[Basic Mafia] Fiddleton - Game Over

[Leelou]

You argue until you are blue in the face. As the sun is fading, you finally reach a decision. You place the noose around Talya's neck and drag her towards the hanging tree. As you throw the rope around the branch, she starts laughing and doesn't stop until it's done.

 

Talya, a member of the mafia, is dead.

 

It is now night. You have until Wednesday 8 am EST to send in night actions.

 

VOTE COUNT

 

Talya (5) - GMaster, Locke, Tina, Tiinker, Mav

GMaster (2) - Talya, Phelix

 

Not voting: Deadly

 

With 8 alive, it takes 5 to lynch.

[danneric]

hmmm thats what i was thinking but i didnt belive that GM was mafia i did belive talya was mafia hence the whole explanation for her. but unfortunately when i said i would reread and then vote i did not know the deadline would show up so fast. jeez. but talya being scum is an indicater that GM could be the finder. so thats what im thinking so far.

[Niniel]

Well, this was really good and kind of confirms GMasters cop claim. (I don´t think scum would kill one of their own this late in the game, see my last post.)

[danneric]

i know what you mean talya but couldnt they scrafice a member to secure at least 2 of their scum in the towns trust. for GM i agree he probaly most definitely the cop.

[Leelou]

MOD Note: Guys it's Easter week. Please try to get night actions in today so we can move the game along. Muchos gracias!

[Mav]

Lets just be extra carefull before we blindly follow GM.

[Talya]

MWUHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAAAaaachhhh...ccc..chchcch....*dies*

[Locke]

FoS Mav.

[Leelou]

You wake with a jump, surprised that you even dozed off. After recovering from the shock, you open the door to your room to leave. A dead, lifeless body falls with a slump into your room. Everyone runs to your room upon hearing your screams.

 

Locke, the doctor, is dead.

 

It is now day. With 6 alive it takes 4 to lynch.

 

Deadline is Thursday 6 pm EST.

[GMaster479]

Damn. Well this game just got interesting. I spied another townie. But I only spied them because I was pretty sure Tiinker was Mafia already. I am thankful that Locke saved me last night even though he was picked off as well.

 

So that being said...vote Tiinker

[Locke]

Yeah, figures.

[danneric]

wow that was a big punch in the face for me. i actually thought he was maffia. now that the doc is dead we really need to study everyones posts definitly! now for one. GM are you absolutly sure that Tiinker is mafia (or have a good argument for it?) i really need convincing to vote for anyone right now.

[GMaster479]

Remember that quote at the beginning of Day 3 where Tiinker just jumped on the vote for me? This is the time where I reference that. Also for when I die tomorrow night my suspects are Phelix and Tiinker

[danneric]

i've been thinking phelix could be mafia too. hes been way to quiet ever since mynds downfall. now that i just said that i bet he will post again anyway they seem likly, phelix and tinker that is, and to think about neither have given much to the finding of a scum except a yes there and a no there if you know what i mean.

[Niniel]

Loosing doc and GMaster viewing a townie. Not a good night at all.

 

I have not done a reread jet but here are my first thoughts.

 

1. GMaster - now I´m conviced that you are the cop. If you were scum you should have "viewed a scum" and make us go after him. Unfortunately you don´t know more then us now so we can´t take your words as facts. This make me believe your copclaim but will also make me questioning your ideas today cos they could be both right and wrong. As you stated I guess you will die tonight. What you can help us with today is 1. to make good cases so you can convince me/us and 2. in case we go after the townie you viewed you can save him/her.

 

2. Tiinker - I was suspisious of him earlier in the game but dropped it cos I thought he answered honestly. He was on the Mynd lynch if we should go back to GMasters theory that maffia was on that lynch. (If I remember correct the ones on Mynds lynch was me, GMaster, Talya, Tiinker, Phelix and Deadly. That means all of us exept for Mav so that doesn´t tell us much.)He did a strange quick vote on GMaster early yesterday. It could have been out of just simple mistrust (GMaster was wrong about Mynd) or a way to surf on the "we-have-hard-to-believ-you-GMaster-wave" and get us all on a quick GMaster lynch. To sum it up I´m unsure about Tiinker.

 

3. Phelix - he has been on my FOS-list since day two when he made that strange comment after Deadly1 was lynched but he has never made it to the top. I would like to hear more from him. He never changed his vote from Talya to GMaster when noone else claimed cop but to be fair I think he disappeared before we settled that. I don´t think he is hiding or lurking around cos I looked at his profile and he hasn´t been on DM since 15th April.

 

4. Mav - The only one who wasn´t on Mynds lynch of us still here. If I remember it right he didn´t vote at all then. I don´t think this make him completely trustworthy though. His comment about not trusting GMaster blindly was odd. But I don´t know...

 

5. Deadly2 - Maybe I understood him wrong earlier? I read his post as he thought both GMaster and Talya were scum but that was not the case? Well, lets say that Deadly has climed on my suspicion list because of all "fluff posts". And he hammered Mynd - didn´t he?

 

So to sum it up again. The only one I won´t vote is GMaster. The rest of you I have found suspicios some time during this game and I have to do a reread and study you more. My current list is:

1. Deadly

2. Tiinker/Phelix

3. Mav

[danneric]

awesome im number one it seems but tina you know i dont know ho to make anything but fluff posts its been that way forever what does a fluff post even mean? anyway im still for GM's claim that tinker is mafia. for one GM is probaly town and two that means you (maybe) me if you lynch i have a post that will be an instigater) and i think mav (i trust him somewhat) are the town. but for a trust count on town i would say thats me and GM for now (nothing personal have to suspect everyone and GM already claimed cop and held it) so if we did vote we have a 2 out of 4 chance to get a scum

 

plus im thinking that GM viewed mav because when mav made an earlier vote hes the one who i thought scum at the time and even GM saw the scummy he layed out (or hinted toward it.

[Mav]

After a reread I have to agree with GM.

 

I saw the past few days that Tiinker and Tina are working perfectly together. Also when I read back I noted that those 3 (+Talya) where rarely poking eachother and when it was done it was easily left alone after one reply.

 

Also, these 2 supported me in overthinking everything untill the last minute of the deadline stalling the lynch on Talya yesterday, needless to say, scum doesn't like one of their own to be lynched.

 

 

Lynch Tiinker

[Leelou]

VOTE COUNT

 

Tiinker (2) - GM, Mav

 

Not Voting - Tina, Deadly, Tiinker, Phelix

 

With 6 alive, it takes 4 to lynch.

 

Deadline Thursday 6 pm EST.

[Niniel]

Ok. I have done a huge reread. First I like to comment on Deadlys thought that GMaster may have viewed Mav. That could off course be correct but I don´t think GMaster should tell who he viewed. If he see that people are jumping to vote the innocent one he could use that to figure out who is scum. Not for sure - but an indicator.

 

Next. GMaster - by fluff posts I mean that you just talk but doesn´t state any own ideas. I haven´t counted but I think you have done the least amount of posting. Hiding from town or scum or just a man of few words? Now I have to confess that I don´t always get your posts but that could be me not understanding the language good enough. You write long sentences and don´t use capitals in the beginning of a new sentence.

 

So we have two votes on Tiinker already. Do I think he could be maffia? Yes, I do. Locke made a possible scum list wich mentioned Talya, Tiinker and Mav. And guess - Locke is now dead!

 

I hesitate to vote. Not that I think you are wrong about Tiinker but it is an important choise this late in the game. I guess I don´t have to remind you that with the doc dead - if we fail this lynch maffia will win... And if I vote Tiinker I will hand the hammering to Deadly (I guess Tiinker won´t vote himself and Phelix seems to be gone) wich is ironic since he is my other main suspect.

 

But ok - Deadly it´s up to you. Vote Tiinker.

[Niniel]

I meant to adress the fluff thing to Deadly not GMaster. Sorry!

[GMaster479]

Well Deadly is right...I did spy Mav. Why he knew that however COULD mean that he is a baddie who had a 50/50 shot of guessing who I spied based on his knowledge of Scum. I say that we still need one more person to jump on the Tiinker vote. Deadly and Phelix are both looking bad in my book right now but one of them can redeem themselves by voting for Tiinker

[danneric]

Dont vew me tonight its a waist because im town anyways might as well...Vote Tiinker

 

 

p.s. if you see me make grammatical mistakes please say something im in a keyboarding class and i need to start getting into the habit of typing correctly.

[danneric]

Vote Tiinker

 

I stand corrected

[Tiinker]

GM can you explain the case for voting me? Cos I didn't quite catch it.. Mav it was you who said that we shouldn't blindly follow him, and yet here you are doing just that!

 

Stalling the lynch? Over thinking? When we were arguing I don't think you we're even present. I don't see how it was wrong for any of us to be skeptical when he had said that he was 100% sure that Mynd was scum and turned out to be 100% wrong. He's doing the same thing here and is going to get the same result.

[GMaster479]

Tiinker, the hammer has already happened. It is too late. Sorry if I got it wrong