[Advanced/Experimental] Game of Thrones Mafia

[Kivam]

 

 

Bronn, a Survivor, has been lynched.

 

Night Actions are due by Noon on Wednesday

 

Final Vote Count

 

CTM (4) - DPR, Hybrid, FDM, Smash, Sakaea

DPR (1) - CTM

 

5 to lynch

[CTM]

DPR = genuis

 

Go Cult!

[the dude]

  On 8/30/2011 at 3:10 PM, Hybrid said:

Who did House Stark try to kill last night?

 

I guess it depends on who you mean by "house stark" but I personally followed orders and killed Barm (I still love ya, buddy!).

 

That lynch happened fast! We got a miss here so i think we better be pretty careful. i can't read back now but i will when i get home.

[Hybrid]

  On 8/26/2011 at 2:19 AM, Kivam said:

Vote Count

Vic (3) - Smash, CTM, Barm

Smash (2) - Vic, Hybrid

JF80 (1) - Sakaea

Sakaea (2) - FDM, Krak

Barm (1) - JF80

 

Not voting: Wombat, Dude, DPR

 

7 to Lynch

 

 

  On 8/26/2011 at 5:04 AM, WWWwombat said:

  On 8/25/2011 at 8:16 PM, Smash said:

To say Im cult after I pushed for the Slats lynch 2 days in a row including the day he was actully lynched is whats absurd here.

 

While you were on slats for a while on the day of the JiF lynch, you didn't really push slats on the day he was lynched. You were on Mynd until switching your vote to slats without giving a reason shortly after Kivam's threat to make a deadline. That being said, I don't think you are cult because I think your vote was a sufficient momentum vote on slats. That being said, Vic had an even bigger momentum vote on slats imo so I don't think he's cult either.

 

This is the last vote count Kivs did where it looked like Mynd might get lynched instead of slats imo:

 

 

  On 8/23/2011 at 8:39 PM, Kivam said:

Vote Count

 

Mynd (6) - Barm, Sakaea, Verbal, the Dude, Wombat, Smash

Slats (7) - JF80, DPR, Bleedin, Hybrid, Mynd, Sharrow, Vic

DPR (1) - Slats

Verbal (1) - CTM

 

10 to lynch

 

 

 

I think we should look at Barm and Sakaea. They were early on the Mynd train and stayed on the Mynd train. I also stayed on the Mynd train, but I know I'm not cult. The dude switched to slats after it was clear where the momentum was going (possible bus job), but he has claimed the Greatjon and claimed shooting the Ape, so he gets a pass for that for now imo.

 

Vote: Sakaea

 

IMO, Sakaea is unlikely to be cult.

[Vicious89x]

Wow, that was insanely fast.

[Smash]

yeah it was and I was going to come back and unvote to give CTM a little time, but thats not happening. I think we have one cult member left so luck may be on our side. DPR Im a little worried that you dragged everyone into this without a real plan to back it up.

[Hybrid]

I'm just hoping that the survivors, if their votes are still being bought, are going to use the gold for Finders instead of vests or NKs.

 

And that one of the survivors isn't a cultist (if cult-recruited survivors can still buy roles), because we're approaching the point where they can wipe out pretty much the entire game.

[Smash]

  On 8/30/2011 at 4:06 PM, Kivam said:

 

 

Bronn, a Survivor, has been lynched.

 

Night Actions are due by Noon on Wednesday

 

Final Vote Count

 

CTM (4) - DPR, Hybrid, FDM, Smash, Sakaea

DPR (1) - CTM

 

5 to lynch

 

Looks a little like I pictured CTM to look, except he has all his teeth

[JF80]

  On 8/30/2011 at 4:39 PM, Hybrid said:

 

IMO, Sakaea is unlikely to be cult.

 

 

+ 1. I've ruled out Sakaea to be cult based on what Wombat had been saying in the Stark QT. That's right, I'm in the Stark QT.

[Hybrid]

  On 8/30/2011 at 5:49 PM, JF80 said:

  On 8/30/2011 at 4:39 PM, Hybrid said:

 

IMO, Sakaea is unlikely to be cult.

 

 

+ 1. I've ruled out Sakaea to be cult based on what Wombat had been saying in the Stark QT. That's right, I'm in the Stark QT.

 

Yeah, I knew. Once I figured out who Wombat was, I was facepalming at how off my Lannister bannerman picks were.

[JF80]

Now that Wombat was a known cult convert (and having spent so much time in the Stark QT with Wombat), I can no longer trust DPR. I'd recommend not listening to his calls for lynches anymore. If the target is not cult, that person will be lynched with a quickness like CTM was, thanks to so many cult votes getting piled on.

[JF80]

My best guess for cult are Far and Smash. They were the 3rd and 4th votes on CTM, respectively. Also, in our QT, Wombat seemed to angle towards protecting both of them.

[JF80]

Oh, and if DPR is converted cult, he and Wombat have both been playing me like a fiddle in the Stark QT.

[Vicious89x]

  On 8/30/2011 at 6:29 PM, JF80 said:

Now that Wombat was a known cult convert (and having spent so much time in the Stark QT with Wombat), I can no longer trust DPR. I'd recommend not listening to his calls for lynches anymore. If the target is not cult, that person will be lynched with a quickness like CTM was, thanks to so many cult votes getting piled on.

 

How much cult do you think is left?

[JF80]

2 or 3? Certainly enough to sway a vote count when it only took 5 to lynch.

[Hybrid]

I don't buy the deputy cult leader stuff. I hate to argue from a balancing perspective, but it strikes me as obscenely overpowered.

 

Btw, I'm rereading from Day 4, and I'm starting to lean not-cult on Smash. IMO, cult is likely to be FDM or DPR (granted, I've been wrong about a lot so far, so . . .).

[JF80]

  On 8/30/2011 at 7:08 PM, Hybrid said:

Btw, I'm rereading from Day 4, and I'm starting to lean not-cult on Smash. IMO, cult is likely to be FDM or DPR (granted, I've been wrong about a lot so far, so . . .).

 

 

I'd be down with taking out Far. DPR is dangerous, but until we hear from him I'm going to be cautiously optimistic that he is still Stark and hasn't been misleading us. If he has been, tip o' the cap.

[Far Dareis Mai]

Well sunshine, let's wait for Day before you throw me up on that cross. :P Doesn't it seem more likely to you that the cult would benefit more from converting members of the Stark House, as opposed to a lone survivor?

[JF80]

  On 8/30/2011 at 7:18 PM, Far Dareis Mai said:

Well sunshine, let's wait for Day before you throw me up on that cross. :P Doesn't it seem more likely to you that the cult would benefit more from converting members of the Stark House, as opposed to a lone survivor?

 

 

I have the power to night kill. Naturally I would be a great conversion candidate, but I doubt cult can convert anymore. Sorry Far but you are # 1 on my target list. I opted not to kill anyone last night and can do so again, but that's where I'm at.

[DPR]

I'm back. Give me a mintue to read and catch-up, and I'll throw the plan out.

[Far Dareis Mai]

  On 8/30/2011 at 7:26 PM, JF80 said:

  On 8/30/2011 at 7:18 PM, Far Dareis Mai said:

Well sunshine, let's wait for Day before you throw me up on that cross. :P Doesn't it seem more likely to you that the cult would benefit more from converting members of the Stark House, as opposed to a lone survivor?

 

 

I have the power to night kill. Naturally I would be a great conversion candidate, but I doubt cult can convert anymore. Sorry Far but you are # 1 on my target list. I opted not to kill anyone last night and can do so again, but that's where I'm at.

 

If you will reread what I said, I did not in any way accuse you of being cult. I am merely saying that it is more likely that someone from house Stark is likely to be cult over a survivor with no faction.

[Hybrid]

  On 8/30/2011 at 7:18 PM, Far Dareis Mai said:

Well sunshine, let's wait for Day before you throw me up on that cross. :P Doesn't it seem more likely to you that the cult would benefit more from converting members of the Stark House, as opposed to a lone survivor?

 

A lone survivor . . . like Ape McClane.

 

I agree that the cult would benefit more from converting Starks at this point in the game but that's not when all the recruiting occurred. For example, I could see slats not recruiting Starks until Night 3.

[DPR]

Okay, here's the board as I see it:

 

Sakaea - claims non-aligned Survivor

Far - claims non-aligned Survivor

Vic - claimes non-aligned Survivor

 

Hybrid - claims Survivor turned Stark Bannerman

Smash - confirmed Stark Bannerman

 

JF80 - confirmed Stark Swordsman

 

dude - confirmed Stark Bannerman - VETTED LAST NIGHT BY KILLING BARM

DPR - Eddard Stark. Paymaster.

 

Here are the rules as I see them:

 

1. Once a Survivor claims a house, they may no longer buy things.

2. *Once a player is turned Cult, they may no longer buy things (or I would be dead).

3. *The cult has no nightkill (or I would be dead).

4. Once a Survivor claims a House, they have no NK.

5. There is no further cult recruitment, or the game would be over.

 

So, the only NK's left in the game are JF80, dude, and the reamining Survivors that did not claim a house.

 

All of the cult and remaining Lannister (yep, I'll bet that there is one left.) are essentially powerless at this point, and do not pose a threat except in how they vote.

 

So, this is how to win:

 

Tonight, let FDM shoot Hybrid with 2 kill shots. If FDM is cult or Lannister, Hybrid has nothing to worry about. If FDM is a Survivor, then Hybrid will die, and statistically be either cult or Lanny.

 

Vic will shoot Smash with 2 kill shots. The same rules apply.

 

At this point, with 8 players, I know that 2 are vetted: Myself and dude.

 

I strongly suspect that JF80 is also immune to recruitment because of his role (but, if I die, look to him first).

 

Out of the remainng 5, no more than 3 can be cult or we would hav already lost, so even if we lose another Survivor, we are still ahead and we still get info on who to lynch the next day.

 

Recap:

 

FDM - shoot Hybrid twice.

Vic - shoot Smash twice

 

dude - holster - do not shoot at all.

JF80- holster - do not shoot at all.

 

We'll vet Sakaea tomorrow.

[Smash]

  On 8/30/2011 at 7:50 PM, DreadPirateRoberts said:

I'm back. Give me a mintue to read and catch-up, and I'll throw the plan out.

 

yeah you do that .

 

JF80 I think there is probably 1 maybe 2 at the most Cult left in the game and I think another recruiter is ridiculous as well. The vote went the way it did because DPR and his master plan pushed it in that direction and most of us followed . What DPR has achieved here is that we cant get a legitimate tell on cult based on the vote, you may be innocent DPR but you botched this up IMO.

[JF80]

OK, I'll go along with that DPR. No night kill tonight from me.