FIDDLETON-UNDER-LYME ~ Werewolf mafia game

[Naeann]

Oh yeah, I'm not the assassin either.

[Xefan]

I was fiddling with the idea of revealing, so I might as well.

 

I was the Assassin.  I didn't use my kill on Night 1 for obvious reasons.  I was looking at going after DSage on Night 2, but thought I'd better wait until there's more info.  And then, Night 3, of course, you know what happened.  I saved that bullet for 4 1/2 years.  If it werent for a werewolf, at least I got Mr. Symp!

 

Now I'm just a regular townie.  Yay!

 

I have a funny feeling about Naeann, so I'm going to do some re-reading and see what I can find.

[Xefan]

Note: I’m going to be reviewing Naeann’s (and anyone else I review's) posts as if she is a werewolf.

 

These are the votes that really stood out to me.

 

Yeah... bite me Vemy. ::)

 

A bit of werewolf humor, maybe?

 

I don't like jumping on the wagon but like cloud said... we have to move it along... I'm sorry if we are wrong [glow=red,2,300]Leelou[/glow].

 

 

I reread and I'm kind of at a loss on what to really think.... Its between Dsage ,Vemy, and Cloud on my radar... Cloud after that seriously long defence of Dsage I'm wondering if he's evil and you are the symp.  Vemy... you always manage to look suspicious.... "Game Vemy" scares me!! lol  All three of you have good retaliations, reviews, and thoughts... I'm not sure which, if any of you, to believe at this point.

 

Interesting how both Leelou and cloudcrono turned up innocent

 

*sends good Karma Dsage's way*

 

There’s no way she could have known that DSage was the symp.  But could this be called irony? (yes, that’s a stretch)

 

Hmm yeah I don't know.... like it was said... Dsage unvoted Vemy and voted Leelou... supposedly to bandwagon... and suddenly after the night jumps almost immedietly on Vemy.  And Vemy plays the drama queen saying the evils set him up.  Its tough... He's been named evil and suspiciousness in every game I've been in with him.  Those playing evil also know that... is he playing us like in www? or are the evils riding on his suspicions and using it to lay low? 

 

I agree.  This would be hard.  You gotta look innocent so when the time comes, you gotta vote off your own team mate.  Very hard.

 

Awww crap... they got the healer?!? We really are screwed. :o

 

Sounds like a pretty classical evil post after a good guy dies.  Don’t say much, just enough to try and bring the point across that you’re “sad”.

 

I think its a good idea.  I was unsure which of those two to pick because I still can't decide which one is telling the truth and we already lost our healer and I'm worried we might pick the wrong one and loose our finder too.

 

Translation: Thank God!  Now I don’t have to look evil by lynching the Finder!

 

Oh yeah, I'm not the assassin either.

 

One question:  If you weren’t the Assassin, why would you post that you weren’t?  It wouldn’t need to be said at all.  Unless you’re a werewolf?

 

In conclusion:  Naeann is quite, doesn’t say much, and lays low.  Since she’s a newer player, that sounds like the perfect strategy for being a werewolf.  Of course, all my posts could be wild speculation.  But, until I find a more suspicious player, my vote goes to [glow=red,2,300]Naeann[/glow]

 

[Xefan]

Because our Moddess started it, but never continued it, plus it was fun to do, here's the list of all the players (alive and dead)

 

1.  Kryos

2.  Dark Justice (Healer) Nightkilled Night 2

3.  Vemynal Lynched Day 2

4.  Naeann

5.  Amethea

6.  Leelou Lynched Day 1

7.  Cloudcrono Nightkilled Night 1

8.  Dsage (Symp) Assassinated Night 3

9.  The Dude (Finder) Nightkilled Night 3

10. Raena

11. Xefan

12. Loreina Lynched Day 3

13. Damane

 

I didn't color my name or anything because I understand that people will not believe me 100%

[damane]

speaking of laying low, Xefan seems to have been laying real low until this point.

[Xefan]

Well, I didn't want to be pinpointed for a nightkill, that would have been bad.

[damane]

well i'll give you that...but what happened to our suspicions on Kryos? if you notice day one and two, there were three people posting accusing each other of being werewolves, that was Vemy, Loreina, and Kryos. Maybe that was their plan, maybe it wasn't. i don't know. although i have had my suspicions about Naeann.

[Naeann]

1. A bit of werewolf humor, maybe?

Only in that it's a werewolf game and I thought I'd try to be funny... if you stretch for the tiniest things everyone on this game could be suspicious enough to be the evil.

 

2. Interesting how both Leelou and cloudcrono turned up innocent

As far as Leelou I voted as a bandwagon.  We were all confused as to who, between vemy and dsage, seemed more suspicious.  Dsage did good at throwing suspicion off and people started voting for Leelou. I believe it was dude that actually said as much.. that since we couldnt decide between them why not just go for the next highest votes.. which was leelou. 

 

3. There’s no way she could have known that DSage was the symp. But could this be called irony? (yes, that’s a stretch)

 

You're right... that is a bit of a stretch.  That was me trying to figure him out.  I did the same to Safir in the Vampire game.  Interesting thought that Safir was one of  the evils in that game.

 

4. I agree. This would be hard. You gotta look innocent so when the time comes, you gotta vote off your own team mate. Very hard.

I don't know what to tell you to explain that. It does look somewhat suspicious.

 

5. Sounds like a pretty classical evil post after a good guy dies. Don’t say much, just enough to try and bring the point across that you’re “sad”.

That is truly what I felt at the time so that is what I posted.  I don't see how that was any different than my other games or anyone elses posts.  If it looks suspicious then I guess it does.

 

6. Translation: Thank God! Now I don’t have to look evil by lynching the Finder!

My first game was WWW and Safir and Vemy both claimed the finder role.  Vemy was the more experienced player and managed to do a good case on his innocence.  Dude and Dsage's double claim for Finder this game went along the same way.  None of us were for sure who to trust.  In this situation even more than on the WWW because in that one Safir made the mistake of laying low as finder and viewed Vem early in the game but did nothing about the info he found out.

 

7. One question: If you weren’t the Assassin, why would you post that you weren’t? It wouldn’t need to be said at all. Unless you’re a werewolf?

 

I had a thought. Maybe it's crazy, but hear me out.

 

What if the assassin were to reveal themselves? Since they have already used their one kill and all. That way, we'd have two known innocents.

That isn't a bad idea actually.  Having two confirmed innocents would definitely cut down our list of suspects.  Well, I guess we've got to start somewhere:  I am/was not the assassin.

I fully agree to the assassin revealing himself. At this point, it'll be a prudent thing to do. It'll give us another innocent or a conflict, and I don't think the werewolf will jump out and call himself the assassin in this case as it would cause him to be easily killed and not win. He's on his own, so he has to tread carefully.

 

I am not/nor was I ever the assassin.

Oh yeah, I'm not the assassin either.

 

Out of the 4 that posted at the time I did 3 of us said we were not the assassin.

 

 

 

I hope I have answered your questions alright, Xefan.  If you have anymore go ahead and ask.  I think it's a great idea for us  to case the remaining players and ask any questions they might have.  Good call.  As for being quiet... If you look at any of the other games I was in that is how I always am.

 

[Xefan]

I agree.  A lot of that was a stretch.  And you're right, I didn't see the other two post that they are/was not the Assassin.  I'll do some reviews on other people.  But my vote stays on you until I find someone more suspicious.

 

damane: Kryos just doesn't seem evil to me.  I could be wrong.  But I'll do my review on him next.  I just got school soon, so you'll have to wait.

[Amethea]

Admittedly, Naeann was one of the people I was suspicious of, although with precious little reason other than a hunch and something I found odd in one of her posts.  When Vemy was about to be lynched, she unvoted him right at the last minute, although Talya didn't count the unvote as she had already posted the results and that her (Naeann's) vote was glowed at the time.  She said that it was because she liked reading Vemy's reviews, but the timing is a little off to my mind.

 

I'll unvote til your review... that puts you at what? 5... I still think you are the most likely candidate but I like your reviews. 

 

Edit:Forgot to glow....

 

It could just be a coincidence, and I said earlier that I was clutching at straws, but this nagged at me for some reason.  Mind you, what with playing in the Nuthouse game and all, I guess I'm just becoming overly used to looking for things that may or may not be there.

 

I'll hold my vote for now, as I'll be doing yet another reread later on.

[damane]

I fully agree to the assassin revealing himself. At this point, it'll be a prudent thing to do. It'll give us another innocent or a conflict, and I don't think the werewolf will jump out and call himself the assassin in this case as it would cause him to be easily killed and not win. He's on his own, so he has to tread carefully.

 

I am not/nor was I ever the assassin.

 

This struck me funny that Kryos would call the werewolf a "He" and "He's on his own"

Any thoughts on this one?

[Raena]

I fully agree to the assassin revealing himself. At this point, it'll be a prudent thing to do. It'll give us another innocent or a conflict, and I don't think the werewolf will jump out and call himself the assassin in this case as it would cause him to be easily killed and not win. He's on his own, so he has to tread carefully.

 

I am not/nor was I ever the assassin.

 

This struck me funny that Kryos would call the werewolf a "He" and "He's on his own"

Any thoughts on this one?

Maybe he just associates werewolf = male. I dunno.

 

 

I'm also suspicious of Naeann. Not only because of the quote Amethea has in her post, but because she

votes for Kryos when the vote count looked like this yesterday:

 

Vote Count

 

the dude: 1 (DSage)

Kryos: 2 (the dude, damane)

Loreina: 3 (Amethea, Raena, Kryos)

 

An attempt to swing the votes toward an innocent Kryos instead of the werewolf Loreina?

 

 

On the other hand, I'm not convinced that Kryos is innocent. Mainly because of what I've already said, the way he suddenly took away his vote from Vemynal. But I don't know.

 

 

[Kryos]

Am I going to have to vote for myself again just to prove that I'm innocent? And I refer to werewolf as "he" in a generalized term. Some may think it is me so it would be appropriate for them to say he, some think it isn't so they'll use a she... I just use "he" as it is quicker to type, and I'm not the only male left that I saw so :p Just because the other proclaimed being the assassin doesn't necessarily make it a true statement, though of course there isn't much choice in the matter in believing that one as everyone else has denied being the assassin save you damane, and I can surmise by your lack of statement that you would be saying you aren't the assassin. So that means Xefan and Damane are both innocent and you both are off the hook. That leaves Raena, Naeenn, Amethea, and myself, and personally, with Raena being the one to suggest the assassin reveal himself/herself, I doubt that would make Raena the werewolf, so in my eyes, that leaves but 2 people left. If you want to vote for me, then by all means do so, and I'll vote for myself to ensure the votes are cast swiftly, but it'll prove futile. So in my eyes it is either Naeenn or Amethea now that is the werewolf. Naeenn seems the most suspicious to me. Believe me or not, but that is how the cookie crumbles.

 

So until swayed otherwise, [glow=red,2,300]Naeann[/glow]

[Amethea]

It's possible that if Raena was the werewolf, then she could have been trying to draw suspicion away from herself by suggesting the assassin reveal.  As it is, though, that's just one of many what-ifs to think of in a game like this.  Pure speculation, and no fact.

 

Still, I can't get over that doubt about Naeann.  I also have a hunch about Kryos, but that could just be concerned with the points already raised earlier in this thread. 

 

Perhaps it's time for me to act on my first hunch and see whether it's correct or not.  I don't have anything else solid to act on, so I'll vote for [glow=red,2,300]Naeann[/glow].

[Raena]

Naeann is the most suspicious to me as well, so. [glow=red,2,300]Vote: Naeann[/glow]

[Naeann]

Going on a hunch and one odd post... that is only odd because it was seconds before Talya ended that day.  I only saw he had 6 votes and it still woulda gone to night had Talya checked tallys and went with it. (as she did) Some go ahead and take the vote off to let people try to retaliate or review others dont and say forget your review lets just kill you.  I like to let people retaliate.   I'm also in nuthouse and see that is common among the experienced players.    Had I posted that an hour before Talya checked the game it would not have seemed that odd.  As for why I  voted Kryos... Dude made a very strong case against him and I agreed with his post.  Kryos, the I'm voting for myself thing so you feel sorry for me only works once per game. ;)  

 

I'll vote [glow=red,2,300]Amathea[/glow].... just because she seems most suspicious to me and because quite often in the game you say "I'm holding my vote for now for such and such."  Just seems fishy... like you might be working with your team on your next move.  

[Amethea]

As you wish.  I usually say I'm holding my vote to either give people a chance to respond, or because I haven't quite made up my mind.  I voted for you because the hunch I had about you was slightly stronger than the one for Kryos.  And I admitted that I was clutching at straws just to reach my decision, too.  Still, if I go overnight or tomorrow, it's been a good game.

[Talya]

Naeann (3): Kryos, amethea, Raena

 

Amethea (1): Naeann

 

4 votes to lynch guys...

[Raena]

Didn't Xefan vote for Naeann as well? This post: http://forums.dragonmount.com/index.php/topic,19643.msg536221.html#msg536221

[Naeann]

Thats what I've been trying to type for ten frigging minutes now.... i hate this stupid computer.... yes, Xefan voted for me too Talya so just kill me off.

[Kryos]

Didn't Xefan vote for Naeann as well? This post: http://forums.dragonmount.com/index.php/topic,19643.msg536221.html#msg536221

 

Yup, it's hard to tell in the post that's for sure, but I saw it... Someone kick Talya... I won't, she may bite me.

[Talya]

Oh you wish Kryos... ;)

 

Well sorry guys I'm not at home...so didn't check as well as I should have...

 

Well after finding the bodies you are so enraged by what you see that. Someone shouts Naeann's name, next thing everyone is shouting it, she tries to protest, and in the end just gives up.

 

this time damane grabs the gun, and says that she wants to do it. With a gratifying look on her face she pulls the trigger at Naeann.

 

You all watch transfixed as the sliver bullet enters her, nothing..or at aleast at first then slowly her purty face turns into a werewolf. The third and final werewolf is dead.

 

The innocents have won and they throw the biggest party this side of the millenium....the werewolves are gone

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

till the next time.....mwuhahahahahahahahaha

 

 

Yep the Innocents won...lol

[Amethea]

Excellent!  I can't believe we won!

[Xefan]

Wow!  Amazing!  What a presen to recieve upon my return to my humble abode!  ;D

 

We did it!  Wahoooooo!

[Raena]

Oh yeah!!  ;D