[Advanced] Star Wars Mafia

Eldrick4221 · June 25, 2015

@Eldrick - can't talk for the others. You are trending down for me mostly on PoE i suppose though there is something i cant put my finger on. Will try to come up at least with the questions by this afternoon or this evening. If not the answers. Otherwise it may just be that ita harder for me to clear you (could be true for others as well) as i dunno you. Will most likely consult others heavily on this.

I will gladly answer them to the best of my ability.

Andrej · June 25, 2015

Csarmi, who are you going to vote?

I won't be voting Sooh.

Won't be voting my villagers. Otherwise i dunno.

I am most torn on your slot.

My gut wants to lynch Eldric or Wombo right now.

Outstanding.

Help me?

Not sure how to, honestly.

I think Sooh is a pretty obvious lynch here - but for whatever reason you're holding onto your town read.

Your other suspects in POE aren't terrible though. I could see how you might be suspect of Eldrick for some of the stuff he says if you don't know him. Tayla looked bad to me D1 but I think she's trended upwards and AH could easily be a wolf. I wouldn't be that upset with you if you ended up on her today fwiw. I think she's likely the next one up after Sooh as it is.

csarmi · June 25, 2015

Hello

I am your mind

Giving you someone to talk to

Hello? (Don't cry)

csarmi · June 25, 2015

@Eldrick - can't talk for the others. You are trending down for me mostly on PoE i suppose though there is something i cant put my finger on. Will try to come up at least with the questions by this afternoon or this evening. If not the answers. Otherwise it may just be that ita harder for me to clear you (could be true for others as well) as i dunno you. Will most likely consult others heavily on this.

I will gladly answer them to the best of my ability.

I just hope i can ask them. Usually getting the questions is the harder part.

Eldrick4221 · June 25, 2015

@Womby: your arguments on me rereading pings but i am gonna buy that you are just trying to be helpful - for now. Well, don't be. Rereading is important. Also, i can assure you that i have read over 350 pages worth of stuff this game.

This hits me on a personal level, and it wasn't even directed at me. I know rereading is important. I will try again.

csarmi · June 25, 2015

Umm sorry Eldrick.

I suggest d1 btw especially the beginning. Usually a fount of information. More than people think. The reason is that the information difference between village/wolf is bigger there so its easier to tell the difference. More chance of peoplr spewing themselves villagers just by being themselves.

Also, another advice is to only read in context. It is everything.

Helps?

Eldrick4221 · June 25, 2015

@Eldrick - can't talk for the others. You are trending down for me mostly on PoE i suppose though there is something i cant put my finger on. Will try to come up at least with the questions by this afternoon or this evening. If not the answers. Otherwise it may just be that ita harder for me to clear you (could be true for others as well) as i dunno you. Will most likely consult others heavily on this.
I will gladly answer them to the best of my ability.

I just hope i can ask them. Usually getting the questions is the harder part.

Yup.

Eldrick4221 · June 25, 2015

Umm sorry Eldrick.

I suggest d1 btw especially the beginning. Usually a fount of information. More than people think. The reason is that the information difference between village/wolf is bigger there so its easier to tell the difference. More chance of peoplr spewing themselves villagers just by being themselves.

Also, another advice is to only read in context. It is everything.

Helps?

I remember you saying that. I have never gotten information from early D1. i've already read it again and got nothing. Thank you for the input, though.

csarmi · June 25, 2015

I've been rereading the thread more carefully.

I snipped out the rest of the MQ, but dude.....I'm completely lost on what the hell you're saying here. I showed you that you said Eldrick was null, asked me why I said villager, and then I explained and you later had him as a ~strong village read. Ok, but then I asked if my explanation made you change your mind, and you mentioned a post that did it, and then quoted it.

I then pointed out this post came before you noted Eldrick as null, and your answer is the above. Suffice to say I have no freakin' clue what you're trying to do here, and it frustrates me. I've been getting used to thinking you're a villager when I can understand you.......and I thought I was understanding you up through this instance.

So please help me here. I think you're the villager I've been reading you as, but you need to help me get over this hump. Help me Sili-Q, you're my only hope.

>_>

<_<

c wut i did thar?

Interesting.

Andrej · June 25, 2015

Clearing imo

csarmi · June 25, 2015

Likely yes. Typical scum!Verb tying. The best is that it works against Sili when Eldrick flips regardless of the flip (wolf: sneaking wolf into town reads, villa: forgot stance on said villa an TMI).

Andrej · June 25, 2015

I thought that casing originally looked good for Verb when I was trying to power thru the thread over the weekend.

I think his point about you and Darthe being opposite sides probably spews you too. Scummy twofer angle

csarmi · June 25, 2015

Maybe.

Scum Verb plans ahead though and creates spew and anti-spew ties too. That's why it's dangerous to rely on him after jis flip. The reason I'm leaning towards believeing this to be at town!Sili is also based on how I perceive Verb tends to talk at villagers. He likes "not understanding" them. He sounds the way he treated me a couple of times as villager too.

I wanted to use it to judge Eldrick but it apears it says nothing of his alignment.

Sili Quirrels · June 25, 2015

Likely yes. Typical scum!Verb tying. The best is that it works against Sili when Eldrick flips regardless of the flip (wolf: sneaking wolf into town reads, villa: forgot stance on said villa an TMI).

You should continue reading. My response is good too.

Sili Quirrels · June 25, 2015

Maybe.Scum Verb plans ahead though and creates spew and anti-spew ties too. That's why it's dangerous to rely on him after jis flip. The reason I'm leaning towards believeing this to be at town!Sili is also based on how I perceive Verb tends to talk at villagers. He likes "not understanding" them. He sounds the way he treated me a couple of times as villager too.I wanted to use it to judge Eldrick but it apears it says nothing of his alignment.

i can list the ways i'm spewed villager if u want?

Eldrick4221 · June 25, 2015

Sup?

I see this is going to be a busy game.

Guess it's time to get SRS already. :(

I really dislike it when you do this, salami, but it does put you on your town meta.

Hey all.

I require one less vote to be lynched (Hated). Should be fun :)

just checking in

-snipped the dolphin pic-

Turdarthin n0 peek

I believe sili

wombocombo

csarmi

shad

What? Why are those names there?

AJ is really harboring some bad feelings from a previous game. Meh. Dingbat, you town?

Seph's posts seem awkward. He is going back and forth on if his peek is real or cover. Not sure if this makes him scum or not yet.

Getting decent vibes from Sili.

Thane is just chatty. I'll have to wait to read Verbal.

I haven't played with Turin in ages. Darthe, too early to tell.

Feeling okay with Dice right now.

[v]Leelou[/v] because it's how I show love

More thoughts after I get home from work tomorrow

below contradicts bolded above:

Oh and btw--I expect to have things to give thoughts on in 18ish hours when I get off from work. If not I'll be disappointed in you all.

Seems like you are trying to save face here. Your first post looks like you came in and didn't read, but posted anyways. Then you stuck around a bit and posted saying you are current.

Shad, not bad. Definitely better first post than in my game.

Sooh has a bland opening post. Don't like her mentioning of pulling a Heart but not saying anything. Means that she at least glanced at the thread but has nothing to add.

Eldrick didn't we just talk about your voting/unvoting briefly in my deadthread and how this makes it easy to make a case on you? You scum or town?

I don't think I know Zander...

Laine, null with townie qualities. There are a few things I'm going to watch for that I saw were different from your scum and town games.

Hi Talya. :waves: liking your thought process so far.

NotBob posting quantity on par for NotBob

At this point, could vote Heart or Sooh. Possibly Seph. I've only seen him as mafia. How is he as town?

Leelou's OP. Bolded living players. Important to comeback to.

csarmi · June 25, 2015

Maybe.Scum Verb plans ahead though and creates spew and anti-spew ties too. That's why it's dangerous to rely on him after jis flip. The reason I'm leaning towards believeing this to be at town!Sili is also based on how I perceive Verb tends to talk at villagers. He likes "not understanding" them. He sounds the way he treated me a couple of times as villager too.I wanted to use it to judge Eldrick but it apears it says nothing of his alignment.

i can list the ways i'm spewed villager if u want?

There is no need for that Sili.

Sili Quirrels · June 25, 2015

Eldrick, i think you vote and unvote a lot of ppl, and it looks jumpy. I can see some merit in what Yates says. On a level it reminds me of your wolf game when you said one thing, only backtracking when reproached. On another level it feels like you're more engaged because of it.

Eldrick4221 · June 25, 2015

AJ is really harboring some bad feelings from a previous game. Meh. Dingbat, you town?

Getting decent vibes from Sili.

Feeling okay with Dice right now.

Heart

[v]Leelou[/v] because it's how I show love

More thoughts after I get home from work tomorrow

below contradicts bolded above:

Oh and btw--I expect to have things to give thoughts on in 18ish hours when I get off from work. If not I'll be disappointed in you all.

Seems like you are trying to save face here. Your first post looks like you came in and didn't read, but posted anyways. Then you stuck around a bit and posted saying you are current.

Sooh has a bland opening post. Don't like her mentioning of pulling a Heart but not saying anything. Means that she at least glanced at the thread but has nothing to add.

Eldrick didn't we just talk about your voting/unvoting briefly in my deadthread and how this makes it easy to make a case on you? You scum or town?

I don't think I know Zander...

Laine, null with townie qualities. There are a few things I'm going to watch for that I saw were different from your scum and town games.

Hi Talya. :waves: liking your thought process so far.

NotBob posting quantity on par for NotBob

Post trimmed to include her feelings on living players at the point of her OP.

Sili Quirrels · June 25, 2015

Maybe.Scum Verb plans ahead though and creates spew and anti-spew ties too. That's why it's dangerous to rely on him after jis flip. The reason I'm leaning towards believeing this to be at town!Sili is also based on how I perceive Verb tends to talk at villagers. He likes "not understanding" them. He sounds the way he treated me a couple of times as villager too.I wanted to use it to judge Eldrick but it apears it says nothing of his alignment.
i can list the ways i'm spewed villager if u want?
There is no need for that Sili.

oh, i see...

well fine then.

Eldrick4221 · June 25, 2015

Eldrick, i think you vote and unvote a lot of ppl, and it looks jumpy. I can see some merit in what Yates says. On a level it reminds me of your wolf game when you said one thing, only backtracking when reproached. On another level it feels like you're more engaged because of it.

I do vote and unvote a lot of people. I've been working on that.

What is the bolded in reference to?

Sili Quirrels · June 25, 2015

Eldrick, i think you vote and unvote a lot of ppl, and it looks jumpy. I can see some merit in what Yates says. On a level it reminds me of your wolf game when you said one thing, only backtracking when reproached. On another level it feels like you're more engaged because of it.

I do vote and unvote a lot of people. I've been working on that.

What is the bolded in reference to?

My impression of your wolf game. Is it wrong? When I look over your iso (and i just looked a bit), and today when you unvoted wombat and voted sooh just now, it looked like you were responding to ppl, changing ur views to fit with new pressures.

Sili Quirrels · June 25, 2015

i feel like there's not much to do besides wait and see how sooh flips atm, and then reevaluate.

of remaining players besides sooh i'd list

zander

talya

eldrick

wombat/aj

notbob

heart

in order of most clear to least clear. players i'm not mentioning shouldn't be lynched.

Eldrick4221 · June 25, 2015

I don't have any objections with Leelou's initial read on dice

She 'felt ok' with him

His game to that point:

Votes Durin

Confrimed when AJ called him villager. Comments on the fact tha AJ can read him (i.e. the book)

Asks why shad thinks it's a joke

Comments on how seph isn't close to being an expert at reading him, like AJ is

Filler about the book

Zander wants Dice to expand on why it's not a joke. Dice says he will after Shad gives his thoughts.

Comments that Salami is in his towny meta.

Thanks me for asking about the vote. Suggests I try to figure it out.

WTL durin and Seph

Talya thought his joke was a vote. She mentions he quoted Turin's vote on Darthe. Dice reminds her that they are a hyrda.

Resoponds to Zander that his posts about AJ were from meta, though slight town read

Comments on how Salami makes a practice of claiming early

Eldrick4221 · June 25, 2015

Eldrick, i think you vote and unvote a lot of ppl, and it looks jumpy. I can see some merit in what Yates says. On a level it reminds me of your wolf game when you said one thing, only backtracking when reproached. On another level it feels like you're more engaged because of it.
I do vote and unvote a lot of people. I've been working on that.

What is the bolded in reference to?

My impression of your wolf game. Is it wrong? When I look over your iso (and i just looked a bit), and today when you unvoted wombat and voted sooh just now, it looked like you were responding to ppl, changing ur views to fit with new pressures.

I can't say one way or the other if your impression of my wolf game is right or wrong. I think my game has changed over the course of the games I've had here since I got back, and that progression just happened to go from wolf games to town games.

As for my vote change to Sooh. That had nothing to do with pressure. I thought about my case on them, and it fell apart. Being I'm not confident they're wolf anymore, why would I continue voting them? I do still think there's a wolf between Wombo and Heart because of Leelou's reads, but I don't know which one it could be.

[Advanced] Star Wars Mafia

Recommended Posts

Archived

Stay Connected

Forum Topics

News items

About Dragonmount

Twitter

Facebook