[Basic] Christmas Mentors & Maffia

[keyholder21]

I saw it for myself. It's not too far after that one.  But you needed someone else to point it out to you before you said you were wavering.

[_CLOUD]

Nobody's play is perfect. Not even mine

[Tommyrod]

Anybody care to discuss the fact that Hoof hasn't been hammered yet?

Was thinking about this too.

[BFG]

@Key - why vote Krak?

[Tommyrod]

Am I crazy, though? Don't a lot of us agree that Via has been really scummy in this game? Or did that sentiment disappear while I was away?

[_CLOUD]

@Key - why vote Krak?

 

Probably to make me shut up about him.

[keyholder21]

 

Well, you could stop acting like it then :p.

[keyholder21]

 

@Key - why vote Krak?

 

Probably to make me shut up about him.

 

BINGO.

[peacesells]

horrible reasoning.  Vote Hoof...and Cloud is quiet until he submits his nk.

[_CLOUD]

Well, you could stop acting like it then :p.

 

You should blame Darthe's training :P

[BFG]

@Peace - when did Cloud become a suspect of yours?  The only person I can remember mentioning him as a suspect through thread is Krak.

[_CLOUD]

horrible reasoning.  Vote Hoof...and Cloud is quiet until he submits his nk.

 

Lol I haven't yet heard one argument from you why you believe I'm mafia, and yet you are calling other people's reasonings for voting Krak horrible?

[BFG]

Ha

 

For once I am the ninja

[_CLOUD]

@Peace - when did Cloud become a suspect of yours?  The only person I can remember mentioning him as a suspect through thread is Krak.

 

The scum team is starting to get desperate. I can smell their fear. Cast the hammer and end their misery.

[keyholder21]

@peace.

 

I really do want Cloud to shut up about it. I'd also like to see his list of revised reads if Krak does flip town. But that's not my only reasoning. Cloud wishes .

 

I'm not sure I want to vote for either of them. You can see my post a few pages back for that.

 

BFG's bringing back up Krak's post about Turin's being "crap" was a good point. Also, now that I've mulled it over, I don't like his response to me about why leelou was killed. He brought up stuff that was revealed the day after.

 

Both have done scummy things. It's not clear to me who should be lynched.

[Tommyrod]

I feel like I'm talking to myself.

How many of us would lynch Via if we're still really unsure about Krak and Hoof?

*raises hand*

[keyholder21]

@Tommy - kinda about Via, for me.

 

I do see some scumy things - mostly her staying in the periphery - but it reads more to me as an inexperience townie. The rest of us are pretty damn vocal and fairly experienced (save maybe BFG), so I can see how it would be daunting. Not trying to excuse her, but it's making me hesitant.

[Tommyrod]

@Tommy - kinda about Via, for me.

 

I do see some scumy things - mostly her staying in the periphery - but it reads more to me as an inexperience townie. The rest of us are pretty damn vocal and fairly experienced (save maybe BFG), so I can see how it would be daunting. Not trying to excuse her, but it's making me hesitant.

Okay. I am trying to come up with some kind of logical work-around for today's dilemma. I thought that would be it.

[keyholder21]

 

 

Well, you could stop acting like it then :p.

 

You should blame Darthe's training :P

 

Don't blame it on anyone else. It's your choice whether to follow his advice and it's your choice what you say, and how you say it, on thread.

 

 

Edited for weird formatting.

[keyholder21]

 

@Tommy - kinda about Via, for me.

 

I do see some scumy things - mostly her staying in the periphery - but it reads more to me as an inexperience townie. The rest of us are pretty damn vocal and fairly experienced (save maybe BFG), so I can see how it would be daunting. Not trying to excuse her, but it's making me hesitant.

Okay. I am trying to come up with some kind of logical work-around for today's dilemma. I thought that would be it.

 

I understand where you are coming from. I really don't like any of the choices. I guess that means the remaining scum are good at tricking me.

[_CLOUD]

I know, Key I'm not being serious when I act arrogant. I'm just having a little fun with myself while playing a game, that's all.

[_CLOUD]

Besides, you may have noticed that I tried experimenting with a couple of different playstyles in this game. It's an ongoing process until I find a way to play that feels comfortable to me and the other people that I play with.

[Tommyrod]

Well I have to go to sleep.

Between Hoof and Krak I think Hoof is the scummier of the two. I've had some experience with Krak on another forum and he's been more engaged here than he was as town in another game, which makes me think he's more comfortable playing here; the underlying tone behind the Krak in that game and the Krak in this one is the same. Kind of snarky, cocksure in weird ways as if people should just assume he's town and they'd be dumb to lynch him, and trying to solve the game. That colors my reads a bit, but in terms of threadplay, Hoof also has a worse record, IMO. I'll be interested in seeing where you guys land on this while I'm asleep.

[keyholder21]

I know, Key I'm not being serious when I act arrogant. I'm just having a little fun with myself while playing a game, that's all.

Oh I'm just teasing love. No worries here.

[peacesells]

Cloud..i've been null on you for awhile.  But your comments like "when hoof flips town" really have me wondering.  Plus you taking credit for all your town reads being right.   Only scum can pull that off.   You haven't proven a scum read yet.