Again, to convince us that Dice isn't the Cop and line Rand up fir next day lynch. Unless you're referring to the question directed at Rand and if that's the case, idk what that's supposed to tell me

And if the towniest town since the creation of town really is town, we'd be hard pressed not to lynch him if Dice in fact turns out to be the Cop

Maybe to convince us to lynch our cop?

I hate to point out the obvious but, Dice isn't the only one that's called you scum for your behavior at EoD. And I gotta say, you doing the "biggest concrete town" spiel just brings me back to how scummy you look. Maybe Dice is the cop, maybe not...it's something we're going to have to figure out. But just because you feel you should've looked town with your behavior and continuously point out how town it looked, doesn't mean everyone agrees.

I see it that yes, town would explain that they're in the process of heading home so service will be spotty. But I also see it that doing it in one liner posts mixed in with the serious direct questions is way too chaotic to be advantageous to you or the rest of us. Yes, but it is also what someone trying to stress their importance without outright claiming would do as well. Just like the way you handled the situation could be viewed as extremely town or extremely scum. My biggest issue is that with the soft claiming, it would've made him a target for the real cop if he isn't the cop. The actual cop could then argue points on Day 2 to get Dice tossed. As it was Day 1, there was time to step back and go another direction which would give a little time for us to determine if he was legit.

He started with this, dropping a hint that there is a reason not to vote him without giving a reason. this was in response to Rand asking if there was a reason he shouldnt be voting Dice. Again, not arguing his case, just stating there is a reason. he's getting more insistent Quotes his previous post, adding more weight to it Hint He was out of options. Here's the thing, could he be lying? Absolutely, but isn't it better to err on the side of caution here? Especially on Day 1. @Verbal32

This whole thing completely reads scummy af. It's obvious Dice was claiming an important town role. But you wouldn't stop until he said which one...fine, I'll give you the benefit of doubt on that one. But the rest of that exchange literally reads as 1) you're spamming the thread with excuses of why you may or may not be available to unvote. 2) said spamming is doing nothing except making it harder for anyone trying to hurry and decide about a vote because they have to read what form of transportation you're currently using. 3) it reads to me like you're making those excuses to buy time. The only reason I can figure you'd want to do that is you're waiting for your scummy buddies to give you input. So you covered yourself by teetering back and forth on whether you'll be available at any given moment. Just based on pages 26-28, I'm almost positive you're scum. Unless you're really new to mafia...idk. Someone hints at an important town role, idk how you go from being absolutely unwilling to unvote dice to sure I'll vote Marsh. Just wanted to get that out there.

That absolutely blows. Thank you

Bloody hell, im finally caught up. Wonderful timing i know. As I missed EoD, I'm sure a lot will be read into that but truth is, I'm old and tired..I fell asleep. I'm wanting to hurry and get my summaries and spreadsheet Posted before night ends in case I don't live to see the day dawn. I do have a quick question though, how can you see exact times for when a post was made? Some say exact time then some say 6 hours ago.

Okay, what's what I've got so far. Gonna try to hurry and get the rest in so I can join the real time convo. Probably won't immediately respond if someone asks something or anything as it's a beast to remember my exact spot if I navigate away and my brain sucks (hence the spreadsheet/page by page breakdowns) 🤷‍♀️

Quick summary of pages 5-7: Heavy is clearly the first real pressure point. DPR is lowkey setting up a possible mislynch or wolfhunt with that group callout. Early tensions are starting to form, especially around Heavy. There’s a lot of emotional posting from Heavy, some mild pressure from Ithi and dice, a few jokes from DPR and ed, and Iron trying to bring a bit of analytical calm to it. Trying to remember DPR's style. Just find it really hard to believe he'd seem so scummy if he were actually scum. But still in the air. --- It seems like Heavy is newer to the group (not sure about this) and feels a little defensive about getting early suspicion, but is trying to lean into the fun ("I AM LYNCH!"), while others like dicetosser1 are joking about lynching Heavy for the memes. Ithi is analyzing reactions, especially Heavy's emotional swings, and is starting to find Iron more suspicious for how they're treating Heavy. Nynaeve is being patient and digging into experience levels for meta reasons. Overall, classic early Day 1 Mafia forum vibe: Light jokes and memes Some early poking at emotional reactions First attempts to form "serious" reads based on tone/behavior, not necessarily solid evidence yet. DPR and his "For the players new to the game, a classic drive-by post executed perfectly. 10/10" 🙄 Weird that he failed to mention others with "drive by" posts or lack of posts at all. But does this lead me to believe he's scum? Idk. He's too smart to head a Bandwagon lynch on Day 1 when blatantly ignoring others...or would that be his defense when I flip town? Vibe: Really wishing I could read Heavy and his behavior...maybe that's the type of frazzle for new age mafia? Watching to see how hard DPR pushes this...and watching to see how he responds when called out for it. Standing as of end of page 7: Strong suspicion of Heavy and DPR. May change when I finish reading? Idk, I can't shake Heavy's game play but still can't tell if it's just because of his seemingly back and forth energy, his defensiveness at times, or if it's his norm.

Summary page 4 Playful chaos is continuing, with a real shift now into some actual early suspicion, especially between Heavy, Ithi, Ed, and a bit of Ironeyes and DPR. Main Dynamics: Ironeyes — Clarifies he’s not actually a lawyer. His tone is defensive but in a joking way. Heavy and Ed both pick at him for it. Early Vote Movement: dice early-votes Iron (playful reason). Ithi votes Heavy — says Heavy is "saying confusing things without saying anything" and "doesn’t feel right." Gonna have to agree. Never interacted with him before so not sure if its out of character...gonna keep my eye on him. Heavy — gets very defensive when voted. Argues back at Ithi, calls the vote "weak sauce," throws shade around in a semi-aggressive tone. Suggests the voters are wolfy themselves. Says he's "never been a wolf" and that the bandwagoners should "out themselves." ed — leans into the confusion humor, lightly poking both Heavy and Ironeyes. Very spammy and chaotic. Ed is always scummy though, even when he isn't scum so....(???) DPR — points out that there’s probably at least one wolf among Iron, Heavy, and Ed — plants an early “wolf grouping” seed. Nynaeve — pushes back on Iron, questioning why he only responded to the part of DPR’s post that mentioned him and not Ed. Heavy vs Ithi mini-fight — Heated but still with jokes layered in. --- Tone Shifts: Less pure spam, more early reads and shade-throwing. The confusion about lawyer jokes turned into real light suspicion. Heavy is starting to come under real pressure. --- Early Observations: Heavy’s reaction to Ithi’s pressure is emotional and defensive, which often (but not always) leans wolfy. Ithi’s case is super light ("you're confusing"), but the push is clear. Ed stays very jokey — suspicious if you believe wolves try to hide early. DPR planting a group suspicion early is notable, could be either good townie instincts or wolf opportunism. Iron feels a bit overwhelmed but in a natural way. General Feel: The vibe is moving toward a messy "wolf or just chaotic town?" puzzle around Heavy, Ed, and Iron. Some serious threads of suspicion are starting, but there’s still a ton of jokey clutter.

Indeed lol

Summary Pages 1-3 Turin is poking at Heavy for saying there's a lot of early votes, asking questions to maybe dig a little deeper (or just stir a little). Heavy is resisting getting pulled into anything serious, saying early actions aren't AI (Alignment Indicative) and that the early votes are just a lot, nothing more. Ithi jumped in, asking what AI meant, leading to a little lingo explanation. Nynaeve and Keyholder started asking about Heavy experience, teasing them a bit because they seemed more seasoned based on how they talked but actually have only played two games. General vibe: playful, a little teasing, a lot of nostalgia since it seems like some of the players are old friends from previous games. No one is seriously scumhunting yet. It’s mostly people re-establishing bonds, feeling out who’s who, and setting the stage for more serious play later.

Okay! I've made it to page 8 in my catching up...a couple of things first I hate holiday but my kids love them so yeah I spent most of Saturday and all day yesterday doing the giant bunny crap. Then last night learned there was a threat made to one of the schools my kids go to so I've been dealing with that today. Also, it's been a minute since I've done this and as I go through every page marking crap down, using a spreadsheet, and summarizing each page so I don't spend forever searching for one specific post. Once upon a time, I had a desktop computer which I used for mafia games, now I'm using a phone so it has slowed the process considerably. Anyway, even know I've only made it halfway through, I'm seeing all the shade being thrown at me...some of which is kinda shady as people failed to mention someone that hadn't checked in yet and someone else that had only popped in for a minute. I wouldn't have thought much about the shade being thrown my way had others not been excluded for the same behavior and honestly DPR, I know you can do better for a day 1 bandwagon lynch. I'll be posting each part separately as well as my overall view to that point. Be patient.

Sorry! I'm here. I had a .... situation... that distracted me. I'm gonna read and catch up then will join the fun. Thanks for the summary Verbal. Lol

Told mine that idgaf what they say as long as I don't get called into school over it. Next day I got called in because my youngest son (17) said ...ummm...."fluff" in front of a teacher after he ran into a door jam.

In defense of myself, i used to use nothing but WoT bad words...especially around my kids. But then I started working at a prison and it was all downhill from there 🤷‍♀️

As the Wheel wills.

It's been a hot minute since I've been here! Haven't played mafia (except our half ass facebook version) in FOREVER. I forget....am I allowed to say ass?

Still have room?