[Advanced] Star Wars Mafia

[seph]

Actually tell me why you won't lynch aj.

I want to hear this 1 more

[Eldrick4221]

Why are you believing the stump claim? No one is even questioning it.

 

My gut is telling me it's Talya ATP.

 

[v]Talya[/v]

[Eldrick4221]

Actually tell me why you won't lynch aj.

I want to hear this 1 more

Gladly, because it was recently brought to my attention.

 

D3, I claimed, and got serious heat for it.

 

Instead of letting the mislynch train go through on me, AJ defended me big time, and got the train going back on Sooh.

[Eldrick4221]

Wombo is almost as town to me as dice is.

[seph]

 

Actually tell me why you won't lynch aj.

I want to hear this 1 more

 

Gladly, because it was recently brought to my attention.

 

D3, I claimed, and got serious heat for it.

 

Instead of letting the mislynch train go through on me, AJ defended me big time, and got the train going back on Sooh.

Instead of letting the mislynch go?

Sooh had 5 or.6 votes.... you were not being lynched.

 

Also I think Tayla is town...

[Eldrick4221]

Mafia were already down 2 members, and had a strong train on the third. something comes along to derail that. Scum!AJ would not prevent the distraction from saving a teammate.

[Eldrick4221]

 

 

Actually tell me why you won't lynch aj.

I want to hear this 1 more

Gladly, because it was recently brought to my attention.

 

D3, I claimed, and got serious heat for it.

 

Instead of letting the mislynch train go through on me, AJ defended me big time, and got the train going back on Sooh.

Instead of letting the mislynch go?

Sooh had 5 or.6 votes.... you were not being lynched.

 

Also I think Tayla is town...

 

Why do you think she's town? She's actually the person in the game I know the least about.

[Eldrick4221]

You know that those numbers could have easily changed to make me the lead train. If Wombo had voted me instead, and convinced 1 person to switch, that's it for me.

[Eldrick4221]

Or thereabouts. I don't have the exact figures handy.

[Eldrick4221]

 

 

 I've been rereading the thread more carefully.

 

I snipped out the rest of the MQ, but dude.....I'm completely lost on what the hell you're saying here.  I showed you that you said Eldrick was null, asked me why I said villager, and then I explained and you later had him as a ~strong village read.  Ok, but then I asked if my explanation made you change your mind, and you mentioned a post that did it, and then quoted it.

 

I then pointed out this post came before you noted Eldrick as null, and your answer is the above.  Suffice to say I have no freakin' clue what you're trying to do here, and it frustrates me.  I've been getting used to thinking you're a villager when I can understand you.......and I thought I was understanding you up through this instance.

 

So please help me here.  I think you're the villager I've been reading you as, but you need to help me get over this hump.  Help me Sili-Q, you're my only hope.

 

>_>

<_<

 

 

 

 

c wut i did thar?

 

Yeah. Actually I'm related to Luke so I even chuckled.

 

Anyway, basically what you said made sense and I was happy you had your own logic to substantiate the read, and it made me lower the bar for Eldrick. Still, what changed my mind is as I was going over the thread one of Eldrick's posts caught my eye. I thought his interest in game solving was very genuine and spontaneous in the posts I quoted, so I adjusted my read accordingly.

 

While looking back at D3, to get my bearings on the numbers then, I noticed notbob quoting this.

 

Sili, how is R2D2 related to Luke?

[seph]

You know that those numbers could have easily changed to make me the lead train. If Wombo had voted me instead, and convinced 1 person to switch, that's it for me.

4-5 votes to 1? I have stated she is town since day 2, and have liked her play since.

I will defend her, is what I said and I still am.

 

You realize if aj is mafia, that is what you call pocketing right?

Yes he would do it as town, and yes he would do it as mafia, as your lynch WAS not going to happen

[Eldrick4221]

Ok, I just skimmed the area after my claim. I don't remember why I felt AJ defended me so strongly. It looks like people were already moving off of me.

 

There was a point that Sooh was 5 and I was 2, but then Laine voted Sooh, because that was the path she intended to take anyway, and she thought my claim was to "distract from her lynch".

 

i do remember there being a post where he defended me, but I don't think it's relevant anymore.

[Eldrick4221]

 

You know that those numbers could have easily changed to make me the lead train. If Wombo had voted me instead, and convinced 1 person to switch, that's it for me.

4-5 votes to 1? I have stated she is town since day 2, and have liked her play since.

I will defend her, is what I said and I still am.

 

You realize if aj is mafia, that is what you call pocketing right?

Yes he would do it as town, and yes he would do it as mafia, as your lynch WAS not going to happen

 

I do realize that, and he was doing a very good job of it, if that's what he was doing.

[Eldrick4221]

Can you please give me reasons that she's town, so I can see it too?

[seph]

She was a suspect day 2. And when she came in she looked very towny to me. You can reread it if you want. Not to far away from start of day 2.

And I have liked her play since then.

 

Also since wombo wants to clear people off of 1 lynch. Look at her vote on thaneballs

[Eldrick4221]

My view really hasn't changed on the masons. I don't think they're scum. But if they are, they both are.

 

So if we take that route.

 

1) They are scum. 1 outs the other. We lynch the other one tomorrow.

 

2) They are masons. One dies and the other is confirmed town. One confirmed town (other mason/seph) gets Nk'd. We go into day with 1 conf town, 1 peek, and 5 others

 

3) They are lovers. We lynch one, killing the other. Seph is Nk'd and we go into tomorrow with Dice and 5 others.

[Eldrick4221]

1. Sili - Mason

 

2. Durin - ???
3. Alannalynn - Town Cop
4. Thaneballs32 - Mafia Roleblocker
5. NotBob - Vig
6. Leelou - Mafia Godfather
7. Sooh - 1x Mafia Janitor
8. Zander - Backup Universal - Cop
9. Eldrick - Vanilla town
10. Talya - Stump
11. Yates - Mason
12. Clov - Vanilla Town
13. Dice - Town peek. Vanilla town
14. Aiel <3 - Doc
15. Shad (BFG) - Not listed in OP. Vanilla Town IIRC

16. Seph - Phoenix
17. WomboCombo - Commuter
18. Csarmi - Hated

[Eldrick4221]

unintentional spacing :P

[Yates]

[V] sili

This might be the best move at this point - despite the fact I'm about 90% sure there is only 1 scum left. We simply can't have this same stupid argument every single day. We'll lose either you, me, or Dice tonight. Then we are back to the original POE tomorrow. My only concern is that last night was another night where the NK target was obvious and Zander could have been targeted by both scum and SK if we have one. So we could potentially lose two confirmed Town in a single night. And that would suck. However, of the two of us, I'd rather you lynched me. Sili has had better reads than me this game and simply has more time to play than I do.

 

Sili I want a straight up HONEST answer from you or Yates

 

Are you Masons or are you Lovers?  And I suggest you be honest cause im thinking to test your claim today

We are mason's, Dice. We have each tried to draw NK's. You don't do that as Lovers.

 

Mason or commuter has to be mafia... heck I have been thinking they all 3 are not town.

What if there was 3 parties? And those two got recruited.

 

You notice how yates comes hard at aj then leaves him alone.

Yesterday aj protects sili

Today sili protects aj....

 

Idk guys but these 2 slots are the only spots who need voted.

JFC. Now you think there's THREE scum left? This is completely out of hand. THERE IS ONE SCUM LEFT. Period.

 

Sili, how is R2D2 related to Luke?

That's actually how I found him. Don't think related like a "relative;" think related like "linked." Luke bought R2 from the Jawas, fixed him, found the message from the Princess, and started this whole saga.

 

@NB - Why didn't you vig one of us last night? You realize we'd have 3 conf Town alive today instead of 2, right?

[Eldrick4221]

1. Sili - Mason

2. Durin - ???

3. Alannalynn - Town Cop

4. Thaneballs32 - Mafia Roleblocker

5. NotBob - Vig

6. Leelou - Mafia Godfather

7. Sooh - 1x Mafia Janitor

8. Zander - Backup Universal - Cop

9. Eldrick - Vanilla town

10. Talya - Stump

11. Yates - Mason

12. Clov - Vanilla Town

13. Dice - Town peek. Vanilla town

14. Aiel <3 - Doc

15. Shad (BFG) - Not listed in OP. Vanilla Town IIRC

16. Seph - Phoenix

17. WomboCombo - Commuter

18. Csarmi - Hated

Claimed roles with active NA: Vig, Commuter (Obviously Mafia NK is on this list)

 

2 hour Night makes sense with this info.

[Eldrick4221]

To be clear, I wasn't implying that mafia is between the commuter and the vig. I was saying it's something that happened last night.

[Eldrick4221]

I've mulled it over, and I really have no idea who could be mafia here. I'll follow whichever path seph and dice want to take.

[Hallia]

OFFICIAL VOTE COUNT:

 

Sili(1): Seph

Talya(1): Eldrick

 

Not Voting: Sili, NotBob, Talya, Yates, Dice, WomboCombo, Csarmi

 

It is Day 5.  With 9 alive it takes 5 to lynch.  A deadline is set for Wednesday, July 1st at 7pm PST.

[seph]

If they are masons
then that leaves wombo as the only mafia.
wombo eld tayla is poe if they are telling the truth

[Eldrick4221]

Right. so which way do you think we should go? Believe them or not?