scum def, though im leaning towards it being Tina. 

[Darthe]

And I am leaning towards it being Des.

 

 

And neither of them likes either of us =p shocker.

 

 

Also, it would be nice if Clov spoke more.

[Tommyrod]

I'm learning a lot already. Is there a consensus scummy player yet or is it mostly small personal battles?

[Lenlo]

Yeah surprise surprise, the two of them are pushing lynches on their two biggest detractors.

[Lenlo]

I'm learning a lot already. Is there a consensus scummy player yet or is it mostly small personal battles?

Mostly small personal battles. Im thinking its going to come down to a thunderdome between me/Tina or Darthe/Des soon. 

[Tommyrod]

Yeah surprise surprise, the two of them are pushing lynches on their two biggest detractors.

Well that doesn't really mean anything... but your possibly townlike frustration has been noted.

[dawnflower8]

Im votong you because you are mafia.

I honestly don't know why, but this post made me laugh. It is a bit suspicious though, to just say it in that way. It sounds like something Ice would say, not something that a more experienced player such as yourself would.

 

Vote Darthe. There's something really strange going on with this.

[Darthe]

I'm learning a lot already. Is there a consensus scummy player yet or is it mostly small personal battles?

 

Well, us four-six are speaking and nobody else is around.  

[Leelou]

Vote Count

 

Des (1) - Darthe

Darthe (1) - Dawn

 

not voting - everyone else

 

With 11 alive, it takes 6 to lynch

 

Deadline Saturday Noon EST (willing to move to Friday or Monday due to the holiday) 

[dicetosser1]

Jack - Emmett Cullen - Town BPV - lynched D1

BFG - Edward Cullen - Town Lover - NK N1

Cory - Bella Swan - Town Lover - Committed suicide D2

 

 

Des

Tina

Verbal

Tommy

Dice

Pral

Hallia

Lenlo

Dawn

Clovdyx

Darthe

 

Thinking Tommy is LOCK CLEAR because of Darthe townspewing him (acted like he was confirmed about Salami being town). Verb looks good to me so far. Think I remember seeing Dice as town from some of his post a while ago. Think it was a tone read. Kinda sad that a couple of my LOCK CLEARS are gone

 

Thinking Tina could have been right about Lenlo. His last post after the lynch was awful, and then he disappeared.

 

86% confident of finding teh scum in my reds, with only a couple of other tinfoiling candidates. Game is close to #solved.

 

Blue   You think darthe is scum. Yet you think tommy is town because Darthe said so? That does not make sense to me. If Darthe is mafia he could be trying to clear a teammate. Csarmi barely posted so there is no way to really get a read on him one way or another. Please explain

 

I am concerned this is more of your hero worship/auto buddying of Tommy.

 

Regarding Darthe, if he is scum, I am not able to understand why he would FoS both BFG (in one post) and Cory (in a lot of posts) and then kill one of them? Doesn't seem logical. 

THIS! tho if darthe is mafia he could be counting on this reaction.

[Darthe]

 

Im votong you because you are mafia.

I honestly don't know why, but this post made me laugh. It is a bit suspicious though, to just say it in that way. It sounds like something Ice would say, not something that a more experienced player such as yourself would.

 

Vote Darthe. There's something really strange going on with this.

 

 

I have no polite response to this.  Can someone help me?  I only want to post gifs that aren't allowed on site.

[dicetosser1]

tommy the biggest running battle is between Darthe and Des. Tina hasn't ereally said a lot.

 

I suspected and voted Cory but obviously i was wrong....tho Bella is definetly evil....

[Darthe]

@Dice and Laya for the quote dice just responded to... That reads like "This looks really town but Darthe is good enough at mafia that it may be counterpsych".  If you have to WIFOM my play to make it fit "scummy" what does that say about me?

 

I'm pointing out illogical play left and right and will continue to regardless of how Des attempts to destroy my character (credibility) in the game.