[Advanced] Nightmare Before Christmas - Town Wins!

[Nolder]

Well. Ok then fair enough.

[Lenlo]

So AJ tomorrow yes?

[Nolder]

AJ

Dice

 

Lenlo

Pizza

Thane

NotBob

 

Shad

BFG

[Lenlo]

Why is AJ Blue? 

[Lenlo]

Actually, could you please just explain the list to me, cause I dont really understand why AJ and Shad are where they are.

[Nolder]

That's where I'm at right now.

Granted I haven't ISO'd Shad yet like I said I would so my first choice for lynch is BFG.

Everyone else I feel OK about or better.

 

I would like to see a more concise case on AJ because Shad's was long and confusing and put me to sleep.

[Lenlo]

Im glad you feel better about me, maybe we can go out for a beer sometime, but im alittle confused.

 

What do you think of AJs "surrender" that happened right before EoD?

[Nolder]

My fate is pretty much decided.

 

You won't get my help killing one of my own, but gg nonetheless.

You talking about this?

It doesn't bother me.

Unless you think AJ would just give in when his team had already survived day 1 and gotten rid of a power role?

I mean it literally makes no sense. The only angle I could see this as is maybe reverse psychology? Pretending to be so obvious to get us to think it couldn't possibly be him?

But again I ask why? They're ahead and afaik there wasn't that much heat on AJ so...makes no sense to do that to me.

[Lenlo]

Theres a good amount of heat imo, but I dont see how it makes sense from a town perspective either. A town shouldnt have a problem dieing if their flip pretty much catchs a scum, which I felt it would with Shad. I just dont see how the move makes sense in either alignment. 

 

The only way I can make sense of it is that he is legit surrendering. Interested in other peoples thoughts cause at this point I am all for lynching AJ.

 

May I ask what about Shad got him so low on your list though? I dont remember you having to many problems with him. Also is that list of yours ordered? I forgot to ask before.

[dicetosser1]

Dear Vig  I would ask you not kill AJ tonight.  shoot ure best guess besides him and do not give any clues who you will shoot

[Lenlo]

Were there hints that a vig existed that I missed? Cause I only remember NotBob asking Nolder who he would shoot and figured that was rhetorical, or something.

[Nolder]

Well you're right about that. It doesn't really make sense as town either but when people make errors like that I usually attribute it to town since mafia tend to pick their words more carefully and play a cautious game. Town just blurts out stupid things sometimes.

 

It's more to do with gut feeling and POE than any solid case on Shad. 

Honestly I don't think ANYONE is playing an obviously scummy game, otherwise we would have seen some better non meta cases by now.

 

How do you feel about lynching BFG ahead of AJ?

If you really think he's outed he could be lynched any time right?

[Nolder]

Were there hints that a vig existed that I missed? Cause I only remember NotBob asking Nolder who he would shoot and figured that was rhetorical, or something.

I think Nomi did something similar as well. There's been a lot of chatter about vig shots.

Not sure why but eh whatever.

[Lenlo]

I guess, but I hate leaving outted scum alive. Its why I fought tooth and nail to get Tab lynched today regardless of alot of people being like "We can lynch her later, lets lynch this guy first". Like if we have scum right infront of us, we should get rid of them just incase they are a PR like Tab you know?

 

As for BFG I wouldnt fight it but I am also not going to go full hog like I did to get Tab lynched today. I havnt followed the BFG cases like at all, cause ive been so focused on getting people to settle down and lynch Tab.

[dicetosser1]

Len tab just flipped BVP in an ADVANCED game.

 

I think a vig is pretty much assured

[Lenlo]

 

Were there hints that a vig existed that I missed? Cause I only remember NotBob asking Nolder who he would shoot and figured that was rhetorical, or something.

I think Nomi did something similar as well. There's been a lot of chatter about vig shots.

Not sure why but eh whatever.

 

Nomi said something about like who volunteers to get peeked tonight or something. I dont remember vig talk from him. If there is one, cool please shoot scum, but im confused where is popped up from is all.

[Nolder]

Len tab just flipped BVP in an ADVANCED game.

 

I think a vig is pretty much assured

Maybe there's a SK?

Maybe it's AJ?

 

We were just discussing how his words don't make sense as town or mafia.

[Lenlo]

Len tab just flipped BVP in an ADVANCED game.

 

I think a vig is pretty much assured

I dont know theorycrafting role balanced BS. Ive never run a game and ive never bothered to learn how to balance one.

[Lenlo]

 

Len tab just flipped BVP in an ADVANCED game.

 

I think a vig is pretty much assured

Maybe there's a SK?

Maybe it's AJ?

 

We were just discussing how his words don't make sense as town or mafia.

 

If theres an SK why wouldnt there be a second kill N1 though? Holster or Doc Protect?

[Lenlo]

Pizza what do you think of EoD and what we should do tomorrow? Id like to know.

[Nolder]

I guess, but I hate leaving outted scum alive. Its why I fought tooth and nail to get Tab lynched today regardless of alot of people being like "We can lynch her later, lets lynch this guy first". Like if we have scum right infront of us, we should get rid of them just incase they are a PR like Tab you know?

 

As for BFG I wouldnt fight it but I am also not going to go full hog like I did to get Tab lynched today. I havnt followed the BFG cases like at all, cause ive been so focused on getting people to settle down and lynch Tab.

Fair point. I dunno that there's any power I'd be worried about except maybe roleblocker? 

For all we know we lost the only town power role that matters though.

Maybe let's see who flips tonight and revisit who to lynch afterward.

[Nolder]

 

 

Len tab just flipped BVP in an ADVANCED game.

 

I think a vig is pretty much assured

Maybe there's a SK?

Maybe it's AJ?

 

We were just discussing how his words don't make sense as town or mafia.

 

If theres an SK why wouldnt there be a second kill N1 though? Holster or Doc Protect?

 

Could have also double up shot with the mafia. Could have been roleblocked. Could have hit the BPV.

[Lenlo]

I can agree to that. To much night talk doesnt help us a whole lot at this point does it?

 

Im trying to learn all these things I never bothered to before, so actually thinking about roles is hard ive discovered.

[Nolder]

AJ are you a SK?

[Lenlo]

So. Much. Role.