[Advanced] Woodstock 1969 Mafia - Town wins

[Krakalakachkn]

Tweren't no lyrics yo

[csarmi]

ah

 

yea I don't really care about the order IF it's surely between us

 

I'm not convinced of that at all though.

[csarmi]

Obviously I'm going to vote YOU if it's between us as I know I'm town... that should be a given.

[hazelkrs1]

Good movie. Not over yet but good pausing point.

 

So. We lynching Salami or Krakalakachakadingdong?

[Thane Vakarian]

my vote stays on Salami

[csarmi]

my vote stays on Salami

 

you should be voting mafia yo

I'm obviously not one else I'd have hammered Drunk (and I probably wouldn't have encouraged him playing and/or questioned him at all)

[Thane Vakarian]

Csarmi, then... we had DT nearly done... you didn't hammer.... so.. if you're town, and Krak would be, then it's DT or Lan... missed your chance there

[Tommyrod]

Thane said something like "would town really have a bodyguard and a doc?" so either he's doc or wanted to spew it pretty hard that he is. Good fake if true. We shall know more after more nights pass.

[hazelkrs1]

It looks to be mainly between Salami and I. Now I know we have mislynch opportunities here, but I'd rather lynch Salami first because I know I'm town and I'd rather lunch on an unknown, and because my majority defense of him has been gut and meta, so nothing really concrete.

 

WTL[unch] Salami

 

Weird wording and tone in this post, altho obv I already find the case on Krak to be strong

 

I'm not ready to vote anyone yet. If you guys insist it's between me and Krak, I'll vote Krak obviously. But for now I'm only convinced as Tommy, Vos, Des are clears (and say Thane 99% clear).

 

Tommy can you fetch the posts that spewed Thane as doc for you?

 

I think we've insisted for some time now that it's between you or Krak, yet you keep trying to put this off (voting Krak)

 

Also if Thane was scum I think he would have slipped/faltered by now. His thread presence has been good and all his reactions to big events have passed muster. He was here during all the shibazz with TG outing himself and no offense to Thane but I just don't think Thane could play that that convincingly as scum there

 

The reluctant tinfoil side of me tho does think it's weird to have two protective roles (Doc and BG) along with two investigative AND a backup, but we KNOW Vos is town so... I will reluctantly admit Thane could be a tinfoil candidate should the game not end with you and Krak being cold in the ground corpses

[csarmi]

Csarmi, then... we had DT nearly done... you didn't hammer.... so.. if you're town, and Krak would be, then it's DT or Lan... missed your chance there

 

And what chance did I miss there exactly?

[csarmi]

Thane said something like "would town really have a bodyguard and a doc?" so either he's doc or wanted to spew it pretty hard that he is. Good fake if true. We shall know more after more nights pass.

 

I'll take that then.

 

Alright, we're down to Dice, Drunk, Krak, Lan (and from your PoV me)

[csarmi]

 

It looks to be mainly between Salami and I. Now I know we have mislynch opportunities here, but I'd rather lynch Salami first because I know I'm town and I'd rather lunch on an unknown, and because my majority defense of him has been gut and meta, so nothing really concrete.

 

WTL[unch] Salami

 

Weird wording and tone in this post, altho obv I already find the case on Krak to be strong

 

I'm not ready to vote anyone yet. If you guys insist it's between me and Krak, I'll vote Krak obviously. But for now I'm only convinced as Tommy, Vos, Des are clears (and say Thane 99% clear).

 

Tommy can you fetch the posts that spewed Thane as doc for you?

 

I think we've insisted for some time now that it's between you or Krak, yet you keep trying to put this off (voting Krak)

 

Also if Thane was scum I think he would have slipped/faltered by now. His thread presence has been good and all his reactions to big events have passed muster. He was here during all the shibazz with TG outing himself and no offense to Thane but I just don't think Thane could play that that convincingly as scum there

 

The reluctant tinfoil side of me tho does think it's weird to have two protective roles (Doc and BG) along with two investigative AND a backup, but we KNOW Vos is town so... I will reluctantly admit Thane could be a tinfoil candidate should the game not end with you and Krak being cold in the ground corpses

 

 

... and before that some insisted Drunk was scum, he got to L-1 and I was reluctant to hammer him too. That I'm interested in this playing out should be telling.

[Thane Vakarian]

 

Thane said something like "would town really have a bodyguard and a doc?" so either he's doc or wanted to spew it pretty hard that he is. Good fake if true. We shall know more after more nights pass.

 

I'll take that then.

 

Alright, we're down to Dice, Drunk, Krak, Lan (and from your PoV me)

 

i was talking about the chance to shorten ^ that list

[hazelkrs1]

 

my vote stays on Salami

 

you should be voting mafia yo

I'm obviously not one else I'd have hammered Drunk (and I probably wouldn't have encouraged him playing and/or questioned him at all)

 

 

This is a dumb defense. "If I was scum I would have" defenses are always terribad and wifom.

 

Plus I think you didn't wanna get your hands dirty with his lynch. I think you wanted to act all incredulous but then use a townflip on him to implicate Dice.

 

So *buzzer sound* try again

 

Csarmi, then... we had DT nearly done... you didn't hammer.... so.. if you're town, and Krak would be, then it's DT or Lan... missed your chance there

 

Dunno what you're trying to say here Thane

 

Thane said something like "would town really have a bodyguard and a doc?" so either he's doc or wanted to spew it pretty hard that he is. Good fake if true. We shall know more after more nights pass.

 

Good point. Don't think Thane is quite leet enough as scum to make that kind of move, breadcrumbing a claim like that in that way.

[Tommyrod]

He also mentioned negative utility for his role, so

 

Makes sense to me. You're right about the TG slip event also.

[Thane Vakarian]

i totally agree that i'm not the best mafia player out there. But i did put some effort into playing townie this game (seeing i usually get seen as scummy from D1 or so)

[csarmi]

 

 

Thane said something like "would town really have a bodyguard and a doc?" so either he's doc or wanted to spew it pretty hard that he is. Good fake if true. We shall know more after more nights pass.

 

I'll take that then.

 

Alright, we're down to Dice, Drunk, Krak, Lan (and from your PoV me)

 

i was talking about the chance to shorten ^ that list

 

 

Well, hammering Drunk would have shortened that list sure, one way or the other. It would have shortened the day too. Why would that have been good?

 

We don't have enough clears to just lynch mechanically without abandon. We need to take the PoE down to as few as possible and lynch then.

[Tommyrod]

Krak and Salami both talking too much about how they are town but not showing us why or who the scum is. They seem insistent on un-clearing other players instead

[Thane Vakarian]

 

 

Thane said something like "would town really have a bodyguard and a doc?" so either he's doc or wanted to spew it pretty hard that he is. Good fake if true. We shall know more after more nights pass.

 

I'll take that then.

 

Alright, we're down to Dice, Drunk, Krak, Lan (and from your PoV me)

 

i was talking about the chance to shorten ^ that list

 

i was talking about this ^^^ Des 

[hazelkrs1]

 

Thane said something like "would town really have a bodyguard and a doc?" so either he's doc or wanted to spew it pretty hard that he is. Good fake if true. We shall know more after more nights pass.

 

I'll take that then.

 

Alright, we're down to Dice, Drunk, Krak, Lan (and from your PoV me)

 

 

Dice is town. DT is very likely town. Krak could very easily be scum. Lan is a tinfoil candidate but I think Lenlo spewed him town.

 

So yeah, pretty much just you or Krak or Lan

 

 

 

It looks to be mainly between Salami and I. Now I know we have mislynch opportunities here, but I'd rather lynch Salami first because I know I'm town and I'd rather lunch on an unknown, and because my majority defense of him has been gut and meta, so nothing really concrete.

 

WTL[unch] Salami

 

Weird wording and tone in this post, altho obv I already find the case on Krak to be strong

 

I'm not ready to vote anyone yet. If you guys insist it's between me and Krak, I'll vote Krak obviously. But for now I'm only convinced as Tommy, Vos, Des are clears (and say Thane 99% clear).

 

Tommy can you fetch the posts that spewed Thane as doc for you?

 

I think we've insisted for some time now that it's between you or Krak, yet you keep trying to put this off (voting Krak)

 

Also if Thane was scum I think he would have slipped/faltered by now. His thread presence has been good and all his reactions to big events have passed muster. He was here during all the shibazz with TG outing himself and no offense to Thane but I just don't think Thane could play that that convincingly as scum there

 

The reluctant tinfoil side of me tho does think it's weird to have two protective roles (Doc and BG) along with two investigative AND a backup, but we KNOW Vos is town so... I will reluctantly admit Thane could be a tinfoil candidate should the game not end with you and Krak being cold in the ground corpses

 

 

... and before that some insisted Drunk was scum, he got to L-1 and I was reluctant to hammer him too. That I'm interested in this playing out should be telling.

 

 

Not really. In fact it's not telling at all since it could EASILY have been (and I think it was) you trying to look protown.

 

In fact the fact that you're trying to tout THAT as being any kind of firm evidence of your towniness pretty much CONFIRMATION that you were acting reluctant about hammering SOLELY for the purpose of looking protown, considering you were urging DT to self-hammer AT THE SAME TIME that you were acting "cautious" about hammering him

[hazelkrs1]

This coffee is delicious

[csarmi]

Krak and Salami both talking too much about how they are town but not showing us why or who the scum is. They seem insistent on un-clearing other players instead

 

In what world is this even remotely true? 

 

I'm interested in CLEARING t6he other people. I can only put limited work in, but I think in this discussion we cleared Des and Thane the very least.

[csarmi]

@Despo - please spell me out why Dice is town then. Same with Despo and Lan. Do that, and you'll have my vote to lynch Krak.

[csarmi]

BTW I'm out in an hour or so, one of my best friends is getting married. I'll be back tomorrow.

[Tommyrod]

@Despo - please spell me out why Dice is town then. Same with Despo and Lan. Do that, and you'll have my vote to lynch Krak.

"How am I unclearing people?"

 

lol