[Basic] Peg + Cat Mafia -- TOWN WIN

[Cass]

 

 

Votes

Pg1

Eldrick - Aussie hydra - cuz hydra (joke vote)

Cass - Eldrick - Post count (joke vote)

Pg3

Alex - Hally - no listed reason

Pg4

Alex - Shanti - no listed reason

Pg5

Redd - Hally - soul read wolf between hally/spades

Shanti - Alex - too defensive too early

Adella - Shanti - welcome vote

Redd - Spades - seemingly omgus to be called wolf

Pg9

Alex - Spades - "good vote". probably irt post 171

Redd - Tigs - no listed reason

Pg11

Tigs - Redd - because he's randomly changing his vote without reason

Pg12

Redd - Alex - no listed reason. Voted after Alex defended Tigs

Pg13

Tigs - Tress - irt stalker comment (joke vote)

Pg14

Redd - Tress - no listed reason

Pg15

Adella - Spades - too defensive? Asked for reasons for people's votes..

Pg16

Eldrick - unvote - liked dice's tone

Eldrick - Alex - paying attention to if he sounds sunny

Pg17

Cass - Led - summon vote

Pg20

Alex - Tress - no listed reason. Maybe irt her responding to Tigs asking about hally's possible slip

Pg21

Led - Ed - cuz of past history (joke vote)

Pg23

Darthe - Alex - found his response to Redd/Tigs interaction scummy?

Pg25

Darthe - Eldrick - "pocket denied"

Pg29

Ed - Spades - "lack of scum hunting and deduction skills" seemed to be directed at everyone, but still voted Spades for it

Pg30

Eldrick - unvote - unsure if there was more reason than "being conscious of how his posting looks"

Pg31

Eldrick - Tigs - No solve

Redd - Tigs - confirming his vote was on her (it wasn't)

Led - Redd - interpreting Redd's vote as a bandwagon vote

 

 

 

If anyone's vote was incorrectly explained, or if you'd like to explain your votes, please respond. Otherwise, this is just for my records, and for any townies that want to make use of the info.

 

At this point I'm not sure if I'm stuck in a tunnel but I think you misrep Redd's votes here

 

p11 Red vote Tiggs (from previous vote on Tiggs) "because he's randomly changing his vote without reason" is weird.

P9 I take the Redd vote on Tigs as because of the intro post of hers he quoted, not no reason as you say.

 

This possibly ties into another post where you mention not liking them/the chop and change?

What bothers you about it?

 

IMO it's probably less sus than park and push (?)

[Shanti]

Sorry I've been quiet/m.i.a. Day before yesterday was last day of my pay period for work so I went at it pretty darn late. I used yesterday as a recovery day. I'm going to hop on my laptop in a few and catch up/do readings

[Cass]

When I was going over the votes, I noticed that Redd wasn't sticking with his scum reads. He'd give a good reason to go after someone, but would drift away seemingly spontaneously.

 

I'm starting to think he might need a wolf.

 

This is the other post I mean.

 

Are there particular votes/changes that bother you?

[Eldrick4221]

 

Your reason is a good one. You're wrong about me being scum, but you'd only know that if you were scum, which I don't think you are.

 

 

 

I'm not worried, but I can see why you might think I am. I didn't ask about her opinions on other people because she has a reads list I haven't read yet.

 

 

I feel like you should be more worried if you were Town?

Why?

 

Only time a town lynch matters is at lylo. I have no reason to worry about votes on me. My death doesn't matter. All that matters is finding scum, and I believe I have in Tigs.

 

(Almost asleep yay. Friggin mafia adiction)

[Eldrick4221]

 

 

 

Votes

Pg1

Eldrick - Aussie hydra - cuz hydra (joke vote)

Cass - Eldrick - Post count (joke vote)

Pg3

Alex - Hally - no listed reason

Pg4

Alex - Shanti - no listed reason

Pg5

Redd - Hally - soul read wolf between hally/spades

Shanti - Alex - too defensive too early

Adella - Shanti - welcome vote

Redd - Spades - seemingly omgus to be called wolf

Pg9

Alex - Spades - "good vote". probably irt post 171

Redd - Tigs - no listed reason

Pg11

Tigs - Redd - because he's randomly changing his vote without reason

Pg12

Redd - Alex - no listed reason. Voted after Alex defended Tigs

Pg13

Tigs - Tress - irt stalker comment (joke vote)

Pg14

Redd - Tress - no listed reason

Pg15

Adella - Spades - too defensive? Asked for reasons for people's votes..

Pg16

Eldrick - unvote - liked dice's tone

Eldrick - Alex - paying attention to if he sounds sunny

Pg17

Cass - Led - summon vote

Pg20

Alex - Tress - no listed reason. Maybe irt her responding to Tigs asking about hally's possible slip

Pg21

Led - Ed - cuz of past history (joke vote)

Pg23

Darthe - Alex - found his response to Redd/Tigs interaction scummy?

Pg25

Darthe - Eldrick - "pocket denied"

Pg29

Ed - Spades - "lack of scum hunting and deduction skills" seemed to be directed at everyone, but still voted Spades for it

Pg30

Eldrick - unvote - unsure if there was more reason than "being conscious of how his posting looks"

Pg31

Eldrick - Tigs - No solve

Redd - Tigs - confirming his vote was on her (it wasn't)

Led - Redd - interpreting Redd's vote as a bandwagon vote

 

 

If anyone's vote was incorrectly explained, or if you'd like to explain your votes, please respond. Otherwise, this is just for my records, and for any townies that want to make use of the info.

 

 

At this point I'm not sure if I'm stuck in a tunnel but I think you misrep Redd's votes here

 

p11 Red vote Tiggs (from previous vote on Tiggs) "because he's randomly changing his vote without reason" is weird.

P9 I take the Redd vote on Tigs as because of the intro post of hers he quoted, not no reason as you say.

 

This possibly ties into another post where you mention not liking them/the chop and change?

What bothers you about it?

 

IMO it's probably less sus than park and push (?)

  

 

When I was going over the votes, I noticed that Redd wasn't sticking with his scum reads. He'd give a good reason to go after someone, but would drift away seemingly spontaneously.

I'm starting to think he might need a wolf.

 

 

This is the other post I mean.

 

Are there particular votes/changes that bother you?

Gonna answer these when I'm not half awake. Can't remember what I was thinking right now

[Cass]

 

 

Your reason is a good one. You're wrong about me being scum, but you'd only know that if you were scum, which I don't think you are.

 

 

I'm not worried, but I can see why you might think I am. I didn't ask about her opinions on other people because she has a reads list I haven't read yet.

 

I feel like you should be more worried if you were Town?

Why?

 

Only time a town lynch matters is at lylo. I have no reason to worry about votes on me. My death doesn't matter. All that matters is finding scum, and I believe I have in Tigs.

 

(Almost asleep yay. Friggin mafia adiction)

 

 

No.

 

No.

 

No.

 

No.

 

 

[v]Eldrick[/v]

[Cass]

You fought me tooth and nail D1 in Hackers when I had you as Scum and you were Town.

 

Why would that philosophy change?

 

Why should it ever be a thing for Town D1, when your alignment is usually the only thing you can be certain of?

 

Zanderrampage.gif

[Cass]

 

 

 

[Eldrick4221]

 

 

 

 

Votes

Pg1

Eldrick - Aussie hydra - cuz hydra (joke vote)

Cass - Eldrick - Post count (joke vote)

Pg3

Alex - Hally - no listed reason

Pg4

Alex - Shanti - no listed reason

Pg5

Redd - Hally - soul read wolf between hally/spades

Shanti - Alex - too defensive too early

Adella - Shanti - welcome vote

Redd - Spades - seemingly omgus to be called wolf

Pg9

Alex - Spades - "good vote". probably irt post 171

Redd - Tigs - no listed reason

Pg11

Tigs - Redd - because he's randomly changing his vote without reason

Pg12

Redd - Alex - no listed reason. Voted after Alex defended Tigs

Pg13

Tigs - Tress - irt stalker comment (joke vote)

Pg14

Redd - Tress - no listed reason

Pg15

Adella - Spades - too defensive? Asked for reasons for people's votes..

Pg16

Eldrick - unvote - liked dice's tone

Eldrick - Alex - paying attention to if he sounds sunny

Pg17

Cass - Led - summon vote

Pg20

Alex - Tress - no listed reason. Maybe irt her responding to Tigs asking about hally's possible slip

Pg21

Led - Ed - cuz of past history (joke vote)

Pg23

Darthe - Alex - found his response to Redd/Tigs interaction scummy?

Pg25

Darthe - Eldrick - "pocket denied"

Pg29

Ed - Spades - "lack of scum hunting and deduction skills" seemed to be directed at everyone, but still voted Spades for it

Pg30

Eldrick - unvote - unsure if there was more reason than "being conscious of how his posting looks"

Pg31

Eldrick - Tigs - No solve

Redd - Tigs - confirming his vote was on her (it wasn't)

Led - Redd - interpreting Redd's vote as a bandwagon vote

 

 

If anyone's vote was incorrectly explained, or if you'd like to explain your votes, please respond. Otherwise, this is just for my records, and for any townies that want to make use of the info.

 

At this point I'm not sure if I'm stuck in a tunnel but I think you misrep Redd's votes here

 

p11 Red vote Tiggs (from previous vote on Tiggs) "because he's randomly changing his vote without reason" is weird.

P9 I take the Redd vote on Tigs as because of the intro post of hers he quoted, not no reason as you say.

 

This possibly ties into another post where you mention not liking them/the chop and change?

What bothers you about it?

 

IMO it's probably less sus than park and push (?)

 

When I was going over the votes, I noticed that Redd wasn't sticking with his scum reads. He'd give a good reason to go after someone, but would drift away seemingly spontaneously.

I'm starting to think he might need a wolf.

 

This is the other post I mean.

 

Are there particular votes/changes that bother you?

Gonna answer these when I'm not half awake. Can't remember what I was thinking right now

Sleep is eluding me, so I'll work on answering these.

 

I said up front that I wasn't sure if I had the reasons for the votes. No misrep was intended. The reasons I gave were from a quick skim looking for votes, and trying to find the reason from context. Not surprised if I got some wrong.

 

Main switch for Redd was to Tress after he was pushing tigs. A lesser one was moving to Hally without letting his previous vote (Shanti?) get a response, which was his later claimed reason for doing so.

[Eldrick4221]

You fought me tooth and nail D1 in Hackers when I had you as Scum and you were Town.

 

Why would that philosophy change?

 

Why should it ever be a thing for Town D1, when your alignment is usually the only thing you can be certain of?

 

Zanderrampage.gif

I'm not as invested in this game as I was that one. I don't know why. I'm still trying to solve, but don't care if I die.

[Eldrick4221]

Fwiw I'm Zebra Mask Guy

[Eldrick4221]

Claiming role is silly. There's only 1 non-vanilla role in the game. For all your know, I'm the seer. Saying so wouldn't save me.

[Eldrick4221]

Mind explaining how me not caring if I gets lynched makes me scum?

[Shad_]

OFFICIAL VOTE COUNT

 

Alex (2) - Shanti, Adella

 

Tress (2) - Tigraine, Alex

 

LZM (1) - Redd

 

Eldrick (3) - Darthe, Spades, Dice/Cass

 

Tigraine (1) - Eldrick

 

Redd (1) - LZM

 

Not Voting: Songstress, Ed, Hallia

 

 

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

 

[Eldrick4221]

[unvote]

[V]Redd [/v]

 

Sorry Shad

[Eldrick4221]

I don't think Tress is scum. I considered moving my vote from Tigs to Tress but Tigs' vote as a bus vote doesn't make sense. Why would she leave a reasonless vote on a teammate when said teammate is at risk of being lynched?

 

I still think Tigs is scum, but my vote is wasted there.

[Eldrick4221]

I also don't know why Redd would try to lynch Tigs either of they are teammates. This game is hurting my head. I'm probably wrong about all 3.

[Eldrick4221]

I could be wrong about tigs. Lack of solve day 1 isn't damning. (That's pg13 in that context, right)

 

If tigs is town, Redd and Tress are fair game.

[Eldrick4221]

I've talked myself into either

 

tigs is town

or

tigs is scum and Redd and Tress are both town.

[Eldrick4221]

If this makes any sense to anyone, please let me know.

 

If it makes sense, Tigraine scum flip could pseudo clear 2 people and that's big day 1

[Eldrick4221]

Going back to tigs. Not wasted anymore.

 

[V]tigs[/v]

[Eldrick4221]

Sorry for my thinking out loud. It helps me process.

[Shad_]

I'm going to be out until close to deadline. Going to try really really hard to get back in time so I don't keep people waiting. Will try to bum some vote counts from the dead thread while I'm gone.

[Shad_]

OFFICIAL VOTE COUNT

 

Alex (2) - Shanti, Adella

 

Tress (2) - Tigraine, Alex

 

LZM (1) - Redd

 

Eldrick (3) - Darthe, Spades, Dice/Cass

 

Tigraine (1) - Eldrick

 

Redd (1) - LZM

 

Not Voting: Songstress, Ed, Hallia

 

 

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

 

currently accurate

[dicetosser1]

 

 

Your reason is a good one. You're wrong about me being scum, but you'd only know that if you were scum, which I don't think you are.

 

 

I'm not worried, but I can see why you might think I am. I didn't ask about her opinions on other people because she has a reads list I haven't read yet.

 

I feel like you should be more worried if you were Town?

Why?

 

Only time a town lynch matters is at lylo. I have no reason to worry about votes on me. My death doesn't matter. All that matters is finding scum, and I believe I have in Tigs.

 

(Almost asleep yay. Friggin mafia adiction)

 

 

wrong. every town lynch gets us closer to lylo.

 

you know this.

 

happy with the maroons vote. Elds apathy is weird cause shes right  he fights HARD. some of his posts just look like busy work.