Mafia: Wild Wild West

[Guest Barmacral]

For future reference, votes may be taken away and added each day until the mod shows up. If a person gains the required amount of votes, and then somebody unvotes before the mod shows up, that person will still be alive. However, since you've all agreed to end the day when you reached 5 votes, I will just pick up from there.

 

Taking SboydW’s example from the previous day Thorum marches Jackdaw into the middle of the street, hauling him by the scruff of his neck.

“Jackdaw is guilty. I know he is. I am certain of it.” Thorum shouts, while you watch on.  You are unsure what to do, since you suspect Jackdaw as well.

Thorum shoots Jackdaw in the back of the head, and his face explodes; a messy kill.

You search him closely, but find nothing.

 

Jackdaw, a roleless innocent is dead. It is now night, please send in your night actions ASAP.

 

[Naeann]

Dang... What a horrid way to go Jack.  :'(

[Vemynal]

Jesus Thorum O.o

 

I mean the guy annoyed me but that was bloody horrible.

 

Jackdaw, why o why do you have to keep coming after me? you've freaking doomed us.

 

I can count it already-

 

Sboyd has pretty much declared for me

Safir has voted for me before

Thorum has declared for me

Nae, considering I think her and twitchy are evil will probably go for me

Twitchy will bandwagon me whether he thinks I'm evil or not if I have 3 votes if for nothing else then self protection

 

I might as well face the music, I'm a dead man walking at this point =/

[Naeann]

Vemy... thats IF you make it that far... there's still the night killing.  Not worried about that?  *smirks*  You wouldn't be if you were evil.

[Vemynal]

Already mentioned this nae a few posts back, why in hell would the murder kill me during the night atm?

 

Right now I'm a sure lynch for day 5, which means if the night kill for nights 4 & 5 go through the murders win.

 

But then again I'm just restating your plan back to you arn't I nae :P

 

So wipe that smirk off your face till you've actually won, I'm not dead yet and I won't let them throw away our chance of winning this without a fight!

 

Safir, Twitchy, leelou! I'm calling on you guys here. Help me kill Nae! Don't let her kill an innocent for day 5 or you. will. lose. !

 

If the 4 of us band together and vote for her we can win this thing! plz! Twitchy, the only reason I'm asking you for help right now is because I'm still not 100% sure where your loyalties are. I can't believe I'm asking for the help of the #2 murderer on my list but if you arn't then plz stop this huge mistake!

 

They need 4 to lynch me; they have 3. If any one of you votes for me then I'm doomed, we are all doomed.

 

To everyone now!; Don't just throw our chances away!

 

If you think I'm evil then fine! But at least consider the chance you might be wrong and look at your fellows more closely!

 

Even if you think I'm evil their is one more of you who is evil, at least examine your fellows before you finish me off!

 

Plz!

[Naeann]

lol Vem I didn't say I was voting for you....

 

 

You keep attacking me this way and I'll  jump on the bandwagon but actually my vote is elsewhere at the moment.  I'm mulling thru in my head who i think the people with the rolles might be.

 

 

Can you give me a clear reason why you think I'm evil?  I can't see anything Calyn or I did that would make one think that.

[Thorum]

To all: let's keep it civil.

[Barmacral]

ALL PM'S NEED TO BE RESENT. MATALINA ACCIDENTLY DELETED MY ACCOUNT, SO ANY NIGHT ACTIONS I RECEIVED ARE GONE.

[Naeann]

Wow That sucks Barmy. :( 

[Vemynal]

I donno, I kinda like the idea of no one being night killed if the murder's don't notice

 

it won't happen I bet but I can hope

 

Ok Nae, since you asked i decided to case you (this isn't exactly a case but it isn't a player review either so I'm calling it a case)

 

DAY 1:

 

after Sboyd's first vote for Talya on day one:

Calyn: "Okay, you're right, good idea.

 

I still would like to wait until everyone is present to vote, if that's okay."

 

Hoping to save her?

 

 

 

 

Talya, a little later, with Calyn and Sboyd being the two most posters: "Kill off an inactive...higly likely to be innocent and you gain no info."

 

some later, still Talya: "Calyn...nothing there neither"

 

Calyn, still day one: "My reluctance to vote for either experienced player stands at this point"

 

In the end, she jumps on the Dorrin-bandwagon.

 

 

 

DAY 2

 

"Vemy, you're being so fumbly you're either evil and trying too hard or just innocent and fumbly. I can't decide which. You kinda freaked me out with your emotional displays earlier. I am going to have to think on it harder. (But PS congrats on passing your exams!!!)": Calyn was much more fumbly than me in the start (see her giant switches in the above quote and the one above that as well)

 

NIGHT 2

 

"WOW!  WE GOT ONE!!

 

No thanks to me... I didn't see that one coming either, yikes.  I must have bad instincts."

 

Obviously trying to be not-knowing

repeats this a couple of times

 

DAY 3

"If it helps any i changed my mind three times before posting.": just after voting jackdaw; probably knowing it was wrong

 

"I didn't vote for you... and from reading the threads I'd have good reason to." Nae, voting for people just because they are voting for you is a bad idea, I've done it twice now (Dorrin, Jackdaw) both times were huge mistakes.

 

NIGHT 3

"How do you know I'll make it that far?  I could die on the night one." Not as afraid as before

 

"Vemy... thats IF you make it that far... there's still the night killing.  Not worried about that?  *smirks*  You wouldn't be if you were evil." Again, not as afraid of a night kill, almost as if waiting for it.

 

 

 

 

Now I'll admit Nae that this helped me, your question helped calm me down. I had gotten stuck in a "Lynch Nae! not me!" fervor and that could have lost us the game.

 

But I still think I have a illegitimate case against you so far, at this point one thats even better then the one I have for twitchy.

[Naeann]

Ok Nae, since you asked i decided to case you (this isn't exactly a case but it isn't a player review either so I'm calling it a case)

 

DAY 1:

 

after Sboyd's first vote for Talya on day one:

Calyn: "Okay, you're right, good idea.

 

I still would like to wait until everyone is present to vote, if that's okay."

 

Hoping to save her?

 

 

 

 

Talya, a little later, with Calyn and Sboyd being the two most posters: "Kill off an inactive...higly likely to be innocent and you gain no info."

 

some later, still Talya: "Calyn...nothing there neither"

 

Calyn, still day one: "My reluctance to vote for either experienced player stands at this point"

 

In the end, she jumps on the Dorrin-bandwagon.

 

 

 

DAY 2

 

"Vemy, you're being so fumbly you're either evil and trying too hard or just innocent and fumbly. I can't decide which. You kinda freaked me out with your emotional displays earlier. I am going to have to think on it harder. (But PS congrats on passing your exams!!!)": Calyn was much more fumbly than me in the start (see her giant switches in the above quote and the one above that as well)Might that be because WE ARE NEW TO THE GAME. Duh.

 

NIGHT 2

 

"WOW!  WE GOT ONE!!

 

No thanks to me... I didn't see that one coming either, yikes.  I must have bad instincts."

 

Obviously trying to be not-knowing

repeats this a couple of times

 

DAY 3

"If it helps any i changed my mind three times before posting.": just after voting jackdaw; probably knowing it was wrongMy other two possibilities were you and Twitchy... like I stated before..... looks too much like a conspiracy.

 

"I didn't vote for you... and from reading the threads I'd have good reason to." Nae, voting for people just because they are voting for you is a bad idea, I've done it twice now (Dorrin, Jackdaw) both times were huge mistakes.I didn't say "because you voted for me" nor would that be why I'd choose someone.  You have attemped to be manipulative and sneaky thru the whole game.  Trying to talk people into voting who you want gone.  If you are evil you know who your partners are and therefor know who the innocents are.

 

NIGHT 3

"How do you know I'll make it that far?  I could die on the night one." Not as afraid as before

 

"Vemy... thats IF you make it that far... there's still the night killing.  Not worried about that?  *smirks*  You wouldn't be if you were evil." Again, not as afraid of a night kill, almost as if waiting for it.lol Pot calling the kettle black... Not so much not being afraid of it as reaction to your panic attack at being possibly lynched. 

[Twitchy]

*Coughs*

If there were 2 Mafia's left, the game'd be over.

*Nods*

There goes conspiracy theory.

 

[Naeann]

How? I thought mafia had to have the same amount as civies to win?  There are still seven playing.  You gotta keep in mind this is the first time ive so much as seen this game, let alone  play it.

 

Plus Vemy keeps going on that you and I are both evil so I assumed there were 2 left.

[Safir]

As did I, Nae.  This is also a first time for me  :P

 

I think it is likely there are 2.  I hope 1, though.

[Naeann]

I remember where I know you from... the siggy... we commented on it in your welcome thread. *nods*

[Safir]

You did?  Funny :D

[Barmacral]

Twitchy crept along, determined to get out of this town before his time came, oblivious to those who followed him. A hand caught him from behind, and the cold steel of a broken spur split his throat open. It was the last thing he ever felt.

A gunshot rang out behind the assassins, who turned to see a dark figure running after them.

“Bloodhounds! All of you! I’ll have you dead for this.”

At the cry of the too familiar voice, which rankled the assassin’s memories without actually placing whom it belonged too the gang members turned and fled into the night. Quickly they disappeared and were not seen again.

“Cowards! You’ll not get away with this. I’ll have your head in a noose.”

To the east, the dawn broke, and light slowly illuminated the still expanding pool of Twitchy’s blood.

 

Twitchy, a roleless innocent is dead. Day 4 has begun, with 6 alive, it takes 4 to lynch.

 

[Safir]

Noooo...Twitch!

 

Damm them!

 

Well, any thoughts?  Are we going to follow jackdaws pleas, or something else?

[Vemynal]

Edit- To my below speculations, Barm has disproved them. You can read this for information that could help you in other games though.

 

 

Twitch wasn't an evil...

 

Nae, I may be wrong about you and believe me when I say I'll be holding off from voting till I can make sense of everything.

 

To everyone else, plz remember that if we don't kill a murder today then we are done for unless our protector finally gets it right (which is only a 1 in 5 shot)

 

So while I know everyone is itching to put the rope around my neck, plz at least take some time to view others.

 

 

Some good news! It sounds as if the finder found an evil! I doubt barm would have written there just for the show!

 

Some bad news, now the murderers may claim to be the finder. Which since we only have a day left to tell we can't decide whom to trust.

 

So while we know who 1 of the murderers is, who do we trust? And now knowing this, will the finder come forward at all? so will only a murder come forward?

 

Sadly it all come back to our own opinions again >.>

 

But at least we can suppose this much:

Because of how few people left there are and the murders close to winning, I doubt they will propose one of their own as a murder for today. So if we figure out who the murder is (pretending to be the finder) we can assume that player is innocent

 

For the real finder will propose a real murderer. So if we can figure out who the murder pretending to be a finder is we can 1) figure out either both the murders or one of the murders based on who the finder viewed/who the murderers choose to pretend to be the finder

 

We can figure out who 2 innocents are! 1 of which is roled and should be protected tonight!

 

There is yet hope^^

[Barmacral]

It was written there just for show. I do not leave hints in my scenes.

[Vemynal]

oh...

 

Well I am opposed to editing out things in this thread (other then grammar/spelling) so I'll leave it there.

 

But i'm gonna edit in a big, "I have been disproved" thing at the top.

 

Sides, i think it was either Barm or Talya in the seanchan game who explained that exact same thing to me and i found it useful for this game so I'll leave it as a tip for the new guys XD.

[SBoydW]

Well...... I thought I had the game figured..... Maybe not..... I'm debating still between naenn and vemy... though safir has been unusually quiet...

[Safir]

I've just been busy in RL, and didn't really have much to say.

[Vemynal]

I think Safir just doesn't get the chance to be on much Sboyd, that and he's the "Quiet & observant" type.

 

He explained this either end of day 1 or beginning of day 2. Don't remember when exactly

[Twitchy]

You big fat jerk murderer.

>:(

 

And yes, I know who you are too.

>:(