[Advanced] Old West Mischief Mafia - Town Wins!

[Darthe]

Ok, starting with this

 

 

We have the lead to afford getting rid of players who've done nothing, theyre good PoE candidates at the very least.

 

I include cass in that list, ftr.

 

Cass is my preference at the moment. Hallia felt genuine regards Eldrick, but that's a lot less than I have for anyone else

I'm cool with that.

 

[V] cass [/v]

Id go towards seph/cuth/bfg, thats my next bracket.

 

I don't think Seph is scum

I don't think any of the three are, I'm just going on strength of read

Im a fan of just voting tbh. We have night to talk and we arent using it, so why assume we would use this day more? Beyond that, she isnt changing our minds and this games virtually locked up. Let's not drag it out for a perceived minor advantage when we can prob end.

Explain the bold pls?

 

And

 

Why me before Hally of the 'inactives'?

 

And why each for Seph/Cuth/BFG as your next bracket?

Look at this immediate spin

[Darthe]

 

in order something like crush>bfg>darthe if cass is telling the truth?

 

don't know how i feel about that

 

like i want to discount darthe because that's self-destructing bussing if it is the case, but idk

AFAIK, Darthe is a hyper-active promoter of the bus when scum - one of the things that has me sus on him. He did seem to be promoting good Town play wrt EoD2 but early vibes and I need to go back over him.

 

I'm not sold on Crusher or BFG for Town either though.

 

Want to discuss more with everyone to figure it out.

[MrsClov]

 

 

Cass isnt a doc, im a roleblocker and blocked her N2.

 

So theres that.

Who else did you RB then?

No one N1 and last night BFG

 

Why not block anyone N1?

[Darthe]

Thats more activity and more developed a read than cass has had in the rest of her posts combined, and it doesnt look good with that liz ppst and the claim. It looks greedy.

[Darthe]

 

 

 

Cass isnt a doc, im a roleblocker and blocked her N2.

 

So theres that.

Who else did you RB then?

No one N1 and last night BFG

Why not block anyone N1?

Because that would be stupid.

[Cuth]

 

 

 

in order something like crush>bfg>darthe if cass is telling the truth?

 

don't know how i feel about that

 

like i want to discount darthe because that's self-destructing bussing if it is the case, but idk

 

AFAIK, Darthe is a hyper-active promoter of the bus when scum - one of the things that has me sus on him. He did seem to be promoting good Town play wrt EoD2 but early vibes and I need to go back over him.

 

I'm not sold on Crusher or BFG for Town either though.

 

Want to discuss more with everyone to figure it out.

 

ill be on here in a bit for some discussion but I kept thinking about the game  even though i was unable to read it.

 

Look at day 2 people. kronos viewed a red. what you have to understand is the mafia knew that. eldrick says he knew he was visited therefore most likely assumed it was a cop role. the first votes before kronos reveal probably has 1 guarantee wolf. possibly 2.

 

I have ideas in my head but i need to go back and read it as well, ill be around in 30 minutes, and Thank god you came back cass! 

 

this is why.

eldrcik basically outed the scum team as having some type of watcher. knowing he had been visited I doubt the would read him as town day 2 as alot of folks did tbh.

 

i thought that until the dpr flip

 

then it could have just been trying to draw a doc shot away from town and survive if he did get killed

 

about 50/50 now

[MrsClov]

 

 

 

 

Cass isnt a doc, im a roleblocker and blocked her N2.

 

So theres that.

Who else did you RB then?

No one N1 and last night BFG

Why not block anyone N1?

Because that would be stupid.

 

Really? You seemed to be all about Liz/I and Eldrick being scum. So why not try to block one of us if we were that scummy?

[Cuth]

does anyone else remember dice being more consensus town than anyone else

 

because i think most people ignored him/gave him a slight town read

[Darthe]

 

Cass isnt a doc, im a roleblocker and blocked her N2.

 

So theres that.

that deserves a hi 5 I believe lol.

I was thinking it was odd she somehow picked one of the 2 watchers day 1. I was about to go read her =p. I also think tink is a wolf this is his first post d2

Up to page 50, Crush and Eldrick are pushing entirely different agendas. Not massively confident in my reads.

 

Eldrick flip flopping doesn't ring any bells but usually he walks through almost all small details which he shows when he says things like "he wrote scum before he wrote town. Indicative?" and things like that but when it came to LizClov he looked super hesitant to join on her votes despite the fact that she was playing ridiculously scummy and when he finally does it's with the reason that she was asking "who my teammates would be?". Sad excuse to vote, like he needed a new reason to vote her since he didn't want to look like he was "bandwagoning".

 

Then he changes his mind when she loses heat because of the amount of heat she's gotten but has slowly convinced himself without having posted much about it in the thread - not in line with his meta.

 

vote Eldrick

 

I mentioned Crush because on page 35 or something Liz had lost a lot of momentum, DPR voted her to bring her back to 3 votes and Crush calls her a "solid scum" but doesn't vote until later.

 

I'm going to take a look at NB train later because I actually didn't think he looked to be playing too differently to how he normally does but I seem to be inept at reading him.

thoughts on this darthe? I want to continue reading before i condemn tink as I have sussed him quite a bit imo.

cass/cuth could be wolves though if your rb is true.

My rb is true. I really dont see tink, and im standing by that. I dont even know what it is im supposed to be seeing there tbh.

[Darthe]

 

 

 

 

 

Cass isnt a doc, im a roleblocker and blocked her N2.

 

So theres that.

Who else did you RB then?

No one N1 and last night BFG

Why not block anyone N1?

Because that would be stupid.

Really? You seemed to be all about Liz/I and Eldrick being scum. So why not try to block one of us if we were that scummy?

Im not basic is why, RBs D1 are godawful for the town.

[Cuth]

leaning towards voting cass now

 

she always has to claim, darthe doesn't

 

darthe looks better from the rest of the game

 

i dislike darthe's posts, but i also dislike the shade she's throwing that way

 

idk

[Darthe]

Mrsclov u seem mad that I just cc'd?

[Cuth]

why didn't you claim the rb earlier darthe

[Darthe]

does anyone else remember dice being more consensus town than anyone else

 

because i think most people ignored him/gave him a slight town read

He was... Quiet. Dice is someone you read late, usually.

[MrsClov]

Mrsclov u seem mad that I just cc'd?

 

Not even remotely mad. I don't believe you.

[Cuth]

no wait that makes complete sense in every way

 

[v]cass[/v]

[Cuth]

 

does anyone else remember dice being more consensus town than anyone else

 

because i think most people ignored him/gave him a slight town read

He was... Quiet. Dice is someone you read late, usually.

 

cass is claiming that he was universally townread n1

[Kaylee]

OFFICIAL VOTE COUNT:

 

Doc Cassiday (2): Darthe, Cuth

 

Darthe (1): Miss Kizzy Clov

 

Not Voting: Cass, Kronos, WiFi, Hallia, Seph, Tiinker, Crusher, BFG

 

With 11 alive, it takes 6 to lynch.

Deadline for Day 4 is Friday, 2/24/17 at 9 AM MST

[seph]

leaning towards voting cass now

 

she always has to claim, darthe doesn't

 

darthe looks better from the rest of the game

 

i dislike darthe's posts, but i also dislike the shade she's throwing that way

 

idk

+1 I was thinking of leaning darthe as well.

Reading over d2 was just reconfirming for me.

 

at the end of n1 he posts he was going after eld/kronos. eventually town reads kronos and goes after eld before kronos reveals. I am always going to be tinfoily for people on d2 tbh.

Just because I assume the mafia has a watcher with how eld played night 1 trying to get the view, and then saying he knew he was visited. I still think 1 wolf will be on eld before kronos reveal so I am going to continue reading and assessing

[Cuth]

although

 

that means kills would be assigned

 

hm

 

if that's the case implies one scum left

[Darthe]

why didn't you claim the rb earlier darthe

Because we have had a steady deluge of claims leading to wolves, but more importantly because I didnt have a hard result. No kill could be the result of a protect or other things.

[Cuth]

too many things would have had to go just right for darthe to be scum here imo

[Cass]

 

Ok, starting with this

 

We have the lead to afford getting rid of players who've done nothing, theyre good PoE candidates at the very least.

 

I include cass in that list, ftr.

 

Cass is my preference at the moment. Hallia felt genuine regards Eldrick, but that's a lot less than I have for anyone else

I'm cool with that.

 

[V] cass [/v]

Id go towards seph/cuth/bfg, thats my next bracket.

 

I don't think Seph is scum

I don't think any of the three are, I'm just going on strength of read

Im a fan of just voting tbh. We have night to talk and we arent using it, so why assume we would use this day more? Beyond that, she isnt changing our minds and this games virtually locked up. Let's not drag it out for a perceived minor advantage when we can prob end.

Explain the bold pls?

 

And

 

Why me before Hally of the 'inactives'?

 

And why each for Seph/Cuth/BFG as your next bracket?

Look at this immediate spin

 

 

What spin??

 

I'm asking you to explain why you're so hungry to get at me/lynch either me [known Town] or Hallia [shortly thereafter cleared-by-peek Town]?

 

 

 

 

in order something like crush>bfg>darthe if cass is telling the truth?

 

don't know how i feel about that

 

like i want to discount darthe because that's self-destructing bussing if it is the case, but idk

AFAIK, Darthe is a hyper-active promoter of the bus when scum - one of the things that has me sus on him. He did seem to be promoting good Town play wrt EoD2 but early vibes and I need to go back over him.

 

I'm not sold on Crusher or BFG for Town either though.

 

Want to discuss more with everyone to figure it out.

 

 

 

Thats more activity and more developed a read than cass has had in the rest of her posts combined, and it doesnt look good with that liz ppst and the claim. It looks greedy.

 

Does it now?

 

I think if you go read my ISO you'll find that during the Day phases when I wasn't at work or recovering from an accident - ie. When the game started, I was freely giving my thoughts and ftr pegged Eldrick off the bat.

 

You've mentored me as scum, you know bussing's not my thing, how does that fit with the way this game's gone down?

[Darthe]

This is pretty locked up rn. What's the argument clov? I'm giving *myself* up for no reason to kill a doc who's been absent?

[Darthe]

Remind me of when you had a wolf read on me before cass?