[Advanced/Experimental] Game of Thrones Mafia

[John McClane]

Questions I asked Kivam:

 

1. Do all Survivors have the same win condition scenarios?

 

2. Do all Survivors have the ability to steal, and if so, are their options the same for all the things they can buy with stolen gold?

 

 

His response was yes to both. So, its strikes me as very, very odd that BG and Red are pondering how there could have been 3 NK's.

 

Kill them both!!!!

[Barmacral]

If you already feel that way, I feel really bad for you, because I'm only getting warmed up. Come on Barm, you've played on JN before, you should know it's only going to get much worse from here.

 

Oh of course, I was just letting you know in advance.

[Barmacral]

Questions I asked Kivam:

 

1. Do all Survivors have the same win condition scenarios?

 

2. Do all Survivors have the ability to steal, and if so, are their options the same for all the things they can buy with stolen gold?

 

 

His response was yes to both. So, its strikes me as very, very odd that BG and Red are pondering how there could have been 3 NK's.

 

Kill them both!!!!

 

Another point to be made was CTM offering up his vote for sale so he could get a weapon to kill you. That and with thief plays in the game, there's bound to be items floating around already. 3 kills in this size a game is actually less than what I'd have expected.

[Red2111]

also, any thoughts on the fact theres 3 NK's?? 2 i could expect seeing as the Lannisters/Starks are essentially two "scum" type teams. i wonder if kiv threw a mnkey wrench in this game and added a SK just to mess with us some more.

 

 

Wha-wha-wee-waaaaaa!!!!

Unvote

Vote Red

 

BIG SLIP.

 

 

not relaly, it's just using common sense John. Kiv designed this game so it's basiclaly boils down to 1 scum team against another; why is it not logical to assume there would be a NK given to each team? in a normal set up with two scum teams and a town, the two teams have NKs, the only difference between this game and a regular 2 scum game is the town has a chance to flock to one side and join the fight instead of sitting around liek a bunch of ducks being caught in the cross fire.

 

 

call your vote what it is, and OMGUS in disguise with a dash of reaching for a reaction

[Bleedin Green]

Questions I asked Kivam:

 

1. Do all Survivors have the same win condition scenarios?

 

2. Do all Survivors have the ability to steal, and if so, are their options the same for all the things they can buy with stolen gold?

 

 

His response was yes to both. So, its strikes me as very, very odd that BG and Red are pondering how there could have been 3 NK's.

 

Kill them both!!!!

So that took you all 5 seconds. Glad you're taking it down a notch. You're just waaaaayyy too over-eager here. Your entire basis for it is your ASSUMPTION of the source of a third NK based on a very specific series of events all taking place on day one and night one, and then that action immediately being followed up on the very first night, all of which I would say have an extraordinarily minimal chance of actually having taken place. Because frankly, it makes zero sense. But I guess it's a little unreasonable to expect you to actually slow down and think things logically through, no matter how many times tell everyone you'll do so. It's ok, when you're wrong we'll get to hear all about your genius traps again.

[Hybrid]

OK, I'm really liking my vote now.

[Kivam]

VOTE COUNT

Lily (3) - Slats, Vic, CTM

McClane (2) - Red, Booboo

FDM (1) - Pac

Mynd (1) - Barm

Red (2) - Hybrid, McClane

[John McClane]

also, any thoughts on the fact theres 3 NK's?? 2 i could expect seeing as the Lannisters/Starks are essentially two "scum" type teams. i wonder if kiv threw a mnkey wrench in this game and added a SK just to mess with us some more.

 

 

Wha-wha-wee-waaaaaa!!!!

Unvote

Vote Red

 

BIG SLIP.

 

 

not relaly, it's just using common sense John. Kiv designed this game so it's basiclaly boils down to 1 scum team against another; why is it not logical to assume there would be a NK given to each team? in a normal set up with two scum teams and a town, the two teams have NKs, the only difference between this game and a regular 2 scum game is the town has a chance to flock to one side and join the fight instead of sitting around liek a bunch of ducks being caught in the cross fire.

 

 

call your vote what it is, and OMGUS in disguise with a dash of reaching for a reaction

 

 

This is a rare occasion for me, to say my vote is not OMGUS... and anyone from JN will tell you that I don't disguise my OMGUS. I wear it like a badge of honor.

 

If you were a survivor, you wouldn't be asking the questions above, IMO.

[Smash]

Vote McClane

[Barmacral]

OK, I'm really liking my vote now.

 

I am too.

 

Unvote

Vote: Red2111

[Kivam]

VOTE COUNT

Lily (3) - Slats, Vic, CTM

McClane (3) - Red, Booboo, Smash

FDM (1) - Pac

Red (4) - Hybrid, McClane, Barm, Wombat

 

13 to lynch

[John McClane]

I'm guessing that Red is a house member - based on his statements above, and the fact that if he weren't on a team he wouldn't have been brought in as a replacement so quickly. Whoever it was that he replaced Kast (or something like that) was a no-show and replaced almost immediately, while others went through D1 with 1-3 posts... I'm guessing there were some whiny teammates beckoning for a replacement.

[WWWwombat]

Vote: Red

[WWWwombat]

I'm guessing that Red is a house member - based on his statements above, and the fact that if he weren't on a team he wouldn't have been brought in as a replacement so quickly. Whoever it was that he replaced Kast (or something like that) was a no-show and replaced almost immediately, while others went through D1 with 1-3 posts... I'm guessing there were some whiny teammates beckoning for a replacement.

 

Red is female. And be careful. That argument is outside the spirit of the game imo.

[Bleedin Green]

not relaly, it's just using common sense John. Kiv designed this game so it's basiclaly boils down to 1 scum team against another; why is it not logical to assume there would be a NK given to each team? in a normal set up with two scum teams and a town, the two teams have NKs, the only difference between this game and a regular 2 scum game is the town has a chance to flock to one side and join the fight instead of sitting around liek a bunch of ducks being caught in the cross fire.

 

 

call your vote what it is, and OMGUS in disguise with a dash of reaching for a reaction

I get exactly what the Ape's reasoning for having an issue with our discussion is, but it's extremely short sighted. Based on info he has, he's making a massive assumption as to what happened regarding last nights kill attempts, and bulldozing ahead based on that. Only problem is that anyone who takes a second to think about it realizes that it's, at best, a reach to assume the series of events that would lead to the Ape's assumption occurred all within a single day/night phase, so I'm not about to eliminate other possibilities because he has chosen already to do so.

[John McClane]

Vote McClane

 

 

I like your case.

 

 

JN Metagaming time... anyone notice how quiet this blockhead has been so far?

[Bleedin Green]

This is a rare occasion for me, to say my vote is not OMGUS... and anyone from JN will tell you that I don't disguise my OMGUS. I wear it like a badge of honor.

 

If you were a survivor, you wouldn't be asking the questions above, IMO.

While I obviously don't have an issue with the initial discussion points, for the reasons already mentioned above, I actually have to agree that I do find it odd that she clearly doesn't see where your issue comes from. Even if I completely disagree with your assumption, it shouldn't be that hard to figure out what it is that you're thinking, assuming the person has the right info.

[John McClane]

not relaly, it's just using common sense John. Kiv designed this game so it's basiclaly boils down to 1 scum team against another; why is it not logical to assume there would be a NK given to each team? in a normal set up with two scum teams and a town, the two teams have NKs, the only difference between this game and a regular 2 scum game is the town has a chance to flock to one side and join the fight instead of sitting around liek a bunch of ducks being caught in the cross fire.

 

 

call your vote what it is, and OMGUS in disguise with a dash of reaching for a reaction

I get exactly what the Ape's reasoning for having an issue with our discussion is, but it's extremely short sighted. Based on info he has, he's making a massive assumption as to what happened regarding last nights kill attempts, and bulldozing ahead based on that. Only problem is that anyone who takes a second to think about it realizes that it's, at best, a reach to assume the series of events that would lead to the Ape's assumption occurred all within a single day/night phase, so I'm not about to eliminate other possibilities because he has chosen already to do so.

 

 

I asked Kivam if objects or gold are stolen on N1, can they then be used or purchase and used on N1... answer is pending.

 

Regardless, Red is trying to allocate kill attempts to the factions - if he knew anything at all about the survivor role, he'd understand why such a discussion is moot.

[Bleedin Green]

JN Metagaming time... anyone notice how quiet this blockhead has been so far?

There's been a lot of oddly quiet JNers this game, smash certainly included. While part of it does have to do with my complete lack of work to do the past couple of days, since when am I a freakin' top 3 poster amongst this crowd?

[Red2111]

and if you were anythign but cult you wouldn't be continuing to push this absurd agenda of yours, especially when your entire plan henged on faulty assumptions that you "neglected" to ask the mod about before proposing them to the town.

 

 

i know your play style John, you say shit for reactions and then jump on like a bull dog with tunnel vision. to me, it seems liek you're on a team and are anxious to kill anyonw your not certain is on it, given your feelings about the lannisters on thread i'm guessing if your a House memebr your a Start but my gut pegs you as Cult.

 

 

go ahead and keep on beating that grass John, and making yoruself look more suspicous

 

 

[John McClane]

and if you were anythign but cult you wouldn't be continuing to push this absurd agenda of yours, especially when your entire plan henged on faulty assumptions that you "neglected" to ask the mod about before proposing them to the town.

 

 

i know your play style John, you say shit for reactions and then jump on like a bull dog with tunnel vision. to me, it seems liek you're on a team and are anxious to kill anyonw your not certain is on it, given your feelings about the lannisters on thread i'm guessing if your a House memebr your a Start but my gut pegs you as Cult.

 

 

go ahead and keep on beating that grass John, and making yoruself look more suspicous

 

 

Bwahahahaha... now I love my vote. You slipped, and now you are trying to redirect suspicion at me. Priceless.

[WWWwombat]

Red accuses John of OMGUS and then pretty much implies that he is either House or Cult when he presses her feet to the coals.

[John McClane]

and if you were anythign but cult you wouldn't be continuing to push this absurd agenda of yours, especially when your entire plan henged on faulty assumptions that you "neglected" to ask the mod about before proposing them to the town.

 

 

i know your play style John, you say shit for reactions and then jump on like a bull dog with tunnel vision. to me, it seems liek you're on a team and are anxious to kill anyonw your not certain is on it, given your feelings about the lannisters on thread i'm guessing if your a House memebr your a Start but my gut pegs you as Cult.

 

 

go ahead and keep on beating that grass John, and making yoruself look more suspicous

 

Does the number 100 mean anything to you?

[John McClane]

Red accuses John of OMGUS and then pretty much implies that he is either House or Cult when he presses her feet to the coals.

 

Red is a girl? Oh, sorry I meant to say "she" and "her"!!! LOL

[slats]

JN Metagaming time... anyone notice how quiet this blockhead has been so far?

There's been a lot of oddly quiet JNers this game, smash certainly included. While part of it does have to do with my complete lack of work to do the past couple of days, since when am I a freakin' top 3 poster amongst this crowd?

 

I mentioned it before, but JF80 stands out as incredibly quiet. He's usually right up there with McApe in the top two, but he's nowhere to be found in this one.