MAFIA - The Suras Hunt [Public Thread]

[Vemynal]

On the bright side though, there are 7 players left! and since theres only 1 assassin that means you can break a few eggs to figure out who it is.

 

List of remaining players:

 

Barm

Admiral

Minister

Loki

Danya

Hax

FDM

[Cleopatra Narisse]

I have missed a lot of days and just cannot go through reading 22 pages to find this answer, if its there but, can the Minister or the Admiral be the assassin?

[Alys Kinch]

Wes, I hope you don't mind that I pm'd him merely to ask if you had restrictions on what could be done with the posts. I don't know if anyone other than Loki has caught on yet, so... :D

[Alys Kinch]

and, btw, I knew there would be some roulette actions soon!

[Vemynal]

Wes, I hope you don't mind that I pm'd him merely to ask if you had restrictions on what could be done with the posts. I don't know if anyone other than Loki has caught on yet, so... :D

 

hmm?

[Alys Kinch]

Loki found the orange in Fiddles. I asked Wes about it.

 

And Vemy, if you know a secret about me... pm me and I might confirm.

[cloudcrono]

Oh Vemmy btw at one point you switched your vote from yourself back to Loki. Why?

 

Cleo:  Technically anyone could be it at this point but the general consensus is that they are probably not and it seems to me that technically DPR confirmed it through his recent postings but the choice is up to you.

[Vemynal]

because Wes pmed me giving me information about those upcoming 3 posts and said that I shouldn't kill myself off just yet and he was giving us more time^^

[DPR]

 

When I PM'd Vemy it was more or less to say "don't vote for yourself!". The main point was that an innocent player does not help their team by voting for themselves- It's a tempting and dramatic move (I've done it) but the bottom line is that every innocent who lives makes it that much harder for the scum to win. Self sacrificing is as pointless as a role reveal with no info to give. And, we have all seen lynches get one vote away, only to turn on new information.  Vemy did not know that I was going to extend the deadline and he was just trying to avoid a finder/healer random kill, so I thought it fair to give him the hint. 

 

And to Alys, I don't mind. There have actually been more than a couple of options/plays/ and spots with "wiggle room" that needed to be more clear. 

 

Last, Cloud made an observation about who he assassin might be.  it important to know that anyone could be the assassin and that the storyline moves along as if everyone alive is still innocent.

 

[Alys Kinch]

Thanks for saying wes. I got into trouble before... ;)

[Vemynal]

Save Hax! its been my suspicion since before the black bonestone has been played that he is our healer.

 

Either way it has to be him or FDM and those are bad odds to be messing with!

[DPR]

 

I just saw Alys' post - how did you get into trouble? I go by Wes, Dreadpirateroberts, or DPR. Or W. And I'm threatening to ask kathana to change me once and for all to Tony Sinclair. Ready to Tanqueray?

[cloudcrono]

Save Hax.  I got a good feeling about it.  Its the closing of the game and if Hax is the healer you will be in even more trouble.  Well if you guys get to normal day and night actions again.

 

Damn I must say this is a really interesting game.

[Vemynal]

Admiral, if he's evil then that means we will get a new evil and have no idea who it is and have to start over again

[Alys Kinch]

wes, with kivam...

[Kivam]

Save Hax! its been my suspicion since before the black bonestone has been played that he is our healer.

 

Either way it has to be him or FDM and those are bad odds to be messing with!

 

Dude - NEVER out the healer.  NEVER.  I don't care how strong your suspicion is, unless they are one vote away from killing him.

 

This is why I always think you're evil - even when you're trying to be innocent, you help the wrong side.

[Vemynal]

Kivam, I'm not exactly dropping a bomb shell now am I? If FDM, Hax, and Loki are the only remaining 3 possible to be the healer are left. And loki has confirmed he is not the healer (by saying so and admiting switching to the evil side before) that leaves only FDM and Hax.

 

Which btw we don't know I'm right, i could me wrong.

 

And this isn't exactly rocket science, I expect if I figured this out then the murderer knows it as well.

[Kivam]

It doesn't matter how obvious it is (I've known for a while), there's always a chance that someone missed it.  You don't do the Mafia's work for them.  We can now pretty much guarantee that Danya will die within the next 3 game nights

[Kivam]

Lynch Far Dareis Mai

 

Why?

 

Because she's the healer, and she didn't heal Danya.  Only a guilty healer would choose themselves over the finder when the game has this few players.

 

And also because she just gave the worst ever "I'm not evil, can't be because I don't know how many evils there are" clue.

 

FDM, sorry if I'm reading this wrong, if you decided to guess at who they would target and guessed wrong, if you actually misread the rules on how the curse worked - but right now, there's more of a reason to think you're guilty than anyone else.  Lynching you is the smart play.

[Kivam]

FDM:

 

1) It didn't matter whether Danya was evil or innocent; Loki was innocent either way (if Danya was evil, nobody else was).  By the same token, any name Danya revealed as innocent today would have been innocent.

 

2) Because of that, the value of keeping Danya alive to reveal a second name outweighed the value of keeping yourself alive.

 

3) I think you're good enough at this game that you knew both 1 & 2.

 

Besides, if I'm wrong, the end game will be Barm, the Admiral and the Minister (since the assassin will kill the innocent and unprotected Loki at night), and I'd love to see what would Wes could do with that setup!

[Kivam]

Nope - even if Danya was evil, any name she revealed would be guaranteed to be innocent

[MsDanya]

this sux  :P

 

you wanna know why I wanted to lynch Hax? well it was because I thought he was evil. I knew FDM was the Healer, I knew Loki was innocent (FDM I am suprised that you didnt really believe me eventho I said it very clear that he IS innocent on the thread. if I didnt know better and was still alive,I would say you were evel just for contradicting my Finding)

 

and I also thought that HAx had a chance of having gone evil, since I had already viewed him once before.

 

oh well.. now I dont have a viewing and i'm dead.. *sighs*

[Kivam]

this sux  :P

 

you wanna know why I wanted to lynch Hax? well it was because I thought he was evil. I knew FDM was the Healer, I knew Loki was innocent (FDM I am suprised that you didnt really believe me eventho I said it very clear that he IS innocent on the thread. if I didnt know better and was still alive,I would say you were evel just for contradicting my Finding)

 

and I also thought that HAx had a chance of having gone evil, since I had already viewed him once before.

 

oh well.. now I dont have a viewing and i'm dead.. *sighs*

 

It's not that bad.

 

*shows Danya the secret room of chocolate*

[MsDanya]

weee!!!!  ;D

 

 

But advising people to off others, even if they are most likely innocent, is never good advice. But what happens, happens. *shrugs*

 

lol FDM, that was the probem. anyone that I hadnt viewed after the blackbonestone could be evil! no one is really most likely innocent, apart from those I have Viewed, but there wasnt that many to choose from, we only had 12 hours, and I had to go to bed  :P so I chose Hax.  :P

[cloudcrono]

*Continues to bite his nails as the epic drama unfolds even further.*

 

Kivam I wouldn't be surprised if DPR figured out a way to use that setup.  Although I think at this point even he is ready to wind down and finish this sucka.

 

I don't like why FDM did what she did.  It seems too suspicious.  Be careful guys.