Fair enough. I'm heading off to work now so will only have a short chance to comment on my break and then a little before deadline.

MOD, can you prod everyone to make sure they know deadline is tonight?

Also, notice the emphasis on Dices I'M in that quote?

 

Someone with a quicker wit than I could have caught that as his claim on D1

Like I already said I noticed Dice's claim but would not expect Dar to as she is not a regular mafia player.

*moves over to the hopefully repaired large Gryffindor chest

Alohomora large Gryffindor chest

Hopefully that worked

But in your post you said Dar said dice claimed Seamus. That was a misrep.

The whole thing you are bringing up about the death eaters is deflection. (It was also something I mentioned in my post regarding this event)

You are changing your arguments because the facts are not in your favour.

[unvote]

[V] Led [/v]

Maybe you should just start posting funny cat pictures.

Still willing to consider voting Elgee or Ed. Anyone else I will need to see a good case.

Rhea, having second thoughts?

Led, where was your vote at EoD yesterday?

I quoted the relevant items. It should be on the previous page.

I disagree. But what can ya do. Gotta defend your scum mate.

And to address the theory that's sprouted up about me being the only one alive out of those who voted Daruya, think for a minute. Use ya brains.

 

I was the first one to vote her. I parked my vote there the majority of D1. Why in the name of all that is holy would I single myself out by killing everyone else on that wagon if I was scum? What would I gain?

 

No, Turin is our scum here. I'm back and forth on Daruya, and I was torn between Lessa and Elgee.

 

My town list so far is much shorter. Me and Verbal.

 

That's my take on it.

What is your case on me again?

Rhea, I would like you to use reparo on the large Gryffindor chest. Consider it a trust building exercise.

For clarity she is Dar and him is Dice.

How is that a misrep Turin? She saw it, she said she saw it. The more you keep defending her the more you are convincing me that you and her are scum.

 

[v]Turin[/v]

She noticed him claim town. Everyone claims town. You said she said he claimed Seamus. This was false. Therefore you misrepresented what she in fact said. It is quite clear. You may have backed away from it but you definitely misrepped her statement.

When I pulled up the roster I noticed something I had not before. Ben is listed as killed on Day 1. To me this means his death was related to Darthe's in some way that is not clear at this time. so anyone suggesting that it was related to a Night action is imo wrong and might be purposely pushing a false theory to put suspicion on the people that got items.

ROSTER:

1. Turin Turambar: TTT

2. Lessa Nikia: Polyjuice thing was weird. Not much in way of memorable posts

3. ed2funy: absent most of the game.

4. Elgee:don't like her cote on Dar. The "reasoning" doesn't match up to me.

5. Rhea: following early IMO, possibly looking to pocket. Some solid posts though. Not a high priority for me.

6. Devil's Advocate:been quiet mostly would liketo hear more.

7. Verbal32: early town read. Bit worried about how he said to not use flavour early but willing to totally accept a late character claim as reason to back off someone.

8. LedZepMan: still don't like the slytherin door choice. Like his changing reason even less. Also not liking the misrep on Dar about Dice's claim.

9. Gentled Ben (m: Nyn) - Neville Longbottom, Town - Killed D1

10. dicetosser1 - Seamus Finnigan, Town - Killed N1

11. Dar'Jen Ab Owain: New quiet, please speak up more. Also please re-explain your thought process on your Darthe vote.

12. Darthe - Harry Potter, Town - Lynched D1

13. Daruya: still think likely town. I may just be refusing to admit mistake tho. I thought early posts were real and not trying to push an agenda. Will re-evaluate.

14. charis sedai: also mostly quiet. Seems to be trying tho. Come on Charis, give us more thoughts.

Rhea, my "following" concern is based on posts that seem to be agreeing with others. To put it another way A lack of original content in my opinion. I only have my phone at present so can't quote and explain better.

I'm working again tonight so will be mostly absent running up to deadline. I will try to give my thoughts on everyone soon.

Have we completed the Gryffindor long path now? The large chest blew up when the path was cleared, but I'm not sure what is down that tunnel.

 

*holds her wand out in front and steps over the rubble to move into the path*

 

Lets keep going guys!

Good morning thread.

Anyone around?

Lessa has solved Deathly Hallows part 2. 

1 point to GRYFFINDOR!!!

If anyone wants to look at Ed's 4 entire posts they are recapped as such:

1.) joke vote on Charis.

2.) nothing vote on me.

3.) response to dice joking with him

4.) says going to reread... 

side note: I didn't use my treasure from yesterday as I feel it would be more valuable later in the game. 

I would like to ask LEssa, Elgee, and Devil if they used theirs. If yes, do we have any results? or at least what the treasure was?

Mine was a 1x of something that I would consider tricksy but can be used to benefit town. I had the small Slytherin chest.

Lessa had the Large Slytherin chest.

Elgee had the Large Hufflepuff chest.

Delvil had the small Hufflepuff chest.

LZM got the small Gryffindor chest today.  

 

YES!!! No DEATHEATER FOR ME!!!!!!!!!!!!! drinks a pint

 

 

 

 

if you think IM trying to levitate that thing think again!!

 

 

Spell name Finite Incantatem! at the magical explosion in the middle of the path

Dice actually claimed his role here.

 

I'm rereAding btw.

 

Dice actually claimed his CHARACTER HERE with the gif which is a common thing for Dice and could also have been him being excited to be able to use Seamus as a fake claim. All he claimed in his words was not a Death eater. Which he actually could have claimed and be a baddie in this game if the baddies are from the pool of Umbridge, Filch, Malfoy, Crabbe and Goyle. The only one with the mark I believe is Malfoy.

Dar actually only noted that he clamed town. I was the one that suggested he was claiming Seamus. Which Dice pretty much confirmed. 

 

[b]Dice appears and claims town and casts FINITE INCANTATUM which stops the explosions but also unconfunds the troll.[/b]

 

 

Daruya notices his claim of Seamus.

 

Quoted for reocrd

Oops my bold didn't work on the last one. This is the first person to say anything about dice claiming.

Zep kinda changes what he is saying. 

 

Looking with side eyes at all the people voting Dar right now.

 

I think she is showing definite town process so far.

Turin defends Dar.

 

I'm starting to think Dar really is scum.

 

Why does my defending her make you think she might be mafia? The only way that works if I am mafia also. I'm not so my defending someone I think to be town has no bearing on her alignment. She might well be mafia but my defense here is Not Valid.

 

Let's stop a moment here. 

 

 

Zepp claims that I noted Dice's claim of Seamus. All I noted was that Dice claimed town. I didn’t even make the connection between Dice’s choice of a Seamus gif as being his character claim.

 

 

Zepp voted for me first. Then Dice voted for me because he mistakenly believed I didn’t want us scum hunting.  Then Darth voted for me. Then Gentled Ben.

 

 

Who, I say, who is the SOLE person still alive that was on my train?

 

 

 

Also note that Zepp is NOT voting for me today? Why? If I was "worthy" of a vote yesterday, and the death of Darthe, Dice and GB makes me that much more suspicious, why vote Turin? 

 

Right now, Zepp is seriously pegging my scum-meter. This isn’t about him being suspicious of me. It’s because of all of the first 4 people that voted for me, he’s the only one left alive. If I was scum, I’d never have been stupid enough to kill Darthe, Dice, and GB because suspicioun would then shift automatically to me. I don't play often but that's just common sense. Personally, I think he’s playing a clever game with his scum-buddies. And I fully expect that if I'm not lynched today, I'll end up getting killed tonight because if I can suss out one of them, they're all at risk.

 

My best friend was killed last night . . . It’s time to get serious about hunting scum because we lynched one of our own yesterday and the scum took out 2 of us last night.

 

Bold: here Dar states that she didn't notice the gif as a character claim and I would not expect her to as she doesn't play on the boards os hasn't seen the propensity of some people to do this. 

I normally don't care for the "I would never do THAT as mafia" argument. In this case I am not jumping at it because in THIS game There is NO way that I kill Dice over several others (The people with the items) As I doubt Dice is able to drive a lynch, he can't be  a PR so he isn't really a threat. It does kind of feel like an attempt to get an easy mislynch.   

Final clues are up!!! there is still time to guess on all the memories, granted it will only be worth 1 point each. You can all still hep your houses. Plus extra credit is still available. 

The scores are very close. A few more people per house could tip the balance.  

I will try to post videos of the various scenes once the game finishes.

[V] ed[/v]

His total contribution on D1 was a joke vote on charis and a wasted vote on me. Need more than that from him.

The Dar case was rubbish. The Dar'Jen case wasn't much better and felt more like Darthe using wordplay to grill a newb.

The interaction with Ben felt like mafia being mad and lashing out because he was getting lynched for what he felt was a bad reason.

If I was going to move I would have moved to Dice or Elgee I think. But I didn't have time to push it so my vote just would have been wasted.

I still think Dar is town and didn't want to have it swing there.

So out of the character names on that list, who is mafia? It doesn't matter if this is HP week. I expect there to be one of the big three as a mafia safe fakeclaim otherwise the game is broken IMO. In LEGO HP mafia none of the big three were even in the game so there is precedent. I believe there have been large characters as fakes in other HP week games as well.

The priority at this point should be getting an answer for why Turin & Daruya did not unvote. Based on those answers, we can continue to analyze votes and discuss......but this is a major issue that needs to be resolved, pronto.

What is mafia hiding on a train more likely to do post and not unvote/ change votes or just avoid the thread altogether? The former opens you up to scrutiny while the second is a built in excuse. Deadline for me was like 3 am. I made my good night post after 1 am. I had been at work for the previous several jours and had a single break. I gave no value to Darthe claiming Harry. I thought he was fake claiming late in order to get out of the lynch. I discarded it tbh.