Pirates of Fiddland - GAME OVER - Page 32

[Dark Justice]

Oh. The reason, finally was just that I dont think Vem would have taken the chance to blow his "finder" role first day. If he is not the finder, it would be weird to claim someone to be evil. You would "view" someone innocent.

[YellowSisterHanacho]

*Feels sad that someone would think she is evil. Puts on her best innocent face.* Me? Evil?? I'm just a sweet little pirate is all. ^_^

 

[glow=red,2,300]Unvote[/glow]

 

[glow=red,2,300]Vemy[/glow]. . . I have to say I agree with Barm. You seem very suspicious. And I doubt the finder would reveal on the first day even if it did mean his "life". Ah well. . . We shall find out soon.

[Dark Justice]

If the finder is about to be lynched, he/she kind of has to reveal. Does not pay to be lynched in silence if you are the finder.

 

That does not mean Vem is the finder. I just kind of dont see the sence of Vems actions if he isnt the finder.

[Vemynal]

hey guys, I've been informed that someone was a little upset (no worries they didn't mention you by name) about how I've been rather aggressive in my play style. My apologies cause I tend to get like that some times in these games and its good for someone outside the games to tell me so.

 

I am sorry for being mean and trying to run this game, because I have in fact been doing so looking on it from that perspective. Rather what I thought I was doing is trying to convince you of my innocence but as it seems I'm merely polarized the group against me.

 

I'm gonna try and calm down now and let you guys take over for a bit, I have a date tomorrow, and an exam to study for on thursday and a birthday party on friday to get rdy for anyways so its perfect timing^^

 

In the mean time I say keep doign what your doing, voting me and barm. But bcx has been right about loreina as well. Since I know which of us is innocent i haven't been worried about it. Maybe its time we all looked at that.

 

peace out^^

[YellowSisterHanacho]

Okay now I am so confused!!!!

 

*Curls up in the corner and decides to think for a while.*

 

[glow=red,2,300]Unvote[/glow]

 

I will vote when I have a better graps of what the Heck is going on!

[Toy and Minion]

Vote Count:

 

Barmacral (2): Vemynal, Dark Justice

Vemynal (2): Barmacral, nephitess

 

ilgross (1): Tigara

 

With 10 alive it takes 7 to lynch

 

***Seeing as how it took people some time to show up, I am extending the deadline to Thursday 3:00 pm (MST).  Don't get used to it though, as this is special circumstance.

[Gryphan_Crymsonstarr]

[glow=red,2,300]Barm[/glow]

 

 

[Guest nephitess]

can we get a reason GRY?  It's always nice to hear reasons...:)

[Gryphan_Crymsonstarr]

I am suspicion of the second claim of finder, I am actually suspicion of both claim but this made my ears prick. And if I am wrong I will feel like a flibberdajibbit for falling into a trap.

[bcxanth]

It seems like everyone is holding their breath, waiting to see what happens.  I'm in a really annoyed mood today, so I'm going to break the silence.

 

Well, I've been thinking about this long and hard, trying to figure out which of the three paths I see before me makes the most since to take.

 

Option 1) Ilgross.  The fact that Loreina suspected him until the end, and was vocal about it despite changing her vote, makes me put him high on my hit list.

 

Option 2) Vemy. Although I found it very strange that, if he was the Finder, he'd declare it on day 1, I can see his rationalization. It's the one piece of info that might help keep you from getting lynched. However, because it can help do that, I can see where someone who isn't the Finder might do it as well, just to save themself.  So there are points for, and against.

 

Option 3) Barm. His reasoning for waiting until day 2 to declare as Finder is strong. If I had been Finder, that's what I would have done.  Well actually I would have held off as long as I could if I was able to get an evil lynched without revealing why I was trying to get them out.  Yet day 2 would have been the earliest I would have declared.  So Barm holding off makes sense. However, the fact that he was accused by Vemy, and then declared, does seem weird timing.  At the same time though, that would be the perfect time to declare it, for the same reason Vemy declared on day 1 if he is the Finder. To save himself.  So a point against, but two points for.

 

So, although Ilgross is still #1 on my list, I think it'd be a wasted vote at this point because everyone else is focused on the Finder debate.  And since obviously one of the two is lying, they can't get away with it forever.

 

So with that in mind, I vote [glow=red,2,300]Vemy[/glow].

 

Sorry man.  The more I think about it, the more I respect your game play. But this is the way the points tallied for me. I hope you understand.

[Vemynal]

its ok, just a game after all anyways bcx^^, just be warned that your gonna look evil as heck when i die =/

 

Vote Count:

Barmacral (3): Vemynal, Dark Justice, gryph

Vemynal (3): Barmacral, nephitess, bcx

 

ilgross (1): Tigara

 

With 10 alive it takes 7 to lynch

[Talya]

Okay, I have been thinking and checking back.

 

Vemy came straight in on day two and voted for Barmy, Now it could have been anyone he choose if he was evil, and yet Barmy counters that, saying he is the finder. Either Barmy id the finder, which makes Vemy evil and a very good guess at making the finder look evil, or Vemy is right. Because he came straight in with that vote, I'm inclining towards Vemy being the finder. Though I still haven't put it passed both of them being evil.

 

So I will go back to my first vote

 

[glow=red,2,300]Barmy[/glow]

[Toy and Minion]

[glow=beige,2,300]WARNING: IN 23 1/2 HOURS I WILL FORCIBLY END DAY 2!!![/glow]

 

Vote Count:

 

Barmacral (4): Vemynal, Dark Justice, Gryphan Crymsonstarr, Talya

 

Vemynal (3): Barmacral, nephitess, bcxanth

 

ilgross (1): Tigara

 

With 10 alive it takes 7 to lynch

 

 

[ilgross]

Why do we have to kill either of them?

 

Chances are thats exactly what the mafia wants. I would always sacrifice one of my mafia comrades to get the finder he is almost the only chnace we have of winning.

 

I say WE tell them who to investigate each night. That way we get maximum infomation, and  ican protect one of the finder's in the hope that its the real one.

 

We know ONE of them is mafia, however the townies will still have the majority for the next couple of days whatever happens. I say we order them to investigate people WE choose. That way we get maximum infomation, still only have a 50% chance of lynching our cop, and have a suspect in custody...

[Dark Justice]

they will both know. They will always come up with the same result. The mafia knows who is who. If we do manage to view a filthy ninja its all good. but as long as innosents is viewed, its just another ninja out there that we could kill...

[bcxanth]

Until the time that we told them to view someone that came up evil. And then we'd have two different stories again, and be stuck where we are now with 50/50 odds of getting the right person.  If we take care of this now, like Vemy and Barm are pushing for, then if we get the wrong person we have enough good guys left to still recover from it and have a chance at winning.  If we hold off and wait until the inevitable conflict in the future, we run the risk of making a mistake we can't recover from.

 

No, like I said in my last post, we need to settle this now. Although I still think Loreina and the circumstances there need to be remembered, we can't let this continue.  So Tigara, if you're out there, I think you might want to change your vote, but it's up to you. :)

[Vemynal]

like 4 hours and counting and me and barm are even

 

/cues the james bond music

[Barmacral]

I Call Oddjob!

 

What? He's cool!

 

Well, off to class for me, I look forward to the results once I get back.

[Vemynal]

heh, I remember the N64 Golden Eye FPS game XD

 

I always liked the dude with  metal jaw^^

[Guest nephitess]

*waits*

[bcxanth]

We need a Bond themed Mafia game.

[Toy and Minion]

No, Vemy, you and Barm are NOT even.  Not by my count.

 

Vote Count:

 

Barmacral (4): Vemynal, Dark Justice, Gryphan Crymsonstarr, Talya

 

Vemynal (3): Barmacral, nephitess, bcxanth

 

ilgross (1): Tigara

 

With 10 alive it takes 7 to lynch

 

Day 2 ends in roughly 35 minutes!

[ilgross]

*sigh*

 

Barm there is no way you would of claimed finder unless you had found another guilty person. No Point.

 

[glow=red,2,300]Vote Barm[/glow]

[Barmacral]

No point in claiming when you have found 1 guilty person? I don't see the logic there... at all.

[Guest nephitess]

????  *waits*