[Basic] Call of Cthulhu Mafia- MAFIA VICTORY!

[Zanube]

That's the first time I've seen a tons of spaces at the end and no tongue in cheek remark after em. Weird.

 

First off Zanube, sorry about mistaking your gender. I can relate hehe.

 

Second, of course you can make any comment you want. You didn't say anything to back up what you said however, or WHY you thought both of us could be scum. It was about as empty a comment you could have made there. It was also your only post of the game, so nothing else to judge you on makes it kinda tough.

 

You DID make a commitment to the other players in the game as well as the mod by the way when you signed up fyi. If you don't participate there's no way for others to decide what your alignment could be. I'm sorry to hear about your internet crashing, but no one else knew about that. Now that you're here though, can you give us any other thoughts about stuff that's happened on thread?

I didn't see the space before posting :) sorry

I do agree that i made a commitment to this game and I promise that I will post more.The internet crashing was a technical reason.

 

I think that both of you are scum as there are instances when people can team up and and work against the townies. Even if one of them die the other is still alive to work against townies. Arguing can be a way to hide this. People may never know.

I am also open on voting Lily as when she stepped of Xthrax's train saying that she wanted to hear what Xthrax wanted to say. AJ then questioned her and after Xthrax made his claim she wanted to vote Xthrax saying that she wanted to hear what AJ was trying to protect.

[hazelkrs1]

X is there a reason you left so many people off your reads list? I see two town reads, two nulls, and one fence-sittingy fos. Not exactly out of the ballpark material.

[hazelkrs1]

 

That's the first time I've seen a tons of spaces at the end and no tongue in cheek remark after em. Weird.

 

First off Zanube, sorry about mistaking your gender. I can relate hehe.

 

Second, of course you can make any comment you want. You didn't say anything to back up what you said however, or WHY you thought both of us could be scum. It was about as empty a comment you could have made there. It was also your only post of the game, so nothing else to judge you on makes it kinda tough.

 

You DID make a commitment to the other players in the game as well as the mod by the way when you signed up fyi. If you don't participate there's no way for others to decide what your alignment could be. I'm sorry to hear about your internet crashing, but no one else knew about that. Now that you're here though, can you give us any other thoughts about stuff that's happened on thread?

I didn't see the space before posting :) sorry

I do agree that i made a commitment to this game and I promise that I will post more.The internet crashing was a technical reason.

 

I think that both of you are scum as there are instances when people can team up and and work against the townies. Even if one of them die the other is still alive to work against townies. Arguing can be a way to hide this. People may never know.

I am also open on voting Lily as when she stepped of Xthrax's train saying that she wanted to hear what Xthrax wanted to say. AJ then questioned her and after Xthrax made his claim she wanted to vote Xthrax saying that she wanted to hear what AJ was trying to protect.

 

 

This is much much better thank you. Moar posts like this. The more transparent you can make your reasoning, the better for town.

[Sedai]

I know it's bad. Didn't read rules. I skim. Sue me :)

[Sedai]

And Desp. Hard to hammer when neither are at L-1 :)

 

I'm voting for one of the two candidates I said I'm okay with. As much as I can do

[Xthrax]

Wow got ninjad by a lot of people while I was typing that post. 

 

6. Leelou-By the way, I found what switch meant. You meant to hit me-bbut I didn't do anything wrong   

 

I understand why you refused to take the viewpoint thing. Your pointing out to Lily that she could have posted something else I agree with because it mirrors my opinion on her. Your posts pointing out Jack idea of how AJ would look based on how I would flip and vice versa comes across as giving a good tone. You are currently leaning town for me. You haven't posted a lot but then I'm fine with what you have said as it mirrors my own stance.

 

7. Des-I understood how that it was joke vote and I responded in kind. But then you should have left it at the joke and not constantly push that. When I felt like you were constantly pushing that I felt I had to say something regarding the bogus reasoning. I also don't understand how you don't think of the first post as a joke and consider it serious. I had intended it as sarcasm, don't know how you saw it. I have only seen you once as mafia till now, but then too you started of with a weak reasoning and continued to push that, throwing out random weak reasons and latching onto to one thing. Eventually you flipped as mafia, that game makes me quite suspicious of your current game. 

 

Based on your other reads, I agree with a few things such as your read of Lily, Leelou, Quibby etc. I am split on your read of Jack. There is correlation between how someone flips and the other person's alignment. They could have been buddying, they could have been bussing. And if someone is lynched and flips town, the last person to lynch looks suspicious for me.

Aj has handled the pressure well, though his part about placing someone on L-1 is a mixed feel for me. You also strongly feel Jack is scum because he says my reaction was joke spam(at least someone kinda felt it was a joke). I don't agree with it and this seems not a right motion to me.

 

But the rest of your opinion of Jack seems good on how he handled AJ's question on Lily. You give me a mixed read Des, but I feel you as somewhat scummy based on how I watched you play as scum.

[Zanube]

I am voting Lily as when she stepped of Xthrax's train saying that she wanted to hear what Xthrax wanted to say. AJ then questioned her and after Xthrax made his claim she wanted to vote Xthrax saying that she wanted to hear what AJ was trying to protect.

 

Vote Lily

[Sedai]

AJ contradicted himself.

 

He believes you acted scummy. Yet unvotes you and votes Lily for leaving you at L-2, even though she stated she thought you were acting suspicious.

 

"IF" I'm remembering correctly (I say if cause I'm on dm mobile and can't check for positive)

 

He (AJ) then goes on about waiting for a deadline but also flipping on the same issue.

[Xthrax]

8. Verbal-Firstly hope you are feeling better. I agree with you that post seemed super cheesy, but I responded to the pushing in that way. You give me a good tone Verbal, you gave your reason for voting. You could have skipped on the reasoning. It gives a town read based on what you have done. 

 

9.AJ-I don't agree with some of your reasoning. Waiting till deadline gives will give mafia an oppurtunity to jump on a townie giving the reason consolidating. I agree with you that putting a person at L-1 gives them time to claim too. But your stance when Jack questioned you gave me a quite good feel. You have stated your reasons clearly under pressure and you stand to your stance. I have a null to town lean on you.

 

10. Zanube-I put down your first post as little weird but then its your first game. I agree with your opinion that 2 players might go for an attempt like that but then you have to post a little more. Nice to see you participating though. I agree with your stance on Lily. Currently you seem as null read but I have a feeling that you might be town. I'd like to see you give a little more. For instance, what do you think about Des and me now? Have your reads changed? What about other players?

 

11.Wombat-I'd like to see you what you think about the other players. Am I right in assuming that your vote on Verb was a D1 joke vote? But your questions so far have contributed somewhat, so I'd peg you as a null lean.

 

Also UNVOTE

[Xthrax]

AJ contradicted himself.

 

He believes you acted scummy. Yet unvotes you and votes Lily for leaving you at L-2, even though she stated she thought you were acting suspicious.

 

"IF" I'm remembering correctly (I say if cause I'm on dm mobile and can't check for positive)

 

He (AJ) then goes on about waiting for a deadline but also flipping on the same issue.

 

I agree with that. He did seem to be contradicting and gave me a kind of suspicious feel. But his stance and response under pressure seems ok.

[WWWwombat]

 

I must've missed it. What exactly do you learn from AJ's flip?

AJ flips scum that means X is scum as he pealed of a vote from X making him L-3 which is just slowing the train. And AJ pealed said vote off with shoddy reasoning and a weak case.

 

However if he flips town. X is still looking scummy from his floundering with very little pressure.

 

 

So in other words, you learn very little from AJ's flip.  I.E. not an info lynch.

 

 

 

 

I must've missed it. What exactly do you learn from AJ's flip?

AJ flips scum that means X is scum as he pealed of a vote from X making him L-3 which is just slowing the train. And AJ pealed said vote off with shoddy reasoning and a weak case.

 

However if he flips town. X is still looking scummy from his floundering with very little pressure.

 

The Fork is strong here.

 

You're leaving out a few options, which is bad. Ishy just pointed one of them out.

 

 

Yep.

 

 

Gonna go back through and combover everything, but quick thoughts while I was catching up on mobile during work-

 

Jack looks vurry scummy to me. Initially just for how much he seemed to be setting up lynches- by saying even if AJ flipped town, X would still look scummy (obv giving Jack someone he could immediately vote the next day). He also seemed somewhat obstinate about explaining WHY AJ made a good info lynch (spoiler alert, he doesn't- altho X does)

 

I didn't like AJ's initial FOS on Lily, her not wanting to be another bandwagon vote when there had already been so many recent ones didn't seem that big a deal to me. But he has handled pressure very well imo, and looks LOCK CLEAR to me. Would not lynch today.

 

Even tho I didn't like AJ's initial FOS on Lily, I didn't like her then hopping on the X wagon later and withholding comment on everything else. Just looks like scum trying to ditch responsibility to scumhunt. Were X to flip town she could defend her vote tomorrow and say she thought AJ was defending a teammate, that kind of noise. I know she's not the most vocal player early on, but still- there's a lot of Oh Gees in this game, and I would normally expect her to be much more comfortable talking with Jack in the game.

 

Kind of wondering if there's a Jack/Lily pairing this game, which would be kinda funny hehe.

 

However X's recent comments still don't look good to me. His initial response to my vote didn't look like he was joking or taking it lightly at all, it looked like he regarded my vote as a serious vote and seemed immediately concerned that he was being focused on. This looks like newbscum a lot more than newbtown to me. Also thinking X is scum and Jack was trying to distance from him and at the same time try to lead a different train instead.

 

As a quick aside before I Wotcraft in this Lovecraft theme- does anyone know what got Ishy so upset? Or who he was talking to in his last post? Seemed to come out of nowhere. This isn't an fos per se, just honestly perplexed by his apparent anger.

 

This is a good post.  I liked it so much I almost read the whole thing.  I agree that AJ has been towntelling (although I'm only town lean on him atm) and that Jack is scummy.

[WWWwombat]

And my vote on Verbal was not a joke.

[WWWwombat]

unvote

Vote: Xthrax

 

He's been a bit scummy with his whyme fryme attitude, and I don't like how Jack is trying to distance from him while voting AJ.

[Sedai]

Unvote vote X

 

As I said. Happy to vote either. Both have earned a vote.

 

@wombat how about AJ's contradictory statements?

[Sedai]

Jack and Lily are undefeated as scum mates. Just saying ^^

[WWWwombat]

Well you passed the test for now, Jack.

 

I didn't see any contradictory statements by AJ, but he has said a couple things that have made me raise my eyebrows.  Overall though, he seems townish to me.  He's trying to figure stuff out imo.

[John E. Kelley]

Damn Jack, can Wom make you balance a ball on your nose too?

[Sedai]

Well you passed the test for now, Jack.

 

I didn't see any contradictory statements by AJ, but he has said a couple things that have made me raise my eyebrows. Overall though, he seems townish to me. He's trying to figure stuff out imo.

I find it odd you said I was distancing from X. That was my second time voting him. I've been on him since his squirming and only flipped to AJ when it looked like he was stalling his train.

 

The contradictory vibe I got was

 

AJ stalling X's train, and calling him scummy. Then proceeding to vote for Lily, because she said "X looks scummy, let's keep him at L-2." And AJ continued to say no matter what if someone looks scummy vote them.

[Sedai]

Damn Jack, can Wom make you balance a ball on your nose too?

Lol I said I was happy either which way. And I stand by that statement. Both have knotted their

own nooses

[Verbal32]

Jack and Lily are undefeated as scum mates. Just saying ^^

If so, you didn't play enough games with some of the current roster. ;-)

[Sedai]

In fact. unvote and vote AJ

 

I'm digging this lynch more then X :)

[Verbal32]

And my vote on Verbal was not a joke.

No, it was a cheesy bury vote.

[Verbal32]

unvote

Vote: Xthrax

 

He's been a bit scummy with his whyme fryme attitude, and I don't like how Jack is trying to distance from him while voting AJ.

Can't wait to see X's coroner now!

[WWWwombat]

My impression was that AJ was saying that X did some archetypically "scummy" things and then got run up, so he thought him likely to be derptown.  That's a valid viewpoint imo.  Of course, it could easily be wrong (X could be derpscum), and it's also one that scum like to take as Ishy pointed out.

 

I found your reaction to X's wagon to be more suspicious than AJ's.

[Sedai]

 

Jack and Lily are undefeated as scum mates. Just saying ^^

If so, you didn't play enough games with some of the current roster. ;-)

Lol probably not. But every game that we've been scum together we've won. I've lost to her. She's lost to me as separate factions. But it's mostly fun to play together and when your having fun your at your best I think