This was intuitive and obvious btw, no clue why it was even a point.

Bruh you can count that one as a hard claim I slept on it and still think this is conceptually wrong enough to be wolf motivation. Words have definitions. A 3 player WTL is a different thing than a reads list. EP getting instantly salty about the distinction is a wolf trying to sell a line. These two questions above are somehow worse. vote: SD Tbh this seemed jokey to me, and I see where it was followed up on. No one would out themselves on page 10 over a thing like this. Hell, the only reason I think EPs or SDs posts are real is because EP has the subtlety and rust of an axe left in the stump and SD is trying to jump on any WIFOM he can find. Cool so Turins town.

There's an incredibly easier one which also happens to be the right answer.

I promise you do not

If anyone needs that explained I have a handy wiki that'll help. https://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?title=Mafia

Vote: EP EZ start

Ah I gotcha. A couple issues there. First, I didn't associate a WTL with a full reads list. Second, and more important, that's not the beating the grass DPR was doing that I referred to.

We are in for a long game aren't we?

Ah, nono. No sus at all, just wariness. He's been watching his spouse play and he sounds not like a noob. Been fooled by new players too many times, acknowledging that I'm not biting on that again to give them free town points is not the same as sussing them. When did DPR ask for the list? That'd actually take away the bit of cred I was giving.

OK I think I got it. You're saying DPR asked for a list from someone and I sussed you for DPR not giving a list. I have no idea how you got that from what I said, but it's what it appears you took away.

I for the life of me can't follow what you're trying to say here.

Woulda been sick if you pulled it off, but that's the game sometimes. What are you seeing so far in this one?

Yeah I dunno that claiming 3p was the most +ev play lol

Tarot, horoscopes, Myers Briggs, it's so human to want to be seen. I kinda dig gettin the empress tho.

Ya'll gotta get with the times, Mudvayne was cool 20 years ago. They still are, but they were too. Saw em in concert once. Reads are pretty non outside of this page. This isn't sus, but I'ma be wary of Teph. He's brand new but he's been watching his wife's games and clearly has the voice of someone who already know the game, so that's a danger. That said, the excitement to play looks good. Unprompted reads list was a positive surprise as well. Wes beating the grass is also positive. EP bit instantly, but the meta's so old that I really just wanna sit on that for now. Are we through the joke phase?

If you don’t derail the next 20 pages for setup spec we’re lynching you

If by this you mean am I gonna try to be the hero and absolutely die for it… Yes.

God it’s good to be town again, that was not the way to come back from a multi-year hiatus. And cabin in the woods imo, best in the genre.

🙂 JK good to see you EP

Who?

In

Key where are the sign ups for that next game? I need to spam lol

You hit nontown every day except day 1 mate. It was a good effort, but the D1 claim and the fact that all town PRs claimed by D2 were disastrous for town.

For anyone who missed it here’s a link to the game doc. I have a few fake-aways for other mods. 1) Give your game enough kill actions that it runs for about 4 days. The crowd here is too busy to engage longer than that, and activity really falls off. This one overstayed its welcome a bit between the no NK N1 and the condemner not popping off, 2) I really wanted to put a ton of effort into the flavor so it rewarded the people returning. A 36 page story (which actually did align with game events FWIW, down to Ithi (John) being the character John McClane and being the one to hammer Heavy (Hummingbird)), role PMs with photos and themes, multi-page GSD, setup options, blah blah blah. You don’t gotta do all that. Putting 2-3 hours a night into a game is not fun like it was a decade ago. 3) Assume good intent, no one who came back is trying to do anything other than have fun. Things got heated once or twice midgame and in hindsight I’m happy I let them roll. You’re all very capable of self policing and expressing boundaries. Maybe not in the healthiest way, but there was nothing here that couldn’t be mended in a few sentences post game. 4) The meta is in a weird spot. People want to believe their expectations of mafia are true. Could just be rust, but a lot of those foundational concepts about the game were held more rigidly than they had been in the past. Anticipate a lot of wins for the mafia team if that trend continues. 5) Remember, your game is only balanced until it starts. After that it’s on the players. There were a number of times I wanted to say something in this game, such as that whole annoying conversation about “what did the mod mean about this part of x role interaction and the condemner”, but anything I said would’ve been alignment indicative for people in the hot seat. Couldn’t do it. If town wants to lose a lynch on that, so be it.

Game Over. Mafia Wins. Congratulations to: Ithillian Turambar - John McClane - Bruce Willis - Die Hard, Mafia Godfather keyholder21 - John Rambo - Sylvester Stallone - First Blood, Mafia Roleblocker ed2funy - Terminator - Arnold Schwarzenegger - Terminator, Mafia Goon Link to the Game Doc Thanks everyone for playing. I hope you all had fun, it was a real treasure to get to mod for you again!