[Advanced] Blackhoof's Cthulhu Mythos Mafia Game- Day 1

[WWWwombat]

 

 

 

 

 

Just lol

 

Moving on... I've read about 20% of the thread.

 

I'd really like it if everyone lists their top 2 scum leans with brief explanations for why.

Despo - Read teh thread

Tommy - Howtroll

Tommy mebbe this is why Wombat aint conversing with you?

 

/shrug

 

And yeah, just looks like Wombat going with Red re: setting up Tommy and me thunderdome to distance and stuff.

 

But I dunno, I could be mortal after all and Red wanted to set up a thunderdome with two townies, and Wombat followed her up on it. If it wasn't for Tommy's last three pages I'd have an easier time believing that. Wombat's tunnel on me is making him look scummier by the post

 

But, if I'm right about all dem, then again, I guess this is scum's best idea of #DAMAGE CONTROL

I don't even know what "Howltrolling" means but it sounds like a buzzword invented to replace having to make an ACTUAL read on me.

 

Wombat, care to explain?

I made it up. It's like I was getting the same vibes I was getting from you in the House game and the Red Wedding game. You were being blatantly wolfish to troll some people while being just villagery enough to not get lynched. Kinda hard to explain cuz it's gut. I'm not getting the feeling from your recent posts, but I know you're Top Tier Wolf, so it's pretty hard to back off that read.

Darthe: check out pages 33-36. Observe our conversation and how the two of us appear to be getting along and going back and forth. His entire reason for not clearing me at the time was "I'm a good wolf." He says it himself in the post above.

 

He never actually backed up his statements about me being trollish. I figured he had moved on so I didn't press for more.

 

Now would be a good chance to explain, Wombat.

 

 

It's simple.  You were scumtelling, then you were towntelling, and now you are scumtelling again.  Overall, you are scumtelling a lot.

[Tommyrod]

 

 

 

 

Have you read the page vomit yet?

Just took me almost 1.5 hours to get to here. This sucks.

Elaborate plx

 

 

 

 

Vos: APART FROM THAT, do you think I'm being scummy? My "I am town" statements may annoy you, but I keep telling you it's not something to read me on. So what about everything else I've said? I must have over 100 posts by now.

You're adorable.

C'mon. Why are you trolling me?

Because you're scummy as balls and it's fun?

I'm exhibiting a ton of townie behavior, nobody here seems to know what "scummy" means.

 

It's UNBELIEVABLE.

Yeah see... Talking about the behaviors you exhibit in relationship to your alignment is generally not viewed positively. It's not scummy behavior per say but it makes us acutely aware that you're putting on your attitude.

I'm PISSED. I'm constantly having my words distorted (you, Wombat) or having people telling me HOW I FEEL (Des, Vos) or outright fabricating lies about me and my play (you, Des, wombat). It's ENOUGH already. I'm going to scream about it because I AM TOWN and NOBODY IS LISTENING TO ME when I feel like it should be REALLY goddamn obvious that I'm too pissed off to give this much of a damn as scum. I can just troll you and blend in and lynch a townie instead. Would be a cakewalk to be scum in this game.

 

Meanwhile, there's only 5 or 6 of us arguing out of the 17 players in this game. Scum doesn't have to do jack, just sit back and watch town in fight, especially if you are town.

 

Which would make me LOL HEARTILY at you.

[Tommyrod]

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Just lol

 

Moving on... I've read about 20% of the thread.

 

I'd really like it if everyone lists their top 2 scum leans with brief explanations for why.

Despo - Read teh thread

Tommy - Howtroll

Tommy mebbe this is why Wombat aint conversing with you?

 

/shrug

 

And yeah, just looks like Wombat going with Red re: setting up Tommy and me thunderdome to distance and stuff.

 

But I dunno, I could be mortal after all and Red wanted to set up a thunderdome with two townies, and Wombat followed her up on it. If it wasn't for Tommy's last three pages I'd have an easier time believing that. Wombat's tunnel on me is making him look scummier by the post

 

But, if I'm right about all dem, then again, I guess this is scum's best idea of #DAMAGE CONTROL

I don't even know what "Howltrolling" means but it sounds like a buzzword invented to replace having to make an ACTUAL read on me.

 

Wombat, care to explain?

I made it up. It's like I was getting the same vibes I was getting from you in the House game and the Red Wedding game. You were being blatantly wolfish to troll some people while being just villagery enough to not get lynched. Kinda hard to explain cuz it's gut. I'm not getting the feeling from your recent posts, but I know you're Top Tier Wolf, so it's pretty hard to back off that read.

Darthe: check out pages 33-36. Observe our conversation and how the two of us appear to be getting along and going back and forth. His entire reason for not clearing me at the time was "I'm a good wolf." He says it himself in the post above.

 

He never actually backed up his statements about me being trollish. I figured he had moved on so I didn't press for more.

 

Now would be a good chance to explain, Wombat.

It's simple. You were scumtelling, then you were towntelling, and now you are scumtelling again. Overall, you are scumtelling a lot.

Once again you are not actually explaining anything. If you don't explain, you can't be held accountable, and more importantly, I can't assess whether you're being genuine or are full of it.

[Darthe]

So give up and die.  You can't possibly be a positive influence on the game at this point and if that's how you feel then i see no reason to continue humoring you and discussing to try and see if I have any reason to alter my read.

 

Peace out Tommy, see you next game.

[Tommyrod]

So give up and die. You can't possibly be a positive influence on the game at this point and if that's how you feel then i see no reason to continue humoring you and discussing to try and see if I have any reason to alter my read.

 

Peace out Tommy, see you next game.

You said you were gonna show me those posts that make RTE lock scum. I'm waiting and willing to read them.

[WWWwombat]

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Just lol

 

Moving on... I've read about 20% of the thread.

 

I'd really like it if everyone lists their top 2 scum leans with brief explanations for why.

Despo - Read teh thread

Tommy - Howtroll

Tommy mebbe this is why Wombat aint conversing with you?

 

/shrug

 

And yeah, just looks like Wombat going with Red re: setting up Tommy and me thunderdome to distance and stuff.

 

But I dunno, I could be mortal after all and Red wanted to set up a thunderdome with two townies, and Wombat followed her up on it. If it wasn't for Tommy's last three pages I'd have an easier time believing that. Wombat's tunnel on me is making him look scummier by the post

 

But, if I'm right about all dem, then again, I guess this is scum's best idea of #DAMAGE CONTROL

I don't even know what "Howltrolling" means but it sounds like a buzzword invented to replace having to make an ACTUAL read on me.

 

Wombat, care to explain?

I made it up. It's like I was getting the same vibes I was getting from you in the House game and the Red Wedding game. You were being blatantly wolfish to troll some people while being just villagery enough to not get lynched. Kinda hard to explain cuz it's gut. I'm not getting the feeling from your recent posts, but I know you're Top Tier Wolf, so it's pretty hard to back off that read.

Darthe: check out pages 33-36. Observe our conversation and how the two of us appear to be getting along and going back and forth. His entire reason for not clearing me at the time was "I'm a good wolf." He says it himself in the post above.

 

He never actually backed up his statements about me being trollish. I figured he had moved on so I didn't press for more.

 

Now would be a good chance to explain, Wombat.

Who are your top three and bottom three. Soul read, go.

Almost certainly town, my lock town soul reads:

Red

Dawn

Tsuki

Vos

 

 

Most likely scum:

Dap

You

Wombat

 

After that it gets fuzzy.

 

I have many more confident town leans than confident scum leans, but that's O.K.

 

I don't need to solve the entire game on D1, I just need to find the best lynch. I REALLY think it's Dap.

 

 

Your scum reads suck.

[WWWwombat]

 

 

 

 

Darthe, on a serious note, why shouldn't I just scream my head off for you to be lynched after me if I was to get lynched?

 

I am going to flip town. What's your next move?

I'll humor you on this once (despite you having asked me before as scum). If you somehow manage to flip town I am going to go on to RTE most likely and Red will fall on my list a lot and I'll likely reread your interpretations of peoples' play, corroborate them with those of Cory early game and reassess. Ya know, like a logical being.

I REALLY think you're gonna head in the wrong direction if you do that.

 

Red is town. Seriously, lock it in.

 

I sincerely believe RTE is town as well, especially with constant pressure on him that never dies, yet people let Dap slip to the sidelines over and over.

Are you crapping me? RTE disappears every single time he gets pressure. Take the blinders off, dudes blatant scum.

Dude -- you're saying the same thing to me about RTE that I'm saying about Dap! Except Dap sounds INFINITELY more guilty and self conscious! He makes excuses in every creaking post he makes. Where is he now? He said he would have lots of free time as of yesterday.

 

At least RTE isn't pulling punches. He's sassy, he's active. His OP was meh but it wasn't the lock scum event lots of you appear to be insisting it was.

 

 

Dap disappeared well before he got pressure IIRC.  Dude is just legit inactive.  Nice try though.

[Darthe]

 

So give up and die. You can't possibly be a positive influence on the game at this point and if that's how you feel then i see no reason to continue humoring you and discussing to try and see if I have any reason to alter my read.

 

Peace out Tommy, see you next game.

You said you were gonna show me those posts that make RTE lock scum. I'm waiting and willing to read them.

 

You said you were going to go read the pages where I said you'd find them.  My interpretation is on thread.  Go read it if you're going to put effort into this game anymore.

[WWWwombat]

 

 

 

Lol what are Darthe and Despo going to say when I flip town AGAIN?

 

Despo should just concede to not being able to read me. Period.

Oh look, RTE claiming scum again.

 

RTE, did you forget you were supposed to still think o might be scum?

Great point here actually. RTE completely ignoring the possibility that Darthe is scum seems pretty sketch given all the back and forth.

This isn't a thing. I talk to people like they are town even if I think they are scum.

 

 

That's not what I was talking about and you know it.  RTE talked to Darthe like he knew Darthe was town.  That is a thing.  Just ask Freud.

[WWWwombat]

 

 

And Tommy, Dap is LOCK CLEAR town because of Red's scummy scummy misrep of him.

 

But oh wait you're acting like she's def town

 

Terrible reason to LOCK CLEAR someone. Skill up.

It's just STUPID. Red isn't scum. So dap is lock clear because red is town? Okay Des. Great job.

 

 

Nice try but dumping on Des to look town ain't gonna work anymore.

[Tommyrod]

 

 

 

So give up and die. You can't possibly be a positive influence on the game at this point and if that's how you feel then i see no reason to continue humoring you and discussing to try and see if I have any reason to alter my read.

 

Peace out Tommy, see you next game.

You said you were gonna show me those posts that make RTE lock scum. I'm waiting and willing to read them.

You said you were going to go read the pages where I said you'd find them. My interpretation is on thread. Go read it if you're going to put effort into this game anymore.

No I didn't. I said I was on my phone and it's not easy for me to do so. You said you would get them. Wtf?

[Darthe]

When do we lynch RTE?  

[WWWwombat]

 

Also, just an aside while I'm catching up, Tommy is playing 100% defense at this point in the thread. The only people he pushes are Dap (who he sees as an easy lynch imo) and Darthe (for obvious reasons).

I'm also pushing you! Yay!

 

 

100% defense.  I don't think I've seen you make a single proactive scum read this game.

[Tommyrod]

 

 

 

 

And Tommy, Dap is LOCK CLEAR town because of Red's scummy scummy misrep of him.

 

But oh wait you're acting like she's def town

 

Terrible reason to LOCK CLEAR someone. Skill up.

It's just STUPID. Red isn't scum. So dap is lock clear because red is town? Okay Des. Great job.

Nice try but dumping on Des to look town ain't gonna work anymore.

What are you even talking about??

 

How are you not scum here?

 

Darthe, are you seeing the pure diarrhea he's spewing today?

[Darthe]

Ah I misinterpreted.

[Darthe]

 

 

 

 

And Tommy, Dap is LOCK CLEAR town because of Red's scummy scummy misrep of him.

 

But oh wait you're acting like she's def town

 

Terrible reason to LOCK CLEAR someone. Skill up.

It's just STUPID. Red isn't scum. So dap is lock clear because red is town? Okay Des. Great job.

Nice try but dumping on Des to look town ain't gonna work anymore.

What are you even talking about??

 

How are you not scum here?

 

Darthe, are you seeing the pure diarrhea he's spewing today?

 

I see dogmatic views.  I don't see diarrhea.

[Nynaeve]

Tommy, you're advocating not locking reads on people but then you're annoyed when people fluctuate on their read on you? :P

[WWWwombat]

I would like to add that wombat originally said that as scum I don't care about pressure. He said that's what makes me good as scum.

 

Now he's saying I'm responding poorly to pressure.

 

Um...?

 

Duh?

 

Yeah, I'm kinda disappointed in you.

[Tommyrod]

 

 

 

Also, just an aside while I'm catching up, Tommy is playing 100% defense at this point in the thread. The only people he pushes are Dap (who he sees as an easy lynch imo) and Darthe (for obvious reasons).

I'm also pushing you! Yay!

100% defense. I don't think I've seen you make a single proactive scum read this game.

YOU, RIGHT NOW.

 

I was also very thorough in my analysis of Dap. Someone else being aware of his scumminess earlier than I was does NOT diminish reality.

[Tommyrod]

Tommy, you're advocating not locking reads on people but then you're annoyed when people fluctuate on their read on you? :P

The point is this:

 

If someone is acting MORE townlike than they were, adjust that read.

 

I can only be seen as more townlike than I was earlier in the game because I'm posting my ass off and I am town. Therefore, my posts are townie posts. Therefore, I should be read as town.

 

It's not rocket science.

[WWWwombat]

NEVER have I played in a game where the players were THIS bad, THIS oblivious to scum staring them in the face, THIS willing to ignore obvious town tells to hone in on ABSOLUTELY ASININE "scumtells" that don't even fracking exist.

 

You're all doing the work for scum instead of letting them expose themselves. Scum likely has a lot of slankers because THEY DONT NEED TO WORK AT GETTING MISLYNCHES. YOU'RE DOING IT FOR THEM.

 

Unless you fracks are actually all scum, in which case -- well done, you snertheads.

 

I award you no points and may God have mercy on your soul.

[Tommyrod]

 

 

 

 

 

 

And Tommy, Dap is LOCK CLEAR town because of Red's scummy scummy misrep of him.

 

But oh wait you're acting like she's def town

 

Terrible reason to LOCK CLEAR someone. Skill up.

It's just STUPID. Red isn't scum. So dap is lock clear because red is town? Okay Des. Great job.

Nice try but dumping on Des to look town ain't gonna work anymore.

What are you even talking about??

 

How are you not scum here?

 

Darthe, are you seeing the pure diarrhea he's spewing today?

I see dogmatic views. I don't see diarrhea.

He's making shit up as he goes!

[WWWwombat]

 

 

Exaggeration isn't your strong suit. It just looks fake. I don't think you'll be convincing anyone I'm scum while yelling from a soapbox like a deranged world is ending conspiracist.

 

If one ignores rhetoric completely, Darthe has you by the balls here.

 

I can't remember getting this much rush from pushing a lynch since I took down DPR.

 

 

And then Verb and Yates got away T_T

[Darthe]

It does affect the potency of the read though.  Honestly, Wombat wasn't first to mention it either.  Pralaya was.  That makes it a popular opinion to have if someone wants to blend in and that was all done before Cory flipped, something I think really thew a lot of people off their games.  That read is reactive as hell btw and I just got ninjad.

[Tommyrod]

It does affect the potency of the read though. Honestly, Wombat wasn't first to mention it either. Pralaya was. That makes it a popular opinion to have if someone wants to blend in and that was all done before Cory flipped, something I think really thew a lot of people off their games. That read is reactive as hell btw and I just got ninjad.

So what do you even want me to do?