[Advanced] Star Wars Mafia

[Eldrick4221]

Cuz I honestly can't decide.

[seph]

at this point we have 2 mislynches before lylo?
unless we get sk kill

I  want to hear thoughts

[WWWwombat]

Why are you believing the stump claim? No one is even questioning it.

 

My gut is telling me it's Talya ATP.

 

[v]Talya[/v]

 

It's a ballsy claim as scum here because the downside of testing it is very low.

[WWWwombat]

Seph is right that that's a lot of town power there and masons might not fit.  Of course, I'm still having trouble understanding why Heart was lolcatting as town, so idk if my head is on straight right now.

[WWWwombat]

Eldrick was definitely in danger of lynch on D3 imo.  Sooh had a lot of votes, but momentum had stalled and the Eldrick came in and put his foot in his mouth and people started saying he was a wolf.  IIRC, Zander and you were both somewhat strongly against him, Seph, and at that point you two had a lot of sway.

[WWWwombat]

 

You know that those numbers could have easily changed to make me the lead train. If Wombo had voted me instead, and convinced 1 person to switch, that's it for me.

4-5 votes to 1? I have stated she is town since day 2, and have liked her play since.

I will defend her, is what I said and I still am.

 

You realize if aj is mafia, that is what you call pocketing right?

Yes he would do it as town, and yes he would do it as mafia, as your lynch WAS not going to happen

 

 

That pocket would make no sense, dude.  AJ and I messed up royally yesterday, but give us some credit here.

[Eldrick4221]

Eldrick was definitely in danger of lynch on D3 imo.  Sooh had a lot of votes, but momentum had stalled and the Eldrick came in and put his foot in his mouth and people started saying he was a wolf.  IIRC, Zander and you were both somewhat strongly against him, Seph, and at that point you two had a lot of sway.

Seph was dead at that point. It was Zander and Laine.

[WWWwombat]

Ok, I just skimmed the area after my claim. I don't remember why I felt AJ defended me so strongly. It looks like people were already moving off of me.

 

There was a point that Sooh was 5 and I was 2, but then Laine voted Sooh, because that was the path she intended to take anyway, and she thought my claim was to "distract from her lynch".

 

i do remember there being a post where he defended me, but I don't think it's relevant anymore.

 

It wasn't just 1 post.  We spent almost the whole day pushing Sooh.  Then you came in and made a sketchy claim for no reason and we almost had to defend you.  AJ and I weren't trying to pocket anyone.  We were trying to lynch scum.  As we were yesterday, with varying results.

[WWWwombat]

 

Eldrick was definitely in danger of lynch on D3 imo.  Sooh had a lot of votes, but momentum had stalled and the Eldrick came in and put his foot in his mouth and people started saying he was a wolf.  IIRC, Zander and you were both somewhat strongly against him, Seph, and at that point you two had a lot of sway.

Seph was dead at that point. It was Zander and Laine.

 

 

You're right.  I remembered it was 2 town leader types though.

[Eldrick4221]

 

Why are you believing the stump claim? No one is even questioning it.

 

My gut is telling me it's Talya ATP.

 

[v]Talya[/v]

 

It's a ballsy claim as scum here because the downside of testing it is very low.

 

It's just as ballsy as commuter is. No way to test it without killing.

 

That wasn't my question, though. Do you believe that she is telling the truth?

[WWWwombat]

 

[V] sili

This might be the best move at this point - despite the fact I'm about 90% sure there is only 1 scum left. We simply can't have this same stupid argument every single day. We'll lose either you, me, or Dice tonight. Then we are back to the original POE tomorrow. My only concern is that last night was another night where the NK target was obvious and Zander could have been targeted by both scum and SK if we have one. So we could potentially lose two confirmed Town in a single night. And that would suck. However, of the two of us, I'd rather you lynched me. Sili has had better reads than me this game and simply has more time to play than I do.

 

Sili I want a straight up HONEST answer from you or Yates

 

Are you Masons or are you Lovers?  And I suggest you be honest cause im thinking to test your claim today

We are mason's, Dice. We have each tried to draw NK's. You don't do that as Lovers.

 

Mason or commuter has to be mafia... heck I have been thinking they all 3 are not town.

What if there was 3 parties? And those two got recruited.

 

You notice how yates comes hard at aj then leaves him alone.

Yesterday aj protects sili

Today sili protects aj....

 

Idk guys but these 2 slots are the only spots who need voted.

JFC. Now you think there's THREE scum left? This is completely out of hand. THERE IS ONE SCUM LEFT. Period.

 

Sili, how is R2D2 related to Luke?

That's actually how I found him. Don't think related like a "relative;" think related like "linked." Luke bought R2 from the Jawas, fixed him, found the message from the Princess, and started this whole saga.

 

@NB - Why didn't you vig one of us last night? You realize we'd have 3 conf Town alive today instead of 2, right?

 

 

I don't think there is an SK.  SK would have to be a dolt to kill Zander last night.  Who are you thinking is scum right now?

[WWWwombat]

 

 

Why are you believing the stump claim? No one is even questioning it.

 

My gut is telling me it's Talya ATP.

 

[v]Talya[/v]

 

It's a ballsy claim as scum here because the downside of testing it is very low.

 

It's just as ballsy as commuter is. No way to test it without killing.

 

That wasn't my question, though. Do you believe that she is telling the truth?

 

 

Not really.  Commuter doesn't let us keep talking after we get killed.

 

I'm not sure what to think on Talya.  Right now I'm leaning towards believing her, but I've been going back and forth on her for much of the game even before she claimed.

[WWWwombat]

Not sure exactly what my PoE is atm, but csarmi, Seph and Dice are my strongest town reads.

[seph]

We have this lynch

Then we go to LyLo because csarmi claim hated.

So 2 more chances

[WWWwombat]

That assuming 4 mafia or 5?

[Yates]

I don't think there is an SK.  SK would have to be a dolt to kill Zander last night.  Who are you thinking is scum right now?

Why wouldn't SK kill cop? I'm not following.

 

I'll answer the second part after this:

Not sure exactly what my PoE is atm, but csarmi, Seph and Dice are my strongest town reads.

Seph and Dice aren't even reads. They are Town.

 

Csarmi has been Town since Day 1 and scum isn't touching that until F3.

 

So obviously Sili, Seph, Dice and Csarmi are off the table.

 

I *want* to think you guys are Town here. How dumb would you feel if Eldrick is actually the last scum? LOL

 

Sili hasn't posted in our QT yet today. I think I'm just going to defer to him - for the most part. There are still huge chunks of this game I haven't read so he's got some wisdom mixed in with the whacked out theories.

[Eldrick4221]

I don't see a reason not to clear up the masons right now. It seems to be the best play.

 

As for your list wombo. Seph is mod confirmed. Dice was clearly cop peek. What you're saying is you have salami as town.

[Eldrick4221]

Nice xpost yates

[Eldrick4221]

Lol. I can only dream of being that good at being scum someday.

[WWWwombat]

 

I don't think there is an SK.  SK would have to be a dolt to kill Zander last night.  Who are you thinking is scum right now?

Why wouldn't SK kill cop? I'm not following.

 

I'll answer the second part after this:

Not sure exactly what my PoE is atm, but csarmi, Seph and Dice are my strongest town reads.

Seph and Dice aren't even reads. They are Town.

 

Csarmi has been Town since Day 1 and scum isn't touching that until F3.

 

So obviously Sili, Seph, Dice and Csarmi are off the table.

 

I *want* to think you guys are Town here. How dumb would you feel if Eldrick is actually the last scum? LOL

 

Sili hasn't posted in our QT yet today. I think I'm just going to defer to him - for the most part. There are still huge chunks of this game I haven't read so he's got some wisdom mixed in with the whacked out theories.

 

 

I think SK would be pretty safe in assuming that scum kill the cop there, so doubling on the cop is a waste.  With Scum GF and roleblocker down, they've probably got limited cop-stuffing ability.  I guess SK could try to kill the same person as the scum to avoid suspicion, but it seems too cute to me.

[Yates]

I don't see a reason not to clear up the masons right now. It seems to be the best play.

We *should have been* taken care of last night. That would have been the best play.

[Yates]

I think SK would be pretty safe in assuming that scum kill the cop there, so doubling on the cop is a waste.

Or the SK is assuming you were lying about not being able to protect or didn't want to take that chance. With the way you went after Heart, the thought crossed my mind that you just said for wifom so I don't know why I'd be alone in having that thought.

[WWWwombat]

I don't see a reason not to clear up the masons right now. It seems to be the best play.

 

As for your list wombo. Seph is mod confirmed. Dice was clearly cop peek. What you're saying is you have salami as town.

 

Yeah, I didn't phrase that the best.  Csarmi is the only one of those that's purely a read.  I am kind of getting town vibes from Yates and Sili here, but that's sketching me out because I can never trust Yates and I tend to scum read Sili a lot.  Talya gives me intermittent town vibes with things she does.  She's also a very experienced player though.  I think the only way you are scum is if you've set yourself up brilliantly with your D3 play.  From my experience playing with you, it doesn't seem like something you'd intentionally do, but it could be something that just happened.  Very unlikely though imo.  NotBob I have been reading as town for a while now and I don't see anything to change that atm.

 

So basically, I have some faulty town vibes here and that's making me uneasy.  At this point, I think Talya and the mason claimants are the most likely ones for me to be wrong on, but I'm still kinda tilted from the Heart lynch.

[Yates]

Anyway - that's it for me for tonight.

[WWWwombat]

 

I think SK would be pretty safe in assuming that scum kill the cop there, so doubling on the cop is a waste.

Or the SK is assuming you were lying about not being able to protect or didn't want to take that chance. With the way you went after Heart, the thought crossed my mind that you just said for wifom so I don't know why I'd be alone in having that thought.

 

 

Makes sense.  Didn't cross my mind though given my PoV.  Still, we've only had 1 kill unaccounted for so far by my count.  Could very easily have been a 1-shot scum role or something.