Clash of Divinity - Advanced Mafia - Day 7 - Reckoning

[dapianoplay3r]

Oh that

Yea nah. I'm not one to hold stuff like that over people. Plus it's a recruitment game. If people change one day to the next I watch out for it

[Tommyrod]

I don't know how to approach lynching people at endgame with the possibility of 2 or even 3 recruiting factions.

I think we have to set wagons and see who picks which side.

[dapianoplay3r]

Thats why i was a fan of dice and i having competing trains today

but new trains could work just as well

[Tommyrod]

Dice quotes Pt 1

 

 

 

waves at laffinboy and votes laffinboy cause he hasn't been around   vote lolguy

 

 

Kindly forward this intro to Rick Riordan so he can see how to integrate mythology into the modern world.  Nice job mods.

 

 

      you didnt just diss the Riordan!!!!   

 

 

Mod if we vote a nickname and its clear who it is will it count?

 

 

lol think thats the first time ive been described as Loud in mafia. 

 

 

in regards to darthe and NKs he DOES seem to get killed N1 or 2 alot. It was even discussed in a mafia QT i was part of once.

 

Regarding no NKS at all   well we DO know its a recruit game but i still think there will be NKs. I think there are multiple teams and each team will want to eliminate the other  hence they need NKs AND lynches

 

 

i think they are talking about GF. GraendalsFriend iircc

 

 

 

 

Couple things:

1- Ley-- RVS is random voting stage. I'm surprised that one is new to you. Your comment @80 is anti-town and is generally a poor way to play. Interact and try and see how people react to your posts. You get information everywhere. Advocating remaining silent doesn't help anyone get more info. Info is the purpose of the game.

 

Don't twist my words. All I said, was that I wasn't going to post if (and only IF) there was nothing to reply to for me, I didn't say I wasn't going to post:

 

 

@Ley

 

what you seem to be saying here is that unless people are talking at or about you, you are not going to participate?  or are you meaning that you will only post when you only have something you want to comment on? please clarify

 

 

 

 

 

Reposting this for clarity. I just realized my question to Ley was in the text box. will fix

 

 

Couple things:

1- Ley-- RVS is random voting stage. I'm surprised that one is new to you. Your comment @80 is anti-town and is generally a poor way to play. Interact and try and see how people react to your posts. You get information everywhere. Advocating remaining silent doesn't help anyone get more info. Info is the purpose of the game.

 

Don't twist my words. All I said, was that I wasn't going to post if (and only IF) there was nothing to reply to for me, I didn't say I wasn't going to post:

 

 

 

 

 

 

@Ley

 

what you seem to be saying here is that unless people are talking at or about you, you are not going to participate?  or are you meaning that you will only post when you only have something you want to comment on? please clarify

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Alright, so now that it seems we'll have some active posters I'll put some stuff out for you guys to chew on.
  so from the get go you are associating activity with info. Something I agree with but thought I'd point it out

1. Turin - Agree in general with Darthe's meta summation. Accept his argument IRT early set-up spec. but the reasoning is also an easy one to place a vote for. Null, leaning scum.
  so the guy disagreeing with you is now null to scummy (easy to back out from)
Similar to me no? Guy disagrees and votes you so you go after them

2. Chaelca (Mentored by Csarmi) - Prob newbtown. Needs to get coached up a bit/post more as advised by other players. Newbtown feel comes from the early sheeping. I have the feeling if scum her partners would've given some kind of pre-emptive advice as the game started.
 cool whatevs

4. Darthe - Leaning town as previously stated. Would still like to see more participation/opinions.
 so one of the posters leaning town, but you wanna see more.
Yea that's not a cliché, run of the mill thing to say in mafia at all

5. TheRagnarok - Leaning town for general attitude. Vote on GF feels legitimate considering GF's posts in-game and that Rag wouldn't necessarily be aware the serial-lurking is GF's typical meta.
  So Turin got a scum to null lean for an easy vote, but rags is ok.


6. WBK - Mostly null/possible scum. I think by now he might've posted more as I think he tends to pick up on inconsistencies rather early. Could be trying to law low.
  so the other null to scum is a low poster in your eyes

7. GF - Serial lurker. Would be fine lynching unless he picks up his gameplay.
  cool. Another low poster is a low town read. Seeing a pattern yet? Cos I do and I like patterns. Strange that the one that disagrees is the issue in the pattern

8. Hallia - A little too jokey for my liking. Typical as far as meta goes, but would like to see more.
  that's weird. No read

9. Dap - Town lean for the secondary vote. Would like some original thoughts.
  secondary vote? Buddying just a tad? Who else is doing that? Oh yea!


10. Chuckles - Nullish. Sort of typical play thus far for him from what I remember.
  nullish. How noncommittal can you be

12. Ley - OP felt a bit forced. I sort of inherently read his posts as scummy though, so I will reserve judgement for now.

13. Golden - Oddly quiet. 1 post so far, would like to see more before making a definitive statement.
 no read and also no talk seems to feel like scummy reading your posts

15 Dice - Seems somewhat engaged, leaning town.
  Engaged means posting. That seems to mean town
 

You feel me?


Edit for reply
It doesn't matter if you pointed it out or not. When I'm mafia I call my team out all the time. The point is he didn't. You actually agree he didn't.

 

 

 

Yes, I agree that he didn't. I'm also saying he hasn't commented on ANYTHING in general. No original ideas, no personal commentary or reads. Basically nothing. You continue to push this angle that since he didn't talk about me specifically that it means something. You are reaching. I suggest you re-read. I think the only other person to weigh in on it is GE. Does that mean I'm teammates with all those other players too? Now you are also linking him with me by saying that we are both buddying you. For one, get over yourself lol. Secondly, your insistence that he and I must be working together coupled with your commentary on there being a mafia team and your discomfort of him seeming attached to you on thread is starting to look like a distancing act. I do find it odd that you continue to bring up the fact that you think he will recruit you. Are you placing me with Chuckles in the hopes that if/when he gets lynched (and shows scum) that I will be next due to some contrived associative tell? C'mon bro... if that's your play here it's terribly transparent.

 

Okay, so for the blue comments now.

 

Turin: I have already explained this read. Also, when did I go after him? We have discussed on thread, sure, but I wouldn't regard that as attacking. Naturally I'm going to question those who vote me. It's called conf-bias. I know that I am town, so when I am attacked I feel like it is natural to be suspicious.

 

Darthe: I provided commentary on my town read for him in another post, so no, it wasn't just about him posting at the time. Are you even reading the thread?

 

Rag: I also felt like I explained this one pretty well. Sure, GF could be considered an easy vote. I also state that I don't find it suspect because Rags wouldn't necessarily know that about GF and his playstyle.

 

GF: Never said he was a town read. And sure, patterns are cool. It suggests consistency. Now ask yourself... which alignment typically is inconsistent?

 

Hallia: Too jokey for my liking should suggest a negative outlook.

 

You: Already touched on the linking comment.

 

Chuckles: Noncommittal shouldn't be a word that is applied here considering this was put out when like half the game had under ~5 posts. Are you having such an easy time bashing my list because perhaps you already know where I am right or wrong?

 

GE: I have liked his posts since this list was made. At the time he really only did have 1 post, which is odd. He is typically pretty active.

 

Now, since you've had such a hay-day with my list, I'd love to see one from you Dap.

 

i notice i was left off this list.

 

Blue  So why didnt you say this the first time?  unvote just in case vote AJ

 

 

 

@darthe  if you play at 7 places is there a trick you use to keep them straight in your head? I have been know to mix up games when only playing 3 on one site lol

 

 

 

 

i notice i was left off this list.

 

Blue  So why didnt you say this the first time?  unvote just in case vote AJ

 

Bold: You were on my original list of players. Here. The post you quoted was me responding to some of Dap's comments.

 

Blue: It was said the first time. Click the link. I literally say 'Hallia - Too jokey for my liking'. This should suggest that I am unhappy with her play thus far. Is the phrase just confusing or something? I think perhaps, since you and Dap have both pointed this out, that it's not a common one where you guys are from?

 

So, now that I've proven that it was stated the first time, I'd like you to explain your vote. Why would you feel that it was warranted even if I hadn't stated it originally?

 

 

i know i was on the first list, thats why i said THIS list.

 

"too jokey for my liking just says you dont like how she is joking around all the time. it gives NO indication of which way you are leaning re is she town or mafia. your second answer does. My vote is that the way you dealt with that and the way you rather ambigously gave that first answer makes me think you are mafia. And that Hally is a teammate that you felt you had to write something about but didnt have enough gameplay to come up with anything else

 

 

 

because of your backflip AJ.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

[TheRagnarok]

Ok, it's been a long day.  I'm not a mirror or anything else.  Straight up nilla town.

 

And here's my question for Darthe...what was this supposed result?  You have nothing.  You've given nothing.  All you've done is claim to have some mythical result. 

 

And the fact that the people who also voted for me have seemingly NO interest in getting anymore info before deciding is either sad or scummy.

[Tommyrod]

Dice quotes Pt 2

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

because of your backflip AJ.

 

What backflip? It's clearly implied in my original post that I am viewing her play negatively.

 

 

Considering 2 people have asked about it would seem to make the argument that it is NOT clearly implied

 

 

 

wonderful. a train that didnt seem to really be going to result in a lynch outs the doc. Well done.

 

 

im here for another 2 hrs but i probably wont be for deadline. its 3 40am my time. Im quite happy where my vote is

 

 

 

im here for another 2 hrs but i probably wont be for deadline. its 3 40am my time. Im quite happy where my vote is

im here for another 2 hrs but i probably wont be for deadline. its 3 40am my time. Im quite happy where my vote is

Everyone go back and look at Dice's reason to vote me after I flip town and try to figure out for yourself what he is quite happy about.

 

 

 

im quite happy because i think you are mafia

 

 

nice scene mod!

 

 

 

turin   nothing mock about it  i think thats 3 out of the last 4 games ive played where either the cop or the doc have had to claim day 1

 

 

 

 

 

 

wonderful. a train that didnt seem to really be going to result in a lynch outs the doc. Well done.

Fake post

 

 

 

did you see my response to turin about this? Ive just been off mafia for a bit   like a month or so but just before that i played  2 or 3  i think it was three games in a row where the Doc or Cop was forced to claim D1   and i have blown up about it before in those games. Dont believe me?  the only one i really rember was LEY  and thats cause he was the first one. he was cop iirc

 

 

 

 

im here for another 2 hrs but i probably wont be for deadline. its 3 40am my time. Im quite happy where my vote is

Scum detected

Dap/dice wagons today; load 'em up

Not sure if Darthe is scum or just Darthe

I would guess he's an indie god or something lol

 

 

You need a new decector bro cause at best you got 1 outta 2 here cause i aint a baddie

 

This is a recruit game and thus is Advanced.

 
1. Turin: meme maker- 
2. Chaelca (Mentored by Csarmi): First game but has a mentor. There are an amazing amount of noob things being put on thread. It looks like trying to hide by looking noobish.(I can't possibly be mafia as I don't know what is going on) leaning mafia.
3. Andrej - Manmohan Singh - Vanilla Town -[/size] Lynched Day 1
4. Darthe:(claims some sort of info role) I had impression from Darthe that he was saying that he would be able to help town as long as he was kept around a few days. He sort of reiterated that with one of his recent posts. Now is claiming some info on Rags. He is either truly roled up town or faking mafia IMO. Darthe loves his fake claims so waiting to see what Rags response is.
5. TheRagnarok:(claimed unkillable independent-think that is a joke) Stated what I think of his case on me. I can see his possible town motivation somewhat as I was the main person advocating AJ lynch. He is acting very stubborn about what appears to be a weak case. Waiting to see what happens in his response to Darthe's allegations.
6. WBK Ley 2.0: Not really enough to go off or ATM. Kronos wasn't very active. In fairness tho he said he was away and then in an accident so... waiting to see what Ley has to contribute and if his play matches his earlier town play.
7. GF:(claimed Doc) not cc'ed at this point. So putting him in the town column. would like less ambiguous/haiku style posting however.

 

8. Hallia: overly jokey IMO and also quite defensive when mentioned in reference to a previous game in which she was mafia. The promised reads never materialized in my opinion. things promised and not delivered ping mightily with me. I think she is mafia.

 

9. Dap: Is all over the place. I liked his response to Tommy re: the shooting and also could see how some of what chuckles did was pingy. I didn't agree with the linking between AJ and chuckles. Dap does a lot of crazy things and likes to change his look frequently. He is currently null to me.
10. Chuckles Tommy(claimed 1x day vig): As mentioned earlier, Chuckles I had as possible mafia. Tommy has been very active and seems to be working toward keeping the conversation going. The little bit of setup has been not unreasonable, if not to my taste. moving him towards town. not there yet tho due to the confirmed town list.
12. Ley - David Cameron - Vanilla Town - Killed Night 1
13. Golden: Not as active in this game as I expected. Might be due to extreme activity elsewhere. I didn't like the way he seemed to point at me and then back off. he is in the second tier of suspects tho
15 Dice: Outrage posts really ping with me. And his explanation about it didn't ease my concerns. His following onto AJ in the manner he did seemed a bit weird. When AJ flipped town Dice moved waay up my list of mafia suspects.

 

So my top 3 are Hallia, Dice and Chaelca. In that order. Rags/Darthe  interaction will likely yield a mafia one way or the other.

 

 

Vote Hallia

 

 

Funny. that highlighted bit was what made me sus of AJ. You never spoke up in agreement with his saying it yet now you use it.

 

 

 

Tommy Darthe was talking to you about my meta. Well when you quoted all my stuff you proved what he was saying. I dont go aggressive as mafia. I know this. im trying to fix it but i haven't been mafia for a while now.

 

 

Are you a man of your word tommy? cause if so i will make you a deal. 

 

and trust me you dont wanna shoot me.

 

 

In case tommy doesnt agree  Vote Turin

 

 

well im off to bed  see yas in about 8hrs

 

 

my deaql tommy is you shoot Turin. If he doesnt flip as a bad guy or gets janitored then i will be quite happy to help you lynch me.

 

 

do we have an agreement?

 

 

 

my deaql tommy is you shoot Turin. If he doesnt flip as a bad guy or gets janitored then i will be quite happy to help you lynch me.

Explain your case on Turin please

 

 

 

sigh

 

 

as far as ley goes i just went thru his posts   theres not much substantial there. but i do note that he was leaning scum on guess who??  

 

Turin.

 

 

i have to go to work

 

 

 

 

 

[Tommyrod]

Dice quotes Pt 1

 

 

 

waves at laffinboy and votes laffinboy cause he hasn't been around   vote lolguy

 

 

Kindly forward this intro to Rick Riordan so he can see how to integrate mythology into the modern world.  Nice job mods.

 

 

      you didnt just diss the Riordan!!!!   

 

 

Mod if we vote a nickname and its clear who it is will it count?

 

 

lol think thats the first time ive been described as Loud in mafia. 

 

 

in regards to darthe and NKs he DOES seem to get killed N1 or 2 alot. It was even discussed in a mafia QT i was part of once.

 

Regarding no NKS at all   well we DO know its a recruit game but i still think there will be NKs. I think there are multiple teams and each team will want to eliminate the other  hence they need NKs AND lynches

 

 

i think they are talking about GF. GraendalsFriend iircc

 

 

 

 

Couple things:

1- Ley-- RVS is random voting stage. I'm surprised that one is new to you. Your comment @80 is anti-town and is generally a poor way to play. Interact and try and see how people react to your posts. You get information everywhere. Advocating remaining silent doesn't help anyone get more info. Info is the purpose of the game.

 

Don't twist my words. All I said, was that I wasn't going to post if (and only IF) there was nothing to reply to for me, I didn't say I wasn't going to post:

 

 

@Ley

 

what you seem to be saying here is that unless people are talking at or about you, you are not going to participate?  or are you meaning that you will only post when you only have something you want to comment on? please clarify

 

 

 

 

 

Reposting this for clarity. I just realized my question to Ley was in the text box. will fix

 

 

Couple things:

1- Ley-- RVS is random voting stage. I'm surprised that one is new to you. Your comment @80 is anti-town and is generally a poor way to play. Interact and try and see how people react to your posts. You get information everywhere. Advocating remaining silent doesn't help anyone get more info. Info is the purpose of the game.

 

Don't twist my words. All I said, was that I wasn't going to post if (and only IF) there was nothing to reply to for me, I didn't say I wasn't going to post:

 

 

 

 

 

 

@Ley

 

what you seem to be saying here is that unless people are talking at or about you, you are not going to participate?  or are you meaning that you will only post when you only have something you want to comment on? please clarify

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Alright, so now that it seems we'll have some active posters I'll put some stuff out for you guys to chew on.

  so from the get go you are associating activity with info. Something I agree with but thought I'd point it out

 

1. Turin - Agree in general with Darthe's meta summation. Accept his argument IRT early set-up spec. but the reasoning is also an easy one to place a vote for. Null, leaning scum.

  so the guy disagreeing with you is now null to scummy (easy to back out from)

Similar to me no? Guy disagrees and votes you so you go after them

 

2. Chaelca (Mentored by Csarmi) - Prob newbtown. Needs to get coached up a bit/post more as advised by other players. Newbtown feel comes from the early sheeping. I have the feeling if scum her partners would've given some kind of pre-emptive advice as the game started.

 cool whatevs

 

4. Darthe - Leaning town as previously stated. Would still like to see more participation/opinions.

 so one of the posters leaning town, but you wanna see more.

Yea that's not a cliché, run of the mill thing to say in mafia at all

 

5. TheRagnarok - Leaning town for general attitude. Vote on GF feels legitimate considering GF's posts in-game and that Rag wouldn't necessarily be aware the serial-lurking is GF's typical meta.

  So Turin got a scum to null lean for an easy vote, but rags is ok.

 

 

6. WBK - Mostly null/possible scum. I think by now he might've posted more as I think he tends to pick up on inconsistencies rather early. Could be trying to law low.

  so the other null to scum is a low poster in your eyes

 

7. GF - Serial lurker. Would be fine lynching unless he picks up his gameplay.

  cool. Another low poster is a low town read. Seeing a pattern yet? Cos I do and I like patterns. Strange that the one that disagrees is the issue in the pattern

 

8. Hallia - A little too jokey for my liking. Typical as far as meta goes, but would like to see more.

  that's weird. No read

 

9. Dap - Town lean for the secondary vote. Would like some original thoughts.

  secondary vote? Buddying just a tad? Who else is doing that? Oh yea!

 

 

10. Chuckles - Nullish. Sort of typical play thus far for him from what I remember.

  nullish. How noncommittal can you be

 

12. Ley - OP felt a bit forced. I sort of inherently read his posts as scummy though, so I will reserve judgement for now.

 

13. Golden - Oddly quiet. 1 post so far, would like to see more before making a definitive statement.

 no read and also no talk seems to feel like scummy reading your posts

 

15 Dice - Seems somewhat engaged, leaning town.

  Engaged means posting. That seems to mean town

 

You feel me?

 

 

Edit for reply

It doesn't matter if you pointed it out or not. When I'm mafia I call my team out all the time. The point is he didn't. You actually agree he didn't.

 

 

 

Yes, I agree that he didn't. I'm also saying he hasn't commented on ANYTHING in general. No original ideas, no personal commentary or reads. Basically nothing. You continue to push this angle that since he didn't talk about me specifically that it means something. You are reaching. I suggest you re-read. I think the only other person to weigh in on it is GE. Does that mean I'm teammates with all those other players too? Now you are also linking him with me by saying that we are both buddying you. For one, get over yourself lol. Secondly, your insistence that he and I must be working together coupled with your commentary on there being a mafia team and your discomfort of him seeming attached to you on thread is starting to look like a distancing act. I do find it odd that you continue to bring up the fact that you think he will recruit you. Are you placing me with Chuckles in the hopes that if/when he gets lynched (and shows scum) that I will be next due to some contrived associative tell? C'mon bro... if that's your play here it's terribly transparent.

 

Okay, so for the blue comments now.

 

Turin: I have already explained this read. Also, when did I go after him? We have discussed on thread, sure, but I wouldn't regard that as attacking. Naturally I'm going to question those who vote me. It's called conf-bias. I know that I am town, so when I am attacked I feel like it is natural to be suspicious.

 

Darthe: I provided commentary on my town read for him in another post, so no, it wasn't just about him posting at the time. Are you even reading the thread?

 

Rag: I also felt like I explained this one pretty well. Sure, GF could be considered an easy vote. I also state that I don't find it suspect because Rags wouldn't necessarily know that about GF and his playstyle.

 

GF: Never said he was a town read. And sure, patterns are cool. It suggests consistency. Now ask yourself... which alignment typically is inconsistent?

 

Hallia: Too jokey for my liking should suggest a negative outlook.

 

You: Already touched on the linking comment.

 

Chuckles: Noncommittal shouldn't be a word that is applied here considering this was put out when like half the game had under ~5 posts. Are you having such an easy time bashing my list because perhaps you already know where I am right or wrong?

 

GE: I have liked his posts since this list was made. At the time he really only did have 1 post, which is odd. He is typically pretty active.

 

Now, since you've had such a hay-day with my list, I'd love to see one from you Dap.

 

i notice i was left off this list.

 

Blue  So why didnt you say this the first time?  unvote just in case vote AJ

 

 

 

@darthe  if you play at 7 places is there a trick you use to keep them straight in your head? I have been know to mix up games when only playing 3 on one site lol

 

 

 

 

i notice i was left off this list.

 

Blue  So why didnt you say this the first time?  unvote just in case vote AJ

 

Bold: You were on my original list of players. Here. The post you quoted was me responding to some of Dap's comments.

 

Blue: It was said the first time. Click the link. I literally say 'Hallia - Too jokey for my liking'. This should suggest that I am unhappy with her play thus far. Is the phrase just confusing or something? I think perhaps, since you and Dap have both pointed this out, that it's not a common one where you guys are from?

 

So, now that I've proven that it was stated the first time, I'd like you to explain your vote. Why would you feel that it was warranted even if I hadn't stated it originally?

 

 

i know i was on the first list, thats why i said THIS list.

 

"too jokey for my liking just says you dont like how she is joking around all the time. it gives NO indication of which way you are leaning re is she town or mafia. your second answer does. My vote is that the way you dealt with that and the way you rather ambigously gave that first answer makes me think you are mafia. And that Hally is a teammate that you felt you had to write something about but didnt have enough gameplay to come up with anything else

 

 

 

because of your backflip AJ.

 

 

 

So looking at this, he's managed to say absolutely nothing, yet voted for AJ due to nonsense reasoning ("you were ambiguous and then backflipped!")

 

Do I really have to point out why this is obviously scum behavior? He's exerting the absolutely bare minimum required to be in the thread.

[Tommyrod]

 

Dice quotes Pt 2

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

because of your backflip AJ.

 

What backflip? It's clearly implied in my original post that I am viewing her play negatively.

 

 

Considering 2 people have asked about it would seem to make the argument that it is NOT clearly implied

 

 

 

wonderful. a train that didnt seem to really be going to result in a lynch outs the doc. Well done.

 

 

im here for another 2 hrs but i probably wont be for deadline. its 3 40am my time. Im quite happy where my vote is

 

 

 

im here for another 2 hrs but i probably wont be for deadline. its 3 40am my time. Im quite happy where my vote is

im here for another 2 hrs but i probably wont be for deadline. its 3 40am my time. Im quite happy where my vote is

Everyone go back and look at Dice's reason to vote me after I flip town and try to figure out for yourself what he is quite happy about.

 

 

 

im quite happy because i think you are mafia

 

 

nice scene mod!

 

 

 

turin   nothing mock about it  i think thats 3 out of the last 4 games ive played where either the cop or the doc have had to claim day 1

 

 

 

 

 

 

wonderful. a train that didnt seem to really be going to result in a lynch outs the doc. Well done.

Fake post

 

 

 

did you see my response to turin about this? Ive just been off mafia for a bit   like a month or so but just before that i played  2 or 3  i think it was three games in a row where the Doc or Cop was forced to claim D1   and i have blown up about it before in those games. Dont believe me?  the only one i really rember was LEY  and thats cause he was the first one. he was cop iirc

 

 

 

 

im here for another 2 hrs but i probably wont be for deadline. its 3 40am my time. Im quite happy where my vote is

Scum detected

 

Dap/dice wagons today; load 'em up

 

Not sure if Darthe is scum or just Darthe

 

I would guess he's an indie god or something lol

 

 

You need a new decector bro cause at best you got 1 outta 2 here cause i aint a baddie

 

This is a recruit game and thus is Advanced.

 

1. Turin: meme maker- 

2. Chaelca (Mentored by Csarmi): First game but has a mentor. There are an amazing amount of noob things being put on thread. It looks like trying to hide by looking noobish.(I can't possibly be mafia as I don't know what is going on) leaning mafia.

3. Andrej - Manmohan Singh - Vanilla Town -[/size] Lynched Day 1

4. Darthe:(claims some sort of info role) I had impression from Darthe that he was saying that he would be able to help town as long as he was kept around a few days. He sort of reiterated that with one of his recent posts. Now is claiming some info on Rags. He is either truly roled up town or faking mafia IMO. Darthe loves his fake claims so waiting to see what Rags response is.

5. TheRagnarok:(claimed unkillable independent-think that is a joke) Stated what I think of his case on me. I can see his possible town motivation somewhat as I was the main person advocating AJ lynch. He is acting very stubborn about what appears to be a weak case. Waiting to see what happens in his response to Darthe's allegations.

6. WBK Ley 2.0: Not really enough to go off or ATM. Kronos wasn't very active. In fairness tho he said he was away and then in an accident so... waiting to see what Ley has to contribute and if his play matches his earlier town play.

7. GF:(claimed Doc) not cc'ed at this point. So putting him in the town column. would like less ambiguous/haiku style posting however.

 

8. Hallia: overly jokey IMO and also quite defensive when mentioned in reference to a previous game in which she was mafia. The promised reads never materialized in my opinion. things promised and not delivered ping mightily with me. I think she is mafia.

 

9. Dap: Is all over the place. I liked his response to Tommy re: the shooting and also could see how some of what chuckles did was pingy. I didn't agree with the linking between AJ and chuckles. Dap does a lot of crazy things and likes to change his look frequently. He is currently null to me.

10. Chuckles Tommy(claimed 1x day vig): As mentioned earlier, Chuckles I had as possible mafia. Tommy has been very active and seems to be working toward keeping the conversation going. The little bit of setup has been not unreasonable, if not to my taste. moving him towards town. not there yet tho due to the confirmed town list.

12. Ley - David Cameron - Vanilla Town - Killed Night 1

13. Golden: Not as active in this game as I expected. Might be due to extreme activity elsewhere. I didn't like the way he seemed to point at me and then back off. he is in the second tier of suspects tho

15 Dice: Outrage posts really ping with me. And his explanation about it didn't ease my concerns. His following onto AJ in the manner he did seemed a bit weird. When AJ flipped town Dice moved waay up my list of mafia suspects.

 

So my top 3 are Hallia, Dice and Chaelca. In that order. Rags/Darthe  interaction will likely yield a mafia one way or the other.

 

 

Vote Hallia

 

 

Funny. that highlighted bit was what made me sus of AJ. You never spoke up in agreement with his saying it yet now you use it.

 

 

 

Tommy Darthe was talking to you about my meta. Well when you quoted all my stuff you proved what he was saying. I dont go aggressive as mafia. I know this. im trying to fix it but i haven't been mafia for a while now.

 

 

Are you a man of your word tommy? cause if so i will make you a deal. 

 

and trust me you dont wanna shoot me.

 

 

In case tommy doesnt agree  Vote Turin

 

 

well im off to bed  see yas in about 8hrs

 

 

my deaql tommy is you shoot Turin. If he doesnt flip as a bad guy or gets janitored then i will be quite happy to help you lynch me.

 

 

do we have an agreement?

 

 

 

my deaql tommy is you shoot Turin. If he doesnt flip as a bad guy or gets janitored then i will be quite happy to help you lynch me.

Explain your case on Turin please

 

 

 

sigh

 

 

as far as ley goes i just went thru his posts   theres not much substantial there. but i do note that he was leaning scum on guess who??  

 

Turin.

 

 

i have to go to work

 

 

 

 

 

 

He's got lots of reasons for why he isn't gonna be around, as if we are really gonna miss his stellar contributions. That indicates he's self conscious about how he's seen by town ("I don't want them to think I'm lurking!"). 

 

He has a bunch of fake tone posts, is "convinced" that AJ is mafia, and then never once talks about it again after AJ flips town, lol. I can actually hear him count "one down!" in his head.

 

Then he tells me to shoot Turin, I ask him why, and he just says "sigh" then tries to use Ley as a springboard to get me to kill Turin.

 

lolwut?

 

So he has no actual arguments for why people are scum, and shows no intention to scumhunt.

 

Do I have to state the obvious?

 

He's one of the 3 gods, and Turin may very well be an opposing god, but Dice can't just out and say that.

[Tommyrod]

Just to give you an idea of what to do:

 

Vote Dice

[Tommyrod]

Turin recruited Chaelca N1

Dice recruited Rags N1


Get @ me

[dapianoplay3r]

So do you think the 3rd had the kill?

[Tommyrod]

So do you think the 3rd had the kill?

 

It makes sense to me *shrug*

[dapianoplay3r]

Two recruits feels too steep. If i were yo run it they would all be on one team or have a rolling GF, recruit, and kill

[Tommyrod]

Es possible, but the way the writeups are framed, I imagine they are actually differing factions 

 

Maybe 1 cult

1 regular NK

 

1 something else

I said this before. I'm just guessing though

Let's just vote Dice 

[Turin Turambar]

Tommy, If you are convinced Dice should die why not just shoot him? 

 

 

And I didn't recruit Chaleca, or anyone else.

 

 

Also, way to speculate, lol

 

[dapianoplay3r]

Even if they are different the thing can rotate

[Tommyrod]

Tommy, If you are convinced Dice should die why not just shoot him? 

 

 

And I didn't recruit Chaleca, or anyone else.

 

 

Also, way to speculate, lol

Still waiting on people to actually take stances in this game.

 

We need MOAR INFO.

[Turin Turambar]

Turin recruited Chaelca N1

 

Dice recruited Rags N1

 

 

Get @ me

 

 

Es possible, but the way the writeups are framed, I imagine they are actually differing factions 

 

Maybe 1 cult

 

1 regular NK

 

1 something else

 

I said this before. I'm just guessing though

 

Let's just vote Dice 

That is two fairly different scenarios you painted in the span of 30 minutes. 

[Tommyrod]

That would be because I do not know

[Turin Turambar]

I can agree about the more stances being taken and several people seeming to disappear for stretches. Speaking of which you out there Hallia?

 

Dap, if the abilities were rotating which would you say is the more powerful? kill, recruit, or whatever your third would be? would it be fair to not be able to recruit until night 3 in a recruitment game

[dapianoplay3r]

Recruit is always more powerful. It sways the numbers and gives you like a second chance to win (you die but your minion doesn't you can still win)

Most mods won't hold off recruiting for that long

I'd say roles will balance the recruit

[Turin Turambar]

Recruit is always more powerful. It sways the numbers and gives you like a second chance to win (you die but your minion doesn't you can still win)

Most mods won't hold off recruiting for that long

I'd say roles will balance the recruit

roles, as in the gods themselves? or are you suggesting they had minions to start?

[Tommyrod]

I think he's saying town PRs will balance out the god PRs but iunno

[Turin Turambar]

Oh, I kinda thought he was talking about balance between the separate mafia/cult factions.

[dapianoplay3r]

I think he's saying town PRs will balance out the god PRs but iunno

This

 

But to the gods would balance eachother most likely

 

But I'm guessing they are all in this together cos otherwise you would get far too much back stabbing. If not it would end as a war of the gods by n3 and be biased against the town