[Advanced] The Dresden Files Mafia - Game Over - Ed loses, Verbal wins

[John McClane]

Well, it´s clear that Ape didn´t view me. So who did he caught in his "trap"? I need to re-read some before adding more but Leelou still looks scummy.

That rules out leelou. I think if you were town you'd be curious why Lenlo and others knew NOT to follow me. Townies would just believe me. I'm an uncountered cop. Scum knows.

 

But you aren't town are you? So that explains the faulted logic

[Niniel]

I´m town. 

[John McClane]

D1 vote trains. Ishy, darthe, lenlo and tglems are the only 4votes not on csarmi. 1/4 are scum. Ishy, darthe are dead amd town. I feel like 50/50 shot that lenlo or tglems is scum.

 

Inform odds with logic, and my conclusion is Lenlo is scum.

[BooBoo]

Who said Vambaram was scum????

 

////This guy!!!

 

Boom!

[BooBoo]

Vote Tina

[BooBoo]

Also, why does Ed keeping pushing this agenda that I'm scum?  If I were scum, why wouldnt the town reporter counter?  Ed next IMO.

 

I picked Verbal last night, btw.

[BooBoo]

Town RB?  Thats new for me and seems like a strange day 1 reveal.  I believe him but I dont like him and want him dead.  Mostly because he chased off the greatest internet persona of all time but also because his Avatar scares me.  That stank eye has been giving me nightmares. 

 

I believe him and raise an eye brow of doubt in everyone's direction who's piling on.  Its day 1, I aint scared of no 3rd party.  I want to skull bash scum.  Not some pansy who has a solo win condition that the town will never allow to win.  Nope.  Not at all.  Not me.

 

Very torn right now.  My heart say kill the bastard in the name of muffin top.  My superior skills tells me he's telling the truth.

 

Going to drink some more coffee, take a nice poop and think about this.

 

 

Feel soooo much better.  Cant think clearly when I'm a little backed up.  Coffee is good.

 

I think we should proceed with killing the angry Euro dude.  A). He chased off the greatest interwebz persona of all time.  B). His Avatar is creeping me the F out.  C).

No sense in having someone around with the ability RB town powers.  I can tell he's not a very talented player so expecting him to find and block scum is unrealistic.  

 

Vote away! 

 

Ape - show me where I suggested keeping him alive.  

 

Pretty clear that I was thinking it out and I was right about him not lying, I just was going through the motions of this role and the reactions to his claim.  I'm sure you'll spin some meta lie about me that nobody but a couple of people can verify (even though they didnt last time you lied about my meta, hence why I viewed Verb and AVM) but I'm typically in favor of keeping claimed players alive on D1 because it reduces the field.  However, RB'ing town power roles is bad so after my poop I suggested proceeding with the lynch.

 

You're the cop but your playing like a boob.  

[Verbal32]

Whoever outed me, if you are town, you are stupid. Wasn't it obvious when Ishy implied Tina was the cop WHY I went at him so aggressively about it?

 

 

 

 

So, we are lynching AVM tomorrow right?

 

No, you.  I re-read every post of yours this game.  Yes, it was painful.  You're totally scum.  You're latching onto anything "scummy" said by players (town say scummy stuff all the time - you've even pointed this out many times), but you aren't giving them that benefit of the doubt.  Scum play the clean games, remember?  You are hunting the people not playing clean.

 

I'm sold on you as scum - you should be run up first thing tomorrow.

 

 

What's up Sally, you want to revisit this?

 

I've got a bone to pick with you, Rand and Ed for all that jibba jabba during night phase.

 

No need to revisit.  See your above quote.  You acted like the real Cop by doing that, and I did notice it.  So I decided to argue with you during the night and "case" you.

 

You really think I read all your posts?  Are you insane?  Hell no, I lied.  I just wanted to argue with you and keep you as a primary lynch contender.  If I recall, you've commented on the merits of night-arguing to stay alive many times.  :-)

[Niniel]

I´m the vig (50% chance to succeed). I shot Vambram last night. I shot Darthe N1. (Sorry, Darthe.)

[John McClane]

 

Town RB?  Thats new for me and seems like a strange day 1 reveal.  I believe him but I dont like him and want him dead.  Mostly because he chased off the greatest internet persona of all time but also because his Avatar scares me.  That stank eye has been giving me nightmares. 

 

I believe him and raise an eye brow of doubt in everyone's direction who's piling on.  Its day 1, I aint scared of no 3rd party.  I want to skull bash scum.  Not some pansy who has a solo win condition that the town will never allow to win.  Nope.  Not at all.  Not me.

 

Very torn right now.  My heart say kill the bastard in the name of muffin top.  My superior skills tells me he's telling the truth.

 

Going to drink some more coffee, take a nice poop and think about this.

 

 

>>>Feel soooo much better.  Cant think clearly when I'm a little backed up.  Coffee is good.

 

I think we should proceed with killing the angry Euro dude.  A). He chased off the greatest interwebz persona of all time.  B). His Avatar is creeping me the F out.  C).

No sense in having someone around with the ability RB town powers.  I can tell he's not a very talented player so expecting him to find and block scum is unrealistic.  

 

Vote away! 

 

Ape - show me where I suggested keeping him alive.  

 

Pretty clear that I was thinking it out and I was right about him not lying, I just was going through the motions of this role and the reactions to his claim.  I'm sure you'll spin some meta lie about me that nobody but a couple of people can verify (even though they didnt last time you lied about my meta, hence why I viewed Verb and AVM) but I'm typically in favor of keeping claimed players alive on D1 because it reduces the field.  However, RB'ing town power roles is bad so after my poop I suggested proceeding with the lynch.

 

You're the cop but your playing like a boob.  

 

 

Suggesting and thinking about it are the same thing.

 

You should have let that fester a while. 

 

Edited: to remove profane insult

[John McClane]

 

Whoever outed me, if you are town, you are stupid. Wasn't it obvious when Ishy implied Tina was the cop WHY I went at him so aggressively about it?

 

 

> 

 

So, we are lynching AVM tomorrow right?

 

No, you.  I re-read every post of yours this game.  Yes, it was painful.  You're totally scum.  You're latching onto anything "scummy" said by players (town say scummy stuff all the time - you've even pointed this out many times), but you aren't giving them that benefit of the doubt.  Scum play the clean games, remember?  You are hunting the people not playing clean.

 

I'm sold on you as scum - you should be run up first thing tomorrow.

 

 

What's up Sally, you want to revisit this?

 

I've got a bone to pick with you, Rand and Ed for all that jibba jabba during night phase.

 

No need to revisit.  See your above quote.  You acted like the real Cop by doing that, and I did notice it.  So I decided to argue with you during the night and "case" you.

 

You really think I read all your posts?  Are you insane?  Hell no, I lied.  I just wanted to argue with you and keep you as a primary lynch contender.  If I recall, you've commented on the merits of night-arguing to stay alive many times.  :-)

 

 

I know what you where doing, I wasn't sure if you were doing it to help me or trick me into thinking you were trying to help keep me alive. It was telegraphed though, so I played along.

[John McClane]

I´m the vig (50% chance to succeed). I shot Vambram last night. I shot Darthe N1. (Sorry, Darthe.)

 

What is your character claim?

 

Interesting the scene makes it sound as if Vambram was shot multiple times, it also makes it sound as if Vambram himself had multiple shots.

 

Unvote

 

Can we discuss the logic of if scum knows you aren't one of them, they'd know I was bluffing to start today, therefore they'd know and perhaps push to get me to lie about having viewed you, in order to then have you lynched, prove me a liar and then perhaps counter claim me and get me lynched. Follow what I'm saying?

 

You could quite easily be an SK. Would you be willing to let us vote on who you shoot tonight? Or can you holster? If I can vet you, I can narrow your pool significantly.

 

 

Anyway, pretty obviously Ed or Lenlo has to die now.

 

Vote Lenlo

[BooBoo]

Unvote

Vote Ed

[John McClane]

Vote Lenlo

[John McClane]

to make sure it gets counted, lol, not all red

[Leelou]

 

I´m the vig (50% chance to succeed). I shot Vambram last night. I shot Darthe N1. (Sorry, Darthe.)

 

What is your character claim?

 

Interesting the scene makes it sound as if Vambram was shot multiple times, it also makes it sound as if Vambram himself had multiple shots.

 

Unvote

 

Can we discuss the logic of if scum knows you aren't one of them, they'd know I was bluffing to start today, therefore they'd know and perhaps push to get me to lie about having viewed you, in order to then have you lynched, prove me a liar and then perhaps counter claim me and get me lynched. Follow what I'm saying?

 

You could quite easily be an SK. Would you be willing to let us vote on who you shoot tonight? Or can you holster? If I can vet you, I can narrow your pool significantly.

 

 

Anyway, pretty obviously Ed or Lenlo has to die now.

 

Vote Lenlo

 

I agree with what you are asking Tina. To try to gather some more information out of today, I'm going to vote for Ed since he's who I'm leaning as scum. I can see Lenlo as scummy too with his posts. 

 

Vote Ed

[ed2funy]

Why, you ask, Boo? Because I don't know if you are mafia (but am pretty sure you are), I don't know if you actually flip people's roles or if you can fabricate them for your team. I'm thinking it's the former, but who knows for sure except you, the mod, and your team. 

 

Interestingly enough, I am Susan Rodriguez (I'm pretty sure I didn't get her just because I'm part Mexican ), and a Reporter. I win with the Town.

Why do you think I unvoted you right after your reveal? I don't know the setup and had to consider the fact that you COULD be town. 

 

 

Yes, Ape, I chose you last night, because Ishy's comments were scummy and off about Tina, and you have been going hard at everyone. 

And yes, apparently my reports are accurate, because Ishy flipped correct and Ape is the Cop. 

 

 

 

Now, time to shower and get ready for work. 

I'm good with voting Lenlo or Boo.

 

For now, 

Unvote

Vote Boo

[ed2funy]

Leelou, besides my being unable to make better posts earlier, is there any actual reason you're leaning scum? 

Or are you just following the major trends still? 

[Leelou]

Leelou, besides my being unable to make better posts earlier, is there any actual reason you're leaning scum? 

 

Or are you just following the major trends still? 

 

It had to do with how you were going after BooBoo and his character has still remained uncountered and from the people who know the source material claim Bob to be a town character. 

[John McClane]

Tina, character claim.

[ed2funy]

Meh. Like I said, I don't know how the game is set up, and I know I'm a Town Reporter. 

 

We already have a Watcher dead plus myself. Two investigative/informative roles. Enough to make me suspicious. Now we know there is also a Cop. 

That's pretty powerful as it is. ANOTHER Town Reporter? I don't sit well with that. Whatever character he claimed. 

[John McClane]

Why, you ask, Boo? Because I don't know if you are mafia (but am pretty sure you are), I don't know if you actually flip people's roles or if you can fabricate them for your team. I'm thinking it's the former, but who knows for sure except you, the mod, and your team. 

 

Interestingly enough, I am Susan Rodriguez (I'm pretty sure I didn't get her just because I'm part Mexican ), and a Reporter. I win with the Town.

Why do you think I unvoted you right after your reveal? I don't know the setup and had to consider the fact that you COULD be town. 

 

 

Yes, Ape, I chose you last night, because Ishy's comments were scummy and off about Tina, and you have been going hard at everyone. 

And yes, apparently my reports are accurate, because Ishy flipped correct and Ape is the Cop. 

 

 

 

Now, time to shower and get ready for work. 

I'm good with voting Lenlo or Boo.

 

For now, 

Unvote

Vote Boo

 

 

So, your case on Booboo is that there can't be two town reporters - right? I'm just trying to understand your logic, not tear it down.

[ed2funy]

That is part of it. In general, I have agreed with others that his actions had a scum feel. That may have painted a bad image of him in my mind, but I definitely already saw him as scummy. Having two town Reporters just makes me doubt him more. 

[John McClane]

I'm alarmed that Booboo wasn't killed last night, but then it does present a scenario where Ed can sell a "there can't be 2 town reporters" case, then back track on it after Booboo flips town. If he does.

 

Verbal made it clear that some people caught me tipping my hand about being cop. So, if anyone on scum noticed that, then if there's a scum reporter they'd expose me.

 

Unvote

Vote Ed

[BooBoo]

Hmmmm...so Ed is claiming he's a town reporter too?  And he outed the Cop last night, who was clearing hinting at being cop when pressing Tina?

 

lmfao - ok.

 

My vote stays.