[Advanced] Arthurian Mafia

[Nynaeve]

I find it interesting that wagonomics is suddenly not a valid scumhunting method, though. That's news to me.

[Leelou]

 

 

 

 

 

 

I screwed that up. I was too scared of Thane's strong defense of me and got paranoid.Eh, I bet cory will have a thing or two to say to me after this game.

Can you remind me what you are talking about here that you screwed up?

Can I be vague and not answer? I'm more likely this way to draw a night kill.

 

 

 

No, they don't want clov gone. He's the only person still serious about lynching me.

 

 

 

 

 

I screwed that up. I was too scared of Thane's strong defense of me and got paranoid.Eh, I bet cory will have a thing or two to say to me after this game.

Can you remind me what you are talking about here that you screwed up?

Can I be vague and not answer? I'm more likely this way to draw a night kill.

Maybe I'm the vigilante?

 

 

 

The combination of these three posts don't make me feel great about Sili right now. I could be assuming a lot, but I feel like if you were the vigilante you would have shot Darthe. 

 

I probably would have shot Darthe lol.

 

I don't care how you feel about me. I'm playing four games at once, different alignments in each one, and I have school to go to. If you want to lynch me, vote me, run me up, then I'll fake claim (*hint*hint) and then you'll be forced to lynch someone else. I do want scum to kill to me, and really, they probably should. They're never getting me lynched this game.

 

 

This post is just awful. 

 

Your soul is wicked.

 

 

It has some redeeming qualities. 

[Nynaeve]

It really does.

[Leelou]

 

You seemed sure that the vig kill was Lily. I was just curious as to why.

Now that Sili has answered, I'll tell you why *I* am about 90% sure... Verb wasn't in the lynch discussion. A vig isn't likely to shoot outside the lynch pool. Darthe and Lily were the two major wagons. Typically, if one goes through and flips Town the vig will shoot the other to remove any doubt. Since neither lynch went through I think it's fair to assume the vig is someone on the Lily wagon - being that the vig would have been on the Lily wagon assuming she was the most likely scum in the game.

 

Easy math.

 

 

Yes, Lily was the obvious vig target. She was up in lynch for being scummy, I thought she was town though, and Darthe was doing his damnedest to come off looking like the persecuted by the old school DM by EoD/Night. The vig had viable 2 choices, not bad, but I still would have gone with Darthe if it was me. 

[Leelou]

 

 

 

 

 

 

I screwed that up. I was too scared of Thane's strong defense of me and got paranoid.Eh, I bet cory will have a thing or two to say to me after this game.

Can you remind me what you are talking about here that you screwed up?

Can I be vague and not answer? I'm more likely this way to draw a night kill.

 

 

 

No, they don't want clov gone. He's the only person still serious about lynching me.

 

 

 

 

 

I screwed that up. I was too scared of Thane's strong defense of me and got paranoid.Eh, I bet cory will have a thing or two to say to me after this game.

Can you remind me what you are talking about here that you screwed up?

Can I be vague and not answer? I'm more likely this way to draw a night kill.

Maybe I'm the vigilante?

 

 

 

The combination of these three posts don't make me feel great about Sili right now. I could be assuming a lot, but I feel like if you were the vigilante you would have shot Darthe. 

 

I probably would have shot Darthe lol.

 

I don't care how you feel about me. I'm playing four games at once, different alignments in each one, and I have school to go to. If you want to lynch me, vote me, run me up, then I'll fake claim (*hint*hint) and then you'll be forced to lynch someone else. I do want scum to kill to me, and really, they probably should. They're never getting me lynched this game.

 

 

This post is just awful. 

 

Your soul is wicked.

 

 

BTW - I'm getting the sense that you are town and people are trying to make you a shiny object. 

[Nynaeve]

Sili

Mrs.Clov

Leelou

Clov

 

Thane

Barm

Dice

 

Yates

Eldrick

Darthe

 

 

This is where I'm at right now reads wise. The order is from most townie to most scummy. Barm and dice are interchangeable order wise. I'm gonna have to ISO them both to make up my mind. But at this point it's not that important. Plus I'm kinda waiting to see more from them. I would also like Thane to step it up. My gut says town but until he starts shifting into gear I can't say for sure, so he'll stay in my POE.

[Nynaeve]

BTW - I'm getting the sense that you are town and people are trying to make you a shiny object. 

 

Give the pretty lady a stuffed teddy

[Thane Vakarian]

i didn't find a teddy, but will this do?

 

 

 

 

[Thane Vakarian]

i'm starting to get why Lily would be the vig target. It's a shame that it took out two players though. 

 

i'm still at work (it's been 10 bloody hours) and i have at least 2 more hours to go

[Nynaeve]

I will admit though that I did have some doubts about Clov. It's true that he likes things tidy and logical and I can understand why the whole exchange with Sili happened. I can see them clashing as far as play style goes and that's fine. I did feel that at some point Clov was pushing a bit too hard for my liking. ie I expected him to give it a rest sooner than he did because after all he does know Sili. It's not their first game together. 

 

With that said, Clov did have a lot of posts I liked. Mrs.Clov pointing out some positive things did put my mind at ease. So I'm looking forward to see his updated reads and what he makes of things. If and when I have to start tinfoiling about misclearing someone, though. That's prolly where I'll be looking. Clov, please don't break my heart <3

[Thane Vakarian]

Sili's posts earlier were... softly speaking... not too great. But Sili can get back into the game, i hope. Probably eeven make some sense to more people.

[Nynaeve]

What are your current reads, Thane?

[Yates]

I find it interesting that wagonomics is suddenly not a valid scumhunting method, though. That's news to me.

Wagonomics is a valid scumhunting method - in the hands of someone who knows what they are doing. :eyeroll:

 

What you are proposing isn't "wagonomics," though, being that a big part of it is knowing the alignment of the party being wagoned. If you want to look for scum on the Lily wagon? Have at it. At least you know everyone on her wagon was voting for a Townie. What you CAN'T do is make any assumptions about anyone on Darthe's wagon until you know his alignment. That's NOT "wagonomins" - that's speculation.

[Nynaeve]

 

I find it interesting that wagonomics is suddenly not a valid scumhunting method, though. That's news to me.

Wagonomics is a valid scumhunting method - in the hands of someone who knows what they are doing. :eyeroll:

 

What you are proposing isn't "wagonomics," though, being that a big part of it is knowing the alignment of the party being wagoned. If you want to look for scum on the Lily wagon? Have at it. At least you know everyone on her wagon was voting for a Townie. What you CAN'T do is make any assumptions about anyone on Darthe's wagon until you know his alignment. That's NOT "wagonomins" - that's speculation.

 

 

Please, Darthe is scum. There is absolutely no reason for his lynch to not have gone through otherwise. Unless scum is in the business of NOT mislynching townies. 

 

But please, get into a semantics argument with me. Those are always a doozy.

[Nynaeve]

Unfortunately for you, you only bought Darthe one extra day. The Verbal choice was a nice touch, but ultimately not good enough.

[Verbal32]

I can't believe nimue died.

 

My response to Alanna once I saw my role PM:  "Sweet, I'm hot!!!"

 

 

gl town

[Nynaeve]

Yates, since you don't want to reread EoD cause apparently you don't think there would be anything useful there..... how about an updated read list? Are you up for that?

[Yates]

But please, get into a semantics argument with me. Those are always a doozy.

It's not semantics, Nyn. You are calling an apple an orange. You are trying to call speculation that Darthe is scum a valid scum hunting tool in order to paint people on the Lily wagon as scum. And that's dumb. Especially since you can simply look at the flip and use that as reason enough. I know you are trying to get me riled up and it isn't going to work.

[Thane Vakarian]

Nyn

Leelou

Yates

 

Darthe

 

MrsClov

Clov

Sili

Eldrick

 

dice

Barm

 

Contrary to popular belief, i'm not convinced that Darthe is actually scum here. Nyn, i get the feeling that you and Yates is some town/town thingy going on. The yellow ones are null, i'm more wary about the orange ones. Both haven't contributed that largely imo. 

 

this is done from memory seeing i don't have time to go deep into the thread and read up closely from EOD on, it's more a 'what i feel it is' list. 

[Yates]

Yates, since you don't want to reread EoD cause apparently you don't think there would be anything useful there.....

Yeah. Keep throwing those darts. It's not like I've readjusted my view of the game based on Lily's flip or looked at the NK and made some off the hip observations about that and the vig shot. I've been so quiet about that stuff this morning.

[Nynaeve]

 

But please, get into a semantics argument with me. Those are always a doozy.

It's not semantics, Nyn. You are calling an apple an orange. You are trying to call speculation that Darthe is scum a valid scum hunting tool in order to paint people on the Lily wagon as scum. And that's dumb. Especially since you can simply look at the flip and use that as reason enough. I know you are trying to get me riled up and it isn't going to work.

 

 

There were two wagons on EOD1. Neither of them went through. One of them was of a townie. One of them was of unknown. Taking a look at the trains and analyzing them is still possible without Darthe's flip. Even when you have someone's flip and look at who was on their train you make speculations. Nothing is certain. I completely disagree with what you're saying right now. I think there's a lot to be gained from looking at people's behavior at EoD. When we have Darthe's flip it will be even more telling. But since I don't have Darthe's flip yet (working on it!), I make due.

[Nynaeve]

 

Yates, since you don't want to reread EoD cause apparently you don't think there would be anything useful there.....

Yeah. Keep throwing those darts. It's not like I've readjusted my view of the game based on Lily's flip or looked at the NK and made some off the hip observations about that and the vig shot. I've been so quiet about that stuff this morning.

 

 

What does Night chit chat have to do with your read list?

[Nynaeve]

 

Nyn

Leelou

Yates

 

Darthe

 

MrsClov

Clov

Sili

Eldrick

 

dice

Barm

 

Contrary to popular belief, i'm not convinced that Darthe is actually scum here. Nyn, i get the feeling that you and Yates is some town/town thingy going on. The yellow ones are null, i'm more wary about the orange ones. Both haven't contributed that largely imo. 

 

this is done from memory seeing i don't have time to go deep into the thread and read up closely from EOD on, it's more a 'what i feel it is' list. 

 

 

I disagree with almost your entire list. But on the up side, I don't think you'd have the balls to be so controversial as scum. So there's that.

[Nynaeve]

I have to take off to do some errands and then exercise. I'll prolly be back around the evening.

 

Yates, try not to miss me too much!

[Thane Vakarian]

For the moment, it's where i'm at. I'll try to look at all the posts from EoD and further to see if i can get some clearer thoughts on the yellow and orange section.