-
Posts
21399 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Store
Gallery
Blogs
News
Downloads
Events
Posts posted by SinisterDeath
-
-
Mat Cauthon - 6
Perrin Aybara - 6
Egwene al'Vere - 9
Nynaeve al'Meara - 6
Lan Mandragoran - 5 (-1)
Thom Merrilin - 6
Min Farshaw - 10
Loial - 7(+1)
Padan Fain - 9
Logain Ablar - 9
Siuan Sanche - 7
Ba'alzamon (Ishamael) - 9
Tam al'Thor - 3
Out
Alviarin Freidhen
Moiraine Damodred
Rand al'Thor
Alanna Mosvani
Leane Sharif
-
(BT) - 7
(WT) - 47
(SG) - 54
(S) - 51
(BT) Arie - 7
(WT) Arie - 4
(WT) WD - 17
(WT) CaddySedai - 3
(WT) Heavy - 23
(SG) Arie - 35
(SG) Lily - 19
(S) SD - 51
-
Mat Cauthon - 6
Perrin Aybara - 6
Egwene al'Vere - 8
Nynaeve al'Meara - 6
Lan Mandragoran - 6
Thom Merrilin - 6
Min Farshaw - 10 (-1)
Loial - 6 (+1)
Padan Fain - 9
Logain Ablar - 9
Siuan Sanche - 7
Ba'alzamon (Ishamael) - 9
Tam al'Thor - 3
Out
Alviarin Freidhen
Moiraine Damodred
Rand al'Thor
Alanna Mosvani
Leane Sharif
-
(BT) - 7
(WT) - 46
(SG) - 54
(S) - 50
(BT) Arie - 7
(WT) Arie - 4
(WT) WD - 17
(WT) CaddySedai - 3
(WT) Heavy - 22
(SG) Arie - 35
(SG) Lily - 19
(S) SD - 50
-
Mat Cauthon - 6
Perrin Aybara - 6
Egwene al'Vere - 9
Nynaeve al'Meara - 6
Lan Mandragoran - 6
Thom Merrilin - 6
Min Farshaw - 9
Loial - 6
Padan Fain - 10
Logain Ablar - 9
Siuan Sanche - 6
Ba'alzamon (Ishamael) - 9 (+1)
Tam al'Thor - 3 (-1)
Out
Alviarin Freidhen
Moiraine Damodred
Rand al'Thor
Alanna Mosvani
Leane Sharif
-
(BT) - 7
(WT) - 44
(SG) - 51
(S) - 49
(BT) Arie - 7
(WT) Arie - 4
(WT) WD - 17
(WT) CaddySedai - 3
(WT) Heavy - 20
(SG) Arie - 33
(SG) Lily - 18
(S) SD - 49
-
Mat Cauthon - 6
Perrin Aybara - 6
Egwene al'Vere - 10
Nynaeve al'Meara - 6
Lan Mandragoran - 6
Thom Merrilin - 6
Min Farshaw - 9
Loial - 6
Padan Fain - 10
Logain Ablar - 8
Siuan Sanche - 6
Ba'alzamon (Ishamael) - 8 (+1)
Tam al'Thor - 4 (-1)
Out
Alviarin Freidhen
Moiraine Damodred
Rand al'Thor
Alanna Mosvani
Leane Sharif
-
I did a little more digging.
The line "weapon against shadowspawn and darkfriends" comes from the Wheel of Time Companion.
The last book to have a Glossary entry on the Three Oathes was New Spring, which was published after a Crown of Swords.
New Spring came out between Path of Daggers & Winters Heart.
Canonically within the books, Moiraine spoke her oath to say "shadowspawn" she did not say dark friends.
So canonically she is bound to the limits of the wording she used on the oath rod, which means she can't use it as a weapon except in the defense of her life or against shadowspawn.
It's possible some other Aes Sedai included the verbiage "and dark friends" and RJ later retconned this in his later novels as he realized he done messed up.- HeavyHalfMoonBlade, Shawlee and Elgee
- 1
- 2
-
(BT) - 7
(WT) - 43
(SG) - 50
(S) - 48
(BT) Arie - 7
(WT) Arie - 4
(WT) WD - 17
(WT) CaddySedai - 3
(WT) Heavy - 19
(SG) Arie - 32
(SG) Lily - 18
(S) SD - 48
-
Mat Cauthon - 6
Perrin Aybara - 6
Egwene al'Vere - 9
Nynaeve al'Meara - 6
Lan Mandragoran - 6
Thom Merrilin - 6
Min Farshaw - 9
Loial - 6
Padan Fain - 10
Logain Ablar - 9
Siuan Sanche - 6
Leane Sharif - 0 (-1)
Ba'alzamon (Ishamael) - 7 (+1)
Tam al'Thor - 5
Out
Alviarin Freidhen
Moiraine Damodred
Rand al'Thor
Alanna Mosvani -
21 minutes ago, Elgee said:
Against Shadowspawn, not against Darkfiends (see my post above)
@Elgee is correct about the Book Oaths.
I just checked New Spring where Moiraine took the Oaths and that's what it says.
I checked the appendix of Shadow Rising and Crown of Swords and they state Shadowspawn, not Darkfriends.
So the "wiki" here is wrong.
https://wot.fandom.com/wiki/Three_Oaths
That said. The oaths as we know of them in the show, omit any mention of the word shadowspawn. -
(BT) - 7
(WT) - 42
(SG) - 50
(S) - 47
(BT) Arie - 7
(WT) Arie - 4
(WT) WD - 17
(WT) CaddySedai - 3
(WT) Heavy - 18
(SG) Arie - 32
(SG) Lily - 18
(S) SD - 47
-
Mat Cauthon - 6
Perrin Aybara - 6
Egwene al'Vere - 9
Nynaeve al'Meara - 6 (+1)
Lan Mandragoran - 6
Thom Merrilin - 6
Min Farshaw - 8
Loial - 6
Padan Fain - 10
Logain Ablar - 9
Siuan Sanche - 6
Leane Sharif - 1
Alanna Mosvani - 1 (-1)
Ba'alzamon (Ishamael) - 6
Tam al'Thor - 5
Out
Alviarin Freidhen
Moiraine Damodred
Rand al'Thor
-
Mat Cauthon - 6 (+1)
Perrin Aybara - 6
Egwene al'Vere - 9
Nynaeve al'Meara - 5
Lan Mandragoran - 6
Thom Merrilin - 6
Min Farshaw - 7
Loial - 6
Padan Fain - 10
Logain Ablar - 9
Siuan Sanche - 6
Leane Sharif - 2 (-1)
Alanna Mosvani - 2
Ba'alzamon (Ishamael) - 6
Tam al'Thor - 5
Out
Alviarin Freidhen
Moiraine Damodred
Rand al'Thor
-
(BT) - 7
(WT) - 40
(SG) - 49
(S) - 46
(BT) Arie - 7
(WT) Arie - 4
(WT) WD - 17
(WT) CaddySedai - 3
(WT) Heavy - 16
(SG) Arie - 31
(SG) Lily - 18
(S) SD - 46
-
Mat Cauthon - 5
Perrin Aybara - 6 (+1)
Egwene al'Vere - 8
Nynaeve al'Meara - 5
Lan Mandragoran - 6
Thom Merrilin - 6
Min Farshaw - 7 )
Loial - 6
Padan Fain - 10
Logain Ablar - 9
Siuan Sanche - 6
Leane Sharif - 3
Alanna Mosvani - 3 (-1)
Ba'alzamon (Ishamael) - 6
Tam al'Thor - 5
Out
Alviarin Freidhen
Moiraine Damodred
Rand al'Thor
-
(BT) - 7
(WT) - 39
(SG) - 48
(S) - 45
(BT) Arie - 7
(WT) Arie - 4
(WT) WD - 17
(WT) CaddySedai - 3
(WT) Heavy - 15
(SG) Arie - 30
(SG) Lily - 18
(S) SD - 45
-
Mat Cauthon - 5
Perrin Aybara - 5
Egwene al'Vere - 8 (-1)
Nynaeve al'Meara - 5
Lan Mandragoran - 6
Thom Merrilin - 6
Min Farshaw - 6
Loial - 6
Padan Fain - 12 (+1)
Logain Ablar - 9
Siuan Sanche - 5
Leane Sharif - 3
Alanna Mosvani - 4
Ba'alzamon (Ishamael) - 6
Tam al'Thor - 5
Out
Alviarin FreidhenMoiraine DamodredRand al'Thor -
Rand al'Thor - 0 (-1)
Mat Cauthon - 5
Perrin Aybara - 5
Egwene al'Vere - 8
Nynaeve al'Meara - 5
Lan Mandragoran - 6
Thom Merrilin - 6
Min Farshaw - 6
Loial - 6
Padan Fain - 11
Logain Ablar - 9
Siuan Sanche - 5
Leane Sharif - 4
Alanna Mosvani - 4
Ba'alzamon (Ishamael) - 6 (+1) (I win again Lews Therin)
Tam al'Thor - 5
Out
Alviarin Freidhen
Moiraine Damodred
-
(BT) - 7
(WT) - 38
(SG) - 48
(S) - 44
(BT) Arie - 7
(WT) Arie - 4
(WT) WD - 17
(WT) CaddySedai - 3
(WT) Heavy - 14
(SG) Arie - 30
(SG) Lily - 18
(S) SD - 44
-
Rand al'Thor - 1 (-1)
Mat Cauthon - 5
Perrin Aybara - 5
Egwene al'Vere - 7
Nynaeve al'Meara - 5
Lan Mandragoran - 6
Thom Merrilin - 6
Min Farshaw - 6
Loial - 6
Padan Fain - 12 (+1)
Logain Ablar - 9
Siuan Sanche - 5
Leane Sharif - 4
Alanna Mosvani - 4
Ba'alzamon (Ishamael) - 5
Tam al'Thor - 5
Out
Alviarin FreidhenMoiraine Damodred -
Rand al'Thor - 3 (-1)
Mat Cauthon - 5
Perrin Aybara - 5
Egwene al'Vere - 7
Nynaeve al'Meara - 5
Lan Mandragoran - 6
Thom Merrilin - 6
Min Farshaw - 6
Loial - 6
Padan Fain - 11 (+1)
Logain Ablar - 8
Siuan Sanche - 5
Leane Sharif - 4
Alanna Mosvani - 4
Ba'alzamon (Ishamael) - 5
Tam al'Thor - 5
Out
Alviarin FreidhenMoiraine Damodred -
Rand al'Thor - 4
Mat Cauthon - 5
Perrin Aybara - 5
Egwene al'Vere - 8 (-1)
Nynaeve al'Meara - 5
Lan Mandragoran - 6
Thom Merrilin - 6
Min Farshaw - 6
Loial - 6
Padan Fain - 10
Logain Ablar - 8
Siuan Sanche - 5
Leane Sharif - 4
Alanna Mosvani - 4
Ba'alzamon (Ishamael) - 5 (+1)
Tam al'Thor - 4
Out
Alviarin FreidhenMoiraine Damodred -
(BT) - 7
(WT) - 36
(SG) - 45
(S) - 43
(BT) Arie - 7
(WT) Arie - 4
(WT) WD - 17
(WT) CaddySedai - 3
(WT) Heavy - 12
(SG) Arie - 29
(SG) Lily - 16
(S) SD - 43
Last One Standing
in Community Games
Posted
Mat Cauthon - 6
Perrin Aybara - 6
Egwene al'Vere - 9 (-1)
Nynaeve al'Meara - 6
Lan Mandragoran - 5
Thom Merrilin - 6
Min Farshaw - 10
Loial - 8 (+1)
Padan Fain - 9
Logain Ablar - 9
Siuan Sanche - 7
Ba'alzamon (Ishamael) - 9
Tam al'Thor - 2
Out
Alviarin Freidhen
Moiraine Damodred
Rand al'Thor
Alanna Mosvani
Leane Shari