[Advanced] Salem Mafia - GAME OVER - MAFIA WIN

[Shad_]

BFG, are you going to respond to my whisper?

[Shad_]

No Lynch is an option.

 

You lynch someone and vote Innocent.

[Eldrick4221]

No lynch happens if there isn't an majority as well

[Eldrick4221]

I don't know why I decided to say you can't vote no lynch being you can just run out the clock. If you want to actively end the day early, I guess it doesn't make a difference.

[Eldrick4221]

Fwiw you can vote no lynch now.

[Eldrick4221]

If that's really what you guys want to do, no point waiting an hour lol

[Shad_]

Jesus christ I get it now

[Shad_]

A lightbulb the size of Manhattan went off in my brain when I pulled up Thane's ISO again

[Shad_]

Thane's reason for sussing me at the start of D1 was fabricated. No rational player can look at that and tell me it wasn't. Seriously, there is no universe anywhere ever where town!Thane thinks "Shad didn't get shot on N0 so he must be non-town." Thane is not dumb. I called it scummy and drilled it home because it's an obviously bogus suspicion. You have all played with Thane. You know he does not think this way.

A lot of players were dismissing my concern, and were unwilling to look at Thane in spite of it. This made no sense to me. I explained the issue, very thoroughly, and it was dismissed out of hand, not by everyone but by a lot of people.
 

Darthe and Sili dead... that is a great loss for town. I know that Darthe is not likely to be seer *nods*

It was this, wasn't it? This didn't even sink in for me before. People gave Thane a pass because they thought he peeked me dirty and wanted to maintain his cover.
 

Thane claimed doc people.

[seph]

Thane's reason for sussing me at the start of D1 was fabricated. No rational player can look at that and tell me it wasn't. Seriously, there is no universe anywhere ever where town!Thane thinks "Shad didn't get shot on N0 so he must be non-town." Thane is not dumb. I called it scummy and drilled it home because it's an obviously bogus suspicion. You have all played with Thane. You know he does not think this way.

 

A lot of players were dismissing my concern, and were unwilling to look at Thane in spite of it. This made no sense to me. I explained the issue, very thoroughly, and it was dismissed out of hand, not by everyone but by a lot of people.

 

Darthe and Sili dead... that is a great loss for town. I know that Darthe is not likely to be seer *nods*

It was this, wasn't it? This didn't even sink in for me before. People gave Thane a pass because they thought he peeked me dirty and wanted to maintain his cover.

 

Thane claimed doc people.

well you have been ignoring me all game. which is pretty anti town, and i didn't really like your case early on,

so what do you think we should do???

[Shad_]

I was ignoring you because I read the set-up and knew the SK was still alive, and I thought your argument that the SK was probably dead probably suggested that you were the Serial Killer and Thane was Mafia. But we're this close to EoD and no one has countered you.

 

I very very strongly believe that Thane is not town. I have explained why many times. I don't know what more I can do in that regard. I think he has the highest probability of flipping non-town of anybody left in this game, and if we lynch a town today we lose short of the other factions bungling something tonight.

[seph]

I was ignoring you because I read the set-up and knew the SK was still alive, and I thought your argument that the SK was probably dead probably suggested that you were the Serial Killer and Thane was Mafia. But we're this close to EoD and no one has countered you.

 

I very very strongly believe that Thane is not town. I have explained why many times. I don't know what more I can do in that regard. I think he has the highest probability of flipping non-town of anybody left in this game, and if we lynch a town today we lose short of the other factions bungling something tonight.

i don't disagree with you. but im not exactly keen on you this game.

but the darthe and seer thing is concerning, and i didn't like his eod today. but what do you think about no lynch?

[Shad_]

No lynch isn't something I've thought much about tbh. I'll look at the mechanics again.

[Shad_]

If there's a Veteran and its kill supersedes night immunities then if we get lucky no lynch can benefit us in that regard.

[Shad_]

Honestly I just want to lynch the scummiest player.

 

How much of your concern with me is based on this phase?  Yes I realize I've avoided the thread recently, mainly because I wanted to talk to BFG in private because I trusted her the most and I wasn't sure how to approach a situation where non-towns could potentially control the majority.  If you look at my game prior to that and don't see town!Shad I don't know what to tell you.  We haven't played together in a while but I don't think my game has changed that much.  I was active and kept things running when half of the player base was afk.  Have I been in a tunnel on Thane for a long time?  Yes, because he's done nothing to change my opinion.

[seph]

I think no lynch and lynching someone both have benefits.
I will do whichever, depending on the situation. I just think no lynch gives town a small % better outcome.

this game is kinda confusing, and i have been thinking about it way to much. and with the way things happened it feels like lylo on day 2.

[seph]

Honestly I just want to lynch the scummiest player.

 

How much of your concern with me is based on this phase?  Yes I realize I've avoided the thread recently, mainly because I wanted to talk to BFG in private because I trusted her the most and I wasn't sure how to approach a situation where non-towns could potentially control the majority.  If you look at my game prior to that and don't see town!Shad I don't know what to tell you.  We haven't played together in a while but I don't think my game has changed that much.  I was active and kept things running when half of the player base was afk.  Have I been in a tunnel on Thane for a long time?  Yes, because he's done nothing to change my opinion.

we will see if anyone is around to lynch. half of my read on you was based on hallia, and your tunnel. you seemed to ignore alot once you went towards thane. and today I felt like you just didn't care.

[Shad_]

A lot of my trust of Hallia was honestly based on her seeing what I was seeing irt Thane. 

[seph]

everyone seems to think thane is guilty, maybe my read is just that bad on him.
the seer thing with darthe just bugs me. but then i rememer thane does weird things, but that is something hard to pass over.

[Shad_]

Why is no one here at EoD?

[seph]

A lot of my trust of Hallia was honestly based on her seeing what I was seeing irt Thane. 

she didn't really contribute, just said you made good points

[seph]

thane and turin are sleepin i think

[Shad_]

 

A lot of my trust of Hallia was honestly based on her seeing what I was seeing irt Thane. 

she didn't really contribute, just said you made good points

 

 

I talked to her in whisper briefly.  She claimed to be tracking what I was saying and was willing to go there, but wanted to use the rest of the day to prod elsewhere first.

[Shad_]

Turin and BFG both peacing out without a vote is weird and frustrating.

[Shad_]

We might be the only people left interested in playing this game.  -_-