[Basic] Reboot Mafia Game MAFIA WINS

[WWWwombat]

 

Verbal, I am disappoint.

 

Wanna cookie?

 

 

 

 

Love how all these people who haven't made a single meaningful vote are calling me out for switching my votes.  Cowards.

 

It isn't that you've switched your votes - it is the method & context by which you've done so.  It doesn't jive with the rest of your posts recently, and more specifically - you mention me as a top 3 and then never discuss me again.  And now you chide me as if I'm a clueless townie.  I thought I'm a scum pick for you?  Why would you be disappointed, then?

 

 

 

No, I'm chiding you because you're not even bothering to come up with an actual reason for voting me.  I expect better of you even when you're scum.

[WWWwombat]

Dot Matrix, VT.  Have fun explaining your votes tomorrow.

[Kaylee]

 

@TG: Fair enough. You have proven that he likes to claim town in both basic and advanced games. It however still doesn’t disprove my point that you were trying to get him lynched without looking at the situation from an objective point of view. If he were to claim to be town then you wouldn’t have believed him because like you said he does that all the time so it becomes a null tell and it also gets him lynched more often than not, but if he were to try and change his meta then you would have again attacked him for it because he is behaving differently than what you are used to seeing from him. I can only guess what his reasoning was for not claiming to be town in this game, but I do find you suspicious for wanting to get him lynched only because of a change in meta that isn't alignment indicative. It looks to me that you aren’t interested in scumhunting and are only looking for the easiest ways to get rid of players.

 

It isn't true that he never claimed to be town as mafia.

 

 

 

Amega? Really? I’m willing to switch to X if it would make you feel any better about me. I don't care as long as both he and TG are the ones who end up getting lynched.

 

 

The paragraph: This is a reasonable response for the most part.  It does become closer to a null tell with over use.

 

However, as to the next line, find me an example where CS early claimed town when he was scum.  You can't because he never has.  Yes he has claimed town when under pressure and about to get lynched, but never the insta-claim.  Not as scum.

 

Bolded:  You're willing to switch for town cred?  Are you that worried about looking town?

 

Agreed, that looks bad for Cloud.

[Kaylee]

We have 9 hours till deadline. Anyone think we should have a different lynch today? If so who and why?

[Verbal32]

 

 

Verbal, I am disappoint.

 

Wanna cookie?

 

 

 

 

Love how all these people who haven't made a single meaningful vote are calling me out for switching my votes.  Cowards.

 

It isn't that you've switched your votes - it is the method & context by which you've done so.  It doesn't jive with the rest of your posts recently, and more specifically - you mention me as a top 3 and then never discuss me again.  And now you chide me as if I'm a clueless townie.  I thought I'm a scum pick for you?  Why would you be disappointed, then?

 

 

 

No, I'm chiding you because you're not even bothering to come up with an actual reason for voting me.  I expect better of you even when you're scum.

 

 

See, it's this lack of addressing all points that has me thinking you're scum.  You STILL have not addressed my point about having me as a top 3 and then never mentioning it again.  And I provided a reason - a few of them.  You might think they suck, but at least say so.  This defense of yours is horrid and nonexistent.

 

 

 

Dot Matrix, VT.  Have fun explaining your votes tomorrow.

 

More of this noncommittal attitude to your defense, or the game in general.  Almost like mailing it in, which I never see you do.  Methinks you might be trying to shrug it off and maybe it'll go away....but you have to know you're L-2 with a pending deadline.  You are a very likely lynch, and instead of formalizing reads and going down swinging, you post stuff like this.

 

I haz a sad about you, Wombat.

[Verbal32]

We have 9 hours till deadline. Anyone think we should have a different lynch today? If so who and why?

 

I want to give Wombat a chance, but he's making it hard for me.  I might have to vote him to ensure we get a lynch.  How about you? 

[_CLOUD]

The bold was my response, the tongue face was Despo's. Anyway, I was the first the point out the no reasoning for Despo's unvote...

Thanks for proving me wrong. I have indeed missed your comment on Despo’s unvote and I guess it was because you responded inside one of his quotes which made me confused what you actually meant to say there.

 

Bolded: You're willing to switch for town cred? Are you that worried about looking town?

I’m only interested in eliminating the entire mafia team and if it means that I have to work together with someone that I have a town read on then so be it.

[_CLOUD]

Everyone appears to have a completly different reason for his vote on Wombat. His train is a mess.

[Verbal32]

 

The bold was my response, the tongue face was Despo's. Anyway, I was the first the point out the no reasoning for Despo's unvote...

Thanks for proving me wrong. I have indeed missed your comment on Despo’s unvote and I guess it was because you responded inside one of his quotes which made me confused what you actually meant to say there.

 

Bolded: You're willing to switch for town cred? Are you that worried about looking town?

I’m only interested in eliminating the entire mafia team and if it means that I have to work together with someone that I have a town read on then so be it.

 

 

Do you mean this to say "scum"?

[Verbal32]

Everyone appears to have a completly different reason for his vote on Wombat. His train is a mess.

 

I can agree with that.

[_CLOUD]

 

 

The bold was my response, the tongue face was Despo's. Anyway, I was the first the point out the no reasoning for Despo's unvote...

Thanks for proving me wrong. I have indeed missed your comment on Despo’s unvote and I guess it was because you responded inside one of his quotes which made me confused what you actually meant to say there.

 

Bolded: You're willing to switch for town cred? Are you that worried about looking town?

I’m only interested in eliminating the entire mafia team and if it means that I have to work together with someone that I have a town read on then so be it.

 

 

Do you mean this to say "scum"?

 

 

No, what I meant with that is I'm fine with proving that I'm town to someone who I think is town so that we can go after a shared scum read.

[Verbal32]

Oh, ok.  The "so be it" is usually a saying to convey settling for something, and I would think working with another townie would be a goal - not a settling for kinda thing.

 

You and I seem to get hung up on semantics lately.

[_CLOUD]

Yeah, I admit that I should have done a better job with explaining what I meant with "working together" in that post.

[Kaylee]

 

 

We have 9 hours till deadline. Anyone think we should have a different lynch today? If so who and why?

I want to give Wombat a chance, but he's making it hard for me. I might have to vote him to ensure we get a lynch. How about you?

Still liking Wombat, but Cloud isn't looking good and I have other suspects. Hally is lurking like she tends to do as scum and her reason for voting Despo was really bad. So if there was a consensus to vote there, with reasons, I'd be willing to look that way.

[Kaylee]

Oh, ok. The "so be it" is usually a saying to convey settling for something, and I would think working with another townie would be a goal - not a settling for kinda thing.

 

You and I seem to get hung up on semantics lately.

Bold: Agreed.

[_CLOUD]

Or, you know, we can actually lynch scum.

 

Just a thought.

[Kaylee]

Which would be? If you don't agree with the Wombat lynch, who would you prefer and why? Give a summary of who you think is likely scum and why. I know you've said so earlier, but give it again now. Part of the problem is not a lot of people appear to be online atm. Perhaps I can be convinced a change in lynch candidates, if the case is strong and makes sense. Of course that also depends on how many other agree and are willing to switch.

[Kaylee]

Or, you know, we can actually lynch scum.

 

Just a thought.

I'm voting for someone I think is scum. 

[Verbal32]

 

 

We have 9 hours till deadline. Anyone think we should have a different lynch today? If so who and why?

I want to give Wombat a chance, but he's making it hard for me. I might have to vote him to ensure we get a lynch. How about you?

Still liking Wombat, but Cloud isn't looking good and I have other suspects. Hally is lurking like she tends to do as scum and her reason for voting Despo was really bad. So if there was a consensus to vote there, with reasons, I'd be willing to look that way.

 

 

Re: Hallia - she is lurky by nature, so that would be null for me

 

Re: reasons for voting her - if you come up with your own that make sense, I'm sure you'll get some traction on a train

[Verbal32]

Which would be? If you don't agree with the Wombat lynch, who would you prefer and why? Give a summary of who you think is likely scum and why. I know you've said so earlier, but give it again now. Part of the problem is not a lot of people appear to be online atm. Perhaps I can be convinced a change in lynch candidates, if the case is strong and makes sense. Of course that also depends on how many other agree and are willing to switch.

 

Also, excessive pushing of casework onto others is a scumtell.  The "who and why" repeated questions?  Also a scumtell.

 

;-)

[Kaylee]

I thought I'd look into her more next day phase. For now I'm happy voting Wombat. As for coming up with my own that makes sense, what doesn't make sense about her vote on Despo with the reason of a pressure vote? It was towards the end of the lynch as well. I know I wasn't the first to point it out, but you don't have to be the first to point something out for it to be correct. Aslo, she's not always lurky by nature. I've seen her active and participate in games. 

[Leelou]

I hate crying babies, and the fact my sister does not seem to know how to clean. I'll be home in about an hour and I'll catch up here then. Promise.

[Kaylee]

 

Which would be? If you don't agree with the Wombat lynch, who would you prefer and why? Give a summary of who you think is likely scum and why. I know you've said so earlier, but give it again now. Part of the problem is not a lot of people appear to be online atm. Perhaps I can be convinced a change in lynch candidates, if the case is strong and makes sense. Of course that also depends on how many other agree and are willing to switch.

 

Also, excessive pushing of casework onto others is a scumtell.  The "who and why" repeated questions?  Also a scumtell.

 

;-)

 

If it gets people talking then I'm fine with that. I want others to pipe in and give reasons why. We have a known scum down and should be using interactions and play to find the rest. I just mean people just coming in towards deadline saying "we need to lynch scum" should be coming up with who they suspect and why so as to try and change people's minds. Otherwise why say anything at all? I want opinions, keeping quiet doesn't help. Neither does just saying someone is scum and not stating why you think so.

[Kaylee]

I hate crying babies, and the fact my sister does not seem to know how to clean. I'll be home in about an hour and I'll catch up here then. Promise.

Look forward to hearing your thoughts.

[Verbal32]

I thought I'd look into her more next day phase. For now I'm happy voting Wombat. As for coming up with my own that makes sense, what doesn't make sense about her vote on Despo with the reason of a pressure vote? It was towards the end of the lynch as well. I know I wasn't the first to point it out, but you don't have to be the first to point something out for it to be correct. Aslo, she's not always lurky by nature. I've seen her active and participate in games. 

 

Hallia is still new to mafia.  She might be using the term "pressure" vote, but not meaning the same thing you might mean with it.  Voting Des was not a bad play, which is obvious.  Was it a bus?  Who knows.  I don't really remember Hallia saying much thus far in this game, so perhaps I've missed something from her.