[Advanced]Lost mafia - Game over - Sili, SK wins!

[Celeste]

@ Shad The difference between the Zander's I see is he doesn't really give much thought after his 1st death, not sure what that means but it's slightly suspicious to me. He's consistent with his defense of Besie which gives him town points. He asks questions but doesn't really follow through with them as much as he did. Those are the main points.

[Sili Quirrels]

 

Celeste: from your point of view, have you done enough to convince us you're town, or not?

Yes, because I don't see this being how I act when playing as mafia. 

 

villagery for u i think.

[Shad_]

*nod*  Thanks for looking into it.

[Thane Vakarian]

Depending on NA's, I think we should be able to get a clearer picture and get a wolf lynched D3.

[Sili Quirrels]

wait maybe not. i'm going to mull this over. i'll come back to it tomorrow.

[Sili Quirrels]

Depending on NA's, I think we should be able to get a clearer picture and get a wolf lynched D3.

one of u masons is dying imo. so gl with that.

[Celeste]

I really want people to see my post about Turin. I don't get why people read him as town. It's like the Nolder suspicion I had in WoW.

[Shad_]

Where is my Lenlo.

[Celeste]

Shad why do you think he is town before his claim?

[Shad_]

You're being more clear with your thoughts tonight Penny and I like that.

 

I mean I like it in general whatever your alignment.  :)

[Celeste]

You're being more clear with your thoughts tonight Penny and I like that.

 

I mean I like it in general whatever your alignment.  :)

It's gotten into town danger zone, we need a scum lynch. I don't like the tie votes.

[Shad_]

Shad why do you think he is town before his claim?

 

I thought he was town based on what felt to me like a lack of spin in his posts on D1.  Granted I disagree with his conclusions quite often, it seemed like he was telling the story straight and just drawing from events differently than I would.  Dice pointed out a jab he made at Besie that seemed a little OOC and I found another one and that concerned me, and I ended up voting him, but after reading his ISO of her I got back to thinking he was pretty clean and just stuck in a tunnel.  I mean it wasn't a strong read but a town lean at least.  I'm quite null on the claim itself.

[Shad_]

Lenlooooooooooooooooooo

[Shad_]

If you're town and just disgruntled that I'm not trusting you please just talk to me a little.  I promise I won't chew your head off.

[Celeste]

I haven't liked Turin at all. My PoE for now is Turin > Darthe > Zander 2.0. I regret switching to besie but it was out of self pres and nobody was going to trust me on Turin.

[Shad_]

Turin's a naturally pretty scummy dude.

 

Like think about his play in WoW.

 

I'm not going to hard defend him or anything, and I could easily be wrong, and I suck to high heaven at knowing what roles are appropriate where and why, but I personally sort of set my normal pings aside with him.  He's a pure meta read for me every time.

[Shad_]

Ok well time's up for Lenlo and Eldrick because I have to sleep sometime tonight.

[Shad_]

So anyway Zander's mafia.

[Shad_]

I'm highly confident on that.

[Shad_]

You can practically watch the paranoia evaporate as D2 progresses.

[Shad_]

A few of my notes:

 

By Zander standards he's incredibly chill with letting Besie's lynch go through.

Pretty much forgets about all his Lenlo suss when Turin becomes the main wagon and goes at him instead.

Instant trust of Turin's claim.

A few sporadic "Celeste's wolfy" posts.

No scum hunting to speak of really. Lots of confusion and conversations that lead nowhere.

[Eldrick4221]

 

 

Besie I mean

Weird misname there. Why did you system seph instead?

I didn't misname anyone. Read again.

You corrected yourself. That's a misname in my book.

 

I was curious why you said seph the first time. What was going on in your head when you posted that and said seph inatead?

[Shad_]

I had three people screaming at me to vote Besie at EoD and two people screaming at me to at least vote someone. Zander's off in lala land arguing with Lenlo about why Celeste is more wolfy than Besie as if that vote was ever moving.

 

He has a brief go at Seph but the only townish comment I see is "Im just wondering cause it kinda seems like you just pulled this slot out of a hat." Normally he's explaining in every other post why he thinks this or that is suspicious, not just asking questions.

 

Or like "People are thinking shes Scummy for how the list was ordered???", shock could be legit but where is the suss of it? Zander's not going to just go "woah some people have really scummy reasons to suss Besie. Shame on whoever they are."

 

Maybe the biggest thing was forgetting and/or dropping Lenlo without explanation when Turin built a train.

 

"Really dislike that Turin train with both Darthe and Celeste there." ~~Useless EoD post. This was ages after Turin had claimed and ceased to be open to discussion for a lynch.  He wasn't even stuck in the past. He goes on to mention they're voting Turin in spite of his claim.  Neither of them had posted in hours iirc.

[Shad_]

That's what all I'd written down.  I'm going to start pulling quotes but we'll be lynching him tomorrow.

[Shad_]

And let's not forget that Nyn played completely out of character.