[Basic]What's the theme? - ad lib mafia

[Andrej]

 

So are you thinking it's a scum slip then, Bop?

i think it is possible

Would lol so hard

 

Her reaction isn't great either

 

I'd still like to hear from Hallia first

[MrsClov]

 

 

So are you thinking it's a scum slip then, Bop?

i think it is possible

Would lol so hard

 

Her reaction isn't great either

 

I'd still like to hear from Hallia first

 

I kind of want it to happen for the entertainment factor.

[Andrej]

I sort of want to, too. Just because I don't like the idea of her continuing to be a question mark later and later into the game. She's never getting NK'd imo.

[MrsClov]

I sort of want to, too. Just because I don't like the idea of her continuing to be a question mark later and later into the game. She's never getting NK'd imo.

I take it she doesn't get easier to read then?

[bopolis]

 

 

So are you thinking it's a scum slip then, Bop?

 

i think it is possible

 

Interesting observation. I honestly wouldn't have picked up on it, of course I didn't check her list of games in her sig either. Total curiosity, but what made you think to check it?

 

because i was looking at her past scum games and i only remember seeing 2 from her sig, so when she mentioned she's been scum 3 times it raised my hampster senses

[Andrej]

 

I sort of want to, too. Just because I don't like the idea of her continuing to be a question mark later and later into the game. She's never getting NK'd imo.

I take it she doesn't get easier to read then?

You'd be correct

[Andrej]

@Bop - pick up any similarities? Earlier you mentioned something about a detail that was missing from her scum games thus far. Mind sharing?

 

@Wifi - reasons with your reads plz. No light salmons? I'm used to more extensive details.

[MrsClov]

 

 

 

So are you thinking it's a scum slip then, Bop?

i think it is possible

Interesting observation. I honestly wouldn't have picked up on it, of course I didn't check her list of games in her sig either. Total curiosity, but what made you think to check it?

because i was looking at her past scum games and i only remember seeing 2 from her sig, so when she mentioned she's been scum 3 times it raised my hampster senses

My internet and I are going to fight tonight.

[MrsClov]

 

 

 

 

So are you thinking it's a scum slip then, Bop?

i think it is possible

Interesting observation. I honestly wouldn't have picked up on it, of course I didn't check her list of games in her sig either. Total curiosity, but what made you think to check it?

because i was looking at her past scum games and i only remember seeing 2 from her sig, so when she mentioned she's been scum 3 times it raised my hampster senses

My internet and I are going to fight tonight.

Apparently my phone didn't think it necessary to post my entire post.

 

I can't remember were you getting a scrum vibe from her prior to this? Has this changed your views on her?

[bopolis]

@Bop - pick up any similarities? Earlier you mentioned something about a detail that was missing from her scum games thus far. Mind sharing?

 

@Wifi - reasons with your reads plz. No light salmons? I'm used to more extensive details.

 

in the scum games most of her early reads seemed to be very hedgy(this is the one she subbed in to) and i don't think she voted very early and here she was on darthe pretty early and voted eldrick so initially i liked her as a villa, but when relooking at the start the eldrick vote was during screw around time so i don't give any cred for that. 

 

initially i liked wildfire because of this because pushing darthe, even though i don't like the reasoning behind it(ie his watcher claim), at least she was taking a stance as opposed to her hedgy could be this could be that reads in the mafia game i looked up.  

 

Also when I looked up her scum games I looked at her opening posts and some of her day 1 posts only, i didn't do a deep dive throughout the entire game.

[bopolis]

 

 

 

 

 

So are you thinking it's a scum slip then, Bop?

i think it is possible

Interesting observation. I honestly wouldn't have picked up on it, of course I didn't check her list of games in her sig either. Total curiosity, but what made you think to check it?

because i was looking at her past scum games and i only remember seeing 2 from her sig, so when she mentioned she's been scum 3 times it raised my hampster senses

My internet and I are going to fight tonight.

Apparently my phone didn't think it necessary to post my entire post.

 

I can't remember were you getting a scrum vibe from her prior to this? Has this changed your views on her?

 

 

slight villa lean on wifi early on, this 'slip' and her reaction make me think she's scum but there is a palpable 'wanting' it to be true that goes along with thinking it to be true

[MrsClov]

 

 

 

 

 

 

So are you thinking it's a scum slip then, Bop?

 

i think it is possible

Interesting observation. I honestly wouldn't have picked up on it, of course I didn't check her list of games in her sig either. Total curiosity, but what made you think to check it?

because i was looking at her past scum games and i only remember seeing 2 from her sig, so when she mentioned she's been scum 3 times it raised my hampster senses

My internet and I are going to fight tonight.

Apparently my phone didn't think it necessary to post my entire post.

I can't remember were you getting a scrum vibe from her prior to this? Has this changed your views on her?

 

slight villa lean on wifi early on, this 'slip' and her reaction make me think she's scum but there is a palpable 'wanting' it to be true that goes along with thinking it to be true

Have you played with her before anywhere or was the information in reply to AJ just research?

[bopolis]

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

So are you thinking it's a scum slip then, Bop?

i think it is possible

Interesting observation. I honestly wouldn't have picked up on it, of course I didn't check her list of games in her sig either. Total curiosity, but what made you think to check it?

because i was looking at her past scum games and i only remember seeing 2 from her sig, so when she mentioned she's been scum 3 times it raised my hampster senses

My internet and I are going to fight tonight.

Apparently my phone didn't think it necessary to post my entire post.

I can't remember were you getting a scrum vibe from her prior to this? Has this changed your views on her?

 

slight villa lean on wifi early on, this 'slip' and her reaction make me think she's scum but there is a palpable 'wanting' it to be true that goes along with thinking it to be true

Have you played with her before anywhere or was the information in reply to AJ just research?

 

I played with her once in lost and i thought she was wolfy and everyone else said this is her village game so i shrugged and said "its on all of you if your wrong" (she was indeed a villa).

[MrsClov]

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

So are you thinking it's a scum slip then, Bop?

 

i think it is possible

Interesting observation. I honestly wouldn't have picked up on it, of course I didn't check her list of games in her sig either. Total curiosity, but what made you think to check it?

because i was looking at her past scum games and i only remember seeing 2 from her sig, so when she mentioned she's been scum 3 times it raised my hampster senses

My internet and I are going to fight tonight.

Apparently my phone didn't think it necessary to post my entire post.

I can't remember were you getting a scrum vibe from her prior to this? Has this changed your views on her?

 

slight villa lean on wifi early on, this 'slip' and her reaction make me think she's scum but there is a palpable 'wanting' it to be true that goes along with thinking it to be true

Have you played with her before anywhere or was the information in reply to AJ just research?

I played with her once in lost and i thought she was wolfy and everyone else said this is her village game so i shrugged and said "its on all of you if your wrong" (she was indeed a villa).

Lol. It happens. I appreciate how forthcoming you are being. I'm hoping someone can give me a good rundown of her play style or something. I can't connect with her posts.

[Andrej]

She's a tough nut to crack, that's for sure.

 

There hasn't been a game where she isn't sussed/mislynched late in the game that I've been a part of from what I remember. The one time I played that she was scum was in a weird set up with no Town roles and a bunch of dueling mafia factions so not a very reliable source imo.

[Andrej]

Plus I basically ignored her D1 for more scummy targets and promptly got capped N1

[dicetosser1]

Players:

2. MrsClov

3. Darthe

4. Bopolis

5. Niniel

6. Verbal

7. Wildfire

8. Dice

9. Eldrick

10. Nolder

11. Lenlo

12. Ironeyes

13. Hallia

 

Just to be clear not everyone who isn't crossed off is a scum read. Those who are crossed off are those I don't want to lynch today.

 

so i am a scum read. Why?

 

Whys on the others would be good.

 

 

 

 

 

What makes you think that's what he's doing?

 

because its what it looks like and i had already wondered if anyone would do it

 

Well I say it looks like he's role fishing. What makes you right and me wrong?

 

 

 because im not the only one to think of it.

 

https://yourlogicalfallacyis.com/bandwagon

 

Try again.

 

Why do you think he's providing cover as opposed to any other explanation of his behavior?

 

 

Because thats what I think he is doing. That is how i read his post

 

 

 

I am ok with lynching Hallia based on her defense of Darthe but considering how many people are coming to Darthe's defense it makes far more sense to me to lynch him instead of risking a mislynch. That said,I will switch later if necessary.

I don't think we can maj anyone on D1. Sooh said there won't be a hammer so I think this phase is just considered plurality when the DL falls.

 

Anyway - what if Darthe ends up being a mislynch?

 

Does it matter really? We vote who we want to see lynched...

 

If Darthe is town I'll have to reassess. It's not like I've never mislynched someone before.

 

 

Ok so earlier when you asked me why I thought I was right? I left something out of my answer because I thought it impolite.

 

This however raises it.

 

The other reason is because you have a bias. and this post above reeks of it. Either that or its one of the scummiest posts going.

 

Could someone be so kind as to fill me in on page 23? I get a really weird error message when I try to load it. :( 

 

me too

[dicetosser1]

She's a tough nut to crack, that's for sure.

 

There hasn't been a game where she isn't sussed/mislynched late in the game that I've been a part of from what I remember. The one time I played that she was scum was in a weird set up with no Town roles and a bunch of dueling mafia factions so not a very reliable source imo.

 

OI! I was Town TYVM!!!

 

 

the only town but still town!

 

 

(hopes he and AJ are thinking of the same game lol.)

 

 

 

@lindz   Wifi takes time. I tend to read her by comparing her to past town games. Things like that Town Queenie comment in her read lists are standard. Its not foolproof but I think ive only been wrong maybe once?

[bopolis]

dice, what do you think of the supposed slip?

[bopolis]

i thought this whole time nolder==calder from lost and he just changed his avatar.

 

lol me

[MrsClov]

 

She's a tough nut to crack, that's for sure.

 

There hasn't been a game where she isn't sussed/mislynched late in the game that I've been a part of from what I remember. The one time I played that she was scum was in a weird set up with no Town roles and a bunch of dueling mafia factions so not a very reliable source imo.

OI! I was Town TYVM!!!

 

 

the only town but still town!

 

 

(hopes he and AJ are thinking of the same game lol.)

 

 

 

@lindz Wifi takes time. I tend to read her by comparing her to past town games. Things like that Town Queenie comment in her read lists are standard. Its not foolproof but I think ive only been wrong maybe once?

That's decent odds at least. I appreciate the help.

[dicetosser1]

dice, what do you think of the supposed slip?

 

i think you make a good point. I like that you spotted that. But I want to hold off on what I think til after wifi responds. Dont want to feed her excuses ya know?

[Andrej]

@Dice - I said not everyone who isn't crossed off are scum reads

 

You're not a scum read but you're not a Town read yet either

 

As far as the others go I have already discussed Lenlo and I'm voting Hallia currently

 

This is my second game with Bop so limited experience and I think he's capable of being a convincing wolf so cautionary read for now pending more development

 

Nini is null. Not a lot of content and her Nolder vote is easy for any alignment to make

 

Marsh doesn't have a lot of content to evaluate

[dicetosser1]

just went back and reread it. My bad bro

[Andrej]

Hallia never came back tonight.

 

Consider me concerned