[Basic/Standard] A Wind in the Door Mafia - GAME OVER, TOWN WINS

[Sleeper Service]

 

Mish: I don't know what else you want

 

How about some kind of information about your character. I'm trying to figure out if you're actually  aurvivor or a mafia fibbing. Lack of co-operation will lead me to assume the latter.

 

 

 

I think we're all supposed to think this post is crazy town-y, but the reality is it's a post ABOUT taking hard stances.

 

And then there aren't any hard stances.

 

I will note that my suspicious about this - which aren't SIGNIFICANT, but do exist - are blunted somewhat by the fact that when I called out monstr for posting nothing useful mish actually figured out whether he'd posted more than me, and after verifying his contribution level came at me about how he'd presumably contributed more. That would be kind of a clever mafia move when it's so easy to just use superior information that you already have instead of FINDING MORE to make fun of me.

 

Still, this is kind of an uncomfortable post. 

 

She's also right though, jmm is just killing us by being secretive.

 

 

I'm not a D1 player; I don't get into the game well until D2 when I have a couple of flips and a lynch train to analyze. Thus lack of hard stances.

 

 

I'm not ignoring you... I'm answering your posts. You're the one who ignores posts by me you don't like. Still haven't gotten an answer from you re: the Dawn situation i.e. And now you're just talking around the issue instead of answering me directly.

 

SHROOP imo

 

 

SHROOP?

 

 

SHROOP is hard to explain. 

 

First, it's always at least kind of a joke.

 

Second, it stands for "Scott Howard's Rule of Odd Posts." He was a dude from POG who had this theory that posts that contained the relics of vestiges of weird POST EDITING were often made by wolves because villagers wouldn't have much reason to be editing the meaning of their posts or re-writing their sentences. It's a dubious theory that I don't actually take seriously, though I HAVE seen it work severa ltimes. Your example isn't a great example, though I honestly do wonder what was supposed to follow the "i.e.," because something was that you either deleted or never wrote.

[Sleeper Service]

 

jmm why are ALL your reads based on like the first 5 pages of the game?

Because the rest is just fluff until something actually happens.  The only thing to go on is first impression or, if you want to (and I don't), 20 some pages of mostly random posting.  

 

 

[Sleeper Service]

relics OR vestiges, rather

[Tommyrod]

I told you my exact character

[michellem]

Ok so this is where I'm at right now.

 

 

Csamtosser

Tina

Monstr

Sleeper

 

Len

Err

 

 

Pral

Sili

Hallia/Yates

 

 

 

Tommy

Jmm

[Sleeper Service]

it appears no one believes you though, Tom, and I have no idea what that claim even means

[jmm]

 

I did not like Tina or Halli's first posts (page 1 and 2 respectively).  Nothing definite for now, but I am watching them.

What did you not like about Hally's first post?

 

Feels too much like "hi I'm here so you know I'm here but I'm not going to actually say anything and in fact I'm going to bed so I have an excuse to be mia for an unspecified amount of time.  plz don't talk about me".

[Tommyrod]

I don't care

[Sleeper Service]

well we've got jmm's MO:

 

first impressions, don't read the thread, don't post thoughts, ???

[jmm]

well we've got jmm's MO:

 

first impressions, don't read the thread, don't post thoughts, ???

Corrected: 

 

first impressions, don't read the thread, don't post thoughts, ???, profit 

[Sleeper Service]

wait, then why were you immediately available to welcome lenlo to the thread

[michellem]

Tommy: I am completly unable to find anything about a character that becomes Xed in the theme... Unless you count the bad guys, of course.

 

 

 

 

 

Mish: I don't know what else you want

 

How about some kind of information about your character. I'm trying to figure out if you're actually  aurvivor or a mafia fibbing. Lack of co-operation will lead me to assume the latter.

 

 

 

I think we're all supposed to think this post is crazy town-y, but the reality is it's a post ABOUT taking hard stances.

 

And then there aren't any hard stances.

 

I will note that my suspicious about this - which aren't SIGNIFICANT, but do exist - are blunted somewhat by the fact that when I called out monstr for posting nothing useful mish actually figured out whether he'd posted more than me, and after verifying his contribution level came at me about how he'd presumably contributed more. That would be kind of a clever mafia move when it's so easy to just use superior information that you already have instead of FINDING MORE to make fun of me.

 

Still, this is kind of an uncomfortable post. 

 

She's also right though, jmm is just killing us by being secretive.

 

 

I'm not a D1 player; I don't get into the game well until D2 when I have a couple of flips and a lynch train to analyze. Thus lack of hard stances.

 

 

I'm not ignoring you... I'm answering your posts. You're the one who ignores posts by me you don't likeStill haven't gotten an answer from . you re: the Dawn situation i.e. And now you're just talking around the issue instead of answering me directly.

 

SHROOP imo

 

 

SHROOP?

 

 

SHROOP is hard to explain. 

 

First, it's always at least kind of a joke.

 

Second, it stands for "Scott Howard's Rule of Odd Posts." He was a dude from POG who had this theory that posts that contained the relics of vestiges of weird POST EDITING were often made by wolves because villagers wouldn't have much reason to be editing the meaning of their posts or re-writing their sentences. It's a dubious theory that I don't actually take seriously, though I HAVE seen it work severa ltimes. Your example isn't a great example, though I honestly do wonder what was supposed to follow the "i.e.," because something was that you either deleted or never wrote.

 

 

 

That's how I talk; the i.e. should probably have been at the beginning of that sentence, cause that was the example I was talking about.

[Tommyrod]

I like this jmm guy

[jmm]

wait, then why were you immediately available to welcome lenlo to the thread

 

 

looks like I got your goat, eh?

[Tommyrod]

Mish, if you're attempting to game the theme you're gonna have a bad time

You should start thinking about what implications that has for this game, wrt Meg especially

[Sleeper Service]

no, I just think you're not helpful and are gonna wind up inevitably dying because of it, which means like 75% of the time you're just a deadweight town who doesn't care to help 

[Sleeper Service]

and for that matter if you're not reading the thread why are you lingering around to welcome someone "to the nuthouse" that you're not even reading

[Sleeper Service]

in before another sarcastic refusal to convey any information at all

[csarmi]

jmm

Start sharing your thoughts or die.

[jmm]

What specifically are you looking for?  I've said plenty of things already; you two are being overly aggressive to try to get a read on a new player.  If you have something specific you would like to know, I would be glad to share it, but I'm not going to adjust play-style for a couple schoolyard bullies. 

[Yates]

 

 

I did not like Tina or Halli's first posts (page 1 and 2 respectively).  Nothing definite for now, but I am watching them.

What did you not like about Hally's first post?

 

Feels too much like "hi I'm here so you know I'm here but I'm not going to actually say anything and in fact I'm going to bed so I have an excuse to be mia for an unspecified amount of time.  plz don't talk about me".

 

To be clear; this is the post you are talking about, yes?

Checking in, annnnd good night!

[jmm]

 

 

 

I did not like Tina or Halli's first posts (page 1 and 2 respectively).  Nothing definite for now, but I am watching them.

What did you not like about Hally's first post?

 

Feels too much like "hi I'm here so you know I'm here but I'm not going to actually say anything and in fact I'm going to bed so I have an excuse to be mia for an unspecified amount of time.  plz don't talk about me".

 

To be clear; this is the post you are talking about, yes?

Checking in, annnnd good night!

 

Yes.

[monstrman]

Looks to me like jmm pulling a crunkus.

 

Also hi.

[Sleeper Service]

jmm, another dumb thing you seem to be pretending to think is that the later posts are "mostly random"

 

why are the posts made later on day 1 more random than the INTRO POSTS? How can you even think this?

[Sleeper Service]

and also, BEING AGGRESSIVE TO GET A READ ON A NEW PLAYER IS WHAT WE'RE SUPPOSED TO DO, ESPECIALLY WHEN THE NEW PLAYER THINKS IT'S A GOOD IDEA TO RESIST BEING READ, WHICH IS WHAT MAFIA DOES