(ADVANCED) Naruto Mafia GAME OVER!

[John E. Kelley]

Re: Boyo--okay, conveniently ignore my point that all he did was say "I can buy that" and vote me, and then "I thought this was the way we should have gone last time." Really, he did? He didn't say much that demonstrates an actual conviction of my guilt. Looks more like a case of "We're Following the Leader" to me.

 

If it was ONLY me who had any doubts of your doc claim, then why am I alive, pray tell? If everyone was as sure as you keep pretending, there's no way they wouldn't have hammered me. I may be in the minority for actually pointing out the flaws in your accusations and claims, but the fact that people were willing to lynch elsewhere means, if nothing else, that they see that I'm not pulling reasons out of my butt--there's something there.

 

Also, sure, you can call anyone who doesn't follow you my scummates, but at least as of yesterDay, that's a majority of the game currently alive. If a majority of the players were actually on a scum team with me, this game would be over. So try again.

 

Let me reiterate the things I brought up that you still haven't addressed, conveniently--were you, or were you not, roleblocked Night 1? How about the fact that your scenario of a scum team revealing two of their number on Day 1 and still leaving the real role alive to counter later is totally ridiculous? And I didn't point this one out, but other people did--all those "hints" you claimed you were dropping, that you posted later as "evidence" didn't come across as hints at the time, nor did they in hindsight. It all sounded like "hmm, I can see he might be scum, but I'm really not sure, maybe." That's what most people were saying, so it's nothing special.

 

By all means, though, keep the taunts coming. It only serves to strengthen my case.

 

Was I roleblocked Night 1? I honestly have no idea, because as I've stated more than once, I have self-protected every night. Due to the fact that no one other than Hoof has claimed a role, and the same day he claimed, Mod killed him. Who else would I protect?

 

And if all these players you offer up as evidence feel the same as you, why is no one else other than you casting a vote my way? Let's look at everyone that has voted for me, and everyone that has voted for you and come up with some totals. It's pretty obvious who believes me and who believes you.

 

And don't worry, we'll be pals again one day, it all has to do with you being scum this game. It's the nature of the beast, yeah?

[Blackhoof]

Your opponent was random. You broke rules. Don't cry about it. Blame yourself for your mistakes I have admitted my own.

 

Rules that didn't exist until I broke them.....

[hotpocket2006]

Vote Ishy I believe Meesh more.

[John E. Kelley]

Vote Ishy I believe Meesh more.

[John E. Kelley]

Vote Ishy I believe Meesh more.

Then you and Meesh are the two scum members left. Easy. My Meesh vote makes me happy. Glad to finally find two scum members. Thanks for making our work easy Song.

[Levity]

Vote Ishy I believe Meesh more.

Then you and Meesh are the two scum members left. Easy. My Meesh vote makes me happy. Glad to finally find two scum members. Thanks for making our work easy Song.

Why would Song give herself away so easily... ?

 

Also, I was going to agree with the point on John--I adamantly believe he should be looked into more. u.u I noticed he's been getting the easy way out of everything for being a top-contributor, especially in the beginning of the game. It almost seems like all of the suspicion on him completely vanished after Nolder died.

[John E. Kelley]

Vote Ishy I believe Meesh more.

Then you and Meesh are the two scum members left. Easy. My Meesh vote makes me happy. Glad to finally find two scum members. Thanks for making our work easy Song.

Why would Song give herself away so easily... ?

 

Also, I was going to agree with the point on John--I adamantly believe he should be looked into more. u.u I noticed he's been getting the easy way out of everything for being a top-contributor, especially in the beginning of the game. It almost seems like all of the suspicion on him completely vanished after Nolder died.

 

Ape may be scum, I wouldn't doubt it. But at this point, I would rather focus on those that are without a doubt scum. Meesh is scum. Period. Without a doubt. Anyone that says they are the Doc when they aren't seals the deal. At this point, you believe me or you believe her. It's time to make a stand. Me or her. The time to decide is now. I'm done with arguing with her. Choose me or her. I'm telling all of you now that I am the Doc, I am town, and if you don't believe me, than vote for me. If you believe me, than vote for Meesh. With as few of us that are left, it's time to make a decision. Do you all think I'm the Doc or do you think Meesh is? I'm done pleading my case. This is it. Decide now because I won't be arguing my case anymore.

[SBoydW]

Hey guys, my internet is down. If it comes back before I go to sleep in a couple hours i'll respond to these latest posts. If not then it will be this evening when I wake up.

[John McClane]

Vote Ishy

 

He is scum. I am the Cop.

[John McClane]

Also...

 

N1 I viewed Red - town.

N2 I viewed Reyrou - town.

N3 I viewed Ishy - not town.

 

My first 2 nights sucked, which is why I've been scumhunting aggressively in day phase. I went with my D1 reads, and they were off. When Ishy countered Meesh on D3, I decided I would view him to try to vet Hoof also. When I saw my result on Ish on N3, I then cast my vote in the Naruto duel for Blackhoof, assuming he was lying this whole time.

 

I was torn about whether or not to reveal this early, but given the laughable case by Corrosive on me and the encouragement by Levity, I get the impression maybe one of them is scum and they figured out who I am. I'll be viewing one of them next. That would mean Ish, Hoof and one of Levity or Corrosive probably are the scum team. I've gotta guess that Nolder was the 4th. We should be in position to win here... I leave it to Meesh to decide to protect me or herself.

[hotpocket2006]

Also...

 

N1 I viewed Red - town.

N2 I viewed Reyrou - town.

N3 I viewed Ishy - not town.

 

My first 2 nights sucked, which is why I've been scumhunting aggressively in day phase. I went with my D1 reads, and they were off. When Ishy countered Meesh on D3, I decided I would view him to try to vet Hoof also. When I saw my result on Ish on N3, I then cast my vote in the Naruto duel for Blackhoof, assuming he was lying this whole time.

 

I was torn about whether or not to reveal this early, but given the laughable case by Corrosive on me and the encouragement by Levity, I get the impression maybe one of them is scum and they figured out who I am. I'll be viewing one of them next. That would mean Ish, Hoof and one of Levity or Corrosive probably are the scum team. I've gotta guess that Nolder was the 4th. We should be in position to win here... I leave it to Meesh to decide to protect me or herself.

 

lol there you have it Ishy. Who's scum now? The ape may be lying, I get that, but if he is on a team with meesh, they deserve it. Otherwise Ish I think you're scum without John's info, and this just reconfirms it in my mind.

 

And your whole, well you voted for meesh and that makes you scum argument was a trifle overdone. That was just the icing on the cake Ish.

 

If you and meesh are scum, John,Kudos. Otherwise if you're both telling the truth, I love wifom nights. *claps hands*

[SBoydW]

Well, I guess I would like a refund on what you sold Ishy...

 

Unvote. Vote Ishy

 

Would you still like an explanation for my voting you Meesh?

[Locke]

Oh my goodness. This is ridiculous.

 

Nolder - Town, Symp. (Will convert to Mafia if the mafia guesses that he is the symp)

 

Red - Town, COP

 

BG - Town, Vanilla

 

Panda - Town, Vanilla

 

Rey - Town, Vanilla

 

Hoof - Town, Tracker

 

Key - Town

 

I'm still waiting for Wombat's alignment. The above is part of the reason I voted for him though. With all those Vanilla Townies, I figured that if a Townie was roled, it'd be a rather common role.

 

I can only assume that you are lying John. Vote Meesh

[SBoydW]

Wait... are you claiming coroner?

[Locke]

Yes.

[SBoydW]

Well bloody burning fire of doom and destruction. You could have saved me a vote change if you posted that a few minutes ago.

 

Though why are you voting for Meesh if John is the one that you have info against, in the form of knowing red was doc...?

[SBoydW]

I mean cop... not doc....

[Locke]

I dunno. They both must be scum. I spent like a minute trying to figure out which to vote for and then just picked Meesh because she already had more votes. (I hadn't seen your unvote at the time)

 

If someone presents a scenario where John would be the better lynch, then I shall gladly switch.

[hotpocket2006]

UNVOTE, VOTE JOHN I think is the way to go, get rid of him first, then meesh.

[hotpocket2006]

I dunno. They both must be scum. I spent like a minute trying to figure out which to vote for and then just picked Meesh because she already had more votes. (I hadn't seen your unvote at the time)

 

If someone presents a scenario where John would be the better lynch, then I shall gladly switch.

 

He's the one caught in the lie. Yes he is protecting meesh, so likely she's scum, but I think it's smarter to take out John.

[Locke]

Unvote

Vote John

[John McClane]

Oh my goodness. This is ridiculous.

 

Nolder - Town, Symp. (Will convert to Mafia if the mafia guesses that he is the symp)

 

Red - Town, COP

 

BG - Town, Vanilla

 

Panda - Town, Vanilla

 

Rey - Town, Vanilla

 

Hoof - Town, Tracker

 

Key - Town

 

I'm still waiting for Wombat's alignment. The above is part of the reason I voted for him though. With all those Vanilla Townies, I figured that if a Townie was roled, it'd be a rather common role.

 

I can only assume that you are lying John. Vote Meesh

 

 

No, I'm not lying.

 

Here is what I believe, I believe Nolder was your scummate. I'm assuming you are saying he was a symp here since I am the one that led the lynch on him - gotta have some sort of explanation for why I'd lead a lynch on scum, to make your counter believable. I believe that the real coroner is dead already, and I believe the scum team must be Ishy, Hoof and you.

 

Desperation play to eliminate me, and lead the remaining town around by the nose with your delayed fake coroner results.

 

Creative counter claim. You need to die after Ishy. I know he is scum.

[John McClane]

UNVOTE, VOTE JOHN I think is the way to go, get rid of him first, then meesh.

 

Big mistake Song.

 

Look at the collective game. Look at his contrived results, that seemingly ONLY indict me. We have scum on the ropes here, this is a pure desperation play.

 

I don't know how better to make it clear.

[John McClane]

I dunno. They both must be scum. I spent like a minute trying to figure out which to vote for and then just picked Meesh because she already had more votes. (I hadn't seen your unvote at the time)

 

If someone presents a scenario where John would be the better lynch, then I shall gladly switch.

 

 

Unvote

Vote John

 

 

Haha... I love the feigned "if someone presents a scenario" line, and then the immediate switch to me, like it wasn't what you intended to do all along.

 

It frustrates me how transparent this is. Seriously.

[hotpocket2006]

UNVOTE so confused, I'm still liking the John vote, but I have *cough* enhanced powers with votes and would still like to discuss things a bit.