[Basic] Peg + Cat Mafia -- TOWN WIN

[Eldrick4221]

How would you feel about lynching Shanti after I flip town? Cuz she's the one that makes the most sense to me to be scum. And her being new has nothing to do with it.

 

Except for the beginning, she didn't interact with either Alex or Darthe.

 

She's the only one alive that didn't address Hally being the seer and change their actions accordingly. This is a good indication that she missed it (which has nothing to do with being new. Everybody misses stuff)

[Tigraine]

Guys I'm sitting in a Wendy's, eating a frosty I don't want just so I can uae their wifi to play mafia...I think I have a problem.

 

I don't know, how does everyone else feel about a Shanti Lynch? Has she been read as even slightly scummy by anyone? Honestly that makes me nervous but it's hard for me to think of lynching someone that reads so town. I get what you're saying Eldrick and it does make sense. I'm having so much trouble getting a real good read. Which maybe that's a good thing...I was %100 that ed would seal the deal, then I KNEW it had to be Adella. I've been wrong.

 

It's throwing me completely off my game. I'd like to hear from Tress, Shanti, and Spades on this all. Is like to see what Shanti has to say in regards to what you've said.

 

But I'm leaving Wendy's, will try to be back in a few hours.

[Shanti]

Woah. I go out to celebrate my weightless accomplishment and come back to being scum. Not NKing Hally was not a rookie mistake, I didn't NK her, or anyone else for that matter because I don't have that ability as Vanilla Town.

 

I was fist to vote Alex in the beginning, because right off the bat he pinged me. Albeit Redd pinged me too, but apparently that was just his playstyle.

 

IIR, I remember stating that I did not like being in agreement with Eld but his points were good ones.

 

But, tbh, this entire game he has frustrated me. Almost from day one he has had the attitude of, kill me I don't care and as your teammate, Eld... and as someone who is new, it would have been nice to have support before the last day. Oh wait... you still aren't really supporting your teammate. You have your vote on me AND tried to lynch yourself... maybe you so have SOME self preservation in there and the whole, fine lynch me, was a bluff. Maybe you're the wolf and you focused on me because the other two were defending themselves and I was an easy target for being new and silent at the time.

 

What is even more frustrating is your response to my vote, which is you, will be to vote yourself, or to stop trying. In my whole one and 3/4 games of Mafia, I have never seen a townie want to be lynched as much as you do, and it has increased since Alex and Darthe have been lynched. Maybe you voted Alex because he wasn't a good teammate and pissed you off, maybe you lynched Darthe because you felt alone and backed into a corner and thought hmmm. This would be the perfect cover, then I can show lack of self preservation and blatantly act wolf so they won't think I'm wolf anymore. Brilliant plan if it's you, kudos for a game well played. I do hope I am wrong and you arent scum, but I havent felt like you were my teammate this entire game, which sucks.

 

[v] Eld [/v]

[Shanti]

Woah. I go out to celebrate my weightless accomplishment and come back to being scum. Not NKing Hally was not a rookie mistake, I didn't NK her, or anyone else for that matter because I don't have that ability as Vanilla Town.

I was fist to vote Alex in the beginning, because right off the bat he pinged me. Albeit Redd pinged me too, but apparently that was just his playstyle.

IIR, I remember stating that I did not like being in agreement with Eld but his points were good ones.

But, tbh, this entire game he has frustrated me. Almost from day one he has had the attitude of, kill me I don't care and as your teammate, Eld... and as someone who is new, it would have been nice to have support before the last day. Oh wait... you still aren't really supporting your teammate. You have your vote on me AND tried to lynch yourself... maybe you so have SOME self preservation in there and the whole, fine lynch me, was a bluff. Maybe you're the wolf and you focused on me because the other two were defending themselves and I was an easy target for being new and silent at the time.

What is even more frustrating is your response to my vote, which is you, will be to vote yourself, or to stop trying. In my whole one and 3/4 games of Mafia, I have never seen a townie want to be lynched as much as you do, and it has increased since Alex and Darthe have been lynched. Maybe you voted Alex because he wasn't a good teammate and pissed you off, maybe you lynched Darthe because you felt alone and backed into a corner and thought hmmm. This would be the perfect cover, then I can show lack of self preservation and blatantly act wolf so they won't think I'm wolf anymore. Brilliant plan if it's you, kudos for a game well played. I do hope I am wrong and you arent scum, but I havent felt like you were my teammate this entire game, which sucks.

[v] Eld [/v]

Weightloss not weightless

[Songstress]

Woah. I go out to celebrate my weightless accomplishment and come back to being scum. Not NKing Hally was not a rookie mistake, I didn't NK her, or anyone else for that matter because I don't have that ability as Vanilla Town.

 

I was fist to vote Alex in the beginning, because right off the bat he pinged me. Albeit Redd pinged me too, but apparently that was just his playstyle.

 

IIR, I remember stating that I did not like being in agreement with Eld but his points were good ones.

 

But, tbh, this entire game he has frustrated me. Almost from day one he has had the attitude of, kill me I don't care and as your teammate, Eld... and as someone who is new, it would have been nice to have support before the last day. Oh wait... you still aren't really supporting your teammate. You have your vote on me AND tried to lynch yourself... maybe you so have SOME self preservation in there and the whole, fine lynch me, was a bluff. Maybe you're the wolf and you focused on me because the other two were defending themselves and I was an easy target for being new and silent at the time.

 

What is even more frustrating is your response to my vote, which is you, will be to vote yourself, or to stop trying. In my whole one and 3/4 games of Mafia, I have never seen a townie want to be lynched as much as you do, and it has increased since Alex and Darthe have been lynched. Maybe you voted Alex because he wasn't a good teammate and pissed you off, maybe you lynched Darthe because you felt alone and backed into a corner and thought hmmm. This would be the perfect cover, then I can show lack of self preservation and blatantly act wolf so they won't think I'm wolf anymore. Brilliant plan if it's you, kudos for a game well played. I do hope I am wrong and you arent scum, but I havent felt like you were my teammate this entire game, which sucks.

 

[v] Eld [/v]

 

Eldrick actually didn't vote Alex, he voted Tigraine when he was tied in votes with Alex.

[Shanti]

 

Woah. I go out to celebrate my weightless accomplishment and come back to being scum. Not NKing Hally was not a rookie mistake, I didn't NK her, or anyone else for that matter because I don't have that ability as Vanilla Town.

I was fist to vote Alex in the beginning, because right off the bat he pinged me. Albeit Redd pinged me too, but apparently that was just his playstyle.

IIR, I remember stating that I did not like being in agreement with Eld but his points were good ones.

But, tbh, this entire game he has frustrated me. Almost from day one he has had the attitude of, kill me I don't care and as your teammate, Eld... and as someone who is new, it would have been nice to have support before the last day. Oh wait... you still aren't really supporting your teammate. You have your vote on me AND tried to lynch yourself... maybe you so have SOME self preservation in there and the whole, fine lynch me, was a bluff. Maybe you're the wolf and you focused on me because the other two were defending themselves and I was an easy target for being new and silent at the time.

What is even more frustrating is your response to my vote, which is you, will be to vote yourself, or to stop trying. In my whole one and 3/4 games of Mafia, I have never seen a townie want to be lynched as much as you do, and it has increased since Alex and Darthe have been lynched. Maybe you voted Alex because he wasn't a good teammate and pissed you off, maybe you lynched Darthe because you felt alone and backed into a corner and thought hmmm. This would be the perfect cover, then I can show lack of self preservation and blatantly act wolf so they won't think I'm wolf anymore. Brilliant plan if it's you, kudos for a game well played. I do hope I am wrong and you arent scum, but I havent felt like you were my teammate this entire game, which sucks.

[v] Eld [/v]

 

 

Eldrick actually didn't vote Alex, he voted Tigraine when he was tied in votes with Alex.

I know, it was mentioned I bussed Alex, that was my response. When I DID follow Elds lead, it was on Darthe and that is ehen I didn't like agreeing with Eld, but felt he was right.

 

Pick me apart, I don't mind and I won't back down. I have nothing to hide.

[Songstress]

 

 

Woah. I go out to celebrate my weightless accomplishment and come back to being scum. Not NKing Hally was not a rookie mistake, I didn't NK her, or anyone else for that matter because I don't have that ability as Vanilla Town.

I was fist to vote Alex in the beginning, because right off the bat he pinged me. Albeit Redd pinged me too, but apparently that was just his playstyle.

IIR, I remember stating that I did not like being in agreement with Eld but his points were good ones.

But, tbh, this entire game he has frustrated me. Almost from day one he has had the attitude of, kill me I don't care and as your teammate, Eld... and as someone who is new, it would have been nice to have support before the last day. Oh wait... you still aren't really supporting your teammate. You have your vote on me AND tried to lynch yourself... maybe you so have SOME self preservation in there and the whole, fine lynch me, was a bluff. Maybe you're the wolf and you focused on me because the other two were defending themselves and I was an easy target for being new and silent at the time.

What is even more frustrating is your response to my vote, which is you, will be to vote yourself, or to stop trying. In my whole one and 3/4 games of Mafia, I have never seen a townie want to be lynched as much as you do, and it has increased since Alex and Darthe have been lynched. Maybe you voted Alex because he wasn't a good teammate and pissed you off, maybe you lynched Darthe because you felt alone and backed into a corner and thought hmmm. This would be the perfect cover, then I can show lack of self preservation and blatantly act wolf so they won't think I'm wolf anymore. Brilliant plan if it's you, kudos for a game well played. I do hope I am wrong and you arent scum, but I havent felt like you were my teammate this entire game, which sucks.

[v] Eld [/v]

 

Eldrick actually didn't vote Alex, he voted Tigraine when he was tied in votes with Alex.

I know, it was mentioned I bussed Alex, that was my response. When I DID follow Elds lead, it was on Darthe and that is ehen I didn't like agreeing with Eld, but felt he was right.

 

Pick me apart, I don't mind and I won't back down. I have nothing to hide.

 

 

That makes no sense.

[Shad_]

OFFICIAL VOTE COUNT

 

Eldrick (2) - Tigraine, Shanti

 

Shanti (1) - Eldrick

 

Not Voting: Songstress, Spadeszee

 

 

With 5 alive, it takes 3 to lynch.

 

[Shanti]

Oops, my bad. I totally missed that. I have zero explanation that actually. Not sure why I would put it.

[Songstress]

@ Spades - you're the only one i trust completely here... I went into this day phase like you, thinking it had to be Eldrick or Tigs and we'd be good going one then the other.

 

I've been ridiculously bad this game and don't even remotely trust my judgment.

 

However, if Shanti is mafia, at least I got one thing right and the N1 kill was specifically not a seer hunt.  I can see a world in which Darthe decided to pull fancy play syndrome out of the hat N1 to sow confusion later in the game.  Heck, the fact that it's gone this far after 2 mafia lynches in 2 days means whatever choices they made, they were impressive indeed.

 

What do you think of Shanti's reaction here? 

[Shanti]

Maybe I'm still drunk. I did partake in gratuitous amounts of alcohol yesterday, but while typing it, for some reason I thought he had voted for Alex and Darthe both, but then once I got finished I reread Elds last bit and forgot O typed that

[Eldrick4221]

 

I still want to lynch lzm because of his interactions with Alex and Ed. Really getting a connection vibe there.

But Hally is making me want to switch to her. Her response to tress' question and her seemingly OMGUS vote on Aussie being the biggest reasons.

Not to mention her focus on us not voting LAM who is reading scummy to multiple people.

  

 

 

Tress gets it...

I do as well, I just need to sniff out the scum and need some help from people have more experience.

I take extreme offense to this, not to mention you're incessant defence of Halli is seeming more wolfy by the minute

  

 

Do we believe in a Eldrick/Cass-Dice w/w world right now?

 

Eldrick is pushing SO HARD at trying to get Hallia or LMZ lynched right now. It doesn't feel right coming from him at all.

While there is a lot that I disagree with when it comes to Eld, I find his reasoning to be quite good on Halli AND LAM. Wanna call me scum too? I feel like I've fought pretty hard to show I'm Town. I'm also pushing hard for Halli amd LZM so why not call me out too?

I really need to step away from this game. I'm beginning to grow extremely frustrated with the logic.

  

As much as I hate to say this, I'm liking Elds logic more and more.

I went back and ISO'd Darthe once again amd he seems even more scummy than LZM atm. Which is saying something.

[v] Darthe [/v]

Let's do this.

Quotes to prove that you didn't realize Hally was the seer.

[Shanti]

I hope you guys have a backup plan for when I flip town. Farmer to be exact.

[Eldrick4221]

You agreed with me when I was going after her.

 

You went after spades when she realized it. (Which btw doesn't fit you thinking Hally was scum)

 

When you switched to Darthe, you still had lzm as scum, who was recognized as cleared by Hally by the thread at that point.

 

You aren't paying enough attention to the thread. You nk'd Cass/dice because you didn't realize it was hally.

[Shanti]

To this point, I am pretty darn proud of my game play in both of my games. I have had zero help so I'm learning as I go. I will admit, the game gets difficult, but even the most seasoned townie messes up from time to time. It's only fitting I would either get confused or slip up here and there because this is not only my second game, this is my first game on DM amd this crap is hard to follow sometimes

[Shanti]

I think I had also mentioned at some point I was no longer having fun playing this game. I have been in over my head throughout this entire seer game. I'm flattered you guys think I would be capable of lasting this long as scum thougj.

[Eldrick4221]

 

 

 

Woah. I go out to celebrate my weightless accomplishment and come back to being scum. Not NKing Hally was not a rookie mistake, I didn't NK her, or anyone else for that matter because I don't have that ability as Vanilla Town.

I was fist to vote Alex in the beginning, because right off the bat he pinged me. Albeit Redd pinged me too, but apparently that was just his playstyle.

IIR, I remember stating that I did not like being in agreement with Eld but his points were good ones.

But, tbh, this entire game he has frustrated me. Almost from day one he has had the attitude of, kill me I don't care and as your teammate, Eld... and as someone who is new, it would have been nice to have support before the last day. Oh wait... you still aren't really supporting your teammate. You have your vote on me AND tried to lynch yourself... maybe you so have SOME self preservation in there and the whole, fine lynch me, was a bluff. Maybe you're the wolf and you focused on me because the other two were defending themselves and I was an easy target for being new and silent at the time.

What is even more frustrating is your response to my vote, which is you, will be to vote yourself, or to stop trying. In my whole one and 3/4 games of Mafia, I have never seen a townie want to be lynched as much as you do, and it has increased since Alex and Darthe have been lynched. Maybe you voted Alex because he wasn't a good teammate and pissed you off, maybe you lynched Darthe because you felt alone and backed into a corner and thought hmmm. This would be the perfect cover, then I can show lack of self preservation and blatantly act wolf so they won't think I'm wolf anymore. Brilliant plan if it's you, kudos for a game well played. I do hope I am wrong and you arent scum, but I havent felt like you were my teammate this entire game, which sucks.

[v] Eld [/v]

Eldrick actually didn't vote Alex, he voted Tigraine when he was tied in votes with Alex.

I know, it was mentioned I bussed Alex, that was my response. When I DID follow Elds lead, it was on Darthe and that is ehen I didn't like agreeing with Eld, but felt he was right.

 

Pick me apart, I don't mind and I won't back down. I have nothing to hide.

That makes no sense.

I'd vote you here if I wasn't already.

 

That's a classic slip. Heated and accidently mentioning that you bussed.

[Shanti]

You agreed with me when I was going after her.

You went after spades when she realized it. (Which btw doesn't fit you thinking Hally was scum)

When you switched to Darthe, you still had lzm as scum, who was recognized as cleared by Hally by the thread at that point.

You aren't paying enough attention to the thread. You nk'd Cass/dice because you didn't realize it was hally.

That isn't entirely true. I didn't NK cass at all.

 

Now you're insulting my intelligence

[Eldrick4221]

To this point, I am pretty darn proud of my game play in both of my games. I have had zero help so I'm learning as I go. I will admit, the game gets difficult, but even the most seasoned townie messes up from time to time. It's only fitting I would either get confused or slip up here and there because this is not only my second game, this is my first game on DM amd this crap is hard to follow sometimes

This is true lol

[Shanti]

I didn't trust Halli.

 

Therefore, I didn't trust her read on LZM.

 

I actually stated that TO her.

 

When I scum read someone why would I listen to their plea of... don't vote LZM!!!! That wouldn't be very wise of me would it?

[Eldrick4221]

 

You agreed with me when I was going after her.

You went after spades when she realized it. (Which btw doesn't fit you thinking Hally was scum)

When you switched to Darthe, you still had lzm as scum, who was recognized as cleared by Hally by the thread at that point.

You aren't paying enough attention to the thread. You nk'd Cass/dice because you didn't realize it was hally.

That isn't entirely true. I didn't NK cass at all.

 

Now you're insulting my intelligence

Your intelligence has nothing to do with it. You seem very smart.

 

I'm calling you scum. That means you had the nk. You are the only one that didn't catch on to Hally being seer. My quotes prove that.

[Shanti]

 

 

 

 

Woah. I go out to celebrate my weightless accomplishment and come back to being scum. Not NKing Hally was not a rookie mistake, I didn't NK her, or anyone else for that matter because I don't have that ability as Vanilla Town.

I was fist to vote Alex in the beginning, because right off the bat he pinged me. Albeit Redd pinged me too, but apparently that was just his playstyle.

IIR, I remember stating that I did not like being in agreement with Eld but his points were good ones.

But, tbh, this entire game he has frustrated me. Almost from day one he has had the attitude of, kill me I don't care and as your teammate, Eld... and as someone who is new, it would have been nice to have support before the last day. Oh wait... you still aren't really supporting your teammate. You have your vote on me AND tried to lynch yourself... maybe you so have SOME self preservation in there and the whole, fine lynch me, was a bluff. Maybe you're the wolf and you focused on me because the other two were defending themselves and I was an easy target for being new and silent at the time.

What is even more frustrating is your response to my vote, which is you, will be to vote yourself, or to stop trying. In my whole one and 3/4 games of Mafia, I have never seen a townie want to be lynched as much as you do, and it has increased since Alex and Darthe have been lynched. Maybe you voted Alex because he wasn't a good teammate and pissed you off, maybe you lynched Darthe because you felt alone and backed into a corner and thought hmmm. This would be the perfect cover, then I can show lack of self preservation and blatantly act wolf so they won't think I'm wolf anymore. Brilliant plan if it's you, kudos for a game well played. I do hope I am wrong and you arent scum, but I havent felt like you were my teammate this entire game, which sucks.

[v] Eld [/v]

Eldrick actually didn't vote Alex, he voted Tigraine when he was tied in votes with Alex.

I know, it was mentioned I bussed Alex, that was my response. When I DID follow Elds lead, it was on Darthe and that is ehen I didn't like agreeing with Eld, but felt he was right.

Pick me apart, I don't mind and I won't back down. I have nothing to hide.

That makes no sense.

I'd vote you here if I wasn't already.

That's a classic slip. Heated and accidently mentioning that you bussed.

Oh sweet baby Jesus.... no, somewhere while rereading someone mentioned I bussed Alex... I will find the quote.. let me get on my darn computer. You guys are so off it isn't even funny.

[Eldrick4221]

Ok. Then lemme ask you this, after I flip town, who will you go after tomorrow and why?

[Shanti]

I knew her claim of seer, I had just finished SCUM reading her though. Oh geez. Lol.

 

Who are you planning to go after once I flip town? Just out of curiosity?

[Eldrick4221]

 

 

 

 

 

Woah. I go out to celebrate my weightless accomplishment and come back to being scum. Not NKing Hally was not a rookie mistake, I didn't NK her, or anyone else for that matter because I don't have that ability as Vanilla Town.

I was fist to vote Alex in the beginning, because right off the bat he pinged me. Albeit Redd pinged me too, but apparently that was just his playstyle.

IIR, I remember stating that I did not like being in agreement with Eld but his points were good ones.

But, tbh, this entire game he has frustrated me. Almost from day one he has had the attitude of, kill me I don't care and as your teammate, Eld... and as someone who is new, it would have been nice to have support before the last day. Oh wait... you still aren't really supporting your teammate. You have your vote on me AND tried to lynch yourself... maybe you so have SOME self preservation in there and the whole, fine lynch me, was a bluff. Maybe you're the wolf and you focused on me because the other two were defending themselves and I was an easy target for being new and silent at the time.

What is even more frustrating is your response to my vote, which is you, will be to vote yourself, or to stop trying. In my whole one and 3/4 games of Mafia, I have never seen a townie want to be lynched as much as you do, and it has increased since Alex and Darthe have been lynched. Maybe you voted Alex because he wasn't a good teammate and pissed you off, maybe you lynched Darthe because you felt alone and backed into a corner and thought hmmm. This would be the perfect cover, then I can show lack of self preservation and blatantly act wolf so they won't think I'm wolf anymore. Brilliant plan if it's you, kudos for a game well played. I do hope I am wrong and you arent scum, but I havent felt like you were my teammate this entire game, which sucks.

[v] Eld [/v]

Eldrick actually didn't vote Alex, he voted Tigraine when he was tied in votes with Alex.

I know, it was mentioned I bussed Alex, that was my response. When I DID follow Elds lead, it was on Darthe and that is ehen I didn't like agreeing with Eld, but felt he was right.

Pick me apart, I don't mind and I won't back down. I have nothing to hide.

That makes no sense.

I'd vote you here if I wasn't already.

That's a classic slip. Heated and accidently mentioning that you bussed.

Oh sweet baby Jesus.... no, somewhere while rereading someone mentioned I bussed Alex... I will find the quote.. let me get on my darn computer. You guys are so off it isn't even funny.

Fair enough. Point dropped.