[Advanced] Star Wars Thrawn Mafia, Heir To The Empire, Town and 3rd party win

[Andrej]

AJ you should read the thread yourself but here are my thoughts for the day's lynch:

 

http://www.dragonmount.com/forums/topic/87452-advanced-star-wars-thrawn-mafia-heir-to-the-empire-day-1/page-21?do=findComment&comment=3153348

 

Nolder quit and has been replaced with Xthrax

 

I'll get at the thread eventually sometime this weekend. Quick question: How did Nolder's wagon start? I'm fine with lynching that slot in order to get the game progressing, he had 5 votes for a reason which I'll be able to look at later on my read through. Sort sucks for X though, his mando-OMGUS on Cory as he subbed in was kind of funny lol

 

vote X

 

Just read from the linked spot to here.

 

Liked Cory's post on motive/tone. @GE - What's your beef with CS?

[Tommyrod]

It's not so much that I've given Des a free pass as much as it is that I've played with or watched him play a bunch of times and I don't think I can accurately read him on D1. If you wanna attempt it, have at it. IMO we just have more suspicious people FOR TODAY and he bounced for the weekend apparently.

[Andrej]

I have a scum lean on Des because I have no reason not to

 

lol

 

I can follow this thought

[Tommyrod]

Tina can you tell me again who is on your radar and why

 

And who you would trust and why

[Tommyrod]

You haven't seemed to care that a few people have you as their #2

 

Why is that

[SickPuppets]

 

Note: I will never do that, ever.

Wat

 

 I won't never show a result on someone's death unless it has something to do with their role or outside interference.

 

It's not so much that I've given Des a free pass as much as it is that I've played with or watched him play a bunch of times and I don't think I can accurately read him on D1. If you wanna attempt it, have at it. IMO we just have more suspicious people FOR TODAY and he bounced for the weekend apparently.

 

I'll do it at one point. His posts were basically "Comment, Wow so scum, Scum post, Scum scum, wow so scum, gif, I love that gif, gif that I love, I love you gif, meaningless stuff, and off topic shit. 

 

I have a scum lean on Des because I have no reason not to

 

lol

 

I can follow this thought

 

Of course you can. 

[Niniel]

The only thing I trust right now is Csarmi´s claim. 

 

I had a null read on Nolder until he dropped.

 

You know why I´m suspicisous of Des.

 

TG seems to try to agree with everyone. 

[Tommyrod]

SP you have some familiarity with him from the Simple Round games

 

You do know it's the same Despot right lol

[SickPuppets]

I'm still sad no one's caught my claim.

[SickPuppets]

SP you have some familiarity with him from the Simple Round games

 

You do know it's the same Despot right lol

Of course I know it is.

[Niniel]

You haven't seemed to care that a few people have you as their #2

 

Why is that

 

People seem to be suspicous of me because I skipped over Nolder and later said I had a null read on him. I stand for what I said. If others disagree with me and choose to see that as scummy then it´s up to them. 

[Tommyrod]

The only thing I trust right now is Csarmi´s claim. 

 

I had a null read on Nolder until he dropped.

 

You know why I´m suspicisous of Des.

 

TG seems to try to agree with everyone.

 

Him quitting is what pushed him from null into scum for you?

[Niniel]

 

The only thing I trust right now is Csarmi´s claim. 

 

I had a null read on Nolder until he dropped.

 

You know why I´m suspicisous of Des.

 

TG seems to try to agree with everyone.

Him quitting is what pushed him from null into scum for you?

 

 

Yes. As I said in the post where I voted him, I have seen him disappear in situations like this before as scum. 

[Mrs. Cindy Gill]

Vote count:

 

 

TG (1) csarmi

Tina (2) Kronos, TG

Kronos (1) darthe

Xthrax (7) Cory, Tommy, Peace, des, GE, Tina, AJ

Cory (1) Xthrax

 

Not voting (4) Monk, Pral, Puppet, Turin

 

With 16 alive it takes 9 to lynch.

 

DL is set for Monday, Feb. 10th at 9 PM EST.

[Niniel]

Tom, what are your reads so far? 

[Tommyrod]

Tom, what are your reads so far?

 

http://www.dragonmount.com/forums/topic/87452-advanced-star-wars-thrawn-mafia-heir-to-the-empire-day-1/page-21?do=findComment&comment=3153348

 

Here's a summary.

 

I'm confused by you; your current responses to make seem more townish than not. The way you said "those are my reads and you'll have to deal with it."

 

Who would you lynch today apart from X? Des?

[Niniel]

Yep. 

 

I feel that I need to clarify my earlier statement. Nolder hasn´t a habit of quitting when it gets tough. He is a fighter. But... I have seen him loose interest/disappear when scum in situations before. I think it depends on how he is feeling at the moment. 

[Tommyrod]

Okay, I can follow that thought process.

 

I'll elevate you from suspect to person of interest. Lol

 

Can you give me some deeper insight into how you approach reaching Des?

[Niniel]

I can be a person of interest. :D

 

No deeper insights on anything as I´m about to go to bed. Will be back tomorrow. Olympics has started but I will probably get time in between cross-country skiing and biathlon. :)

[monk2310]

I don't like Tina right now. Her posts haven't stuck out to me, which I take as a town tell.

Hello everyone!! Just checking in now, doing a read of all that happened. Oh, a vote for me. And there's only one of me.

 

Vote Cory

 

Ah, I hope its not too big a hole-will give it my best shot then.

Why are you voting Cory?

 

Usually I would not vote people that has just entered the game but unfortunately I have seen Nolder disappear (quit or just become inactive) in situations like this. (Happened in Darthe/Wombat´s 3 in 1 game for example.)

 

Unvote. Vote X

 

I´ll keep my eyes on Des. I don´t understand the defense of him. I do agree with him about TG though. TG seems to just echo others. 

 

Des - before you say anything about it - yes, it´s okay to have conflicted reads on day 1! 

Vote Tina

[Mrs. Cindy Gill]

Vote count:

 

 

TG (1) csarmi

Tina (3) Kronos, TG, Monk

Kronos (1) darthe

Xthrax (7) Cory, Tommy, Peace, des, GE, Tina, AJ

Cory (1) Xthrax

 

Not voting (3) Pral, Puppet, Turin

 

With 16 alive it takes 9 to lynch.

 

DL is set for Monday, Feb. 10th at 9 PM EST.

[monk2310]

Oh, and I forgot to say thanks for making me catch up on 500 posts. Nice.

 

I really having trouble understanding these arguments being made on people, but I guess its the new players aspect.

[Tommyrod]

 

 

AJ you should read the thread yourself but here are my thoughts for the day's lynch:http://www.dragonmount.com/forums/topic/87452-advanced-star-wars-thrawn-mafia-heir-to-the-empire-day-1/page-21?do=findComment&comment=3153348

Nolder quit and has been replaced with Xthrax

 

 

I'll get at the thread eventually sometime this weekend. Quick question: How did Nolder's wagon start? I'm fine with lynching that slot in order to get the game progressing, he had 5 votes for a reason which I'll be able to look at later on my read through. Sort sucks for X though, his mando-OMGUS on Cory as he subbed in was kind of funny lol

 

vote X

 

Just read from the linked spot to here.

 

Liked Cory's post on motive/tone. @GE - What's your beef with CS?

Why are you voting X if you don't know why he's scummy -____-

 

Yes, he is scum, but seriously, read the thread.

 

The basic case was that he was fabricating reasons for lynching people, both now and later, that are not based on threadplay or argument. He voted both me and Salami for "spam" and then said "let's lynch the inactive people" like ten hours into the game. When questioned, he got really defensive and then quit the game. He also pretended he didn't understand that some statements were obviously humorous and tried to use them as evidence of scummy behavior; then he tried to convince me my scum tells were out of date or some other non-argument nonsense.

 

 

Nolder, my point was this: you're not attacking people for what they've actually SAID. You've set yourself up to vote people for things that are wholly removed from in-thread logic and arguments.

"Vote people who have the highest or lowest post counts." That is not "vote the scummiest people" or "vote out people whose logic is suspicious or flimsy."

You said "I am not those other scum" earlier when I said scum love to do that stuff. Right back atcha: why would you vote someone for having either a high or low post count when they aren't those other scum?

So here's your argument and defense so far:

-Let's lynch people for out of thread logic reasons.

-Your arguments against me are invalid because your scum tells are outdated or they don't apply to me since I'm not those scummers you're comparing me to

Flimsy reasoning that avoids getting your hands dirty with logic? Hypocritical defenses?

Come on bro.

 

 

One snippet of our argument

[Tommyrod]

Monk...

[SickPuppets]

Monk....Monk....Monk