[Basic] Pirates of the Caribbean (Curse of the Black Pearl) Game Thread - D2

[dyachei]

so why take the risk?

[dyachei]

did daarthe also hammer a wolf in that game?

 

If you look at everything together, there's no way it makes sense for me to be a wolf. Not even looking at individual posts

[monstrman]

Dyachei had the game won as a wolf

 

Same reason I can't be a wolf

 

That would mean tiink was a villager and I'd have won instead of voting besie

 

Besides on d2 I came gunning for both besie and Sooh so

[dyachei]

I dunno, her insistence is striking me as pretty wolfy, too

[Wildfire Sedai]

what about Pral. He's been flying under the radar.  I KNOW I am TOWN.  I don't know what I can do to convince you otherwise.  It has to be pral. I just thought of it.

 

me

monstr

tiink

pral

wifi

 

 

most town to most scum IMO

 

dya is cleared by darthes view on her and for changing her vote to besie.

monster is cleared for changing his vote to besie.

tiink is cleared cause he was the alternate train to besie. Though I still don't get how that clears him.  We could have had TWO w/w trains going. BUT for the sake of argument lets say that tiink is town. 

That leaves me and pral.

[monstrman]

Me too

 

I'm tempted to nuke wild tomorrow despite no lynch probability increase

[monstrman]

We should definitely no lynch tomorrow though

[dyachei]

what about Pral. He's been flying under the radar.  I KNOW I am TOWN.  I don't know what I can do to convince you otherwise.  It has to be pral. I just thought of it.

 

me

monstr

tiink

pral

wifi

 

 

most town to most scum IMO

 

dya is cleared by darthes view on her and for changing her vote to besie.

monster is cleared for changing his vote to besie.

tiink is cleared cause he was the alternate train to besie. Though I still don't get how that clears him.  We could have had TWO w/w trains going. BUT for the sake of argument lets say that tiink is town. 

That leaves me and pral.

he's not just cleared because he was a counterwagon.

 

Look at his interactions with besie. there's no way there were w/w

[dyachei]

and yes, you and pral.

 

I probably should ISO before I die and see if I find anything but I'm tired as hell

[monstrman]

and yes, you and pral.

 

I probably should ISO before I die and see if I find anything but I'm tired as hell

You good

 

You showed up and lynched a wolf

 

You did your part for the game. You're peeked. Rest now, little pop tart.

[dyachei]

Well, I started the pralaya ISO.

if he's scum, he deserves the win. Early suspicion on Besie and defense of tiink. reads list later looks bad - full town on sooh and null to town on besie despite earlier suspicions. Gets back to besie scum on d2. his ISO on sooh also leads to the besie conclusion. And he pushed her from that point on

 

you've played with him before, correct, monstr?

[dyachei]

I think it's just wifi here. wish we still had a vig though

[Wildfire Sedai]

 

and yes, you and pral.

 

I probably should ISO before I die and see if I find anything but I'm tired as hell

You good

 

You showed up and lynched a wolf

 

You did your part for the game. You're peeked. Rest now, little pop tart.

 

 

You know I am reading what monster is saying, telling you to rest now. He doesn't want you to look too deep.  I am thinking that maybe after all is said and done that I was right all along and monstr is the wolf? He seems to want you to go to sleep and not think about the game anymore except to do a ML in the morning. Maybe.

 

Maybe not.  However, I did an ISO on pral a lotta pages back.  Though to be honest I didn't do a conclusion for it, except for in the beginning to say that I think he is scummy because: and then quoted posts he made/commented on them.   

[dyachei]

wifi you keep trying to suspect those that are basically lock cleared. It's not a good thing to do

[Wildfire Sedai]

 

what about Pral. He's been flying under the radar.  I KNOW I am TOWN.  I don't know what I can do to convince you otherwise.  It has to be pral. I just thought of it.

 

me

monstr

tiink

pral

wifi

 

 

most town to most scum IMO

 

dya is cleared by darthes view on her and for changing her vote to besie.

monster is cleared for changing his vote to besie.

tiink is cleared cause he was the alternate train to besie. Though I still don't get how that clears him.  We could have had TWO w/w trains going. BUT for the sake of argument lets say that tiink is town. 

That leaves me and pral.

he's not just cleared because he was a counterwagon.

 

Look at his interactions with besie. there's no way there were w/w

 

 

Could have been staged.  Darthe and I did it during the Grimfrostbitten one...not as deep as that but that's because we were hardly on at same time in the qt.  tiink is in the UK and besie is where again??

 

We should definitely no lynch tomorrow though

 

why no lynch though.  I do not understand.  The only time I remember a no lynch happening it was for the wolves to win.

 

 

wifi you keep trying to suspect those that are basically lock cleared. It's not a good thing to do

 

I am trying to find a deep wolf cause I KNOW I am NOT a wolf.  You are pointing fingers at ME.  So either 1 of 2 possibilities is true:

 

1. You are the last wolf

2. You are misguided townie who is grasping at straws and doesn't know that there is a deep wolf who looks "lock cleared" but is really a wolf.

[monstrman]

No lynch increases probability of lynching a wolf because it reduces the pool of living players. Mechanically it is sound because we cannot lose from no lynching, only go from f4 to f3

[monstrman]

WiFi what do you not get about "if we were wolves we would have won already?"

[monstrman]

Mechanically if I am a wolf that means tiink is a villager

 

You voted tiink to bring him to 3

 

Instead of WINNING THE GAME, I comment that "wow the wolves are besie/wild." Then proceed to lynch my wolfbro

 

I don't think the list of wolf plays has this one in it

[dyachei]

 

 

what about Pral. He's been flying under the radar.  I KNOW I am TOWN.  I don't know what I can do to convince you otherwise.  It has to be pral. I just thought of it.

 

me

monstr

tiink

pral

wifi

 

 

most town to most scum IMO

 

dya is cleared by darthes view on her and for changing her vote to besie.

monster is cleared for changing his vote to besie.

tiink is cleared cause he was the alternate train to besie. Though I still don't get how that clears him.  We could have had TWO w/w trains going. BUT for the sake of argument lets say that tiink is town. 

That leaves me and pral.

he's not just cleared because he was a counterwagon.

 

Look at his interactions with besie. there's no way there were w/w

 

 

Could have been staged.  Darthe and I did it during the Grimfrostbitten one...not as deep as that but that's because we were hardly on at same time in the qt.  tiink is in the UK and besie is where again??

 

We should definitely no lynch tomorrow though

 

why no lynch though.  I do not understand.  The only time I remember a no lynch happening it was for the wolves to win.

 

 

wifi you keep trying to suspect those that are basically lock cleared. It's not a good thing to do

 

I am trying to find a deep wolf cause I KNOW I am NOT a wolf.  You are pointing fingers at ME.  So either 1 of 2 possibilities is true:

 

1. You are the last wolf

2. You are misguided townie who is grasping at straws and doesn't know that there is a deep wolf who looks "lock cleared" but is really a wolf.

 

Ok I'm going to try to explain why no lynch is the best play. Tonight we have a townie die. That leaves us with 4 players. 3 are village, 1 is a wolf. Villagers have to decide which 1 of 3 is the wolf. Random guess would be 33%. If you no lynch, another town dies overnight. That leaves us with 3 players. 2 are village, 1 is a wolf. Villagers now have a 50% of randomly guessing the right player to lynch. It decreases your pool of suspects. not to mention that it gives us more time to go over everyone's posts again.

 

 

I don't think it could have been staged. That's what I've been saying all evening. And even if it were staged with besie, staging it with sooh as well doesn't make sense. and then you add on he was counterwagon to a wolf. His passion and drive scream town to me, too.

 

 

You've sussed me and monstr and we're the clearest of the remaining players. Screams desperate wolf.

[Wildfire Sedai]

Okay. Now I understand.  Thank you for explaining it to me.  In all honesty: you could put a black box in front of me and tell me it was a black box and I would say, "No, it's white."  However, if you put a white box in front of me and a black box behind me and asked me which one I saw; I would say, "The black one." That is how my mind works.  I don't see the obvious.  You have to show it to me.  

[monstrman]

I miss you zander </3

[monstrman]

Rereading the game to see if there's something I missed

[dyachei]

When does night end? Tomorrow evening?

[Nynaeve]

“We hardly believe in sex chest ghost stories, Besie.”

 

“Aye. That's exactly what I thought when first told of the tale. Buried in the island of the dead that which cannot be found except by those who already knows where it is. Find it, we did. And there be the Tom’s sex chest... and inside, be some really weird sh*t. We took them all! Used them, traded 'em and fritted 'em away, for drink and food and pleasurable company. But the more we used them, the more we came to realize, man is this sh*t weird. WTF Tom? The drink would not satisfy, food turned to ash in our mouths, nor the company in the world would harm or slake our lust. We are cursed men, people. Compelled by greed, we were. But now, we are consumed by it. And basically scarred for life. 

 

"Let us end your suffering then, Besie. What has been seen cannot be unseen.”

 

Besie let out a sigh and pouted. “But but but….oh no… not the butts…. I’m getting flashbacks.”  :/

 

A dozen of muskets were aimed at her head. “There’s a lesson to be learned. Next time you see a sex chest, keep on walking.”

The muskets fired. Besie was dead. Brain matter scattered all around, making a huge mess. And the only clear thing at this moment was that neither Nyn or Halli were going to clean that up.

 

 

 

Besie was quite dead… she was Ragetti, Mafia Goon

 

 

 

 

It is Night 4. You have 24 hours to submit your NAs.

 

Roughly 24 hours from this post or when all NAs are in. Whichever happens first.

[dyachei]

ty Nyn!