Greek Mythology: Man Vs. Gods [Advanced] - GAME OVER - TOWN WINS!

[csarmi]

Darthe, your argument is full of holes. Why would you believe anyone's race human/titan race claim - at any point of the game.

 

If Dice is telling the truth, the maffia started with 4 gods. Their natural assumption should be that gods = maffia. So they'd claim human, titan, whatever that's not god.

[csarmi]

 

What's this talk with claimed watcher? What did I miss? What with the tracker?

Didn't someone claim watcher?

 

I don't recall such an event. But I'm gonna go through this now.

[Darthe]

Oye! You lot!

 

You like playing mafia? Its a fun hobby and passtime of the site and our group of friends?

 

Then sign up for the games! DM mafia can't live without players after all.

 

This has been 9 days in sign-ups and has 5 people in it.

 

http://www.dragonmount.com/forums/topic/84423-die-hard-for-mafia-sign-ups/page-2?do=findComment&comment=3027273

 

Join and lets play together

[csarmi]

Darthe, you claimed Titan and nothing else, right?

[csarmi]

Despo is one of the players claiming human very early, by the way. By Darthe's argument, he'd be confirmed town :D

[csarmi]

The claims I found:

 

Berf claimed human (very early, #3019026)

Pralaya claimed today that he had no protective or blocking roles.

Dice claimed a whole lot of things. Oracle + Lover for himself, and lots of setup talk. Don't have a current list on that. I ahd summarized that some time ago.

MCS hinted at beign God. I claimed I'm not a god.

Ithi claimed God + Doc.

Mish claimed Clumsy Switch, then survivor. Confirmed (lynched).

Darthe claimed he was Titan.

Krak did no play.

Hally is Innocent Child.

Song did no play.

Wombat claimed nothing. (He pointed out that directing Cop/Doc is stupid because maffia watcher can find the PR, for instance)

Basel claimed Vanilla Titan. Confirmed (got NK'd).

Despo claimed human very early (#3018907). He also claimed a lot of BS. Like not being NK'able only certain way, VigX3, etc (confirmed scum 3xjanitor)

Thorum claimed full Vig.

Tina claimed nothing.

Cloud claimed human (#3019589).

[csarmi]

From most scummy to least scummy.

 

Cloud

Tina, Wombat, Pralaya, Berf

Dice, Thorum

Ithi, Darthe

Csarmi, Hally

 

Krak, Song = null read, if I had to decide which one of them were scum, I'd say Krak because of his lurking.

[csarmi]

If I had to bet for the maffia team right now, I'd say:

 

Cloud (I have a very strong scum read on him, I'd be comfortable with shooting him)

Krak (no participation, but some attempt at it)

Berf

[Darthe]

Darthe, your argument is full of holes. Why would you believe anyone's race human/titan race claim - at any point of the game.If Dice is telling the truth, the maffia started with 4 gods. Their natural assumption should be that gods = maffia. So they'd claim human, titan, whatever that's not god.

1) Salami argues that logic is poor because people may not be truthful. This is inaccurate because logic holds true as an objective standard where the player decisions are subjective.

 

2) We have already clarified that people claimed Titan/Human before Dices information was puvlic knowledge. Unless they grew foresight this is just wishful thinking for your little mafia heart.

 

3) The player switches their stance on Dice. "IF" Dice is telling the truth. Its only stated this way because otherwise two wouldn't make sense.

 

4) Started?

 

5) This has been said by like half of us. Beyond that, it WIFOMS god claims. If I was unclaimed mafia I would claim to be a God just because of the inherent WIFOM.

[Darthe]

Despo is one of the players claiming human very early, by the way. By Darthe's argument, he'd be confirmed town :D

  

 

You're just trolling now. Des was a counter claimed Vig who intentionally tried to flush other claims. Its like arguing that you are town because you claimed a non-god despite yiur evrry attempt to wiggle out of situatio s that help us.

 

 

From most scummy to least scummy.CloudTina, Wombat, Pralaya, BerfDice, ThorumIthi, DartheCsarmi, HallyKrak, Song = null read, if I had to decide which one of them were scum, I'd say Krak because of his lurking.

You put yourself in the list...

[csarmi]

2) We have already clarified that people claimed Titan/Human before Dices information was puvlic knowledge. Unless they grew foresight this is just wishful thinking for your little mafia heart.

Ae you drunk?

Yea they claimed before Dice made his play. Does that validate their claims?

 

Darthe - is Despo confirmed town?

[Darthe]

You're confirmed dumb.

 

Deal with it.

[csarmi]

 

Despo is one of the players claiming human very early, by the way. By Darthe's argument, he'd be confirmed town :D

You're just trolling now. Des was a counter claimed Vig who intentionally tried to flush other claims. Its like arguing that you are town because you claimed a non-god despite yiur evrry attempt to wiggle out of situatio s that help us.

 

I'm trolling? Seriously?

Despo claimed human on like the third page or so, way before this whole Dice story began (and the whole Vig story was much later than that).

 

I'm wiggling out of situations that help us?

You're kidding, right?

 

IVe tried to stop sillyness like claiming races, lynching Dice, not checking Dice's claims thoroughly, blind shooting with Vig, not pressuring Cloud or lynching a claimed survivor.

 

All of those actions were anti-town. Yes, the Mish lynch included.

 

You put yourself in the list...

I've put every living player on the list if they contributed to the game.

[csarmi]

You're confirmed dumb.

 

Deal with it.

Darthe, you keep insulting me (personally) in almost every game we play together. I've already pointed out that it's getting old, and it's rude besides.

[_CLOUD]

It's probably just Darthe's way of showing affection.

[Darthe]

I do nothing to people that they don't do to themselves. Your des argument doesnt hold water. As with anything else exceptions can be made, but do you honestly believe your own counterargument? If so then by all means feel free to attempt and lynch everyone that didn't claim a God and we will see where that gets you.

[csarmi]

I'm creating a new list because Darthe has complained I was put on it.

 

There you go:

 

Cloud

Tina, Wombat, Pralaya, Berf

Dice

Thorum

Ithi

Darthe

Hally

 

Krak/Song are no-read.

[_CLOUD]

I'm not mafia.

[csarmi]

I do nothing to people that they don't do to themselves.

Your des argument doesnt hold water.

Which argument? That you made a clearly ridiculous statement about how anyone who claimed titan/human early must be town?

 

As with anything else exceptions can be made, but do you honestly believe your own counterargument?

I don't make an argument that I don't believe in. When I hear stupidity, I point that out. Your statement about how early claims vet players alignment was a dumb one.

 

If so then by all means feel free to attempt and lynch everyone that didn't claim a God and we will see where that gets you.

WTF?

 

I can't even find words for this leap. Zero logic, and you try to attribute some actions for me?

Why the hell would I want to start lynching people who didn't claim a God?

Seriously, are you trolling? Or wtf is going on?

 

For the record, I'd like to lynch people I find scummy. That's the way the game's meant to be played, right?

[csarmi]

I'm not mafia.

Who do you think the maffia are then?

[Darthe]

I'm creating a new list because Darthe has complained I was put on it.

 

There you go:

 

Cloud

Tina, Wombat, Pralaya, Berf

Dice

Thorum

Ithi

Darthe

Hally

 

Krak/Song are no-read.

This 2 r bad. U hav 4 people on one row and teh entir basis of ur argument (Dice) is 3 to lasst?

[Darthe]

What's the point in giving Hally PRs? Everytime she gets a solid claim in a game she coasts on it and stops helping her team.

[Darthe]

 

I do nothing to people that they don't do to themselves.

Your des argument doesnt hold water.

Which argument? That you made a clearly ridiculous statement about how anyone who claimed titan/human early must be town?

 

As with anything else exceptions can be made, but do you honestly believe your own counterargument?

I don't make an argument that I don't believe in. When I hear stupidity, I point that out. Your statement about how early claims vet players alignment was a dumb one.

 

If so then by all means feel free to attempt and lynch everyone that didn't claim a God and we will see where that gets you.

WTF?

 

I can't even find words for this leap. Zero logic, and you try to attribute some actions for me?

Why the hell would I want to start lynching people who didn't claim a God?

Seriously, are you trolling? Or wtf is going on?

 

For the record, I'd like to lynch people I find scummy. That's the way the game's meant to be played, right?

Don't break my heart. I'm not responding to this one on a phone.

[ReleaseTheEvil]

Scene added. Still waiting on those NAs.

[WWWwombat]

/squelch csarmi