[Basic] The Circle Mafia - Game over

[Darthe]

Back to the fun?

 

Hey Key, I think you're town. What did you think of Kaylees reactions in the last few pages? I found them to be poor and my forming rhoughts on her are becoming quickly escalated by how universally ignored those reactions are.

[Darthe]

Bold: I deally love methodical scumhunting. D1 was weak. Recent reactions look promising.

 

Underlined: He has done nothing to change that read except abuse it a bit but then, what townie doesn't?

[keyholder21]

I'm getting to looking at Kaylee's recent stuff.  Just responding to the stuff I can easily respond to before the analyzation, if that makes sense.

 

Bold:  Okay, I follow.

 

Underlined:  Not sure I feel the same way, but wanted to go back and look at his posts anyway.

[Tommyrod]

Pages 1 and 2: purely tone read of town on Ishmael and Aida, sketchy read on Trickster, null/sketch on Slappa and Blueberry

Null everyone else. Lets see how this develops 

[Tommyrod]

So self-preservation is your primary goal in the game? Got it.

 

 

Vote Aidanna

 

Literally just for this I would lynchthis dude and not lose sleep over it

[Tommyrod]

 

True. Has everyone checked in?

I have. So the game is already a huge success.

 

 

This fellow is good to go already lol 

[Tommyrod]

Just checked.  Yes, everyone has checked in.

 

I thought much the same Kaylee - it's so quiet!!! 

 

If by chance it does pick up, I have to take my oldest to the dentist for a check-up today, so after this I may get quiet for little. I can't check mafia from my phone because I will make a mistake or something and I don't want to get killed because of my phone...

 

See you later guys!

 

I don't find it weird that Aidanna wants us to know that she won't be around but I do find the bolded interesting.  Why would you be afraid to make a mistake and get killed?  Especially day one?  

 

This is like a 19 ft long reach

[Tommyrod]

 

Just checked.  Yes, everyone has checked in.

 

I thought much the same Kaylee - it's so quiet!!! 

 

If by chance it does pick up, I have to take my oldest to the dentist for a check-up today, so after this I may get quiet for little. I can't check mafia from my phone because I will make a mistake or something and I don't want to get killed because of my phone...

 

See you later guys!

 

I don't find it weird that Aidanna wants us to know that she won't be around but I do find the bolded interesting.  Why would you be afraid to make a mistake and get killed?  Especially day one?  

 

Because she allegedly "accidentally" edited a post when using her phone and Wheel told her she would give her 1 warning and then modkill if it happens again.

 

Come on, that's just lazy scum hunting, there's only 3 pages to read to see what she meant.

 

 

Okay at least I agree with this guy now

[Tommyrod]

 

My point to you was before she made that point, three may be something to it, maybe not.

 

Your vote was about self preservation, not her being afraid of making a mistake. One's about her looking bad (mistake) yours about her wanting to stay alive.

 

They are one and the same. She is afraid of making a mistake that is going to get her killed. You are arguing semantics right now.

 

 

Unvote. Vote Kaylee

 

 

I looked at OP again and I replaced Aida so I know Kaylee isn't a wolf/wolf thing since I'm town

 

It could be wolf protecting village but we'll see 

[Tommyrod]

Cloud - Not caring how your play comes across is very unhelpful as town.  

 

Golden - No worries.

 

Luci - You can ask Darthe for an explanation, but don't expect a real answer.  

 

Kaylee - you're starting out fairly aggressive.  Fair point on Golden possibly defending Aidanna, but your jumping on him without reading the entire thread seems opportunistic. 

 

Hey Darthe what level player is this guy at? He still new?

[John E. Kelley]

 

Cloud - Not caring how your play comes across is very unhelpful as town.  

 

Golden - No worries.

 

Luci - You can ask Darthe for an explanation, but don't expect a real answer.  

 

Kaylee - you're starting out fairly aggressive.  Fair point on Golden possibly defending Aidanna, but your jumping on him without reading the entire thread seems opportunistic.

 

 

Hey Darthe what level player is this guy at? He still new?

I'm not Darthe, my penis is much larger, but I can answer this.

 

Key is very experienced, very good, and very hot.

[John E. Kelley]

And a chick, I should probably have made that distinction.

[Darthe]

Oye, comparing that pencil tree of a wang to my well proportioned and vastly more enjoyable self seems a bit unfair.

[Tommyrod]

Luciena seems fake 

 

Key/Cheesecake is probably biggest scum read by page 5

 

I don't trust Kaylee for some reason

 

Yeah I know it's vague, I'm running on 0 cylinders, pretty damn tired

 

Vote Key

[Darthe]

And yes Key has played for a long time.

[Tommyrod]

I still don't like Key by end of page 8

I wouldn't lose sleep over a hallucination lynch

peace's "there's no GF this game" comment strikes me as more mafia than town since I didn't bother to take the time to read all of those setup options and I assume all wolves would

 

I see the Kaylee wagon has gone fairly smoothly, with Key being the most recent jumper at end of page 8

[Tommyrod]

I do not see Kaylee's playing as suspicious, she has played the same as in the other game we were together in. She might come off as aggressive but that doesn't necessarily mean she is mafia. It's just how she is. I could say the same thing about Cloud's analysing every word. 

 

Luciena's post is a solid 10 minutes after Ish and Darthe both made a statement about it

 

I thought she was fake before so this isn't helping my feelings about her

[Tommyrod]

 

Then lynch me. At least it'll give town something to go off of next day phase.

 

Key: I'm town and therefore am not sure of anyone's alignment but my own. So yes I could be wrong. Weak argument.

 

The point isn't that you aren't sure of their alignment, the point is that of course you could be wrong.  But that's what most of the game is, going by what you feel/notice and guessing as to the alignment of someone else.  So, I don't think it's necessary to point out the obvious.  It seems like a way to appeal your innocence if the flip isn't in your favor.  Like "oh, oops!  I did say I could be wrong though".  

 

Also, I wasn't in the game with Aidanna so I didn't know that is what she meant.

 

Don't know how else to explain. Guess when I'm town I should not give any reads, only respond.

 

Not trying to be emo:but I've explained what I've done and why. If course I'm looking for something Key...otherwise I'd be lurking and not contributing. I don't know about you but at least I'm trying to find scum.

 

Not sure if you're replying to me when it comes to your comment about Aidanna or not.  

 

Bold - kinda emo.  Analyzing what people say is part of the game.

 

Of course contributing is better than lurking. But "going after anything that might go somewhere" just sounds sketchy, to me.   

 

 

It's probably a bad sign that I disagree with almost everything this guy says

 

Wait, I'm voting him already, carry on then 

[Tommyrod]

unvote vote hallu

 

Frozen

 

I had Darthe's opening and pretty typically Darthy and I was thinking this when I bumped into this post so it's good that we've mind-melded... through space and time

[Tommyrod]

^ should say *as pretty typically Darthy

[Tommyrod]

Official Vote Count:

 

Hallu (2): Snow, Darthe

Aida (1): Golden

Golden (1): Aida

Kaylee (3): Cloud, Des, Key

Darthe (1): Hallu

Cloud (1): Kaylee

Key (1): Ishy

 

With 13 alive, 7 is needed to achieve a lynch.

Not Voting (4): Peace, Dice, Luci

 

Deadline Monday 2AM GMT+1 http://www.timeanddate.com/countdown/generic?iso=20131209T02&p0=1375&msg=End+of+D1

 

So by this point: I like Ishy and he's voting someone I dislike (Key), that's good

 

Cloud, Des and Key are all on a Kaylee wagon, and I think that could be a mislynch attempt, because I can't figure out why I distrust Kaylee and because I already dislike those 3 players

 

Kaylee is on Cloud, that's fine with me, he's definitely sus

 

Aida was on Golden because of their dumbass argument I guess

 

And I don't remember who Snow is, but hallu is odd and Darthe is on him

 

Noted that Peace, Dice, and Luci all haven't voted yet because mafia does have a habit of voting later rather than sooner, and all three of them fall flat upon first read. Like they're not really trying to stick their necks out.

 

So Cloud/Des/Key/Peace/Dice/Luci pick from this pile and you've got most of the mafia I'd say. 

 

*looks at OP*

 

Okay Peace is dead so 

 

Cloud/Des/Key/Dice/Luci choose 3 

[keyholder21]

OMG.  I just freaking lost my ISO of Kaylee in the middle of analyzing it. 

 

@(*%()#*()^*()#^*()^*()#*^()#*^()*#()^*#()*^()#*^)

 

I freaking HATE the new way that DM quotes work, how they don't translate properly to Word and back.  Makes it way harder.  Des, how do you do all yours?

 

I will redo this in the morning, as well as look at Ishy and Des, when I am not super tired and super irritated at DM quote thingys.

[keyholder21]

It's probably a bad sign that I disagree with almost everything this guy says

 

Wait, I'm voting him already, carry on then 

 

 

I'm a girl, love. 

 

Other than that, carry on.

[Tommyrod]

I'm not even in this game but I'm supposed to be voting Key.

 

Wait, I am?

 

Unvote, Vote Key

 

 

 

Don't like the emo martyr play from Kaylee but it does seem kinda genuine.

 

 

 

I'm not even in this game but I'm supposed to be voting Key.

 

Wait, I am?

 

Unvote, Vote Key

 

 

Why?

 

 

 

 

Don't like the emo martyr play from Kaylee but it does seem kinda genuine.

 

This is odd coming from you because I'm used to seeing you call people out for AtE.

 

 

I really disliked what Des said here about the post seeming genuine, but then Cloud called him out on it. And Cloud's posts here particularly stick out to me because...

 

 

 

 

I have counted votes in read, and votes that didn't say "vote" in front of the name, so far... I will not continue to do so past D1. Please format your votes as per the rules :) Makes one think you haven't read the rules ;)

 

 

 

a) *red

b) rules don't say they have to be black, so red should be fine, such that they're bolded?

 

 

 

and unvote Hallu, vote Cloud

 

Do I have a reason?

 

No, it was just a feeling.

This happened right before it. Cloud is really anal about asking people for justifications and reasons, but doesn't even care when Snow votes him for admittedly no real reason? We know Snow is town now, so... I have to wonder why he wouldn't care at all since it's not a wolf bus so it shouldn't just be outright ignored. I don't really get it, it feels inconsistent but not necessarily scummy. Cloud can go back to null I guess, because if he was wolf I'd see him being all over that. 

[Tommyrod]

Des I can only assume that you have children by the usage of words like poopie.

 

I feel you there.

 

Your votes stand out simply because of how quickly you switched them. First it was on Kay, which seemed bandwagon-y and you taking the opportunity to hop on the highest train and then quickly turned around to vote Key next.

 

Also, I mentioned your early vote on Snow for basically nothing. Even if he was quoting the Joker, what would that have to do with his alignment? Or I guess I should say mine at this point, but you get the point.

 

Well AJ flipped town so I certainly don't feel better about Des after this little battle