Enter the Dragon Mafia [Basic] D5: Town Wins!!

[csarmi]

Also, what's your exact role? Just Cop?

[peacesells]

I'm not really buying this claim.

[dapianoplay3r]

meh what can you do

 

deadline was hours ago

[csarmi]

Me neither, but can we risk lynching someone who claims cop?

[csarmi]

Deadline is in 5 hours or so, isn't it?

[csarmi]

 

CURRENT VOTE COUNT

 

RTE (1) - Peace

Dice (5) - Tiink, RTE, Nolder, CSarmi, Darthe

Tsuki (2) - Dapiano, Misheru

 

Not Voting (4): Dice, Tsuki, Millon, Hallia

 

With 12 alive it takes 7 to lynch 

 

Deadline

: The Deadline will be Tuesday at Noon EST (US). Countdown: http://www.timeandda...on Mafia: Day 3

 

 

There you go.

[dapianoplay3r]

oh i thoguht it was 5 hours ago!

 

Ok well im here for the next 2 hours so ill vote to consolidate if need be

 

till then. vote RTE

[csarmi]

Vote Tsuki

[csarmi]

Dap, you're still not voting RTE. (unvote)

[dapianoplay3r]

I thought i wasnt voting anyone beofre?

 

unvote vote RTE

[Tiinker]

Unvote, Vote RTE

[Tiinker]

This is sadness.

[csarmi]

Okay.

 

I'm a 3-shot cop.

 

RTE and Player are town.

[peacesells]

Okay.

 

I'm a 3-shot cop.

 

RTE and Player are town.

 

 

So..what are your feelings on Dice?

[peacesells]

UNVOTE

[dapianoplay3r]

god dammit. I was sure of RTE

 

So Dice is faking?

 

unvote vote dice

[peacesells]

god dammit. I was sure of RTE

 

So Dice is faking?

 

unvote vote dice

 

Maybe...Csarmi only claimed 3 shot cop.

[csarmi]

I viewed Player first night (well, Tigs did, anyway) - Town.

I viewed RTE second night (myself) - Town.

 

I can't say I believe Dice, for several reasons:

 

1) The timing of the claim.

2) His unwillingness of answering questions.

2) I don't believe a full-cop and a 3-shot cop would exist in a game. That there were no NK's so far makes me think it even more unlikely.

[peacesells]

Do I have this right?

 

Players

1. ReleaseTheEvil  confirmed by Csarmi

2. MisheruSedai

3. Darthe

4. Hallia  doc

5. Tiinker

6. Nolder

7. Tsukibana

8. peacesells  confirmed by hallia

9. dapianoplay3r confirmed by hallia and Csarmi

10. dicetosser1 claimed cop

11. Tigraine CSarmi  claimed 3 shot cop

12. Millon

13. RandA lThor, Tournament Fighter, Vanilla town, Lynched D1

[peacesells]

3 - shot cop would be a crafty fake claim.  Not saying I don't believe you Csarmi..but I can see a scenario where the scum team want the real cop lynched and came up with a claim like this.

 

Dice flips real cop and you still have your 3 shot claim intact. 

[dapianoplay3r]

if there is a full cop, his 3 shot is completely invalid IMO

[csarmi]

While I do believe he's telling the truth about his RL problems (I know some of that from other games / QT's), I also think that the way he plays does fit him being scum.

 

With that said, I voted Dice because I felt it was a good shot. I dislike lurkers and dying games.

 

Math tells me that

- lynching scum is good (obvious reasons)

- lynching unconfirmed (non-PR) townies is better than no lynch (because it gives us information on the coroner, also it reduces the number of players that we can't be certain of)

 

Also, I think that - if no other information present - lynching players that participate less is not a bad idea in general.

 

So this is why I did vote him.

 

Now I think he's scum, but I've been giving him the benefit of doubt and I still believe that I can't be 100% sure. Something about the setting, my PM's, my role (3x-shot) says that this game is not simple (even if basic).

 

So I do think we have to lynch someone today (we need information) and I would say I'M about 95% sure that Dice is lying. I think our best play is to lynch someone else. 

 

I claimed because we can't risk losing RTE, and we can't really risk our healer being misdirected.

Alsobecause while now there's a possibility that I'd die tonight, I think we have enough wine to make the maffia sweat on tonight's kill - and because I have only 1 shot remaining anyway. 

[peacesells]

if there is a full cop, his 3 shot is completely invalid IMO

 

I agree...but I'm leaning towards believing Csarmi atm.  I think the questions he was asking gives a clue to his own role.

[csarmi]

if there is a full cop, his 3 shot is completely invalid IMO

 

Yea, and I think it goes the other way too. See my reason 3) above.

[peacesells]

Well, I'm voting Dice or Tsuki at this point.