[ADVANCED] KaeKey Game of Thrones Mafia - GAME OVER! NIGHT'S WATCH WINS!

[John E. Kelley]

"That's all you got?"

 

I'm close to making my decision....

[hazelkrs1]

Mynd Jr.?

 

Having one dude that's the best Mafia player I've ever seen is bad enough.

 

Two of them would destroy my ego.

 

And yes, in my limited experience, Mynd is easily the best Mafia player I've ever played with.

 

*deceiving him in Ithi's game is my greatest Mafia moment*

 

Peeps should quit riding Mynd's jock imo. He's a great player, but too many people put his play on a pedestal. I think they are somewhat fooled by his swaggeriffic manner. He's more confident in general while he's playing, so I think people tend to think he IS actually as good as he claims to be lol

 

I'll say this once again: Him getting away so smoothly with that braggadocio, while mine seems to irritate others, tells me I'm not nearly as charming as I would like to believe

 

Argh.

 

This indecisiveness is making me feel like I'm not in control of my actions.

 

Vote BG

 

Wait, what? You post saying how you don't quite like Darthe's case, then vote BG?

 

As I said, I was ninja'd by a couple of posts. I didn't think the case was that strong tho.

 

Lolwut? And is anyone reading the 20 pages of case I posted?

 

Not as convincing as BG's case on you.

 

Hmm. You may be onto something EP. Not in control of his actions.....

 

...

 

So you disagree with what I had to say about BG then?

 

Remind me what you said about BG again?

[hazelkrs1]

"20 pages?"

 

C'mon Broseph, exaggerating isn't helping your case....

 

Literally, that was my casework on BG for his posts between exactly pages 50 and 70. Hmm, if despo can't vote me then that is interesting. I wonder if he could hint to us in any way?

 

@ you people.

 

My voting record for today has been Very Chaotic

[Gabriel Kross]

If it had been investigative roles I would have agreed, Gendry is a blacksmith, enabling blockers kinda makes sense don't you think? Also we can assume the mafia has a roleblocker since John was blocked, why a town blocker would block a claimed Ned is unthinkable. Which also brings Razen back into the spotlight for his saying that your points are still as effective for a blocking enabler. Which isn't the case as we know both sides have a blocker he is more balanced than what he would have been had it been as you posted. Your ability will have been wasted if BG is being truthful. Now I can choose someone other than Darthe now too since we know his ability works as a day action.

 

Also, I'm pretty sure Desp posted it on a billboard big enough for all of us to see.

 

I also agree with BG here, I read the in between parts and I remember BG saying he was going to be gone for awhile on day 1.

[Darthe]

See? You ruin your case by stating that Verb is Town. Tying yourself to Verb is killing you. I would be willing to trust your case, but Verb's? Not so much.

 

Ishy, it is killing me how quickly Verbs train built today. And that you and EP had some interplay that we are all being told to trust but not what happened. If there was concrete evidence then you picked a bad person to roll with for the Verb case but the fact of it is that nobody has presented anything beyond extremely circumstantial claims. I am simply attempting to be logical about this with some unknown. EP almost certainly isn't mafia and I get the feeling you aren't either, but that doesn't mean you two can't be wrong.

[Gabriel Kross]

"20 pages?"

 

C'mon Broseph, exaggerating isn't helping your case....

 

Literally, that was my casework on BG for his posts between exactly pages 50 and 70. Hmm, if despo can't vote me then that is interesting. I wonder if he could hint to us in any way?

 

@ you people.

 

My voting record for today has been Very Chaotic

 

 

I think they missed the billboard Desp.

[Gabriel Kross]

See? You ruin your case by stating that Verb is Town. Tying yourself to Verb is killing you. I would be willing to trust your case, but Verb's? Not so much.

 

Ishy, it is killing me how quickly Verbs train built today. And that you and EP had some interplay that we are all being told to trust but not what happened. If there was concrete evidence then you picked a bad person to roll with for the Verb case but the fact of it is that nobody has presented anything beyond extremely circumstantial claims. I am simply attempting to be logical about this with some unknown. EP almost certainly isn't mafia and I get the feeling you aren't either, but that doesn't mean you two can't be wrong.

 

We already said what the chatter between me and Ishy was about.

[John E. Kelley]

So you disagree with what I had to say about BG then?

 

Remind me what you said about BG again?

 

For f**ks sake lemme find it......

[bgrishinko]

"That's all you got?"

 

I'm close to making my decision....

 

Its 1 am and my wife isn't too happy I'm on my phone and not going to bed, so that's all I got. Anything much more than a short response will need to wait till tomorrow afternoon.

[Darthe]

BG did indeed say that he had a family issue on D1 that would require some of his attention. And if I recall correctly he was gone for about a quarter of the time. That doesn't change his behaviors, posts, or general activity in the game. Weaksauce excuse though. It is 2 AM here, I am heading to bed and will do more casing in la manana. Goodnight.

[John E. Kelley]

I don't know, I'm starting to rethink my position here. Darthe was able to back up his claim, at least as it pertains to his role. Alignment is a different story though.

 

BG, on the other hand, has no way to back up his claim, and when I asked what role he enabled, answered "investigative" roles. Really? He enables each and every investigative role that we may have? Not just Cop, but all of them? That seems a little far-fetched to me. Putting that much importance on one player doesn't seem quite right. If he is taken out, that would cripple Town to such an extent that we may not recover. That may be an exaggeration, but not by much. And by claiming such, he almost assures that Town players wouldn't dare mess with him.

 

So to sum up, BG's claim is a little suspect to me, firstly because I can't see one player that could effectively ruin every investigative role that Town has, and secondly, because it's the perfect claim for him to make when his lynching is in question. I haven't made up my mind, because this is all WIFOM anyway and I'm hesitant to make the move that I just described. But you have to admit, this is easily a claim that savvy player like BG would make as scum. I'll consider and return.

 

Finally, it looks like Basel didn't agree with the idea that we wait to give Darthe time to get home to make his case. Duly noted.

 

There it is.

[Gabriel Kross]

So you disagree with what I had to say about BG then?

 

Remind me what you said about BG again?

 

For f**ks sake lemme find it......

 

It's on page 96 i think

[Gabriel Kross]

Ninja'd >.>

[John E. Kelley]

And the fact that both BG and Darthe have thrown their hands up in the air and said screw it for tonight doesn't make me feel comfortable with either of them.

[hazelkrs1]

See? You ruin your case by stating that Verb is Town. Tying yourself to Verb is killing you. I would be willing to trust your case, but Verb's? Not so much.

 

Ishy, it is killing me how quickly Verbs train built today. And that you and EP had some interplay that we are all being told to trust but not what happened. If there was concrete evidence then you picked a bad person to roll with for the Verb case but the fact of it is that nobody has presented anything beyond extremely circumstantial claims. I am simply attempting to be logical about this with some unknown. EP almost certainly isn't mafia and I get the feeling you aren't either, but that doesn't mean you two can't be wrong.

 

Why does it bother you that they haven't come out with all of the specifics of what went on? IMO they said more than they should have. Either way townies wouldn't really feel the impetus to ferret out what happened. Mafia tho might be annoyed that they don't know exactly what happened.

[Gabriel Kross]

And the fact that both BG and Darthe have thrown their hands up in the air and said screw it for tonight doesn't make me feel comfortable with either of them.

 

Women can be scary if you keep them waiting.

[John E. Kelley]

And the fact that both BG and Darthe have thrown their hands up in the air and said screw it for tonight doesn't make me feel comfortable with either of them.

 

Women can be scary if you keep them waiting.

 

Are you insinuating that I have a uterus?

[Gabriel Kross]

And the fact that both BG and Darthe have thrown their hands up in the air and said screw it for tonight doesn't make me feel comfortable with either of them.

 

Women can be scary if you keep them waiting.

 

Are you insinuating that I have a uterus?

 

No read BG's goodnight post again.

[hazelkrs1]

I don't know, I'm starting to rethink my position here. Darthe was able to back up his claim, at least as it pertains to his role. Alignment is a different story though.

 

BG, on the other hand, has no way to back up his claim, and when I asked what role he enabled, answered "investigative" roles. Really? He enables each and every investigative role that we may have? Not just Cop, but all of them? That seems a little far-fetched to me. Putting that much importance on one player doesn't seem quite right. If he is taken out, that would cripple Town to such an extent that we may not recover. That may be an exaggeration, but not by much. And by claiming such, he almost assures that Town players wouldn't dare mess with him.

 

So to sum up, BG's claim is a little suspect to me, firstly because I can't see one player that could effectively ruin every investigative role that Town has, and secondly, because it's the perfect claim for him to make when his lynching is in question. I haven't made up my mind, because this is all WIFOM anyway and I'm hesitant to make the move that I just described. But you have to admit, this is easily a claim that savvy player like BG would make as scum. I'll consider and return.

 

Finally, it looks like Basel didn't agree with the idea that we wait to give Darthe time to get home to make his case. Duly noted.

 

There it is.

 

Ahhh that one. Well, that post seemed kind of pointless to respond to, tbh, because BG said he was an Enabler to blocking type roles, not investigative type roles.

 

So since the role he's claiming is really a lot more balanced than you make it seem, it also seems less convenient.

 

I do agree with you about Basel's vote on Darthe tho. If it is townie on townie violence, Basel's vote seems the most opportunistic

 

And the fact that both BG and Darthe have thrown their hands up in the air and said screw it for tonight doesn't make me feel comfortable with either of them.

 

You wanna be comfortable with both of them?

 

Kinky

[John E. Kelley]

And the fact that both BG and Darthe have thrown their hands up in the air and said screw it for tonight doesn't make me feel comfortable with either of them.

 

Women can be scary if you keep them waiting.

 

Are you insinuating that I have a uterus?

 

No read BG's goodnight post again.

 

Ah.

[Gabriel Kross]

Out of curiosity Desp, what are your thoughts on what I've said since the challenge started?

[John E. Kelley]

So Despo, you are in agreement with BG, and not Darthe? Give us an opinion bro.

[John E. Kelley]

Guess that's the end of Drunk MafiaTM for tonight.

 

Later kids.

[hazelkrs1]

Out of curiosity Desp, what are your thoughts on what I've said since the challenge started?

 

They've generally been pretty sound thoughts imo. Didn't think that Darthe was that scummy before, and immediately after the challenge was issued, but after recent developments he has seemed more likely to be antitown.

 

Where there other things specifically you wanted me to comment on? I can go back and check

 

So Despo, you are in agreement with BG, and not Darthe? Give us an opinion bro.

 

I think BG's case on Darthe was more convincing than Darthe's on BG. BG's case seemed more objective, whereas Darthe's case seemed to be a little more forced.

 

If I was you, I'd vote Darthe tbh.

[hazelkrs1]

Guess that's the end of Drunk MafiaTM for tonight.

 

Later kids.

 

Can Tress come back and party after she's dropped you off?

 

 

 

 

 

/evil