[Basic] Call of Cthulhu Mafia- MAFIA VICTORY!

[John E. Kelley]

Just home from work. Give me five minutes to figure this out, then I'll win this for you slobs.

[WWWwombat]

 

How is that an information lynch?

Andrej pealed off of X at first opportunity. Seems a mafia thing to do.

 

 

And that makes AJ an info lynch how?

[Sedai]

Bad post Jack.

 

1. You're calling X scum regardless.

2. Explain how going to DL helps the mafia win.

 

You talk about being proactive but I fail to see how rushing to lynch someone on D1 is helpful or very proactive. At this point X is an easy lynch with how others have bandwagoned on his train.

 

What do you really think you'll learn from his flip at this point?

Bad post? Lolzzzz

 

1. I said I have a scum lean on X. That was before you jumped from his train with a bs reason. Looks like you derailed it or attempted to. And only people who would do that would have to know the persons alignment. So if you flip scum. X is pretty much scum in my book. If you flip town, x looks scummy from his earlier posts just not enough to say 100%

 

2. If I have to explain then it's a hopeless situation. Deadlines promote speed lynches 1 hour of less before it hits. If you wait for a deadline vote scum can hide on bandwagon train using the excuse "any lynch is better then a random one." Or you could kill off a power role and that person not have time to respond

[Sedai]

 

 

 

How is that an information lynch?

Andrej pealed off of X at first opportunity. Seems a mafia thing to do.

And that makes AJ an info lynch how?

Already stated. :)

[WWWwombat]

I must've missed it.  What exactly do you learn from AJ's flip?

[John E. Kelley]

X train is weaksauce. Going after the new guy for lulz and then watching him flounder (shocking in a new player amirite ) is lame.

 

That being said, what is even dirtier is the White Knight swooping in to save him.

 

Vote AJ.

[Sedai]

X train is weaksauce. Going after the new guy for lulz and then watching him flounder (shocking in a new player amirite ) is lame.

 

That being said, what is even dirtier is the White Knight swooping in to save him.

 

Vote AJ.

5 games isn't new. But yeah ^^

[Andrej]

 

Bad post Jack.

 

1. You're calling X scum regardless.

2. Explain how going to DL helps the mafia win.

 

You talk about being proactive but I fail to see how rushing to lynch someone on D1 is helpful or very proactive. At this point X is an easy lynch with how others have bandwagoned on his train.

 

What do you really think you'll learn from his flip at this point?

Bad post? Lolzzzz

 

1. I said I have a scum lean on X. That was before you jumped from his train with a bs reason. Looks like you derailed it or attempted to. And only people who would do that would have to know the persons alignment. So if you flip scum. X is pretty much scum in my book. If you flip town, x looks scummy from his earlier posts just not enough to say 100%

 

2. If I have to explain then it's a hopeless situation. Deadlines promote speed lynches 1 hour of less before it hits. If you wait for a deadline vote scum can hide on bandwagon train using the excuse "any lynch is better then a random one." Or you could kill off a power role and that person not have time to respond

 

 

1. It really doesn't matter if you call it a solid scum read or scum lean. Words don't me Jack (geddit lol ) The point I'm making is that you are still calling X scum regardless of how I would flip. This is bad.

 

2. I can agree to a certain point that there are lots of late pile-ups in games, but that's more so on the players for not participating as they should. Regardless though, even those late pile-up wagons still provide info. I'm not saying we need to wait until the last second to lynch someone, but I don't find it productive to rush it now.

 

Does X look bad for his reaction initially? Sure. Does that mean he is really scum? Maybe. But couple with how quickly his wagon has gained speed with the current phase we are in and it makes me leery. I am aware of the stigma that is created by my action and I accept that. If I'm wrong about X or Lily then I am wrong, but in the end I will absolve myself through my play.

[Sedai]

I must've missed it. What exactly do you learn from AJ's flip?

AJ flips scum that means X is scum as he pealed of a vote from X making him L-3 which is just slowing the train. And AJ pealed said vote off with shoddy reasoning and a weak case.

 

However if he flips town. X is still looking scummy from his floundering with very little pressure.

[Leelou]

 

I must've missed it. What exactly do you learn from AJ's flip?

AJ flips scum that means X is scum as he pealed of a vote from X making him L-3 which is just slowing the train. And AJ pealed said vote off with shoddy reasoning and a weak case.

 

However if he flips town. X is still looking scummy from his floundering with very little pressure.

 

 

Wouldn't it be better to lynch X in this situation? 

[Andrej]

 

I must've missed it. What exactly do you learn from AJ's flip?

AJ flips scum that means X is scum as he pealed of a vote from X making him L-3 which is just slowing the train. And AJ pealed said vote off with shoddy reasoning and a weak case.

 

However if he flips town. X is still looking scummy from his floundering with very little pressure.

 

The Fork is strong here.

 

You're leaving out a few options, which is bad. Ishy just pointed one of them out.

[Sedai]

X looks scummy. He did that independent of you. So why would your flip do anything but cement his scummy status or keep it the same. It's purely logical

[Sedai]

 

 

 

I must've missed it. What exactly do you learn from AJ's flip?

AJ flips scum that means X is scum as he pealed of a vote from X making him L-3 which is just slowing the train. And AJ pealed said vote off with shoddy reasoning and a weak case.

 

However if he flips town. X is still looking scummy from his floundering with very little pressure.

Wouldn't it be better to lynch X in this situation?

At this place and time I am 100% okay with either candidate.

[Andrej]

Because you are neglecting to think that I could be scum WKing X as Ishy just pointed out.

 

You are basically making a lose-lose situation for X, which I find very bad.

[Sedai]

However that leaves you with. A wifom if you lynch X first.

 

Did AJ try and stop the train cause he knew he was town so he could come of looking better?

 

Eliminating AJ now cuts through the Wifom

[Sedai]

Because you are neglecting to think that I could be scum WKing X as Ishy just pointed out.

 

You are basically making a lose-lose situation for X, which I find very bad.

I'm gunna say this one more time then not clutter the game with it.

 

X got the votes for his scummy behavior. Not for anything else.

 

You pealed off a vote from him sliding back his train. Like it or not. That action ties you two together if one flips scum.

 

X made himself scummy independently.

 

You made each other scummy codependently

[Sedai]

vote X

Couple all that with your vote with no explanation before X started squirming and the fact you peeled it off with weak reasoning that's best I have. Any more questions on the matter will be addressed with the following two characters :)

[Andrej]

I understand the premise dude lol

 

And I accept the way it looks. If X flips scum I am aware that I have tied myself to him, it happens.

 

That said, his train was building fast and the statement Lily made pinged me. As I said, she shouldn't have issue putting him at L-1 even if he hadn't claimed if she found him scummy. If someone were to come in and hammer afterwards THAT person would be under fire the next phase. So really, her statement came across as a way to nudge along X's train while simultaneously staying off with a safe 'pro-town' play.

[Sedai]

I understand the premise dude lol

 

And I accept the way it looks. If X flips scum I am aware that I have tied myself to him, it happens.

 

That said, his train was building fast and the statement Lily made pinged me. As I said, she shouldn't have issue putting him at L-1 even if he hadn't claimed if she found him scummy. If someone were to come in and hammer afterwards THAT person would be under fire the next phase. So really, her statement came across as a way to nudge along X's train while simultaneously staying off with a safe 'pro-town' play.

Hammer is rarely looked at as hard as the person placing him in hammer range. In my experience

[Blackhoof]

Good work with all the activity guys, I am very pleased with how this game is going

 

Vote Count

 

Zanube- Xthrax (1)

Xthrax- Des, Verbal, Leelou (3)

Verbal- Wombat (1)

Lily- Andrej (1)

Andrej- Jack, Ishy (2)

 

Jason- Quibby (1)

 

With 12 alive it takes 7 to lynch

 

Deadline: None

[John E. Kelley]

You missed my vote sir.

[Andrej]

 

I understand the premise dude lol

 

And I accept the way it looks. If X flips scum I am aware that I have tied myself to him, it happens.

 

That said, his train was building fast and the statement Lily made pinged me. As I said, she shouldn't have issue putting him at L-1 even if he hadn't claimed if she found him scummy. If someone were to come in and hammer afterwards THAT person would be under fire the next phase. So really, her statement came across as a way to nudge along X's train while simultaneously staying off with a safe 'pro-town' play.

Hammer is rarely looked at as hard as the person placing him in hammer range. In my experience

 

Depends on the circumstance I would say. In this situation if X had been hammered without time to reveal I think that person would catch heat, most likely regardless of how X flipped.

[Blackhoof]

Sorry Ishy, all fixed now

[Sedai]

I disagree. 3-5 is sweet spot to get bandwagon started L-1 is getting him on the edge for rush hammer and trying to avoid guilt. Scummiest places to vote

[Andrej]

I'm not sure what you're expressing in that.

 

How well do you know Quibby's meta?