[ADVANCED] KaeKey Game of Thrones Mafia - GAME OVER! NIGHT'S WATCH WINS!

[John E. Kelley]

Glad you decided to join us here in the deep end of the pool Cyan.

 

On Wednesdays, we lynch Nol.

 

Ed's fleas aren't spreading.

 

Red loves the Washington Redskins.

 

And no, your eyes aren't deceiving you. I really am this handsome.

[RandA lThor]

Noldy. I never expressed doubt at you or John. Just EP.

What makes Johns claim hold any more weight than EP's in your eyes?

And I'd consider the fact that you are choosing to vote EP while I support him doubting me

 

And as Peace said, I just don't think your words hold any weight. Yes, I believe you when you say Starks will be Town, but I didn't necessarily believe EP, nor your blindly saying he is who he says he is.

Because no, in mafia, you don't just believe someone claiming a main character with no counter claim right off the bat. A smart player decides to see where they are going with that and then counter claims once they gleaned information from the whole thing.

One might mistake your caution as an excuse to push a quick lynch on a strong town claim

Not really, because you're vetted town doesn't mean that your opinions are right.

 

Yeah its true. And I could never think of Cyan as an old vet. >.<

I just don't know her and made an assumption based on her post count

It was a mistake on my part

 

She likes to spam. :P

 

Glad you decided to join us here in the deep end of the pool Cyan.

 

On Wednesdays, we lynch Nol. true

 

Ed's fleas aren't spreading. false

 

Red loves the Washington Redskins. false, she loves the Niners

 

And no, your eyes aren't deceiving you. I really am this handsome.

[beanie]

Heh thank you for taking it easy on me Nol xD This is only my third and a half game so yah I figured the only way to learn was to jump in with both feet and hope I don't drown lol.

 

 

Yeah its true. And I could never think of Cyan as an old vet. >.<

I just don't know her and made an assumption based on her post count

It was a mistake on my part

 

Rand

 

And yah I happen to be a tincy bit addicted to spam

[beanie]

Glad you decided to join us here in the deep end of the pool Cyan.

 

On Wednesdays, we lynch Nol.

 

Ed's fleas aren't spreading.

 

Red loves the Washington Redskins.

 

And no, your eyes aren't deceiving you. I really am this handsome.

 

 

I figured I'd give it a shot. It seems a lot more complicated than the basic games.

 

*raises eyebrow at the last part*

[RandA lThor]

Heh thank you for taking it easy on me Nol xD This is only my third and a half game so yah I figured the only way to learn was to jump in with both feet and hope I don't drown lol.

 

 

Yeah its true. And I could never think of Cyan as an old vet. >.<

I just don't know her and made an assumption based on her post count

It was a mistake on my part

 

Rand

 

And yah I happen to be a tincy bit addicted to spam

 

In the same way Elgee is a tincy bit addicted to kaf.

[beanie]

Heh thank you for taking it easy on me Nol xD This is only my third and a half game so yah I figured the only way to learn was to jump in with both feet and hope I don't drown lol.

 

 

Yeah its true. And I could never think of Cyan as an old vet. >.<

I just don't know her and made an assumption based on her post count

It was a mistake on my part

 

Rand

 

And yah I happen to be a tincy bit addicted to spam

 

In the same way Elgee is a tincy bit addicted to kaf.

 

Shhh bad Rand!

[RandA lThor]

Heh thank you for taking it easy on me Nol xD This is only my third and a half game so yah I figured the only way to learn was to jump in with both feet and hope I don't drown lol.

 

 

Yeah its true. And I could never think of Cyan as an old vet. >.<

I just don't know her and made an assumption based on her post count

It was a mistake on my part

 

Rand

 

And yah I happen to be a tincy bit addicted to spam

 

In the same way Elgee is a tincy bit addicted to kaf.

 

Shhh bad Rand!

 

don't worry, addiction to spam is a good thing! I am too! I just can't do it now as much. To think, I used to be the largest poster per day in DM.

[John E. Kelley]

Spam in a KaeKey game = bad.

 

They'll pull out the billy clubs and go all police brutality on your ass.

[beanie]

*shuts up* Sorry.

[RandA lThor]

Oh right, forgot about that, my sincere apologies Kae and Key.

[Nolder]

Red loves the Washington Redskins.

Is that why she's Red?

I thought it was because she's a redhead

[Nolder]

Heh thank you for taking it easy on me Nol xD This is only my third and a half game so yah I figured the only way to learn was to jump in with both feet and hope I don't drown lol.

I will definitely take that into consideration in the future

[John E. Kelley]

Red loves the Washington Redskins.

Is that why she's Red?

I thought it was because she's a redhead

 

Yes, that's why her name is Red. Her diehard love for all things Redskin.

[Nolder]

Not really, because you're vetted town doesn't mean that your opinions are right.

This has nothing to do with my opinions

Use common sense please

 

I am modconfirmed town and I'm a Stark

EP claims Jon Snow with no counterclaim

 

-IF- someone is Jon Snow and not counterclaiming I promise I am going to go off on them post game

 

It's not a good play

EVER

If someone claims your role you KNOW they are scum

You don't let KNOWN scum live

[John E. Kelley]

And while Nol's opinions may not be right (you can be wrong Nol, shocking as the idea may be), I still lend a little more credence to a vetted townie than others I'm not sure of. Just common sense.

[John E. Kelley]

Think about it, a confirmed townie has who's best interest in mind? Town's duh.

[RandA lThor]

Yeah, Nol, but some people believe that if someone claims doc, then you shouldn't claim. What if Jon Snow was a really important role like the cop?

[John E. Kelley]

We're not talking about roles. This is a discussion about characters so far, two different things.

[RandA lThor]

Right, but obviously, if Jon Snow reveals, he will be one of the mafia's top targets, and if he is the doc, I don't think he would want to reveal. I'm not saying I think EP is mafia, I think he's town, but I don't think its as proven as Nol thinks it is.

[John E. Kelley]

Counterclaiming a character is much less risky than CCing a role. Who the hell knows what Ed Starks role is? Could be anything.

[RandA lThor]

Counterclaiming a character is much less risky than CCing a role. Who the hell knows what Ed Starks role is? Could be anything.

 

Still risky, and if he is an important character, then perhaps too risky.

[ed2funy]

Having the Town's best interest in mind doesn't mean you are right. Yes, you know they are town and good, one less person you have to worry about. But that does not mean in any way that they are somehow smarter or know more in that game. It does not mean their words get more weight. Because a vetted Town may be wrong just as any other Townie who isn't vetted.

 

And as of right now, I believe EP. But that is no where near the concrete knowledge that you are Town, Noldy. Snow is a step above him. And that is only because his playstyle hasn't been so stupid.

 

 

Outright counterclaiming is not always the best option. Great, you know one person who is scum. But if you wait, you get more knowledge and info on who might be their possible allies. And knowledge is power in this game. So I think it is you who should know better, Noldy.

[ed2funy]

Not sure why Rand is tying in the Role at the moment. I kinda understand, but since that isn't what this is about, pinging.

 

 

And also, because of FB.

[RandA lThor]

Not sure why Rand is tying in the Role at the moment. I kinda understand, but since that isn't what this is about, pinging.

 

 

And also, because of FB.

 

And I tied in the role because it might matter if that character has a strong role and mafia decide to kill him, he is done for

[Nolder]

Right, but obviously, if Jon Snow reveals, he will be one of the mafia's top targets, and if he is the doc, I don't think he would want to reveal. I'm not saying I think EP is mafia, I think he's town, but I don't think its as proven as Nol thinks it is.

Whether he's the doctor or not is irrelevant because whoever IS the doctor can protect him

 

And as of right now, I believe EP.

Your actions contradict this statement, just sayin