Jump to content




  • Content Count

  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by Terez

  1. I got the feeling from reading it that it was very much both - even that maybe Moridin had planned it that way exactly, or maybe that, when Rand was backed into that corner, he  unconsciously allowed Moridin's desire for revenge against Semirhage (that we saw in the prologue) to come through, along with the knowledge of how to get out of that corner.  But that was the last chapter I read, and in truth I only skimmed it, so I can't say really.

  2. Cool, so it's left open, huh?  Lews Therin has 'left his head' before...but I'm interested to see how this one reads.  And yeah, I wasn't trying to say that you implied that would count as Rand's death by the prophecies - that's just a popular theory that I hate.  I've never denied that it could happen - Lews Therin 'dying' - just that it would count as Rand dying.


    In your opinion, does it count for Min's 'touch/merge' viewing?

  3. haha, I just gave that one at the Malazan forums, and got the impression it hadn't been posted anywhere else.  ;D 


    I didn't post that one at Theoryland, but I did get one of my Theoryland friends to guess it by leading him around a little.  Okay, a lot.  That one was counterintuitive - we all knew Rand was headed for the merge-whatever thing, but I don't think anyone expected it to step up that quickly.


    Also, sdboka - I didn't actually get to buy the book, just got to read it in store.  So I'm confused about a few bits I had to read really fast, and that's one of them - did he or did he not balefire her with the True Power?  I read earlier in this thread that it was a weave to rip her out of the Pattern that he learned from Moridin (perhaps in Tel'aran'rhiod in book 3).  Anyway, I saw that bit and my mind categorized it as 'balefire'.

  4. I know a good number of people that weren't going to buy the book until I spoiled them and got them interested. I can't imagine why spoilers would make anyone not want to buy it.


    I'm happy with this one - there were a lot of things I was right about, and a lot of surprises too, just the right combination to make me happy, I think.  I will concur that chapters 22-23 are the first 'OH SH-' moment of the book, where you really just kinda have to stop and scream to yourself for a minute.

  5. Take a break, Davian...I'm pretty sure I can explain this better than you can.  ;)  Perhaps even better than Callandor...Callandor is the one that convinced me, but there are several aspects of his arguments that I disagree with, and his terminology I think is the worst aspect of it.  He uses quite a few too many terms that are interpreted differently by different people, and I agree with Ares that the "summation of memories" definition of personality isn't sufficient.  It's Callandor's idea that, for a personality to be "real" (which is the foremost of those ambiguous terms), then all of the memories must be present.  This seems to me to be blatantly false - even normal folks with only one set of memories are constantly learning and forgetting things.  What, then, is a "summation" of memories?  How can you describe any set of memories as being "complete"?  You simply can't.  Rand's Lews Therin memories are certainly spotty - not a set of memories that any person would consider normal in its scope.  The memories that come to Rand are usually the memories that he needs, but not always.  For instance, the memory of the plum orchard wasn't particularly vital, nor is the tendency to hum and thumb his earlobe when he sees a pretty woman.  But when Rand spoke to Taim about the Forsaken and their deeds, he certainly seemed to be drawing on a very comprehensive knowledge of the Forsaken.  A "summation" of Lews Therin's memories about them (this is perhaps the best example of a "summation" of memories from Lews Therin in the books).  But Rand thought of it afterward as though he consciously drew on these memories - certainly as if he made a conscious choice to speak the words.  Other things, such as Rand having to be told what certain Old Tongue words mean, show that the memories are limited, not only by the bits and pieces that every person forgets, but by whole large swaths of knowledge.  A normal person simply does not up and forget a language in which they are fluent.


    There are a few other disagreements that I have with Callandor's theory - one of them is his method of "demonstrating" that Semirhage was lying, with the Graendal quote, which I believe can be interpreted a couple of different ways.  Semirhage's comments aren't particularly troubling to be, because I don't believe that, when she says Lews Therin's voice is "real", it necessarily means that she's implying that Lews Therin is a being with a mind of its own.  Yes, it's quite possible that she's lying, and it's pretty certain that she has a limited understanding of what's going on inside Rand's head, and also quite possible that even Graendal had a limited understanding of such things.  But Semirhage told them that Rand knew who she was because Lews Therin told him, which isn't exactly true.  Rand recognized Semirhage.  He recognized her because of Lews Therin's memories, but Lews Therin was silent.


    The distinction that I feel is ultimately important in the Rand/Lews Therin situation is that Lews Therin is not a being with a mind of its own.  The speaking, acting Lews Therin is an illusion created by Rand because he refused to accept the memories, in much the same way as the body will sometimes reject an alien organ after a transplant operation, and for similar and yet completely different reasons, if that makes any sense.  :)  Rand wanted not only to disassociate himself from Lews Therin's legacy as much as possible, but he also hates the knowledge of what he might become.  This is evidence in his paranoia concerning the girls (how he's always trying to send them away, and taking great care to protect them), and it is especially evidenced in his excessive self-flagellation with the litany of dead women.  It is evidenced in his thoughts when he was first told that he was the Dragon Reborn, and it is evidenced in his extreme denial (I am not Lews Therin!  I am Rand al'Thor!) when he first realizes the source of his alien memories.


    The issue of graduality (I think I just made that word up) isn't really one that can be claimed by either side as an indicator of the correctness of their theory, but I believe that the specific manner in which Rand developed the ability to actually converse with Lews Therin is pretty telling.  The Fires of Heaven is pretty much the exposition of Lews Therin (Rand didn't realize, or at least didn't admit to himself where the memories were coming from before Chapter 6 of that book), but that ability to converse was developed in Lord of Chaos.  Those two books in particular are, I feel, vital to understanding the nature of the relationship between Rand and Lews Therin.


    this has gotten fairly heated.

    This debate usually does get that way, but it doesn't have to stay that way - I'm sure that everyone here (including Ares and Davian) are capable of discussing this rationally and politely.


    LTT was there at the wells when rand burst out of the box, actually LTT showed rand how to break the sheild.

    Yes, this is the first time that Rand and Lews Therin really have what might be considered a conversation, and also one of the only times that Lews Therin has actually "told" Rand how to do something.  Usually, important memories come to Rand without commentary, and the commentary is generally  arbitrary.


    LTT was with rand when he severed the AS.

    Lews Therin is an aspect of Rand - or an aspect of his soul, if you prefer.  He's always "with" Rand.  But between Cadsuane's comment about voices and madness, and Rand's first meeting with Torval, Lews Therin apparently wasn't "with" Rand.  Do you know why?  Do you know where he might have been?


    LTT was there to show rand how to weave deathgates.

    Whether you believe that Lews Therin has a mind of his own or not, Lews Therin didn't "show" Rand how to weave Deathgates.  Rand (or Lews Therin) just wove them, and as they were forming, Rand knew what those weaves were called, with no commentary.


    these were fairly stressful and emotional moments for rand, and LTT was there.

    I'm of the opinion that Lews Therin, the apparently sentient personality, is born of stressful moments - in particular the stress that the memories cause Rand, and his desire to disassociate himself from those memories by denying them.


    for myself, it is the active interaction that makes LTT more real and less construct.

    Have you ever read Calvin and Hobbes?


    he provides information known only to LTT and shows rand some pretty nifty and useful tricks that rand may otherwise have never been able to think of. many of the weaves taught by LTT to rand have not been seen since the war of power.

    It's undeniable that Rand has gained a great deal of vital knowledge from Lews Therin's memories, but most of the important stuff comes to Rand without commentary.  Lews Therin's "presence" is generally very arbitrary, and as far as I can see, it only serves one real purpose.  With Lews Therin's "presence", Rand can pretend that the memories have nothing to do with him (especially those memories of his final mad act, and what we saw in the prologue of The Eye of the World).  Also, it is a convenient outlet not only for that guilt but also for other thoughts and emotions that Rand finds inconvenient.  Lews Therin's wild reactions to Taim and Asha'man in general are a good example of this - when Lews Therin is "gone" in the period I mentioned before, those thoughts and emotions remain, but Rand can no longer pretend that they are not his own thoughts.


    This is a rather involved subject, though I feel that the construct theory satisfies Occam's Razor far better than the assumption that Lews Therin is a sentient entity separate from Rand (why some supernatural being whose "presence" isn't quite logical when there is a much simpler and logical psychological explanation?) and what I've said here isn't anywhere near a comprehensive defense of this theory - I'll probably never have time to present a comprehensive defense on this board - but I hope I was able to elucidate what the construct theory actually implies.

  • Create New...