[Advanced] Woodstock 1969 Mafia - Town wins

[Tommyrod]

I'm the scummiest so far but I'm still town.

 

 

Lenlo should be the lynch because he is Lenlo and his defense was actually pretty scummy. Deflecting with a joke isn't a defense len.

I still like this post from Arsis (Lan). I don't know if he hard buses as scum but I doubt it.

[Tommyrod]

 

 

I'm the scummiest so far but I'm still town.

 

 

Lenlo should be the lynch because he is Lenlo and his defense was actually pretty scummy. Deflecting with a joke isn't a defense len.

Your right its not a defense. Theres nothing to defend against though Arsis. Your voting me as payback for killing you when you were a survivor. Im not gonna defend against something that was amusing for me to do in another game.

And this basically spews Arsis clear.

[Tommyrod]

I would blind lynch Darthe just cause after his ~5 posts this game.

 

The longer BFG is silent the more positive I become that she is scum. Her one and only post this game was a late add-on to the joke mass claim that started the game, and a vague one at that.

I forgot about BFG...

[Tommyrod]

 

 

 

 

I'm fine with Darthe; it's likely to be pro-town regardless of his alignment and NOBODY has brought him up as a scum suspect so far.

Except me and you.

That's what I mean. I said I was going to leave my vote on Darthe when this game started and nobody even took me up on that. As the game has gone on, nobody has brought him up as a lynch alternative.

 

Why? Did everyone just forget about him? Do people think he's town? Or is he just scum and therefore not low-hanging townie fruit for scum to push like someone like Thane might be?

Tommy GOAT

[Tommyrod]

My vote stays on Des for now. I stand behind my case on him. He didn't look "shook" or anything with the spat with Tommy, he looked legit emotional and pissed. However, the outs that he took in order to get back on Tommy's good side jives with my reading Tommy and town and Des deciding to buddy up and salve what he could.

I was going to make a post about how TG should be pushing Des harder if he's been suspicious of him for multiple days but then I remembered he did pull up his quotes and try again earlier today.

 

I'll give TG some townie brownies for that.

[Al'Lan Mandragoran]

What's GOAT?

[Tommyrod]

 

 

I don't remember dice this game tbh. What was so scummy about him?

His chainsaw defense of Des (assuming Des!Scum) by attacking CSarmi and the interaction of Des pointing out how townie Dice was.

Des has defended Dice several times in this game. Could be a real read, maybe not. Just a reminder.

[Tommyrod]

What's GOAT?

Greatest of all time

[Al'Lan Mandragoran]

Ah

[Tommyrod]

 

 

Yates and I are both out of town this weekend - for different reasons, pretty sure. Otherwise would be weird if he was here for my husband's birthday O.o

 

I wasn't included in the role PM off the bat, was just added last night while I was asleep, so I'm trying to catch up on mobile atm.

 

Tommy > Des in that argument, imo. Like Des better today.

 

CS being stubborn is not new, don't know what to think atm.

 

After just playing two games with him, I don't see why Arsis is subbing out as town. This isn't any different than Tommy in Avengers, imo.

 

Don't like Hally's backing Tommy up, because f anyone in the game, Tommy doesn't need it, imo. Also, he didn't seem like he was in any danger at the time, so why?

 

Also, three days makes sense for roles bc that's how long Woodstock was.

Back at the beginning.

 

Krak vote for Tommy out of the gate to "get rid of that wifom" is scummy. Tommy can be great scumhunter for town, so why want to get rid of him ASAP?

 

Len's nonchalance looks like town bc he usually tries at least a little to look involved as scum.

I feel like these posts from Key will be important later.

GOD those posts from Key are like exactly wrong. I have trouble moving beyond those two posts.

[Tommyrod]

Speaking of Arsis- he's obvscum to me. I might make an iso on him, but yeah everything about his play so far screams scum. His opportunistic voting pattern is turrible- he's not even trying to actively push people he thinks might be scum, he just seems interested in lynching anyone other than himself. His response to Tommy recently about how he'd play as scum was awful, he tried saying he'd be acting completely different this game if he were, and even said he would have CC'ed Tommy's claim which is absolute dogshit. It was an obvious attempt to try and defend himself with bizarro meta to make himself look better. He's also WAAAAAAY too concerned with himself and his appearance, and essentially not concerned at all with actually trying to find scum

 

I kinda left Thane on the backburner for a bit cause I realize he can def be lynchbait and often looks scummy as town, but yeah with TG moving off my list Thane could prob take his place. His reads a while ago were as safe as they get, and failed tone tests as well. If he is scum that would make me feel slightly better about Csarmi incidentally since Csarmi called Thane out pretty early and it didn't look like a bus move (also Csarmi doesn't tend to bus for the sake of bussing, he'll try and react naturally to teammate's posts, but won't usually try and bus them to make himself look better)

 

As for Csarmi, haven't really seen anything from him recently so meh I'll keep him red for now but I don't really think I'd be trying hard to lynch him today.

 

I might do an iso on Krak to flesh that read out more- I don't think I'm wrong per se but I want to look for more specifics to back up the feelings I have on his slot. I will say tho that I've noticed he's a lot more active as scum than town- as town he often either doesn't care that much or falls behind very easily, but as scum he's more self-conscious so participates more.

 

Hrmmmmm what else- Key's drop in posts looked good for her. She's great at looking townie as scum, so I won't blue her yet, but might green her after I look at my POE again.

 

Lenlo's responses to minor pressure looked bad, and it's Lenlo so I'd def be down to lynch him either way. His thread presence sucks right now and he's not fluffing as much, which is more null for him anyways but eh he could be finally coming to the realization that fluffing a ton as scum WON'T keep him from getting lynched.

 

Speaking of crappy thread presence, DERFFFFF. Where the hell is he?

 

All I got for now, if I remember something else I wanted to say I'll mention it, otherwise I might drop back by later to do those iso's

Can I get some opinions on this post?

[Tyler Glembo]

We lost.  We f#@*ing lost.  We were up all game and they hit two threes to send it to OT and they just out hustled us.  So pissed right now.

 

And it always effing kills me because I had a g*****m 20/10/5 game but I still feel like if I had just gotten one more rebound, one more assist, hit one more shot.  Ugh.

 

Then our team just blew up post game, blaming each other.  Not.  A.  Good.  Night.

 

edited for language.

[Tyler Glembo]

 

Speaking of Arsis- he's obvscum to me. I might make an iso on him, but yeah everything about his play so far screams scum. His opportunistic voting pattern is turrible- he's not even trying to actively push people he thinks might be scum, he just seems interested in lynching anyone other than himself. His response to Tommy recently about how he'd play as scum was awful, he tried saying he'd be acting completely different this game if he were, and even said he would have CC'ed Tommy's claim which is absolute dogshit. It was an obvious attempt to try and defend himself with bizarro meta to make himself look better. He's also WAAAAAAY too concerned with himself and his appearance, and essentially not concerned at all with actually trying to find scum

 

I kinda left Thane on the backburner for a bit cause I realize he can def be lynchbait and often looks scummy as town, but yeah with TG moving off my list Thane could prob take his place. His reads a while ago were as safe as they get, and failed tone tests as well. If he is scum that would make me feel slightly better about Csarmi incidentally since Csarmi called Thane out pretty early and it didn't look like a bus move (also Csarmi doesn't tend to bus for the sake of bussing, he'll try and react naturally to teammate's posts, but won't usually try and bus them to make himself look better)

 

As for Csarmi, haven't really seen anything from him recently so meh I'll keep him red for now but I don't really think I'd be trying hard to lynch him today.

 

I might do an iso on Krak to flesh that read out more- I don't think I'm wrong per se but I want to look for more specifics to back up the feelings I have on his slot. I will say tho that I've noticed he's a lot more active as scum than town- as town he often either doesn't care that much or falls behind very easily, but as scum he's more self-conscious so participates more.

 

Hrmmmmm what else- Key's drop in posts looked good for her. She's great at looking townie as scum, so I won't blue her yet, but might green her after I look at my POE again.

 

Lenlo's responses to minor pressure looked bad, and it's Lenlo so I'd def be down to lynch him either way. His thread presence sucks right now and he's not fluffing as much, which is more null for him anyways but eh he could be finally coming to the realization that fluffing a ton as scum WON'T keep him from getting lynched.

 

Speaking of crappy thread presence, DERFFFFF. Where the hell is he?

 

All I got for now, if I remember something else I wanted to say I'll mention it, otherwise I might drop back by later to do those iso's

Can I get some opinions on this post?

 

 

[Tyler Glembo]

Almost everything is wrong about that post.  Arsis, or his alt Lan, looked terribad at that point, so I can't fault Des for that.  But everything else.  Fencesitting/soft-pseudo FOSing on Thane, CS, and Lenlo.  Calling out his teammate Darthe to start posting to save himself from being a lynch candidate, weak meta about Krak, and everything about Key.

[Tommyrod]

I hate it too.

 

[unvote]

 

[v]Des[/v]

[Tyler Glembo]

[unvote][v]Des[/v]

 

CFD onto Des is go.

[Tyler Glembo]

Tommy, what are your thoughts on Lan so far?  Did Arsis create an alt?

[Tommyrod]

Tommy, what are your thoughts on Lan so far? Did Arsis create an alt?

I actually did think about that but his account is quite a bit older than this game so shrug. Probably not.

 

If this is Lan's first game he's... at least trying. I kinda doubt it's his first game (suggests an alt) but who knows. I don't have a reason to think he's scum right now.

[Tyler Glembo]

 

Tommy, what are your thoughts on Lan so far? Did Arsis create an alt?

I actually did think about that but his account is quite a bit older than this game so shrug. Probably not.

 

If this is Lan's first game he's... at least trying. I kinda doubt it's his first game (suggests an alt) but who knows. I don't have a reason to think he's scum right now.

 

 

I'm tinfoiling it because he seems to be fitting in too well.  As in, I don't think this is his first game at all. 

[Tommyrod]

For all I know it's Xthrax but whatever. I think Arsis was town.

[nervositee]

 

 

Tommy, what are your thoughts on Lan so far? Did Arsis create an alt?

I actually did think about that but his account is quite a bit older than this game so shrug. Probably not.

 

If this is Lan's first game he's... at least trying. I kinda doubt it's his first game (suggests an alt) but who knows. I don't have a reason to think he's scum right now.

 

 

I'm tinfoiling it because he seems to be fitting in too well.  As in, I don't think this is his first game at all. 

 

 

Well he said he had been shadowing a few games. 

 

I think an alt account is tinfoil. If Verb is following the game loosely then he can check, but its pretty reckless and doesn't quite fit with the dramatic exit. 

[Al'Lan Mandragoran]

First game. I promise you that. I have followed along with a few other games on DM. Dr. who in SG and the tail end of Darthe's Inglorious basterd game. But this is the first time ive played.

[Yates]

You guys mind copy-pasting post #24 in your QT for me?

Interesting choice:

 

keyholder21

09-08-2014

05:27 PM ET (US)

 

If I get us lynched, sorry lol. People I guess think I'm scummy because I look town and they think I'm good at that? *scratches head*

[Tommyrod]

It's not a coincidence.

[dicetosser1]

 

 

im not comfortable with the Darthe train. partly because it is D1 and pushing an inactive feels wrong and partly cause im worried the push is based on carried over feelings from avengers

 

I don't think so. If we were going for inactives there are several to pick from, nor do I think it's anything from Avengers (at least for my sake).

 

It's more the quality/content of the posts and the attitude.

I forgot Dice made this post.

 

Given Darthe was a scum PR...

 

Looks bad.

 

Dice you scum?

 

[unvote]

 

[v]Dice[/v]

 

 

Nope im not

 

 

 

 

not that much in favor of Voting Arsis, we'll have to see how the replacement will do. And Vos... dunno...not feeling like lynching him. I would however vote for Darthe, seeing he usually is way more talkative in games, and isn't helping town at all for the moment.

 

vote: Darthe

 

i'd also like to see a bit more from the inactives, otherwise they might just as well be lynched in order to find the wolves.

 

dont like this. pushing an inactive D1. yet he also didnt want to push BFG who at the time was inactive. Dont like the put arsis off for now so he can be replaced argument. if you think arsis is mafia then lynch him. why wait for a replacement that a) didnt happen the first time and b) may cloud things because we have a new body in the slot?

 

 

i see that i'm being set up as lynchbait here.... Csarmi, if you're really town, than i would think you'd have better suspects than me, really.... the only thing i will confirm here is that i'm town, but that's about it. You don't buy it? Your loss. It's a game, and i'd like to play untill the end and finish this game with town victorious. I doubt it'll happen, but we'll see

 

Ive seen you say this lynchbait thing before. and im pretty sure you were scum then.

 

thane is now in my scum pile

Roundabout defending Darthe here.

 

 

a little unclear on this. Are you saying I'm roundabout defending Darthe here? Cause im not getting how you see that. I was going at Thane. Also note the use of lynchbait   its coming up again in a minute

 

 

I can see a Drunk/Dice team.

 

Only if you see us as town. otherwise i'll give you my glasses so you can relook cause im not scum.

 

Re DT  it is simply that i can totally see what he is saying a couple of times. Kinda a mindmeld.  I was feeling the same way with Yates in the HP game too. in fact thats one of the things that makes me feel kates is scum.

 

but back to DT  i dont have a real read on him tho. im leaning town but its not super solid

 

 

Speaking of Arsis- he's obvscum to me. I might make an iso on him, but yeah everything about his play so far screams scum. His opportunistic voting pattern is turrible- he's not even trying to actively push people he thinks might be scum, he just seems interested in lynching anyone other than himself. His response to Tommy recently about how he'd play as scum was awful, he tried saying he'd be acting completely different this game if he were, and even said he would have CC'ed Tommy's claim which is absolute dogshit. It was an obvious attempt to try and defend himself with bizarro meta to make himself look better. He's also WAAAAAAY too concerned with himself and his appearance, and essentially not concerned at all with actually trying to find scum

 

I kinda left Thane on the backburner for a bit cause I realize he can def be lynchbait and often looks scummy as town, but yeah with TG moving off my list Thane could prob take his place. His reads a while ago were as safe as they get, and failed tone tests as well. If he is scum that would make me feel slightly better about Csarmi incidentally since Csarmi called Thane out pretty early and it didn't look like a bus move (also Csarmi doesn't tend to bus for the sake of bussing, he'll try and react naturally to teammate's posts, but won't usually try and bus them to make himself look better)

 

As for Csarmi, haven't really seen anything from him recently so meh I'll keep him red for now but I don't really think I'd be trying hard to lynch him today.

 

I might do an iso on Krak to flesh that read out more- I don't think I'm wrong per se but I want to look for more specifics to back up the feelings I have on his slot. I will say tho that I've noticed he's a lot more active as scum than town- as town he often either doesn't care that much or falls behind very easily, but as scum he's more self-conscious so participates more.

 

Hrmmmmm what else- Key's drop in posts looked good for her. She's great at looking townie as scum, so I won't blue her yet, but might green her after I look at my POE again.

 

Lenlo's responses to minor pressure looked bad, and it's Lenlo so I'd def be down to lynch him either way. His thread presence sucks right now and he's not fluffing as much, which is more null for him anyways but eh he could be finally coming to the realization that fluffing a ton as scum WON'T keep him from getting lynched.

 

Speaking of crappy thread presence, DERFFFFF. Where the hell is he?

 

All I got for now, if I remember something else I wanted to say I'll mention it, otherwise I might drop back by later to do those iso's

Can I get some opinions on this post?

 

 

Did he ever do the Arsis ISO?  i dont think so.

 

or the ISO on krak??   if the answer to these are no then Des is going down my list. Dont like that twice in one post he said he might ISO but then didnt (if he hasnt)

 

The BLUE   i have a concern about both Des and Thane using this term as a thane defence. i may be tinfoiling but it kinda sticks in my brain.