[Advanced/Experimental] Game of Thrones Mafia

[Smash]

  On 8/30/2011 at 8:08 PM, DreadPirateRoberts said:

Okay, here's the board as I see it:

 

Sakaea - claims non-aligned Survivor

Far - claims non-aligned Survivor

Vic - claimes non-aligned Survivor

 

Hybrid - claims Survivor turned Stark Bannerman

Smash - confirmed Stark Bannerman

 

JF80 - confirmed Stark Swordsman

 

dude - confirmed Stark Bannerman - VETTED LAST NIGHT BY KILLING BARM

DPR - Eddard Stark. Paymaster.

 

Here are the rules as I see them:

 

1. Once a Survivor claims a house, they may no longer buy things.

2. *Once a player is turned Cult, they may no longer buy things (or I would be dead).

3. *The cult has no nightkill (or I would be dead).

4. Once a Survivor claims a House, they have no NK.

5. There is no further cult recruitment, or the game would be over.

 

So, the only NK's left in the game are JF80, dude, and the reamining Survivors that did not claim a house.

 

All of the cult and remaining Lannister (yep, I'll bet that there is one left.) are essentially powerless at this point, and do not pose a threat except in how they vote.

 

So, this is how to win:

 

Tonight, let FDM shoot Hybrid with 2 kill shots. If FDM is cult or Lannister, Hybrid has nothing to worry about. If FDM is a Survivor, then Hybrid will die, and statistically be either cult or Lanny.

 

Vic will shoot Smash with 2 kill shots. The same rules apply.

 

At this point, with 8 players, I know that 2 are vetted: Myself and dude.

 

I strongly suspect that JF80 is also immune to recruitment because of his role (but, if I die, look to him first).

 

Out of the remainng 5, no more than 3 can be cult or we would hav already lost, so even if we lose another Survivor, we are still ahead and we still get info on who to lynch the next day.

 

Recap:

 

FDM - shoot Hybrid twice.

Vic - shoot Smash twice

 

dude - holster - do not shoot at all.

JF80- holster - do not shoot at all.

 

We'll vet Sakaea tomorrow.

 

DPR I dont mind taking one for the team here but whats your reasoning ? What if your wrong ? We all jump on to lose ? Also why would Vic have to shoot me twice and how could he possibly do that when I already tracked him last night and he visited no one ? You think he holstered last night ?

 

The one thing we do need going aganist cult is numbers an you seem to be shaving them down which is very culty to me DPR. Im beginning to wonder if you were converted,

[Hybrid]

I strongly dislike this plan.

 

My position in gunning for Red on Day 2 should tell you that I'm not a Lannister House member. My successful thief play from Verbal should tell you that I'm not a Lannister bannerman -- I lost the ability to thief play and my starting bulletproof vest in addition to the ability to buy roles when I declared.

 

My position on the slats lynch should tell you I am not cult -- I'd say I played a pretty solid role in shifting the momentum onto him (Mynd 7, slats 3 => Mynd 6, slats 4).

[Far Dareis Mai]

The only problem with this, is that if DPR and 80 are the last two cult. Then what the hell do we do?

[JF80]

  On 8/30/2011 at 8:25 PM, Far Dareis Mai said:

The only problem with this, is that if DPR and 80 are the last two cult. Then what the hell do we do?

 

 

If that were the case, it would be game over already.

[DPR]

This is turning out better than I expected. Y'all sound a lot like Krak and Barms.

 

There are overwhelming odds that if you are who you say you are, then you'll live, no problem. And, on the off chance that you don't we'll have vetted more players.

[Vicious89x]

I claimed stark.

[Hybrid]

  On 8/30/2011 at 8:29 PM, DreadPirateRoberts said:

Y'all sound a lot like Krak and Barms.

 

Unlike Krak and Barm, I actually gave a defense. What do you think about my points?

[Hybrid]

IMO, we shouldn't go through with this plan unless DPR gives a reasonable answer to the above before the deadline.

[Sakaea]

I think DPR's plan will work, if FDM and Vic do what DPR said to. And I am exactly what I said I am, so I'm not worried.

[Hybrid]

The problem is that if DPR is cult, he's preserving his survivor voting block while offing his bannermen. Frankly, if any survivors have enough gold, I'd encourage buying Finders and aiming them at the Stark House members. I'd be perfectly OK with this plan if DPR and JF80 are vetted.

[Smash]

  On 8/30/2011 at 8:58 PM, Hybrid said:

The problem is that if DPR is cult, he's preserving his survivor voting block while offing his bannermen. Frankly, if any survivors have enough gold, I'd encourage buying Finders and aiming them at the Stark House members. I'd be perfectly OK with this plan if DPR and JF80 are vetted.

 

Im not sure there is a way to vett anyone in this game. So its either we trust DPR or we Dont but before that I would like to hear more from him just like you suggest hybrid

[DPR]

  On 8/30/2011 at 8:25 PM, Far Dareis Mai said:

The only problem with this, is that if DPR and 80 are the last two cult. Then what the hell do we do?

 

 

What a load of shit this is. If I was cult, I'd buy the lynch everyday and win. I have thousands in gold left.

 

 

 

 

[Hybrid]

Survivors can purchase Servants (Finders) to learn either alignment or role.

[DPR]

  On 8/30/2011 at 9:08 PM, Hybrid said:

Survivors can purchase Servants (Finders) to learn either alignment or role.

 

Sure. Then they can lie like rugs about the results. Not so great, eh?

 

Much better to be sure.

 

 

 

 

 

[DPR]

  On 8/30/2011 at 8:29 PM, Vicious89x said:

I claimed stark.

 

Wrong answer. That's disappointing - I was really hoping you were a Survivor.

 

 

 

 

[DPR]

  On 8/30/2011 at 9:06 PM, Smash said:

  On 8/30/2011 at 8:58 PM, Hybrid said:

The problem is that if DPR is cult, he's preserving his survivor voting block while offing his bannermen. Frankly, if any survivors have enough gold, I'd encourage buying Finders and aiming them at the Stark House members. I'd be perfectly OK with this plan if DPR and JF80 are vetted.

 

Im not sure there is a way to vett anyone in this game. So its either we trust DPR or we Dont but before that I would like to hear more from him just like you suggest hybrid

 

Of course there is - dude vetted himself last night by killing Barm.

 

There is no more cult recruitment or we would have already lost. Vetting is easy.

 

 

 

[DPR]

Alright, CHANGE OF PLANS:

 

SAKAEA - PLEASE SHOOT VIC TWICE.

 

DUDE- PLEASE SHOOT HYBRID.

 

JF80 - PLEASE SHOOT FAR.

[DPR]

Wait, hold off on Far for a minute - i want to hear what she has to say about this.

[Hybrid]

  On 8/30/2011 at 9:12 PM, DreadPirateRoberts said:

  On 8/30/2011 at 9:08 PM, Hybrid said:

Survivors can purchase Servants (Finders) to learn either alignment or role.

 

Sure. Then they can lie like rugs about the results. Not so great, eh?

 

Much better to be sure.

 

Let's assume you're Stark, not cult.

 

If they tell the truth -- DPR is Stark -- we can go through with your plan without worrying about being stabbed in the back.

 

If they lie -- DPR is cult -- we can lynch you, then them, and win the game.

 

Why the sudden aversion to being targeted by a Finder?

[Hybrid]

  On 8/30/2011 at 8:20 PM, Hybrid said:

My position in gunning for Red on Day 2 should tell you that I'm not a Lannister House member. My successful thief play from Verbal should tell you that I'm not a Lannister bannerman -- I lost the ability to thief play and my starting bulletproof vest in addition to the ability to buy roles when I declared.

 

My position on the slats lynch should tell you I am not cult -- I'd say I played a pretty solid role in shifting the momentum onto him (Mynd 7, slats 3 => Mynd 6, slats 4).

 

Bump. No comments?

[Smash]

  On 8/30/2011 at 9:15 PM, DreadPirateRoberts said:

  On 8/30/2011 at 9:06 PM, Smash said:

  On 8/30/2011 at 8:58 PM, Hybrid said:

The problem is that if DPR is cult, he's preserving his survivor voting block while offing his bannermen. Frankly, if any survivors have enough gold, I'd encourage buying Finders and aiming them at the Stark House members. I'd be perfectly OK with this plan if DPR and JF80 are vetted.

 

Im not sure there is a way to vett anyone in this game. So its either we trust DPR or we Dont but before that I would like to hear more from him just like you suggest hybrid

 

Of course there is - dude vetted himself last night by killing Barm.There is no more cult recruitment or we would have already lost. Vetting is easy.

 

So you think The Dude Vetted himself by killing a Lannister ?? Are you thinking about what your saying here ? You realize it makes no difference to a cultist if they shoot a Stark or Lannister

 

So NO Dude is far from vetted.

 

Honestly If i had a shot it would be on you tonight . Your turning what should have been an easy win into a cluster f

[DPR]

STATUS:

 

Far - not looking good, but not damned either.

 

Vic - damned himself. Most likely cult.

 

Sakaea - Willing to rock and roll. We'll know tomorrow.

 

Hybrid - Why bring up all of these objections? All you are doing is giiving cult places to hide while we dwindle the numbers of players down. NOT GOOD AT ALL.

 

Smash - We'll see. He's been a great candidate for a recruit, but he's also played like himself all game.

 

 

dude - vetted Stark afaic.

 

DPR - vetted Stark afaic.

 

JF80 - vetted Stark afaic.

 

 

Out of the 5 possibles, I expect 2-3 cult, and 1 Lannister.

[Far Dareis Mai]

I think this is stupid. I have two shots tonight that you gave me. I had planned on shooting Hybrid as you said. I'm just saying is that we are talking a hell of a lot of faith here. And I'm just going to throw out there that if someone shoots at my ass, I'm shooting right back. And its not because I'm evil, but because you are stupid for not using my two shots first before you lynch/nk me.

[Vicious89x]

  On 8/30/2011 at 9:17 PM, DreadPirateRoberts said:

Alright, CHANGE OF PLANS:

 

SAKAEA - PLEASE SHOOT VIC TWICE.

 

DUDE- PLEASE SHOOT HYBRID.

 

JF80 - PLEASE SHOOT FAR.

 

Bull. I 100% guarantee DPR is a cult bastard. This is garbage and he's been hanging around waiting to implement this plan. So far it's gotten us nothing, If DPR flips Stark speed lynch me tomorrow, this is utter BS, CTM got killed and he was the one who pointed out how Starks are compromised. I'm fine if you want to shoot me, but I am now certain that DPR is cult. Call this my version of the dudes cromwell.

[Smash]

  On 8/30/2011 at 9:14 PM, DreadPirateRoberts said:

  On 8/30/2011 at 8:29 PM, Vicious89x said:

I claimed stark.

 

Wrong answer. That's disappointing - I was really hoping you were a Survivor.

 

 

  On 8/30/2011 at 9:15 PM, DreadPirateRoberts said:

  On 8/30/2011 at 9:06 PM, Smash said:

  On 8/30/2011 at 8:58 PM, Hybrid said:

The problem is that if DPR is cult, he's preserving his survivor voting block while offing his bannermen. Frankly, if any survivors have enough gold, I'd encourage buying Finders and aiming them at the Stark House members. I'd be perfectly OK with this plan if DPR and JF80 are vetted.

 

Im not sure there is a way to vett anyone in this game. So its either we trust DPR or we Dont but before that I would like to hear more from him just like you suggest hybrid

 

Of course there is - dude vetted himself last night by killing Barm.

 

There is no more cult recruitment or we would have already lost. Vetting is easy.

 

 

  On 8/30/2011 at 9:17 PM, DreadPirateRoberts said:

Alright, CHANGE OF PLANS:

 

SAKAEA - PLEASE SHOOT VIC TWICE.

 

DUDE- PLEASE SHOOT HYBRID.

 

JF80 - PLEASE SHOOT FAR.

 

 

  On 8/30/2011 at 9:18 PM, DreadPirateRoberts said:

Wait, hold off on Far for a minute - i want to hear what she has to say about this.

 

These last 4 posts tell me you have no plan and no freakin idea what your doing. I suggest you guys holster because losing numbers in a cult game = LOSE and I dont think we should be on this crazy ass wagon DPR is pushing.