[Basic] Christmas Mentors & Maffia

[_CLOUD]

 

You mean Peace and Via right? I already had Hallia as a town read at the time.

 

Yo Cloud. No, I meant the discussion you and Via had about Hallia's "vindicated" comment. I thought you were giving Via fuel for the Hallia fire but on second read don't think it really means anything.

 

 

But Peace was the one who had that discussion with Via. You should take a second look at the posts that you quoted there.

[_CLOUD]

 

 

Yeah, I'm fine with either a Cloud of Hoof lynch. Pretty sure both are scum, rated in that order. What has Cloud really done this game other than harp on me and faux scum hunt? Sure he was on Golden's lynch, but I'm not clearing him for that. Looks like he's getting giddy ever since BFG posted his math read and Elf was modkilled.

 

I'm fine with going for Hoof today though. ##Vote Hoof.

 

This actually made me laugh. You did a good job with delaying your OMGUS vote on me for so long.

 

What have I really done this game? Oh I don’t know. I have only been right about most of my town reads so far and I’m pretty confident that I have pegged the remaining mafia members too. You know as much as anyone else here that you weren’t the only person I have harped on so please don't try to act like I have been tunneling on you all game long. It’s also very easy to accuse me of fake scumhunting without providing any sort of proof or reasoning why you think so.

 

 

It's also good to know that Hoof is town.

 

-------------------------

Dude...that was like the opposite of an OMGUS vote. The mere fact that you called it an OMGUS is enough to label you scum. That was a serious slip.

 

-------------------------

 

 

@Hoof - what do you really have on Cloud that's actually beneficial to town?

 

I find it interesting how you said “you” instead of “we” before you mentioned town. A possible scum slip?

 

That's the best you got? It's come to reaching for pronoun slips?

 

When I said 'you' I obviously meant you as in Hoof, which makes 100% sense in the context I used. Now if you had commented on how I said 'town' instead of 'us,' then that would be better, but still a reach.

 

 

I know that the post was in response to Hoof, but the way you asked him what he had on me that is beneficial to the town is what struck me as a possible scum slip. You were argueing that I have been pretty much useless this game, so wouldn't it have made more sense for you to say "what do we really have on Cloud that's actually beneficial to town?" if you wanted to see me lynched?

 

My reasoning for believing that you are mafia isn't only based on this post. It's because you decided to follow me onto Hoof while you just before that had a scum read on me and you didn't bother explaining what made you change your mind. You explained that you had good reason for switching your vote to Hoof, but when I asked you to clarify what that reasoning was you explained that you did it to get reactions from me, Tom, and Turin. I found this a really weak reason to make such a move and I asked you a couple of time what the results were of your reaction test, and after a lot of dodging you reluctantly responded by admitting that you didn't get any results out of it. This was of course obvious to me because what kind of results do you expect to get when you purposefully make a bad move that you know will result in people questioning you? The answer is none because their attacks would be completly justified. We then had a small back and forth which I think made you look only worse in the end. You even ended up changing your story who you were testing by saying that you were curious about Hoof's response towards you instead of mine, Tom's and Turin's. When I called you out for this you replied by saying that it didn't state what I think it states but that I made a nice try. This kind of response isn't in any way pro-town because it shows that you aren't interested in explaining yourself or being helpful, and instead are only trying to force the issue aside by acting condescending. Oh and you also didn't end up voting for any of the main suspects during the end of Day 1.

 

 

*edited because of my bad spelling

[_CLOUD]

Dude...that was like the opposite of an OMGUS vote. The mere fact that you called it an OMGUS is enough to label you scum. That was a serious slip.

 

I almost didn´t see this because you posted this in my quote. You are right that it isn´t really an OMGUS vote, but last night when I wrote that post I couldn´t think about a better word for it. The reason why I find your sudden suspicion about me scummy is because you had me as a null read until now. I was chasing you for the majority of the game and yet you never said that I was outright scummy, but now that there are less players alive I´m suddenly the most obvious scum candidate for you. The reasoning that you used to explain why I have been scummy is also ridiculous. You claim that I haven´t done anything in this game, that I have been fake scumhunting and that I have started acting giddy recently. I actually found your arguments this game although scummy at times to be reasonable for the most part, but this has completly changed at the start of this Day as you started using all these unfounded accusations against me.

[_CLOUD]

Hoof will flip town. I´m calling it now. Those of you who are actually interested in achieving a town victory should vote for Krak.

[csarmi]

Vote Count 3.5

 

Krak (3) - Hoof, Cloud, Nolder

Hoof (3) - Peace, Tommy, Krak

 

Not Voting: Key, BFG, Via

5 to lynch.

 

DL will be 10PM PST on Monday, January 13.

 

 

It's day 3. 

Deadline: 2013-01-14, 06:00GMT

Timer: End of Day-3

[csarmi]

A little more than 14h left.

[_CLOUD]

Where is everyone?

[csarmi]

I'm in the basement

You're in the sky

I'm in the basement - baby, drop on by.

[Krakalakachkn]

I'm at work but it's looking like a slow day.

[csarmi]

I'm home from work early, feeling really unwell. My neck hurts more than usual.

I don't think I'll be around to give votecounts but AJ should be. Hammer rules apply.

[Tommyrod]

Why have three people still not voted? I believe this phase ends today.

 

Feel better, Salami.

[Tommyrod]

Game is dying

[Krakalakachkn]

I can't do much more at the moment. I'm not self-voting.

[Tommyrod]

How selfish.

 

Cloud, you reallllllllly think there's zero chance Hoof is mafia??

[_CLOUD]

Of course not. I just find it very unlikely after the happenings of this Day.

[Tommyrod]

Haha if you said yes I was about to bonk you upside the head.

 

I think this is now the longest running game I have ever been in, in terms of real life days.

[keyholder21]

Sorry guys.  Had to actually do some work this morning.  I'm about to go to lunch with a coworker, but then I should be here after that.

[keyholder21]

I'm not voting because I still don't know who I want to vote for.

[_CLOUD]

Haha if you said yes I was about to bonk you upside the head.

 

I think this is now the longest running game I have ever been in, in terms of real life days.

 

 

I think this is the longest time I have been alive without anyone having any serious suspicion about me

[peacesells]

Hoof will flip town. I´m calling it now. Those of you who are actually interested in achieving a town victory should vote for Krak.

 

It's statements like this that make you look really scummy. 

[_CLOUD]

:/

[keyholder21]

Agreed with peace about that Cloud. FTR, I think it makes darthe look scummy too, but apparently he's "allowed" it because it's his meta.

 

 

I have a hesitation with voting either of them, tbh. I obviously will if we need it, but wanted to let people know.

 

Krak looked less scummy to me upon reread. I think he's made some good points, but doesn't make many elaborate posts so they are overlooked.

 

Hoof ALWAYS seems scummy to me, which messes with me. I'm also afraid that if I don't vote him, I'll want to look at him again tomorrow.

 

 

Also I partially want Via to vote before I do because votes are what matter and I'd like to see her take a stance.

[_CLOUD]

H8U both >.>

[keyholder21]

You wound me sir!

[keyholder21]

Krak & Hoof, care to explain to me why I shouldn't vote for you?