[Advanced] Blackhoof's Cthulhu Mythos Mafia Game- Day 1

[hazelkrs1]

And Tommy, Dap is LOCK CLEAR town because of Red's scummy scummy misrep of him.

 

But oh wait you're acting like she's def town

 

[Darthe]

 

Dap is clear town and you already got a townie killed with your pushes when you hadn't even read the game. I'm never going to let a single townie take the fall for someone I am damn sure to be scum and why would I?  That entire line of reasoning is a fabrication from you, one I know from experience.  Nyn can be forgiven for her ignorance on the matter but you don't fool me anymore Tommy and I am NOT going to play to it.  Your reads are crap, your methods are opportunistic and conceived around whatever will get a lynch and your tone is off, has been since Cory threw you with that suicide.  The immensely veteran players pushing for your lynch didn't come to the conclusion that you are scum without reason.  We know your game now.  

 

Cory got himself killed, like RTE said. Secondly, you had a scum read on Cory as well. Lets not forget that.

 

I pointed out before that I really didn't like Tommy proclaiming Cory scum from reading the first 4 pages and basically using his entrance into the game as the main, if not sole reason for it. This still stands against him. I do think, however, that he made some good points after he caught up. I remain undecided at current in regards to him. 

 

Putting that aside... no one is gonna bully my vote on anyone nor am I going to submit to someone's whims just because he's threatening to sub out...because boohoo everyone is being mean and not asking how high when he says jump. 

 

 

 

Totally did think Cory scum at the time.  His AtE was awful though to be fair I am beginning to see that as more of a null factor unless it is directed at specific people.  I don't get your final paragraph.  I want your vote on Tommy because I think he is scum.  If you don't vote there it doesn't mean I am going to call you scum or anything.  I'm just pushing my scum list.  It's squirming a lot too, something I like to see.

[Tommyrod]

Okay, so for the sake of in the moment narration, I'm seeing Darthe and Des desperately push a lynch on me as a counter wagon to the Dap wagon. Darthe keeps screaming that Dap is "clear town" but has no explanation as to why we should think that. When prompted by me to explain, he pushes the issue away.

 

That's not town behavior, so I'm thinking Darthe is either playing REALLY bad or he's scum with Dap, which is the more likely scenario.

 

Des could still be town and is being taken advantage of because we hurt his feelings. What this game doesn't need is another Cory situation, so I do kind of hope he subs out if he's going to maintain this whiny attitude.

 

So Darthe, the VERY FIRST THING you need to do now is EXPLAIN IN DETAIL WHY YOU KEEP INSISTING DAP IS 'CLEAR TOWN.'

[Darthe]

And Tommy, Dap is LOCK CLEAR town because of Red's scummy scummy misrep of him.

 

But oh wait you're acting like she's def town

 

She probably is town... 

[hazelkrs1]

Darthe, I wish I could hug you

 

 

I felt so freaking frustrated before, all the scum were ganging up on me, just saying I'm terrible at mafia and blah blah blah, and all you had was sheeple town eating it up

 

Darthe coming back in was him throwing me a lifeboat

 

[Darthe]

Okay, so for the sake of in the moment narration, I'm seeing Darthe and Des desperately push a lynch on me as a counter wagon to the Dap wagon. Darthe keeps screaming that Dap is "clear town" but has no explanation as to why we should think that. When prompted by me to explain, he pushes the issue away.

 

That's not town behavior, so I'm thinking Darthe is either playing REALLY bad or he's scum with Dap, which is the more likely scenario.

 

Des could still be town and is being taken advantage of because we hurt his feelings. What this game doesn't need is another Cory situation, so I do kind of hope he subs out if he's going to maintain this whiny attitude.

 

So Darthe, the VERY FIRST THING you need to do now is EXPLAIN IN DETAIL WHY YOU KEEP INSISTING DAP IS 'CLEAR TOWN.'

Here comes the switch to pushing me as scum.

 

AGAIN YOU HAVEN'T YET REFERRED TO WHAT POST OF YOURS YOU WANT ME TO RESPOND TO.  HOW CAN I RESPOND TO SOMETHING IF I DON'T KNOW WHAT IT IS?  

 

Keep pushin that Agenda Tommy.  

[Tommyrod]

And Tommy, Dap is LOCK CLEAR town because of Red's scummy scummy misrep of him.

 

But oh wait you're acting like she's def town

 

A townie talking about another player doesn't clear anyone, what are you even talking about?

 

You don't KNOW Red is scum. If you do and are a day cop or something, then you should claim that. Otherwise, shut up. Red reads as her genuine annoying absolutely batshit insane town self in this game and is going hard as a bulldog at a bone festival. Your scum read on her is extremely likely to be wrong or simply fabricated.

 

If you REALLY want to leave the game we can lynch you instead, but I still think you can play better and act like a reasonable person. Up to you.

[hazelkrs1]

 

 

And Tommy, Dap is LOCK CLEAR town because of Red's scummy scummy misrep of him.

 

But oh wait you're acting like she's def town

 

She probably is town...

Nope. Reread her and watch how she fabricates a scum read on Tommy, then tries leading town into setting up competing trains on the two of us, then starts acting like every post has her more and more convinced that Tommy is town after all.

 

Obvious scummates bro.

[Tommyrod]

 

 

Okay, so for the sake of in the moment narration, I'm seeing Darthe and Des desperately push a lynch on me as a counter wagon to the Dap wagon. Darthe keeps screaming that Dap is "clear town" but has no explanation as to why we should think that. When prompted by me to explain, he pushes the issue away.

 

That's not town behavior, so I'm thinking Darthe is either playing REALLY bad or he's scum with Dap, which is the more likely scenario.

 

Des could still be town and is being taken advantage of because we hurt his feelings. What this game doesn't need is another Cory situation, so I do kind of hope he subs out if he's going to maintain this whiny attitude.

 

So Darthe, the VERY FIRST THING you need to do now is EXPLAIN IN DETAIL WHY YOU KEEP INSISTING DAP IS 'CLEAR TOWN.'

Here comes the switch to pushing me as scum.

 

AGAIN YOU HAVEN'T YET REFERRED TO WHAT POST OF YOURS YOU WANT ME TO RESPOND TO. HOW CAN I RESPOND TO SOMETHING IF I DON'T KNOW WHAT IT IS?

 

Keep pushin that Agenda Tommy.

YOU'RE DODGING ME. WHY IS DAP 'CLEAR TOWN?' EXPLAIN YOUR CONFIDENCE IN THAT READ. TEN MINUTES. GO.

[Tommyrod]

 

 

 

And Tommy, Dap is LOCK CLEAR town because of Red's scummy scummy misrep of him.

 

But oh wait you're acting like she's def town

 

She probably is town...

Nope. Reread her and watch how she fabricates a scum read on Tommy, then tries leading town into setting up competing trains on the two of us, then starts acting like every post has her more and more convinced that Tommy is town after all.

 

Obvious scummates bro.

Uh... even if she WAS scum, that would almost definitely spew me clear.

 

I think you know this. WTF?

[Darthe]

Darthe, I wish I could hug you

 

 

I felt so freaking frustrated before, all the scum were ganging up on me, just saying I'm terrible at mafia and blah blah blah, and all you had was sheeple town eating it up

 

Darthe coming back in was him throwing me a lifeboat

 

<3

I need your vote.  I recognize that it would be better to get Tommy today but I don't think it's going to happen unless we can show that we are on point elsewhere.  He REALLY doesn't want to see an RTE lynch.  It's kind of funny actually.  Tommy thinks RTE is town and doesn't seem ok with letting him get lynched but won't talk about it.  I think Dap town and am not ok with letting him get lynched but will talk about it.  

 

I am taking the town approach, Tommy is trying to chainsaw defend RTE by setting me up for a lynch.  AINT GONNA HAPPEN.  Ironic, eh?

[hazelkrs1]

 

And Tommy, Dap is LOCK CLEAR town because of Red's scummy scummy misrep of him.

 

But oh wait you're acting like she's def town

 

A townie talking about another player doesn't clear anyone, what are you even talking about?

 

You don't KNOW Red is scum. If you do and are a day cop or something, then you should claim that. Otherwise, shut up. Red reads as her genuine annoying absolutely batshit insane town self in this game and is going hard as a bulldog at a bone festival. Your scum read on her is extremely likely to be wrong or simply fabricated.

 

If you REALLY want to leave the game we can lynch you instead, but I still think you can play better and act like a reasonable person. Up to you.

If all you're going to say all game is that I'm terrible at mafia and blah blah blah, just know I will never play mafia with you again. I don't care if you're scum, this is just bs disrespectful crap that you should have elevated past long ago

 

I'm legit pretty good at mafia, and completely caught you and most of your team. Whine on the QT all you want about it, but continuing to disparage my play is just going to lead to me blacklisting you

[hazelkrs1]

I'm completely serious when I say that Tommy.

 

And that goes for anyone else really- I don't play mafia to have assholes resort to continuously disparaging my play when they can't think of a better defense to my arguments. Learn to play nubs.

[Darthe]

 

Dap is clear town and you already got a townie killed with your pushes when you hadn't even read the game. I'm never going to let a single townie take the fall for someone I am damn sure to be scum and why would I? That entire line of reasoning is a fabrication from you, one I know from experience. Nyn can be forgiven for her ignorance on the matter but you don't fool me anymore Tommy and I am NOT going to play to it. Your reads are crap, your methods are opportunistic and conceived around whatever will get a lynch and your tone is off, has been since Cory threw you with that suicide. The immensely veteran players pushing for your lynch didn't come to the conclusion that you are scum without reason. We know your game now.

Let's start small.

 

How is down "clear town?" I quoted one of his really bad posts that I broke down and showed it to you again. You ignored it. So the onus is now on you to show us why Dap is clear town.

 

Good luck!

 

 

Why can Tommy not quote this post?  Can anyone explain that?  He says here that he wants me to examine a post that he believes shows DAP as scum.  I said directly after this that if he quoted it I would respond to it point for point and consider the points that he has made, thus showing my position on Dap as town but also allowing for his case to sway my view since I COULD be wrong.  I say this here:

 

 

http://www.dragonmount.com/forums/topic/89954-advanced-blackhoofs-cthulhu-mythos-mafia-game-day-1/?p=3279081

 

Since then Tommy has been calling me a liar, saying that I am fabricating reads and am scummy and that I am arguing without reason for not giving responses to a post that he will not provide.

 

CAN ANYONE EXPLAIN THE ABOVE FROM A TOWNIE?  No?  Me EITHER.

[Tommyrod]

 

 

And Tommy, Dap is LOCK CLEAR town because of Red's scummy scummy misrep of him.

 

But oh wait you're acting like she's def town

 

A townie talking about another player doesn't clear anyone, what are you even talking about?

 

You don't KNOW Red is scum. If you do and are a day cop or something, then you should claim that. Otherwise, shut up. Red reads as her genuine annoying absolutely batshit insane town self in this game and is going hard as a bulldog at a bone festival. Your scum read on her is extremely likely to be wrong or simply fabricated.

 

If you REALLY want to leave the game we can lynch you instead, but I still think you can play better and act like a reasonable person. Up to you.

If all you're going to say all game is that I'm terrible at mafia and blah blah blah, just know I will never play mafia with you again. I don't care if you're scum, this is just bs disrespectful crap that you should have elevated past long ago

 

I'm legit pretty good at mafia, and completely caught you and most of your team. Whine on the QT all you want about it, but continuing to disparage my play is just going to lead to me blacklisting you

Des: Jesus Christ. I am not mafia.

 

Do you understand those four basic words?

 

So your reads CANT BE GOOD and you can't "catch my team" when I'm town!

 

I think Darthe is playing you HARD right now and you need to stop having a pity party and choose:

 

1. Lynch Dap.

2. Lynch Darthe.

3. Lynch yourself.

 

That's it, those are your options.

 

Which do you think is MOST LIKELY to be the most +EV play for town?

 

And don't dodge me please.

[hazelkrs1]

 

 

 

 

And Tommy, Dap is LOCK CLEAR town because of Red's scummy scummy misrep of him.

 

But oh wait you're acting like she's def town

 

She probably is town...

Nope. Reread her and watch how she fabricates a scum read on Tommy, then tries leading town into setting up competing trains on the two of us, then starts acting like every post has her more and more convinced that Tommy is town after all.

 

Obvious scummates bro.

Uh... even if she WAS scum, that would almost definitely spew me clear.

 

I think you know this. WTF?

 

It most certainly does NOT.

 

It's plain as day obvious that she was trying to distance from you, then y'all tried reverting to instead making a power scum group to browbeat the rest of town into agreeing with y'all about Dap.

 

OBVIOUS SCUMMATES BRO

[Nynaeve]

Totally did think Cory scum at the time.  His AtE was awful though to be fair I am beginning to see that as more of a null factor unless it is directed at specific people.  I don't get your final paragraph.  I want your vote on Tommy because I think he is scum.  If you don't vote there it doesn't mean I am going to call you scum or anything.  I'm just pushing my scum list.  It's squirming a lot too, something I like to see.

 

In regards to Cory, from what I've seen of him in previous games, it is a null tell. 

 

As for what I said in the second paragraph, I'm expressing my displeasure at the tone the game has taken recently. I really don't like it.

 

 

 

I'm running late now so I should take off. I'll try to check in from my phone some if I can. Toodles!

 

 

 

Nyn

[Darthe]

I have a 1 meeting at school =/  I'll be back in a bit, sorry for ducking out here.

 

 

Totally did think Cory scum at the time.  His AtE was awful though to be fair I am beginning to see that as more of a null factor unless it is directed at specific people.  I don't get your final paragraph.  I want your vote on Tommy because I think he is scum.  If you don't vote there it doesn't mean I am going to call you scum or anything.  I'm just pushing my scum list.  It's squirming a lot too, something I like to see.

 

In regards to Cory, from what I've seen of him in previous games, it is a null tell. 

 

As for what I said in the second paragraph, I'm expressing my displeasure at the tone the game has taken recently. I really don't like it.

 

 

 

I'm running late now so I should take off. I'll try to check in from my phone some if I can. Toodles!

 

 

 

Nyn

 

 

I can acccept that.  It's not a fun tone to work with either but I have been trying to wade through it to get a solid grasp of the game.  I do think that Cory threw the entire scum team (which seems to have rolled badly anyhow) and now it's really biting them.  I usually wouldn't have this good a grasp on early game.

[Tommyrod]

 

 

 

 

Vote Count

Nyn(1)- Wombat

ReleaseTheEvil(3)- Darthe, Nervo, Des

Darthe(1)- cory

Nervo(1)- Red

cory(3)- Mynd, Quibby, Tommy

With 18 alive it takes 10 to lynchDeadline: No deadline

I do love me some competing trains

 

I don't think I've ever played with Corey before

But I appreciate the case on him and respect the three people voting him (all three don't tend to play very tight games)

However I really dislike RTes reveal and don't think his train will continue given the new momentum on Corey

Therefore in the interest of having those competing trains

[v]vote RTE[/v]

 

In other news I'm going to bed, exam in the morning so don't expect to hear from me for a while ( 16 hours or so)

Once I'm back though I'll be a free man

This post is bad, bad, bad. Not only does he bandwagon here, but he eggs on the cory lynch, self consciously acknowledges his wagoning, tries to rationalize it, and then provides scumscuses for his eventual absence, as if anyone cares, followed by a promise to play a lot more.

 

It would be difficult to pen a post more conspicuous and oozing with awkwardness than this one.

 

We need to lynch Dap today, seriously. He's scum.

Darthe if you think a townie made this post I have a bridge on mars to sell you

Darthe; the post is RIGHT HERE, just a few pages back, not even 6 hours ago.

 

NOW RESPOND TO IT.

 

You're arguing like a five year old.

[Tommyrod]

 

 

 

 

 

And Tommy, Dap is LOCK CLEAR town because of Red's scummy scummy misrep of him.

 

But oh wait you're acting like she's def town

 

She probably is town...

Nope. Reread her and watch how she fabricates a scum read on Tommy, then tries leading town into setting up competing trains on the two of us, then starts acting like every post has her more and more convinced that Tommy is town after all.

 

Obvious scummates bro.

Uh... even if she WAS scum, that would almost definitely spew me clear.

 

I think you know this. WTF?

 

It most certainly does NOT.

 

It's plain as day obvious that she was trying to distance from you, then y'all tried reverting to instead making a power scum group to browbeat the rest of town into agreeing with y'all about Dap.

 

OBVIOUS SCUMMATES BRO

Are you just messing with me for fun? Because your tone sounds like you're mocking me.

[Darthe]

Oh, before I go... I predict ~10 pages of my name getting trashed by RTE/Tommy.

 

If you all have forgotten, RTE was getting DESTROYED by Des and I and he likely got told to STFU in a QT somewhere.  Now RTE IS FROZEN.

 

RTE CAN YOU EXPLAIN ANY OF THE STATEMENTS YOU MADE THAT WERE BLATANT SCUM SLIPS?  TRY NOT TO COPY PASTE FROM TOMMY IN THE QT.  

[hazelkrs1]

 

 

 

And Tommy, Dap is LOCK CLEAR town because of Red's scummy scummy misrep of him.

 

But oh wait you're acting like she's def town

 

A townie talking about another player doesn't clear anyone, what are you even talking about?

 

You don't KNOW Red is scum. If you do and are a day cop or something, then you should claim that. Otherwise, shut up. Red reads as her genuine annoying absolutely batshit insane town self in this game and is going hard as a bulldog at a bone festival. Your scum read on her is extremely likely to be wrong or simply fabricated.

 

If you REALLY want to leave the game we can lynch you instead, but I still think you can play better and act like a reasonable person. Up to you.

If all you're going to say all game is that I'm terrible at mafia and blah blah blah, just know I will never play mafia with you again. I don't care if you're scum, this is just bs disrespectful crap that you should have elevated past long ago

 

I'm legit pretty good at mafia, and completely caught you and most of your team. Whine on the QT all you want about it, but continuing to disparage my play is just going to lead to me blacklisting you

Des: Jesus Christ. I am not mafia.

 

Do you understand those four basic words?

 

So your reads CANT BE GOOD and you can't "catch my team" when I'm town!

 

I think Darthe is playing you HARD right now and you need to stop having a pity party and choose:

 

1. Lynch Dap.

2. Lynch Darthe.

3. Lynch yourself.

 

That's it, those are your options.

 

Which do you think is MOST LIKELY to be the most +EV play for town?

 

And don't dodge me please.

Imma go with option D and lynch your scummy ass

 

And don't Boohoo to me, you brought this on your freaking self by playing a lolwilf game. Bandwagoned onto Cory in a scummy manner. Backtracked off your gauntlet throwdown. Voted me while begging me to read you as town. Tried clearing your teammates and casting aspersion on LOCK CLEAR townies as your version of #DAMAGECONTROL

 

Then you have the freaking audacity to disparage MY play? Get real bro. And learn to freaking play. Calling someone lolbad in lieu of actual defense from their GOD level arguments ain't freaking mafia.

[Tommyrod]

Hey Darthe, the mythical post is waiting for you.

 

For onlookers -- Darthe has still refused to explain his town read on Dap.

 

He keeps dodging me, acting like I'm pulling hairs when I just want him to back up his own statements with evidence. He hasn't.

[Tommyrod]

 

 

 

 

And Tommy, Dap is LOCK CLEAR town because of Red's scummy scummy misrep of him.

 

But oh wait you're acting like she's def town

 

A townie talking about another player doesn't clear anyone, what are you even talking about?

 

You don't KNOW Red is scum. If you do and are a day cop or something, then you should claim that. Otherwise, shut up. Red reads as her genuine annoying absolutely batshit insane town self in this game and is going hard as a bulldog at a bone festival. Your scum read on her is extremely likely to be wrong or simply fabricated.

 

If you REALLY want to leave the game we can lynch you instead, but I still think you can play better and act like a reasonable person. Up to you.

If all you're going to say all game is that I'm terrible at mafia and blah blah blah, just know I will never play mafia with you again. I don't care if you're scum, this is just bs disrespectful crap that you should have elevated past long ago

 

I'm legit pretty good at mafia, and completely caught you and most of your team. Whine on the QT all you want about it, but continuing to disparage my play is just going to lead to me blacklisting you

Des: Jesus Christ. I am not mafia.

 

Do you understand those four basic words?

 

So your reads CANT BE GOOD and you can't "catch my team" when I'm town!

 

I think Darthe is playing you HARD right now and you need to stop having a pity party and choose:

 

1. Lynch Dap.

2. Lynch Darthe.

3. Lynch yourself.

 

That's it, those are your options.

 

Which do you think is MOST LIKELY to be the most +EV play for town?

 

And don't dodge me please.

Imma go with option D and lynch your scummy ass

 

And don't Boohoo to me, you brought this on your freaking self by playing a lolwilf game. Bandwagoned onto Cory in a scummy manner. Backtracked off your gauntlet throwdown. Voted me while begging me to read you as town. Tried clearing your teammates and casting aspersion on LOCK CLEAR townies as your version of #DAMAGECONTROL

 

Then you have the freaking audacity to disparage MY play? Get real bro. And learn to freaking play. Calling someone lolbad in lieu of actual defense from their GOD level arguments ain't freaking mafia.

Are you really arguing now that I'm a bad player? Seriously?

 

Grow up.

[Darthe]

 

 

 

 

Vote Count

Nyn(1)- Wombat

ReleaseTheEvil(3)- Darthe, Nervo, Des

Darthe(1)- cory

Nervo(1)- Red

cory(3)- Mynd, Quibby, Tommy

With 18 alive it takes 10 to lynchDeadline: No deadline

I do love me some competing trains

 

I don't think I've ever played with Corey before

But I appreciate the case on him and respect the three people voting him (all three don't tend to play very tight games)

However I really dislike RTes reveal and don't think his train will continue given the new momentum on Corey

Therefore in the interest of having those competing trains

[v]vote RTE[/v]

 

In other news I'm going to bed, exam in the morning so don't expect to hear from me for a while ( 16 hours or so)

Once I'm back though I'll be a free man

This post is bad, bad, bad. Not only does he bandwagon here, but he eggs on the cory lynch, self consciously acknowledges his wagoning, tries to rationalize it, and then provides scumscuses for his eventual absence, as if anyone cares, followed by a promise to play a lot more.

 

It would be difficult to pen a post more conspicuous and oozing with awkwardness than this one.

 

We need to lynch Dap today, seriously. He's scum.

Darthe if you think a townie made this post I have a bridge on mars to sell you

Darthe; the post is RIGHT HERE, just a few pages back, not even 6 hours ago.

 

NOW RESPOND TO IT.

 

You're arguing like a five year old.

 

Last response I'll make.  

 

Cory *WAS* scummy.  Like ten people egged on that lynch and he was baseless emotional town.  I consider the red to be null in light of how many of us were pushing Cory.  It likely did have some scum pushing it but that doesn't make it Dap.  

 

I acknowledge that the Yellow is bad but it does fit with DAP's meta.  He says that in almost every game because his big holdup is on train equality and analysis etc.  Still, fairly a point against him.  

 

Nobody that has played this long lies about IRL.  That's a crap point and you know it.  I am leaving for class.  Is that a scumtastic excuse?  No.  Disappearing without reasoning is scummy.  Stating you have crap to do is life.  Same for the blue.

 

There is literally one thing in this entire post that may be pingworthy objectively and the rest of it is absolute bullshanks.  If that's the best you have how the hell did this lynch train get five people?  I'll tell you how: Scum motivated.