[Basic/Standard] A Wind in the Door Mafia - GAME OVER, TOWN WINS

[Tommyrod]

JMM,

 

Who would you NEVER lynch in this game?

 

Who would you shoot tonight if you could?

[jmm]

Never lynch is really strong.  Probably no one at this point.  If I was forced to pick a nolynch, it would be HalliYates.

Shoot would be Sili. 

[Yates]

SirBluJohn of Cairhien

Do/did you know Gym?

[jmm]

 

SirBluJohn of Cairhien

Do/did you know Gym?

 

 

Name's not familiar... =/

[Yates]

 

Do/did you know Gym?

Name's not familiar... =/

 

This is a scum claim.

 

I'm voting for you in the morning.

[Tommyrod]

Never lynch is really strong. Probably no one at this point. If I was forced to pick a nolynch, it would be HalliYates.

 

Shoot would be Sili.

You are pretty insistent that Sili is a wolf but I don't recall why other than bad feelings

 

Imagine I'm super patient and understanding and full of love and want to know everything there is to know about JMM and his thoughts

 

Explain to me in detail why Sili and how he's earned and maintained your top scum read

[jmm]

 

 

Do/did you know Gym?

Name's not familiar... =/

 

This is a scum claim.

 

I'm voting for you in the morning.

 

 

I... what?

[Yates]

I... what?

Just...

Explain to me in detail why Sili and how he's earned and maintained your top scum read

[jmm]

 

Never lynch is really strong. Probably no one at this point. If I was forced to pick a nolynch, it would be HalliYates.

 

Shoot would be Sili.

You are pretty insistent that Sili is a wolf but I don't recall why other than bad feelings

 

Imagine I'm super patient and understanding and full of love and want to know everything there is to know about JMM and his thoughts

 

Explain to me in detail why Sili and how he's earned and maintained your top scum read

 

 

To me this game is all about tone reads.  It's what I'm used to.  The trick is picking out who has an unfavorable tone because they just play like that, and who has an unfavorable tone because they have something to hide.  What makes the exceptionally hard for me is that I've never played with you guys before (yes I can go back and read old games, but that's not the same).  However, when I made my initial list, I suspected Sili for mafia, and everything I've seen has reinforced that. My opinion of most of the players in this game has changed around a lot, but not my opinion of Sili.  Sure, he doesn't like that I've been on his case all game and has let me know about that, but it's irrelevant to me.  I'm tone reading him negative, and if you don't like it, go ahead and get me lynched, but I'm sticking to my guns unless something really changes my mind. 

[Tommyrod]

Yates,

 

If I have a negative utility night action, who should I *not* use it on? E.g. who is ~always town here?

[Tommyrod]

 

 

 

Never lynch is really strong. Probably no one at this point. If I was forced to pick a nolynch, it would be HalliYates.

 

Shoot would be Sili.

You are pretty insistent that Sili is a wolf but I don't recall why other than bad feelings

 

Imagine I'm super patient and understanding and full of love and want to know everything there is to know about JMM and his thoughts

 

Explain to me in detail why Sili and how he's earned and maintained your top scum read

To me this game is all about tone reads. It's what I'm used to. The trick is picking out who has an unfavorable tone because they just play like that, and who has an unfavorable tone because they have something to hide. What makes the exceptionally hard for me is that I've never played with you guys before (yes I can go back and read old games, but that's not the same). However, when I made my initial list, I suspected Sili for mafia, and everything I've seen has reinforced that. My opinion of most of the players in this game has changed around a lot, but not my opinion of Sili. Sure, he doesn't like that I've been on his case all game and has let me know about that, but it's irrelevant to me. I'm tone reading him negative, and if you don't like it, go ahead and get me lynched, but I'm sticking to my guns unless something really changes my mind.

What I want are examples. This doesn't tell me anything that might help convince me to see your POV. Being stubborn about your stance suggests you are wrong anyway, but go ahead and talk me into it if you can

[Yates]

However, when I made my initial list, I suspected Sili for mafia, and everything I've seen has reinforced that.

Can you give 3 specific examples or quotes to substantiate this?

[Yates]

Yates,

 

If I have a negative utility night action, who should I *not* use it on? E.g. who is ~always town here?

Salamitosser.

[Tommyrod]

I kind of want to mess with them though

[Yates]

I kind of want to mess with them though

It would make me sad.

[Tommyrod]

Can I mess with Lenlo then

[Yates]

Can I mess with Lenlo then

Yeah. That's *ALWAYS* a fun option.

[jmm]

No, I'm not going to give specific examples, and you are going to hate me for that. 

If you want to see it from my PoV, go read through just his posts.  They're bland.  There's no conviction. There's no substance. It's all status quo.  Either he is the most bored villager (in which case, why even post as much as he has) or he is trying to remain hidden in plain sight. 

If you want examples of specific posts, go read pretty much all of them. 

[Yates]

Can I mess with Lenlo then

Just another thought...

No, I'm not going to give specific examples, and you are going to hate me for that.

[Tommyrod]

No, I'm not going to give specific examples, and you are going to hate me for that.

 

If you want to see it from my PoV, go read through just his posts. They're bland. There's no conviction. There's no substance. It's all status quo. Either he is the most bored villager (in which case, why even post as much as he has) or he is trying to remain hidden in plain sight.

 

If you want examples of specific posts, go read pretty much all of them.

Can't tell if wolfy or villagery

[Tommyrod]

JMM, I appear to care more about figuring you out than you care about anything

 

Do you see the problem with that, and I don't just mean mechanically

[dicetosser1]

No, I'm not going to give specific examples, and you are going to hate me for that. 

 

If you want to see it from my PoV, go read through just his posts.  They're bland.  There's no conviction. There's no substance. It's all status quo.  Either he is the most bored villager (in which case, why even post as much as he has) or he is trying to remain hidden in plain sight. 

 

If you want examples of specific posts, go read pretty much all of them. 

 

yates  that sound like sili 2.0 to u?

[Yates]

yates  that sound like sili 2.0 to u?

Meh... I don't have a baseline for jmm. Did you read my ISO on jmm?

[Tommyrod]

If you guys are suspecting Sili for not going HAM anymore, that was a calculated effort on his part to balance his range. He's doing it in all of his games. He's gone back to his original style instead of emulating me and cory. Judge him based on him making sense more than anything else.

[dicetosser1]

on what he has been saying??  then he's scum.