Dirty Cops Mafia - GAME OVER!!!

[Toy and Minion]

Peacesells, disregard Cubarey's first question.

[mcs0083]

I wasn't wanting to do this, but it's the only way I see to protect myself from being lynched at this point. I have the doctor role. I used it on myself last night because I didn't really know who else to use it on.

[CUBAREY]

Peacesells, disregard Cubarey's first question.

 

It was a rhetorical question as I presume he would not admit he was circumventing the rules.

[Toy and Minion]

Rhetorical or not, don't ask questions like that.

[Myndrunner]

Peacesells, you should view yourself tonight.  If your viewing comes back as mafia, then you will know that you are a crazy cop who always gets the opposite view.  If your view comes back innocent, then you will know you are either a normal cop or naive cop, but the likelyhood of Thorum being innocent will increase.

 

I'm still not getting this whole Catina is Mafia thing.  If we lynch her and she is innocent, what then? 

 

Is anybody buying MCS's claim to be the healer?  Or as he puts it, doctor?

[peacesells]

Wouldn't you think that a crazy cop could have 2 different viewings on the same person?  Viewing myself in that case would only give me exact confirmation 50% of the time.

 

I'm not ready to vote catina....just looks suspicious.  More of a case has to be built in my opinion.

[cosmicpanda]

Peacesells, you should view yourself tonight.  If your viewing comes back as mafia, then you will know that you are a crazy cop who always gets the opposite view.  If your view comes back innocent, then you will know you are either a normal cop or naive cop, but the likelyhood of Thorum being innocent will increase.

 

I'm still not getting this whole Catina is Mafia thing.  If we lynch her and she is innocent, what then? 

 

Is anybody buying MCS's claim to be the healer?  Or as he puts it, doctor?

 

Do view yourself. Be careful about what you say, though, since no doubt the mafia will try to target the sane cops.

 

To be fair, your 'if we lynch her and she is innocent, what then?' line applies well to everybody in this game.

 

Is MCS a cop as well as doc?

 

 

 

 

@ Peacesells:

 

http://mafiascum.net/wiki/index.php?title=Cop#Sanities

 

That's what those of us who have played a bit of mafia think is going on in this game to some extent.

 

[peacesells]

Thanks for that link..that is a huge help.

[Toy and Minion]

Lynching Ballot

 

Mcs (4): Myndrunner, Pandy, Dark Justice, Thorum

 

Catina (2): Talya, Cubarey

 

Talya (1): Catina

 

With 14 alive, it takes 8 votes to Lynch.

 

Day 2 ends Thursday 2 at 3:00 PM (MST)

[Myndrunner]

On lynching MCS.....

 

Pro

1) He has been making a lot of frantic moves, indicative of a newbie with an important role. 

2) He is a lying liar who lies.  (see the fake glowing issue)

3) His reactions to my prodding on Day 1 pinged my scum-dar big time.

4) He is obviously communicating off thread with someone.

5) My gut is telling me he's scum.

6) His coroner report will give me, and likely everyone else, a lot of answers.

 

Con

1) Unless I am Naive or Crazy, I have reason to believe he isn't scum.

2) He has claimed to be the healer and no one has counter claimed. 

3) There are others who are starting to ping more now, like Talya and Cubeary.

 

The Catina lynch doesn't make much sense to me at all.  We need to hear on this from some of you less actives......We have plenty of time before Thursday, but the one thing we cannot do is NO LYNCH.  Someone has to go.  Do we wanna risk lynching our healer on an MCS lynch?  Is he full of bullshanks?

 

Barmy? Danya? Dark Justice? Lia? What are your thoughts on all this? 

 

[Toy and Minion]

6) His coroner report will give me, and likely everyone else, a lot of answers.

 

....

 

1) Unless I am Naive or Crazy, I have reason to believe he isn't scum.

 

One more post saying anything like these, and you are modkilled.  You are trying to bypass the Finding Ballot, which I will not stand for.  It is there for a reason.  This goes for everyone else as well.  One more post even HINTING at what your view may or may not have resulted in, or anything of the kind, without first winning the Finding Ballot, and you will be modkilled.

 

*Humble Mod turning into Mean Mod*

[cosmicpanda]

He pushed at me in my game as well  :D

[CUBAREY]

3) There are others who are starting to ping more now, like Talya and Cubeary.

 

My name is CUBAREY. Acceptible substitutes are" cubarey, Cuba, cuba, Rey, or rey. Cube and Cubeary are not acceptible variations. You can also call me Mud.

[mcs0083]

On lynching MCS.....

 

Pro

1) He has been making a lot of frantic moves, indicative of a newbie with an important role. 

2) He is a lying liar who lies.  (see the fake glowing issue)

3) His reactions to my prodding on Day 1 pinged my scum-dar big time.

4) He is obviously communicating off thread with someone.

5) My gut is telling me he's scum.

6) His coroner report will give me, and likely everyone else, a lot of answers.

 

Con

1) Unless I am Naive or Crazy, I have reason to believe he isn't scum.

2) He has claimed to be the healer and no one has counter claimed. 

3) There are others who are starting to ping more now, like Talya and Cubeary.

 

The Catina lynch doesn't make much sense to me at all.  We need to hear on this from some of you less actives......We have plenty of time before Thursday, but the one thing we cannot do is NO LYNCH.  Someone has to go.  Do we wanna risk lynching our healer on an MCS lynch?  Is he full of bullshanks?

 

Barmy? Danya? Dark Justice? Lia? What are your thoughts on all this? 

 

Look, I already told you guys I am not a cop, I'm a doctor.

Also, [glow=red,2,300]Catina's[/glow] information was kinda lame to get us all excited, so I think we should go ahead with a lynch on her.

[Myndrunner]

Big surprise here, MCS.  You suddenly feel Catina is mafia?  Or are you just trying to save your own butt?

[mcs0083]

I have my reasons. I don't think I have to believe someone is scum to vote to lynch them. In fact I stated my reason as to why I did.

[Myndrunner]

I have my reasons. I don't think I have to believe someone is scum to vote to lynch them. In fact I stated my reason as to why I did.

 

....are.....you.....kidding.....me?  ::)

[Toy and Minion]

Barmacral has just informed me that he will not be able to continue due to RL.

 

Officer John Makela had always been good at tying his shoes.  He made sure, every morning, that his shoes were properly tied.  Every few hours he would look down to see thos little bunny ears poking out of his pants legs, and he'd know he had done a good job.  Today was like any other day, except he had not tied his shoes properly.  He had caught a cold recently and had been rushing to the bathroom when he tripped over his loose shoe lace and fell head-first into the bath tub, breaking his neck.

 

Barmacral AKA John Makela a Dirty Cop, has died.

 

It is still Day 2.

 

With 13 alive it takes 7 votes to Lynch.

 

---

 

And yes, I have decided to change the 'coroner report due to Modkill' rule, due to...certain circumstances.  Sorry, for ANOTHER change/add.  It's frustrating me more than it's annoying you.

[peacesells]

I have my reasons. I don't think I have to believe someone is scum to vote to lynch them.

 

This is very true if you are scum. 

 

I still don't believe MCS is scum...but he is playing this horribly.  He's just asking to be lynched.

 

 

[mcs0083]

I have my reasons. I don't think I have to believe someone is scum to vote to lynch them. In fact I stated my reason as to why I did.

 

....are.....you.....kidding.....me?   ::)

All I can say to that is, is that all you have to say? No I'm not. Even if someone is not scum, I find lynching them a good choice if it makes it easier to get to the scum because they are complicating things. I'm not a kill joy though, for you have to be careful about the way you go about it.

[mcs0083]

My last post should suffice for you too peace.

[Liathiana]

Wow guys...I'm gone for like...24 hours (or did I just check Saturday? Ugh, work sucks! Melts my brain :P ) and there is 17ish pages of posts! Took me an hour to read them :P

 

Tomorrow is my last day of work. Normally I'd be on a lot more but our power AND internet (which is a moot point with the power) are out so I have to come over to my Grandma's to get on and post. Only gives me about 2 hours instead of the 10 >.> a day I'm used to.

 

Now my thoughts.

 

MCS: I get the mafia vibe from him because of all the points used before (i.e. editing posts especially concerning votes, etc). However he is a newbie and I don't think he has the skill to try and pull off a fake doctor claim. Unless he's a mafia doctor...are they always innocent?

 

Tayla: Jumping quickly on Catina, who has given me mafia vibes as well especially concerning her weird connection with MCS (see: post edit/change of finder vote). I have to say that almost every game she gives me a mafia feel though so I can't trust feelings!

 

Catina: I'm going to wait on her, while she does give me a mafia vibe or two I can see her reasoning for nominating herself for finder concerning with the feelings of day 1 concerning Danya. And frankly I didn't see anyone else jumping onto the finder's ballot (there isn't a limit I can see) who got a mafia find. From the hints that aren't supposed to be dropped but were, from those who did, they all got innocentish finds. We don't know if anyone got a mafia find (the only ones who nominated themselves were Catina, Mynd and...am I forgetting someone?) so from what I can see, no matter what, the person who revealed would have an innocent find. Am I missing some logic here?

 

Anyways, I don't feel I know enough yet to vote a lynch and we still have some time. And I have ALL DAY Wed. off! ;D

 

Hmmm...new info while I was posting! Mod question: If we discover we're a certain type of cop can we share? And, can we reveal previous finds if we're voted in the finder's ballot?

 

However I'm taking a hard look at Tayla, Catina and MCS.

[mcs0083]

*poses for Liath*

Not sure what your looking for but fire away :)

[Toy and Minion]

...If we discover we're a certain type of cop can we share? And, can we reveal previous finds if we're voted in the finder's ballot?

 

No to the first, yes to the second.

[Liathiana]

Awesome, thank you Mod Sir.

 

I'm looking for mafia tells MCS! :P