FIDDLETON-UNDER-LYME ~ Werewolf mafia game

[Leelou]

I'm just doing what vemy suggests, that's going with a gut feeling. And quite frankly I'm not sure you are evil but you sure are attacking me and I don't see  any real reason for it. I've told you I'm innocent and you'll find that out like I said after y'all lynch me.

[damane]

well i guess we shall see...

[damane]

the reason is that you haven't given me any reason not to other than trying to play a guilt trip on me and that's not a good enough reason

[Leelou]

It's the first day. the only think I can do is stress that I am innocent.

[Vemynal]

As its page 20, I'll do a review again. But It likely won't be up this page or by page 21 since I don't know when I can do it

[damane]

soooooo am i.....

[Dark Justice]

Right. Im considering changing my vote here, to get the game moving. Just dont get the bad vibe of Leelou though..

[Toy and Minion]

Dude, you asked how new I am a couple pages back.

 

I played the Pirates at Sea that Talya modded, though it don't count in my book, seeing as I was rarely there at all.

 

I played the Suras hunt and sacrificed myself on Day 1 so that the chances of losing a roled innocent were less.

 

I played the Wild Wild West where I was Night Killed Night 1.

 

I am playing this game.

 

So, to answer your question:  I'm sort of in limbo between Newbie and "experienced" (Played more than 3 games)

[Naeann]

Wow Dsage.... It looks as though Leelou might be at least a bit more experienced than you... She has at least lasted all the way thru the games she has played.  Guys!! Lets be nice and let him live thru a day for once! lol

[Toy and Minion]

It's my karma.  I just couldn't help it.  I just had to steal that old mans cane...  *shakes head*

[Naeann]

*sends good Karma Dsage's way*

[Toy and Minion]

*:-* Nae*

[Vemynal]

So Dsage, is it late enough for you to dance in your room and take a drag on your cig yet?^^

 

 

[damane]

Dsage just doesn't feel right to me, but i could be wrong...i need proof.

*looks at Dsage*Are you evil?

i want to watch too

[Toy and Minion]

Yes, it's late enough Vem.  The Lunar Equinox isn't right for it though.

 

damane: Yes-NO!  Oh dammit!  I always get that question wrong!  *sorry, just got done watching Summer Sucks... >.>*

 

What are you expecting me to say?  Everyone playing this game would say they are innocent.  Sort of a retorical(sp?) question, huh?

[Toy and Minion]

Oh, damn!  Knew I was forgetting something, dude.  I also played in the Double-Blind and was Ishamael.  I lasted until about Night 4.  That game right there probably made up for my recent games, though...

[Talya]

Leelou (6): Damane, Raena, loreina, Amethea, Cloudcrono, Naeann

Dsage (3): Dark Justice, vemynal, Xefan

Vemy (2): Kryos,

Damane (1): Leelou

 

7 votes to lynch

[Toy and Minion]

What the hell.  [glow=red,2,300]Leelou[/glow]

 

Sorry, babe.

[Vemynal]

Dsage.. i finished you part of the review a while ago, then you go and do a thing like vote XD

 

make me work harder /mumbles

 

i've been working on this damn thing for 5 hours already and I'm only just done with Raena! >.<

 

well, best to get this damned day over with so we can get past this boredom of day 1. i think its been a turn off to the new players (specifically kryos and Xefan, haven't seen them post much).

 

now if you'll excuse me, I have a date with Xefan's posts (luckily so few XD) and its 2:14 am atm XD

[Toy and Minion]

Your welcome Vem.

 

ah, you're an hour behind me.

[damane]

*looks at Dsage quizzically* well who would expect anything at this point..

[Vemynal]

Blue-confirmed innocent

Purple-roled innocent (assassin, healer and finder)

Yellow-unknown

Orange-Symp

Red-Murderer

 

Note: I'm editing out useless details this time round, last time the reviews for each person were slightly over sized because I added things like "Kryos thinks we won't get a murderer day 1". not helpful but also not evil.

 

Alive:

Kryos- Loreina questions his reasoning and Kryos questions loreina for defending me and explains that its his gut instinct and he feels justified in it. Says he will begin watching Loreina a lot more closely. Says he can't wait to see my review, but wonders whether he can trust it. since his post saying he's waiting for my review he hasn't posted again, so kryos, if you see this. plz post so we know your at least ok and reading the thread. In sum: Kryos suspects I'm evil and he's also not showing any signs of newbie mistakes as an evil or experienced mistakes as an evil. He's either really inactive or really quiet, which to take something from that is meta-gaming. For now, me thinking he's innocent

 

Dark Justice- votes for Dsage saying that while no one is standing out as truly suspicious, Dsage is still being more suspicious then others and that there are a couple other people he's watching. dark comments that while he's not convinced Dsage is evil, he's the best choice for the time. Asks Dude who would be better to vote for. Agrees with Dude that the finder should view me night 1. Says Dude is good with hunches. agrees with cloud but asks for me not to be killed till I'm viewed. he later calls for people to vote so we don't face w/e talya has for us. Most recently Dark has expressed possibly unvoting Dark for leelou to get things moving. in sum: Votes Dsage and stay quiet. To get to day 2 he has expressed unvoting Dsage for leelou. He doesn’t want me lynched till I’m a confirmed evil, which Dude agrees with him. But Dark agrees that I’m really suspicious and probably an evil. i don't find him that suspicious or Dude that suspicious but I'm really curious about Cloud, though this is the wrong spot for that.

 

Vemynal- i thought an experienced player might be evil, I’m certain that Dsage is evil. I leave it to someone else to review me.

 

Naeann- Doesn’t vote anyone before my previous review and spamed some. says she was sick and couldn't really play in the beginning. says she doesn't like voting Dsage because he keeps dying day 1, but that he looks more suspicious then some. votes leelou because she has the most votes. Thinks me, Dsage and cloud are acting weird and that cloud's "seriously long defense" is something a symp might do. Doesn't know who to believe. Just now called for us to not kill Dsage because he's played less then leelou (/cough sob story /cough). spams a bit with him. I'd link nae to Dsage and Amethea for her slightly random vote for nae. I think she's suspicious because i think Dsage is evil and she has a back him up repeatedly by this point with the sole exception of calling cloud a possible symp.

 

Amethea- She's looking for people laying low which explain her vote for nae. explains her symp/assassin comment. Amethea later unvotes naeann and comments shes going to look at both leelou and Dsage, eventually she votes leelou. Amethea has always been a very non-active poster who thinks things through and is slow to vote. Thats what I'm seeing here. I do slightly place her with naeann because her voting Nae could have just been a trick to separate them. if nae's evil i'd suggest lookign at her closely, but pardoning that for now I think she's innocent.

 

Leelou- leelou starts off having already been voted for by damane, doesn’t vote back. Votes Dsage on the comment that I convinced her it is a little weird about her voting Dsage, my review of Dsage has only managed to convince her and Xefan of his guilt. Comments she doesn't know what she can do to make us see her as innocent. Dude feels bad when she asks him to unvote her since shes new and he eventually does. claims repeatedly if we lynch her we lose an innocent. leelou unvotes Dsage and votes Damane, claiming while she knows it won't do any good, she feels justified in her decision and disputes her innocence and Damane's possible guilt.  And because of everyone else's various confusion to what in the hell i was saying I find it a little weird. in Sum: keeping my eye on her, just not enough for me to unvote Dsage, but definantly on a "list" of candidates.

 

Cloudcrono- Agrees with me on my experienced player theory. Cloud disagrees with me about Dsage and says Dsage is just being Dsage. He says he will look over everyone, especially me and Dsage. first post of page 14 Cloud cases me for being evil and then proceeds to vote me, his excuse for not casing dsage (as evil or innocent) is that I'm so obviously evil he shouldn't have to. He seriously comes to Dsages defense and spend what looks like an absorbent amount of time on his case of me, what so horribly valuable about Dsage to him to defend? Nonetheless Cloud could just be an innocent person trying to help out Dsage because Vemy is picking on him. But is Dsage turns out evil then Cloud is like my prim suspect as an evil or as the symp. Votes leelou in an attempt to avoid a random kill. Questions Damane as to who she says she will vote next (she claimed to know). In sum: well, i kinda already said my sum. if Dsage is evil I'm gunning for cloud faster then a fat kid on a cupcake. I connect him to Dsage but thats about it

 

Dsage- I'm gonna skip my case of Dsage from last time and just go with what i should have said all along. My instinct tells me he's evil. No he hasn't really done anything obviously suspicious for day 1. But he certainly feels it to me and I don't see a reason to remove my vote. moving on: Dsage defends himself against my case. Dsage then votes me for pressing my vote against him so much. Dsage claims he doesn't care any more. Dsage unvotes me once its finally made clear that its my instinct thats causing me to vote him and that the case and everything was to try and explain why I felt this way. explains his playing experience to Dude.  He's the 7th and final vote on leelou. In sum: whats the first thing I said? My instinct says he's evil, i wasn't wrong in the vampire game and I'm not wrong here =/

 

Raena- In her first post answers my question about the symp. says she doesn't know what the assassin does. Raena doubts the idea of an experienced player *for sure* being evil (its good reasoning, top of page 8 ). Asks me whether Dsage wanting a coroner report is what made me think he's evil (A: no). Claims Dude's hunches are usually right. Raena votes leelou but claims because I'm so active I need "watching". Says she's not convinced Dsage is evil, but not convinced to unvote Dsage. Says that they should be careful when discussing who the finder should view. Hasn't posted since then (few pages ago). still seems innocent to me, but I'd link her with damane though only for them choosing the same person to vote for (which eventually killed leelou as we now see)

 

Xefan- hadn’t voted for anyone prior to my review. Afterward he also votes Dsage because it seems Dsage is trying to gain sympathy. That post 2 days ago was the most recent post of Xefans. evil or no evil, I'm a bit worried =/. in sum: where he go? still not enough information. linked to leelou only because either i some how convinced him or Dsage's sympathy parade somehow went in reverse on him when everyone else got weak kneed.

 

Loreina- doubts that its an experienced player for the fact of just being experienced. questions Kryos' reasons for voting me. she says that it is strange of Dsage to be so happy that its a coroner game and comments about Dsage knowing if he kills a roled innocent. Comments its odd Damane picking leelou at random. Agrees with the dude about voting with you instinct. Loreina goes over information she finds important. because she trusts Dude and others have voted leelou she votes leelou. in sum: I'd link loreina to Kryos and Dude for the time being. shes a little less suspicious then last time. But her fight with Kryos was just so blatant with neither voting for the other that I really don't believe it.

 

Damane- votes for leelou off the bat. comments that Dsage is just to obvious a choice for being evil, that it can't be right. comments that she thinks all those voting for Dsage are werewolves (and while I'm not at least. technically the reasoning she gives is very good. middle pg.14). Sticks with her vote because leelou hasn't defended herself. Heres omething i actually ddin't understand: And also Vemy having a hunch and voting for DSage, well let's just ask ourselves who's innocent and who isn't..Cause is Vemy is evil, then his hunch(for him) might be right. i just can't tell if shes really saying that because I'm likely evil that Dsage is likely evil or what shes saying. Says she doesn't plan on unvoted leelou. comments she knows who shes voting next. and i think I finally get how I looked while trying to get you guys to understand me about Dsage, cuz damane is looking horribly suspicious for pursuing leelou so hard. Thing is, since I know I'm not evil and did that that Damane here could also not be evil and doing that. We could just have similar playing styles (we bother are rather blunt and loud it seems). Starts to question Dsage. In sum: damane is looking suspicious as heck, but there is still the fact that she could have just made the same mistake that i did in pursuing the person she thinks is evil. I want a bit more time observing this one before we start to reel her in for anything.

 

my god >.> done at last.

 

that took me 6 hours >.<

 

its 3am >.<

 

in any event I'm going to bed, hopefully we know leelou's role by that time.

 

I also leave for work tomorrow same time as always durign the week (1:30pm), but I don't know if I will really be comign home because i may be seeing a movie with friends tomorrow night after I go to college orientation (its basically a BBQ on the campus field^^). so after i leave for work tomorrow. don't expect me back till *LATE*

[damane]

okay what i was saying about the hunch was that yes Vemy's hunch could be right for Dsage because Vemy is (not Dsage)evil. Does that make more sense? if not i can explain further..i just thought the evils were trying to kill off us innocents, and if that's the case then Vemy would want to vote off Dsage because he is innocent. Better? Geez, i didn't want to post a book, but i guess maybe that's what it comes down to. and yes i'm hard headed until proven wrong. and yes i'm innocent, but i know just saying that doesn't make anyone believe it. So, if further explanation is needed, will do. i'm just reading posts and trying to put two and three together.

[Toy and Minion]

I don't know if I understood you corectly.  Let me clarify for the newest newbs.  Innocents don't know who any one is.  Werewolves know who their fellow werewolves are, therefore, they know who the innocents are.  What we have in our favour is that the werewolves don't know who the Healer, Finder, or Assassin are.  But then, we don't know who they are either, but still.

 

When I read your post, damane, it sounded like it's a known fact that Vemy is evil because he is trying to kill me.  I dunno about that.  Us innocents are trying to kill the werewolves just as bad as they're trying to kill us.  The thing is, a werewolf isn't going to say he's a werewolf, they're going to say they're innocent.  So that's where it becomes tricky.  Who to trust?

 

I personally don't think Vem is evil, he's just going after the wrong guy here (me).

[the dude]

Hey DSage  8)

 

I'm still reading this last page of posts, but I thought I'd interject here after seeing a couple of your posts.

 

First, I was mostly just teasing about how new you were; just a lame joke on my part.  :-[

 

And you were in the Double Blind!?  That's a harrowing experience for just about anyone...  DAMN I was so close to taking it down too....  Aaaah, good times.

 

Okay, back to reading up for this game....